Viticulture World: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for viticulture world the cooperative expansion to vivi culture um so uh this was sent to me as a review copy um so take that with what you will but let's talk about fadi culture world okay would you like me to begin sure first question because this actually isn't my game um it also it is not just cooperative world can be played the traditional competitive way yes no no world is strictly cooperative world is purely cooperative okay but they they changed cards within the decks that work in cooperative as well as competitive so so pretty much you just need the expansion um and any changes you make to the original game because you also do need the original game to play uh you don't have to take cards out every single time you want to play competitively right so they work in both in both instances which is good um but yeah so they have multiple countries that you can play in uh europe north america south america asia africa um i think all the continents no antarctica isn't isn't in it yeah it's pretty hard we're looking at terraforming right
but it's uh but they all play different um so and your variety besides of picking a different continent to play is that um for your first few games that's there's more cards than just the six events but you play one through six yes but then any other time so if we play europe again you you can shuffle the events and and so that will happen variable difficulty um versus being like oh hey i know in year three we're gonna get this benefit so you don't know um i'm conflicted i'm conflicted on this game okay because it has the same fundamental problems that i have with viticulture now in that how how easy or how hard the game is is just how well your ability to top deck is a lot of it yeah like if you're sitting there because i feel like this game is extremely slow it feels slow yeah you're involved and you're sort of an engine builder because we're not competing for spaces usually right right in fact we want to share them and strategize sharing themselves yeah so it's like they took a competitive game and was like okay well for some reason let's make it cooperative and it's like okay sure i don't know a single person who was asking i want viticulture to be cooperative but it is and but it's like i i'd rather cooperative games be like
how well you can strategize around what's happening versus like well i sure hope you know we can draw you know vines that give us what we need and fill orders that we need um because it's not like we're not running one vineyard together right you're still playing vidi culture yes but now it's just like now you can trade with each other and we're trying to help each other achieve our achieve goals yeah rather than we're trying to get in each other's way yeah and that's kind of it's so it feels still like a competitive game because of just that fundamental aspect it's not now oh how can we all utilize our workers in one way to share the common goal of a vineyard um it's well i still have to do my stuff like i still have to get 25 points you still have to get 25 points so if you have a better setup of harvesting and planting and all that and you can fill orders left and right well i also have to try to do that or go a completely different route and be almost a hindrance the entire time um i don't know i i feel like i'd rat i would have liked it more if it was like here's the vineyard board here you know we share one vineyard we're running that together instead of it just being two separate things it's just so strange yeah that's really what i would describe
this cooperative experience as strange like i think it's challenging and then it's not different enough from the competitiveness no and that it's well because it is but it's not see that was my feeling is i am really really impressed by the idea that they could take the exact same mechanics and turn it into a cooperative without with changing very little of the actual gameplay so people who know viticulture and like viticulture people who like cooperative games yeah i think that it it there's there's almost no learning curve there's there's no change yeah and that impresses me a lot now i'm not saying that that is something that i like i'm saying that it's really impressive because most most competitive games that try to have be cooperative yeah or games that are released to blue both yeah generally fail at either one or sometimes both yeah that's true this this to me feels like the exact same game except they're strategized together instead of separately yeah yeah no you're absolutely right and i think my my biggest thing is it still almost doesn't feel like it needed to be made like it's just so bizarre of an expansion like either nowadays games come out where they are both hey there's a cooperative there's a one verse many there's a there's a competitive um and it's like i usually stay away from those games because i'm like okay you did all of those poorly also like uh there's a solo variant like it's like no nope no i'm not touching that uh and so vidi culture was always like
kind of like the the quintessential work replacement game that a lot of people generally like right um even even though we had our issues with it we still rated it fairly highly but it's like yeah okay now it's cooperative maybe it's just a different mindset where and i will say in the cooperative nature it does feel good to play a different strategy because in the competitive mode it's like well we're all kind of doing the same thing like just in different orders uh here i literally didn't plant a single grape like there is not one grape on my vines and i was able to get 25 points that way which as you pointed out is what what you now consider to be a fundamental flaw of all of this right is that the theme is you can play with without the theme at all yeah yeah like i just like i felt like i um like i bought a vineyard and that was me i was the ceo of a vineyard and i was just raking in the money and just doing all the pr stuff yeah and you were the one doing all the work which you know and again different ways to win they both apply equally yeah in the competition the cooperative as well yeah because it feels good because it's like in it like to try that in a competitive and regular video culture like it's it's and i did in our run through and i wasn't do it wasn't you know too bad but very well um for never planting you're not planting a single thing i don't know
why for some reason that's just more fun to me uh because it's like well everyone is obviously planting well i don't want to be like everyone else well that way we're also competing for the same spaces yeah you go a different way you've got a lot more freedom yeah so it works out really well on the cooperative because we are targeting different spaces to do different things right right and then hey i'm i've got a valuable grade why don't i hand it to you yeah yeah why and and the utilizing different workers where it's like i was mainly all summer like i think i used two workers max and winter to fill an order whenever i happen to bring in the stuff and to pay for the influence um so the cooperative let's let's talk about the actual cooperative gameplay of of it um so it's slow it's about an hour and 40 minutes to two hours of of the overall game it feels your first couple years are gonna feel like you are not doing anything right no not getting any points right and the talk is ticking yes so your eye in that in every single year that passes by you're like we're not it's it's impossible like we can't do it and each time you and i have played this it always came down to like the last year and we just edged out like the 25 points now i will point out minor spoiler the intro not even continental but the intro the green goalie charter stone crossover
yeah the the one that you learned to play this version um really gave it away that is true i mean it it would have been impossible without all the gifts you get later on right which took away any enjoyment i had at that point for sure it doesn't matter what i did right i was doomed and then suddenly here's a kitty right you did it um but there's a good boy i will say that the the tutorial still did a really good job of introducing you to this cooperative experience oh yes um because if you think about it in regular vidi culture there is no timer it's a race to 25 points and so people can just have the freedom to be like oh i'll just okay i'll get a couple points here and there and then you know and then do the few leaps of points and in viticulture world you don't have that time like every single worker you place is like you need to be very exact and very meticulous because most cards are like oh take away a point to gain something you don't want to do that here like literally i did that once and i just got 25 points so it's like luckily it didn't hurt us we weren't like oh no we're down you know we lost by one point because each player has to get 25 points yeah and then you just have to get influence up to 10. but it makes me wonder why not why they put the artificial time limit on it because it could have just been how long did it take you to get to the goal and then you rank yourself based on you know a power system
i feel like that kind of stuff works best in solo play okay like a beat your own score kind of thing is best in solo and cooperative it's there's for me i would kind of feel like well what's the point like let's just say we did something versus oh [ __ ] like is having the timer and cooperative games are supposed to be hard and having an arbitrary we got 80 points this time or we did it in 10 rounds or whatever doesn't hold any weight in my opinion okay um but like terraforming mars and stuff for solo play is a kind of beat your own score hey this time i got you know 100 points and last time i only did 95 or whatever and it's like oh yeah i did it gotcha um so i do like that the the year track is there and because and you mentioned uh during the run through it's like oh well this is hopeless and i was like yeah it [ __ ] might be like i was agreeing with you but they do something in this that i very much enjoy with cooperative games is strategizing in turn order like so many times it's like okay i need to go here first yeah and then you need to come here and afterwards so we can do this so i can give you this stuff i mean it has that pandemic feel like very very specific orders on actions this card when i went there after you fulfilled your order put me over the top right it wouldn't have happened right but it had to be in the right order and i had to have the right workers left yep and the fact of trading things where it's like and i think
that's what makes the individual viti culture or many cultures the individual vineyards not well sorry not the individual vineyards it's the top decking it in cooperative it's not as bad because of the trading element yeah that is way bigger than what the introduction ever made it out to be yeah like this game was like we used the training so much because it was like well i don't have any vineyards oh i don't have any i don't have any grapes i'm not harvesting yeah i need to rely on whatever piddly-ass wines i can get and if you're gonna draw orders because if in in cooperative if i draw an order that's not good for me but it's good for you well sucks to suck you sorry you didn't draw that one but here it's like it's like oh man i really need a sparkling like that's the only thing i got oh you drew it okay so now we can trade and you can give that to me yeah but they restrict the trading enough that it's not game breaking no it's not free trade it's yeah you pick one thing yeah and you can do one give one take yep and that's it yep and you have to go to the same spot and it almost feels yeah it's no special guy it almost feels worse because you have to give up your grande worker to do that so it's either you have to hopefully find a spot that both players or all players i guess know both players who's trading want to go to and if that works out then it's like great oh you want to play a you know a summer visitor i also want to play one so you
can go there first and i can go there and we can trade or we need to trade yeah we did a couple of times so where are we both going to go yeah and in what order yeah exactly and there's a lot of strategizing co-strategizing which is again really good really impressive yeah and i think the reason why it's like i don't think this expansion is bad by any means i just think it's huh it feels odd i just think it's very weird it's it's an odd concept um that like you said most people would fail at but they were able to pull it off in some way um but there are a couple things that i don't like about it um sure i i really like the events i like that the events like because we did the medium europe is a medium difficulty and it didn't it felt fair like they had a few events that were kind of like oh you pay an extra coin you know if you harvest or if you do something like and they try to tie in some theme or some history whatever into it um but other times it's like hey if you do an action pay three coins and you can gain an influence and i like that i like that the events allow you to gain something extra but also might penalize you yeah what i don't like is that i do not like the innovation tiles um okay like well i like them i like that i like their abilities like but the your game is once again easier harder in the order that those come out
that's true and that is very frustrating especially because the order tiles are not dictated by continent so they're always the same one so you could be like well i [ __ ] know that the play two winter cards is in there but where is it like okay i guess we're just not getting it yeah um or if you're struggling with a money engine and you're like well we need influence but the the one i mean we didn't get the one that made it cheaper until way later right um replayability by randomness but you sacrifice strategy right right and it just doesn't feel all that fair um and yeah it's just kind of like hey how can we make the game really difficult or and it's almost arbitrary difficulty yeah it's like well you didn't really strategy you didn't come up with a creative way to make it hard you just threw randomness in there which will make it hard or potentially really easy it's like oh man the ones we need for our i mean like the trade the trade one was perfect because i needed to get structures out and it's like okay well i was going for that anyway oh perfect so i like their abilities i think that they are very very helpful you almost have to innovate um at least some yeah at least a few yeah yeah but but i mean other than that i don't like how they come out and the oval ones we didn't get a single one we didn't bother this time we did last time we did but and it was okay but it wasn't yeah
as as important as these yeah it was it cost the same it costs the same and the only people who can benefit from these are trained workers i don't like the training yeah that's probably another kind of negative i've never trained one in all the games i played yeah i've never bothered because i've always been growing and fulfilling orders yeah so pretty much equal summer and winter and i just didn't use the time and the money to get out of that space yeah it's it's pretty expensive and training doesn't feel as good in this one and the regular it does because you get more workers in a worker placement that's good but then this it's just like well two and two is pretty solid like like yeah i guess he's a trained worker so now he can go anywhere which could be nice if you need to change strategy yeah uh mid but like every time we've played it well we've always got the the third wild card yeah in any given year someone can choose to have a fourth mm-hmm yeah so it's kind of like well training doesn't feel that great these oval tiles are the only thing that makes training worth it because your grande worker the the extra bonus worker and any train worker can gain from these right um what i mean the secondary nature of these is the fact that it doesn't restrict spots to one person in a two-player game it's that oh if this is here anyone can now go there yeah um operative how hard how how many players
six cooperative yeah one to six [ __ ] no yeah absolutely not i can't i'm having a hard time imagining even three i same just just with the level of strategy and the level of randomness like yeah that would all it does well technically a three player game still has the same number of influence you start at three in a two and three and four the six you start at zero so the difficulty now becomes you have a third person trying to get 25 points and to trade with and to figure out what all the spots to go on yeah because all the spots are um still limited to the first one yeah so and maybe it's just a two-player game these aren't as good but in a three player game i can see these being a lot better because well obviously we all want to go do something we all want to fill an order so let's put one of these on there but it makes it like if we put an oval spot on the fill order space you have to pay a two penalty if you want to do it on the trained one three players you need to get rid of two cards so you need to get rid of a point so it's um i don't know i think it's i never felt like oh we need another person i i think that would just way complicate things and make it less enjoyable yeah and wait longer yeah like it's already a longer cooperative game that it is long i will say it it doesn't feel like it oversees its welcome right like it feels pretty good yeah probably because it picks up it does yeah um and and so
you're getting more excited and you're oh we're almost done we got it becomes even more crucial toward the end because the first couple years are what are we doing and is it gonna work right yeah i mean the first couple years is you kind of just are drawing a bunch of cards yep maybe yeah and that kind of brings me to my next kind of concept of it's cooperative and culture i wouldn't say has the greatest of replayability anyway so it's like well am i going to play this any different you know like this strategy i mean the strategy i probably wouldn't do a lot but what's incentivizing you to play any differently um when something has worked in a cooperative game just the randomness the randomness and potentially the different continents with the event decks well yeah different difficulty levels in different different ways europe was about these objectives i think that was nice these were cool um not impossible to do and gain points or if you need money and that's another way to gain influence if you get both um so i mean overall i think it's i think it's a balanced game um it doesn't have necessarily uh really any major flaws like i'm not sitting there like oh i absolutely despise this um it for i mean i don't necessarily like saying stuff like this but it if you have problems with vide culture and like it's pure randomness and like oh lucky you you drew all the right cards for you and i didn't yeah um
that goes away so the cooperative expansion fixes that where if you want to like the game and you're like well now it's in even playing field who cares who draws what because we can trade with each other then everyone's working together and for me it doesn't fix the problem it just expands it to we're all in the same boat sure but it's still random enough that if you don't draw key cards or if you draw some useless card they're still the same mitigations but it still feels it feels the same yeah to me it's just we're strategizing together instead of i'm being really quiet i guess i guess it doesn't feel per yeah it doesn't feel personally um upsetting like the game itself is yeah still like well this is annoying we're not drawing any cards but because of will you draw there's one more mitigating factor in that we can't trade yes yeah uh i mean that's that's really like it because it's like it's hard i mean if you if you like vid well here's the thing if you like vidi culture and you like cooperative games and you like cooperative games that's just i don't know who this is for that that that group yeah because i mean i would imagine if people could probably not the sort of viticulture is not going to draw a lot of cooperative game lovers yeah that's the strange part is like if you really love vinnie culture well you probably love it because it's competitive so i couldn't that's it at the back of the beginning it's like this is strange this is strange i think what's bothering you is who thought of this right
what the hell like why did as you said viticulture you know we need people working together yeah it's so because and that's just lately what stone meyer has been where it's like who the hell is coming up with with these ideas who is this for red rising yeah it's not for red rising fans i can tell you that much it's not for fans of fantasy realms it's for that weird group of people that loves both um vinnie culture the cooperative expansion yeah i think it's a really good cooperative game it has a really good flow has a good build up um tight timer where you're like man are we gonna do it and you just make it and you're like awesome because like in every game we've played it has come down to like i don't think we're gonna do it and i think we're gonna do it right and then being like oh okay if we do this in this very specific way we can do it and that brings out the level of strategy the problem solving that that i i thrive off of in cooperative games um it almost gave me that very sp have you played spirit island yes i don't remember it very well okay that is probably my favorite cooperative game okay um because every single round is you need to do this in this order that'll allow me to do well not you if you do that then then i can do this that's going to do this and it just so many like step-by-step things um with a little element of randomness to kind of throw a wrench in things yeah but you're constantly
problem solving and this cooperative expansion did bring that out yeah or like you said pandemic pandemic housing any of the more complex um cooperatives yeah so but then it's like yeah like no one was asking for a furry libertalia remake um no one was asking for red rising and no one was asking for a cooperative expansion to viti culture i feel like the only reason i think no because even a friend of mine because he was he was kind of excited because he's a solo gamer but like well vinnie culture has a solo variant yeah so it's like just play that does demer have any other cooperatives i can't think of any but i don't know all of them they're out of cooperative modes but no fundamentally cooperative games oh man do they not wingspan no no wingspan uh wingspan euphoria scythe um man they might not try to think of that rolling right the the stonemeyer jerk off game between two uh castles between two castles is kind of yeah it's not really no not really it's working it's working together to make me win pretty much yeah between two castles mad king ludwig between two cities charter stone no euphoria that's competitive libertalia pendulum red rising rolling
realms scythe um tapestry viticulture no wingspan no they do not have a single cooperative game so maybe that was where the inspiration came from that's that's impressive i have never thought of that like huh so my maybe somebody said hey you don't have any cooperatives well which of my games can i make coop or which one can you know has been popular enough that i can get away with risking it yeah that would probably be it vadi culture i mean out of all the games i just named vidiculture is probably the better themed one to um to go into a cooperative more universally loved wingspan wingspan blows this out of the water in terms of well in terms of actual sales and i would say love wingspan definitely kills it um but this one this one was one of their very early ones and um probably put them on the market oh yeah uh and so meyer always makes i mean out of i mean we even like the new libertalia remake it was it's really good and like i kept it but no one was asking for it everyone was pissed off when the art was released so yeah this this is an expansion that exists i can't say i i do recommend it like it's um it's it's good enough to be like you know what i feel like
doing wine and i don't feel like you know getting somebody yeah i don't feel like getting screwed about randomness and i don't feel like playing vignos so let's do vidi culture world and yeah and it's another thing stonemeyer makes and it's just it's just kind of there yeah i'm definitely in a i i'll i'll absolutely play it again yeah but i don't hey you know what we should do right now right out of all the cooperative games like no one's popping vinnie culture out like not yet yeah because i guess they don't have it but it hit the market and then i here's here's my prediction i think that this is it it's gonna sell probably relatively well because it's viticulture and people are uh like not watching well yeah they're not watching a lot of people's reviews um because they're not being made but they're um they're enticed by the idea i think it will die i think people will be like that was [ __ ] weird like or yeah it's pretty good but in a in a market where cooperative games are thriving and there's just it's it's niche it is very niche yeah unlike wingspan which is much more universal appeal or or tapestry or any uh a lot of i mean sorry the thing with every single like every single cooperative game i own i would play before i played this one okay like which is isn't to say it's bad it's just that i don't want to play viticulture as a cooperative game it's like it's just
it's an expansion yeah does it work absolutely does it do the cooperative nature really well absolutely is it impressive that they took a competitive game purely competitive made it cooperative and it's their oh their first foray into the cooperative genre that's it's really good respect yeah that's so but love yeah like i just can't see myself breaking this out to play cooperatively okay that's kind of that's why it's weird it's polarizing in the sense that it's good and i would recommend it if someone were to ask me my thoughts on it but if they're like oh well do you want to play it not really like let me explain and then i'll walk away right yeah i'll teach you guys how to play it here's um here's the rule book like here's your nothing rule book that's the whole rule book this is the whole rule book okay yep and it it barely i mean granted because it's it is vivi culture so yeah to play this you have to understand that could be very annoying um for some people yeah that's true you can't really play this until you until you have played viticulture um so you would have to grab the viticulture rule book understand that and then read this so for graduates of viticulture and lovers of viticulture yeah who like also but again competitive game suddenly let's try it cooperative
and see what happens it's it's going to be more niche than they're projecting i i agree with you yeah so and that's even another thing so the rule book for the expansion is very very thin and no no clarification no nothing so because trading isn't a thing in regular video culture so the one we had where it's like can you give me a higher level and my sellers can hold i mean i see why it should be no but that's no different than a specialist giving me something i can't technically have so based off the trading rules as written it says any value wine depending on how special the specialist is yeah the difference for me in that was that the specialist is a single unique card yeah if you happen to get it you can use it right trading is something you can universally do right that's why i was thinking it would be kind of broken if we could but that's the one thing you can skirt the rules yeah consistently but technically as written it says any value wine you trade any value wine okay if it said because it making wine makes sense like hey you could have easily added you know recipient must yeah within sellers yeah within housing or within seller or it could be devalued to something they can hold yeah yeah but because stuff like that is not explained in here it's a subpar rulebook and yeah obviously you need the expansion it literally says viticulture is required to play most expansions are yeah so but it is annoying that someone wants to try cooperatively most the time
they don't have to read the previous game's rule book so you have to read that and i would even say you couldn't even read the viticulture rule book and then play this you would probably have to play viticulture to understand how it works and then you would help us so this is definitely made for people who already have viticulture because and that's what their rule book is like oh actually there's a lot of them yeah and there's a lot of people who still enjoy playing it yep and if you have everything for video culture it's all they they don't have to you know change anything like you want structures boom you can have them flip the board you don't have to have structures you can add um the mon park paw cards the only thing that they don't have in the expansion is the uh stars like the weird area control stuff yeah the tuscany map that's not in here but it's it's just as simple as you being like yeah oh well i literally can't move a star so give me a new one yeah i didn't really like that yeah it was whatever part of the other one anyway so yep very strange very strange i'm curious to see where it is in like a few years from now yeah hope it works not holding my breath yeah it's not off to a great start in the eyes of the public so uh well who knows who knows what happens but um yeah i think that's it i think that's all i got uh on a scale of one to ten what would you give viticulture world
hmm again it's a split thing because i love the idea i love the execution i i am i want to try the other continents okay like it's not it's it is intriguing enough i think that's also where it will die once people kind of get over oh we've played every continent yeah okay so let's randomize the cards and that's that's real that's pretty much it which is more random something that we already find a little irritating yeah yeah um it doesn't it still doesn't feel as bad like like it's more personal when it's like man i wish i drew the card that gave me eight points you know off of that but i guess i didn't all right so scale so i want to rate it higher just because of all the positives but as far as the actual game itself and playing it seven which is not bad not at all yeah that's that's where i'm at like i'm i think i'm giving it a seven also uh because i think i i'm the one in the boat that oh once i've played the six i think there's six continents once i've played those okay once i'm done so we i've seen those that's kind of fun like it does the cooperative nature extra you know extremely well with the planning and stuff but now there's not really much much more to see um like i mean even for europe we could technically be like oh what would they have been poor harvest after a player harvest at least one field this year vna action decrease the value skyrocketing prices place the event token on action i wherever that is up there whenever a player draws a
uh order a wine order uh via action i this year they also receive two coins there we go we've seen europe and now the only difference is we shuffle that if you want to play europe again um obviously there were there were a bunch more orders so it's that in a different order and whatever your objectives might be have two or more wines in your large cellar have at least a value have at least 10 value among all your planted um vines so that's kind of have at least oh wait this would have been great for me have at least 15 coins like so maybe it's not so much the events that are different but that in tandem with objectives or special powers or whatever it might be but they're still just minor variants of the same game yeah yeah so i'm still gonna give it a seven i think it's definitely worth checking out uh and giving a shot um but but yeah all right you got anything else nope sorry that is our thoughts on vivi culture world uh less than what you think of the expansion in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other
run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you