Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dale of Merchants: Anniversary Edition - Preview - Time To Bring It Back!

Transcript 23:38

Hi everyone, I'm the Broken Meeple. Win or lose, I'm going to be honest with you and hmm, okay, this ain't going to work. All right, move that a little bit over there. Yeah, uh this is a preview video for Dale of Merchants. Now, you know that I don't tend to do a lot of preview videos on the channel, but when I do, I cherry-pick my favorites. So, you know, Dale of Merchants is a game that I can't remember if I've reviewed. I think I've reviewed the collector's edition from previous, but I can't remember if I've ever reviewed Dale of Merchants like in the old days, like back in the first days of the channel. But, I've definitely spoken about this one highly on my top 50 and top 100 videos, so certainly no shortage there, but Dale of Merchants is getting a reprint. So, below here you can see the one that I had before. So, let's move these off the top here just a second. This is the Dale of Merchants collection. Used to be the game in small boxes. Basically, I had all of those and then this box was printed and then I grabbed this and basically I've got everything in here.

So, everything in here, all sleeved, all different like animal folks from pandas to owls to comedians and stuff. This is just a solid deck-building game.

Good job.

But, Dale of Merchants has been a staple in my collection for ages as a deck builder. It's simple, it's beautiful, it's got a ton of variety with all the different animal folks once you buy a bunch of sets or you can just play casually with only a small box set for six of them works perfectly well. And it does a few little twists that other deck builders don't do, you know, the whole you don't discard your hand at the end of the round like most others do. Uh you when you buy a card, it goes to your hand, so you have it available for the next turn. You have to wait for it to come back around from your discard pile. And you're racing to a finish point, not getting victory points based on what's in your deck. So, there's a few little nice twists on the typical deck-building genre, but you don't see a lot of people talk about this. You know, it's had relatively, I'd say maybe small-scale distributions only over the last few years, but you know, I want to see more people play this cuz I think it is a solid game. Well, this is what I had before, so I'm going to leave that over there now, and this is the new. So, Dale of Merchants is getting a reprint, same publisher, same designer, you know, Sami Laakso from you know, Snowdale Design, you know, a very small sort of indie company. And basically, what they're doing is they are reprinting all the old material. So, this is effectively going to be a second edition of Dale of Merchants, not an upgrade pack. You're going to have to deal with that, you know, so I know some people are like, "Well, why Where is the update pack for this?"

Stop whining.

You wouldn't be able to because not only has the artwork undergone some revision changes, um all like about half the cards in the entire game have had a revision in terms of their text, their layout, you know, their their abilities and such. You know, some have been completely replaced and changed, some have just had little tweaks, but also the graphic design has been updated to, you know, allow for a much easier reading, an easier playing, a new rulebook, and even more animal folk. You know, so you've got, you know, the traditional amount of animal folks which I believe sort of comes in the first three boxes of here. I mean, some of this is black and white, you know, sketches because it is obviously a prototype, but they now come in these sort of like rectangular boxes now rather than these small thin boxes. And there's now going to be another, I think it's something like another nine factions included. So, I think previously we had about 27 odd, now we got 36. You know, it's going to be a ridiculous amount of different animal factions that you have in this game, and a collector's box so that you can actually store most of your collection, which is different from the other one.

The other one came with animals and different rules and other cards. This is mainly just a box.

We just make boxes here.

So, just to give a very brief synopsis on the game, because I have reviewed this before and I do urge you to check out those reviews for more detail, but essentially this deck builder has you racing to build eight stalls. All these animal folks are basically traders and you're building eight trading stalls. As soon as you built your eighth stall, that's it, you win. There's no victory points, just instant win. All the different animals uh like uh basically a deck of cards, that's a solo card, we'll put that aside for now. Um they come in a bunch of different varieties with numbers 1 2 3 4 and 5. You've got your basic ones that everybody will start the game with and then you've got the 2 3s 4s and 5s which are unique different cards. And the idea is is that you mix together a bunch of factions depending on the player count and they make one giant market deck. You'll then have a display of cards that you're able to buy from in the middle of the table. I'm just going to use the feeling raccoons on their own for illustration. And on your turn you get to do one action. You get to either buy a card from the market, you get to play a card for its effect, you get to build one of your stalls, or you get to discard and redraw cards from your hand as a choice. Do one of those actions, move on to the next turn, and you don't discard your cards at the end of the turn, you draw back up to your hand size. And the idea is is that these numbers correspond to the number of the stall that you're trying to make. So, the first stall has to be number one. So, okay, I can play this person and that's permanently out of the game effectively as my number one stall.

The next one has to add up to two. And it also has to add up to two from the same faction all the time. You can't mix and match. So, I could use a two card here. I could use a three card here. For the next one, I could use a three and a one from the same faction to make that a four. I could use a five on its own. I could use a five and a one for the next faction. And you know, you basically go up in that kind of sequence from one to eight until you get to your eighth stall. At that point, you win. And that's pretty much the rules of the game. Yeah, there really isn't a lot to learn. Most of the rule set is like, you know, just reading the cards themselves and obviously understanding the synergies and different interactions with all these different animal focus. Each one has their own unique rule set and kind of like how they work and interact with players. And also a sort of complexity level. Like for example, Thieving Northern Raccoons. I mean, have a guess what they're like. Yeah, they're pretty interactive. They're also kind of mean. I mean, you get to put cards that players don't want on top of their decks. You get to nick cards off them.

You get to nick cards off their deck and discard pile. Yeah, they're raccoons. They're yeah, trash pandas. They're going to do stuff like that. So, this is a fairly low complexity, high interaction, fairly mean deck that you can throw in. Although, there are meaner factions in this game. You know, if you look for all of this.

The Raccoons.

So, what are these new changes that have been made? Well, let's talk about the individual boxes first. So, previously, you had a kind of thin rectangular box that you bought. It came with six animals and you could play the game out of those sets. So, whether you bought Dale Merchants 1, 2, 3, 4, whatever, you could play it as a stand-alone game or just combine the lot. Well, the same premise happens here, except they now come in these more big more chunkier boxes. You might think, well, this takes up more space, surely. But, they are better organized because in each one this is where the Thieving Raccoons came from, actually. They store very neatly everything you need from the board, the rules, the cards, the extra pieces like dice, etc. Some of the factions use dice in various ways. And even dividers. You didn't get that before unless you bought the collector's set. So, you've got a little box here for, you know, the different like sub-rules that you need. Like for example, the Ocelots, or kitty cats, basically, require red dice. This is just for the red dice.

You've then got the different cards, as well as the dividers. You've got a rulebook that explains the entire game, as well as some basics about the like factions you're using, and a fold-out wooden board sorry, wooden cardboard board to house the market display. And, you know, it's a decent well-compact box. And I like the fact you've got dividers now. These are pretty good dividers and they separate out everything you need. So the junk cards, the basic cards and in here we've got giant pandas, northern raccoons, the ocelots, the veiled chameleons, the scarlet macaws. Is that how you pronounce it? And the Siberian flying squirrels, you know. So I didn't realize that flying squirrels were a Siberian thing. But you know, this is basically six factions and you can happily mix and match these to your heart's content. But it stores really neatly cuz even sleeved I haven't sleeved this cuz it's a prototype obviously, but you know, you basically have the cards in there. You put the rule book and the yep, the rule book and that and they slot to the right on there. You can basically, you know, there's plenty of space to fit more cards in here. So you could buy two of these sets and possibly get as much as you need in one little box.

One of these is meant to be the thieving raccoons. So I'll just pop you in your divider. Yeah, there we go. And you can put Oops, sorry. Tuck the cards up a little bit neater. Pop this little box in here. And then on we go. Boom. And it stores pretty nicely. And you should be able to get a bunch of these on a Kallax shelf. In fact, I dare say you would probably be able to get two or three of them in a row on a Kallax square with three above. So you can do a decent amount of storage with this. And of course, there's going to be six of these things.

Collect them all and you can become royal crown chocolate master.

So what kind of things have they changed? Well, firstly the artwork. The artwork is similar to what it was before, but it's a bit more detailed, a bit more cleaner and you know, just it just looks better than it did before. I mean, it was still nice artwork, but this is an improvement and it's more reminiscent of the recent stuff that they've done. So the you know, those these games that I've been touting all recently, you know, the artwork in those is kind of more like this one. So you can see kind of an evolution over time. And the art is lovely here. I mean, Sami Laakso does his own artwork along with Jesus Delgado. I hope I'm pronouncing that right. But you know, the two of them make a really nice, beautiful game. I mean, the you know, the boxes when you've got them on your shelf are going to have, you know, lovely artwork. The cards are going to be nice. And it's not like there's a ton of detail in the pictures. You know, most of it's like you've got the background and then an object and then the background and then a picture of the creature, but it's not it's not wasting space. It's not you know, the space that is on here is being used effectively. So, you don't need massive cards.

Uh the other thing that's changed is that you now have a helper card to select the factions you want to use. So, this one is contained with all of them and I like this because it tells you a rating out of three for complexity, interactivity, nastiness, and randomness. So, you get an idea of what the faction's like before you decide if you want to use it as well as a blurb that basically tells you what the faction is doing. So, we'll take the Veil Comedians, all right? Three complexity. Yeah, your copying abilities with this one is a little bit more complex. Interactivity, two. You're copying other people's cards. You're definitely going to be interacting. Nastiness, none. You don't copy anything to make it mean, so it's like that's fine. And randomness, one. You are at the mercy a little bit of what cards you get on available at any particular time, but for the most part you can kind of control it. And then it explains Comedians make you play your cards as if they're other cards in the game. They're recommended for more experienced players with long-term plans. And the nastiness, interactivity, and randomness may increase based on other decks. Yeah, so you get a nice, simple blurb explaining what the faction is like. I really like these.

Um the other thing here is a specific solo card. on to the uh solo mode a little bit later. Um and what they've done is kind of something pseudo similar to Sentinels of the Multiverse. Remember my definitive edition video I did? Well, Sentinels of the Multiverse when they made their new edition, they shortened how much text there was on the card because there was always a ton of stuff to read. So, they took word they took phrases and skinned them down down to say one word or they took phrases and put an icon instead. Same treatment here. So, yeah, for example, the ability that was called that they said to throw away this card into the discard pile, blah, blah, blah, it will now just say the word toss with bold text and color. So, you can see it a lot easier and read it a lot quicker. But, they also use iconography for certain things like cards. I mean, you don't have to have the word cards, you can just have a nice little symbol for a card. You know what it is. You can have a nice symbol for, you know, for like a number of cards, like your hand. So, you can have several of them on there. The plus symbol that means that you can play a second card in your turn, it's no longer a tiny plus in the corner, it's now a big solid, uh, let's see if I'm getting an example. You won't be able to see it really on camera, but it's now a big sort of solid plus symbol in the text of the card, so you can't really miss it. They changed the font a little bit, so it's a bit easier to read. The font's a little bit larger in terms of the number and the symbol in the top corner, so it makes it easier to read on the display. Just nice little subtle changes that aren't huge by themselves, but when you put them together, it makes a big impact. And certainly, it's a very easy to read and

understand what these abilities do. Now, that's not to say that the game doesn't lend itself to a few FAQ moments at times. They are going to have to work on some of these abilities. Um, there were times playing, uh, some of the sets where, you know, some of the abilities on the more complex creatures weren't as easy to tell what they were. And, you know, they're going to have to sort of make sure that they solidify those as they produce the game, but plenty of time for them to do that. You know, we can give them feedback in terms of rules that were a bit confusing, and they just make it a thing to explain it a little bit clearer in the books in the future. So, that's all well and good. Some of the abilities have absolutely, like, completely changed. There are some abilities that they thought just weren't that interesting, so they got rid of them. A couple they've even moved to other decks where they think, "Oh, this ability is actually better if we put it with this animal faction, so we're going to have this new faction for the pandas, and this one can go over here with the beavers or something." And it's like, again, very cool based on the feedback.

So, these little changes are going to make the game more approachable, as if it wasn't already, easier to grok, easier to read, nicer to look at, you know, all of these are changes that I approve of. So, the collector's box is listing here. So, previously, the big square collector's box I had there came with a few other factions, all the storage that had the dividers in it, not these, and it also included like some player powers like Cosmic Encounter style, as well as a few other little ones like traps and stuff. I have never used the trap cards. They're pointless, they're not really worth putting in. And honestly, because I'm usually teaching this game a lot, the Cosmic Encounter style like breaking game powers, they're fun, but they increase the complexity of the game to and sort of chaos of the game to a level that I don't want it to be. So, I never really use them much either. So, I didn't get a huge amount of value out of the collector's box other than just having a place to store it. Well, they're not doing that this time around.

This time, you basically get a box with, you know, some nice artwork and that. Um, oh, that's a prototype uh sleeve that I'll get rid of that. But, you basically get a So, it will tell you the basics of the game in one little rulebook or one elongated rulebook like this. And basically, it's just storage space. So, this isn't going to be like a oh, this comes with limited edition stuff or anything like that. This is purely just a storage option. And you're more than welcome to just simply have a few of these and stick them on your shelf. But, this now gives you another option for storing the game, and it stores quite a lot of cards. I mean, I don't think you're going to be able to store every card in the game if you were to sleeve it, so you may need a couple of these, but I don't think these are going to be too expensive. And again, you know, a couple of these should be able to fit on your shelf pretty easily.

And you can just basically grab one of these and take it to your club night because, well, you've only got to combine so many animal factions, so you can just take one and still have all the variety. But, yeah, they're neat. It's colorful. I like the stark background with all the paint splodge colors and that. You know, it's another beautiful-looking box.

You have my curiosity. Now you have my attention.

So, now to quickly talk about the solo mode. There's not a huge amount to explain on this one, but essentially each of the factions has a single card in it. It's called the mono card. Think of mono as basically like the capitalist of this particular like universe here, and it has a giant M on it for its logo and a unique effect. And basically there is one for each faction. You set the game up as if it was a two-player game. So, you're going to have three of these as well as the typical ones and like junk cards in their deck. And what happens with this, I'll just sort of showcase with the like comedian deck for example, you play the game as normal for yourself, but for the AI you basically list lay out their hand of five cards, and then they prioritize from left to right what card they're going to play, and they've basically got a flowchart that they follow near the back of the book. I'll just showcase it for ease.

So, essentially, yeah, that thing there. In layman's terms, it's basically saying, "Right, can it play its own mono card?" In which case it will do that and it will have a specific effect and it will also allow them to, you know, try and build stools and that. But, they're basically not playing animal folk cards for their abilities, they're just basically playing a card if it's got a plus symbol on it or playing the mono card if they can, and they will prioritize trying to build stools, but they won't always be able to do that. So, if they can't do that, they [clears throat] effectively try and acquire from the market deck until eventually they can. So, it's kind of like playing against a timer where you need to act fast in order to beat it to eight stools because it's going to be going at a fair pace. It is certainly not an easy AI to beat. I've certainly lost as many times as I've won this game. And it functions nicely, but there are a couple of little concerns I do have which I will, you know, feed back to the publisher.

Firstly, the game does have you doing a lot of the AI piloting. So, it's not that there's a ton of stuff to do in your turn, but if you imagine that right, I'm going to do this, which means I'm going to be using that card, and then that shuffles in there, and then these ones slide across, and then I need to lay out more. Okay, fine. We'll put those two out. And then let's say they use all their cards on a future turn. It's like, okay, right. So, these go to the discard pile. Oh, and then I need to 1 2 3, and let's say they're out of the game. All right, I need to reshuffle these. Hang on. Yeah, it's it it does have quite a lot of card laying out and shuffling for dealing with the AI's hand. Thankfully, it's not, you know, a lot that you have to pilot in order to resolve their turn, but yeah, there is a fair amount of card shuffling and laying out in order to do it. The other The other problem I do have is that I found the rules to be a little bit ambiguous with like what card it was meant to be taking, you know, what is it actually like what cards are they actually playing if it can't play a mono card and that. The rules weren't 100% crystal clear on how they worked. I mean, I eventually sort of grasped it and all right, it makes sense, but the rules as they're written currently are going to need a little bit of a rework, a little bit of a tweak, but this is already days, it's the prototype. We're going to give feedback, no doubt others are going to give feedback, and I will certainly be wanting to proofread solo rules because one thing that I have asked for in Dale of Merchants for a long time is a solo mode. So, to finally get one, I'm going to make sure it damn well works.

Hooray!

It's a work in progress with the solo mode, but it does work nicely. You get to just mix together three factions and have fun playing the game as you normally would up against the timer with an enemy faction who's basically going to be going a little bit faster than you at times, but also might have some abilities depending on the animal factions that mess around with you as well. So, it's just like, you know, it recreates a unique style of a two-player game without it being just identical to a two-player game. But, all well and good. I certainly look forward to seeing this develop.

This is why Superman works alone.

Now, I'm not going to spoil all the factions that you can possibly get. I mean, come on, we want to leave some excitement for you lot on the Kickstarter.

But I wanted no!

But in terms of the new ones, you've got the Cluttered Snow Monkeys, medium complexity, medium randomness, dealing with junk. So, they like to thrive in junk so much that they can generate it for themselves, but be careful cuz you might drown in junk with no one else to blame but yourself. Um another medium complexity, we have the Manic Blue-Tongue Skinks, uh end of turn effects. Some turns are the more cards, some turns are fewer, but many things are always going to occur at the end of your turn. Medium complexity, a little bit of interactivity, not much randomness. And then Playful Sunglass Frogs, the high complexity one of the set, repeating actions. In addition to playing cards from the hand, the glass frogs can play them from the discard as well. Experienced players see their cards jumping from place to place on the game area. So, you can see that there's, you know, a good amount of, yeah, variety with the factions in general, and that's just having six in a box.

Now, you've got 36.

You have a lot of factions now. This is going to get ridiculous. Of course, I don't know anything about the pricing that they're going to do with any of the sets, so hopefully we'll see this be reasonably priced, but it didn't cost a lot to buy these individual sets when you bought them from retail, so I would imagine that you'll pay a reasonable amount in order to get the whole lot as one big collection as well as some of these, and if you want play mats and any upgraded stuff, then fine. But honestly, this usually is probably going to be one of the more cost-effective Kickstarters I've ever imagined or Gamefound projects in this case. And obviously, don't take my word for that, you know, it could be different. I mean, it's been a while since these games were released on retail, but, you know, there's not a lot here apart from the six sets and the collector's box. What more do you need? This game is just a solid deck builder.

I've liked it a lot. I've always liked it. It's always been in my top 50, top 100 games. It's just a It's a beautiful, pleasant, charming deck builder. It almost feels like a palate cleanser. You can make this game complex if you want to put loads of high complexity factions together, great. But, personally, you just mix and match three or three to six I mean, it's three When I say three, it's three in a two-player game. It's more when you play with more players. It goes up to four players, 30 to 60 minutes, doesn't take more than an hour to play, and it's just a really solid one. I have sung the praises of this enough. You can go check out my previous reviews for the collector's set and if I've done one, the actual game itself. I can't remember if I have or not, but you know, you'll see a picture and a link if if I have. I'll make sure I find out. But, honestly, I'm very keen to see this come out in a new glossy second edition for, you know, I've been granted if you've got the first set, then whether you want to get this new set is really going to depend on whether you want the changes and the updates. You know, if you want those updates, if you want the new factions, then you're probably going to want to get in on this new set. I mean, you could just buy some of these boxes and that would do. But, you know, if you're new to the game, then definitely this is the set to jump in and it's a perfect way to do it. You know, it's a great game, one I've always enjoyed. If you want me to show it to you sometime, I'll try to, you know, that will be certainly welcome. And I look forward to seeing this with none of the sketches, all the artwork, all the stuff, and of course from our feedback when we do when we relay it back to the

publisher, any changes that we can do to make sure it's as good as it can be. So, yeah, I'm hopeful that this will do well.

Shut up and take my money.

So, that's it for me on this episode of the Broken Meeple. If you like what you see, then please thumb it up and leave some comments below. Do you love or hate the game? You interested in this, not interested in this? What are your favorite factions? Don't ask me to rank them or tell you my ones because I can't physically remember [clears throat] all 27 of them that were there before. But, if you've got any favorites that you know of, then by all means let us know. I'd be interested to hear your thoughts and why. Of course, I will put a link to the Game Found project in the description as well as any reviews I have done in the past. So, if you want more information on Dale of Merchants in general, hopefully that will give you all you need. But, feel free to ask a question in the comments if you want because I'm keen to see this one do well because I like it. You know, this is me when it comes to Gamefound and Kickstarter previews. I, you know, occasionally will take on a new game I've not played before. But, it's got to be something that takes my interest or it's got to be something that I already know is good so I don't have to feel like I'm just doing an advert. So, that's it for me. Take care and remember, it's only a game and I'll see you on the next Broken Meeple video. Bye for now.

Progress saved