Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is That Sheep Looking at me? - Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip

Transcript 4:01

So, final grade for Is That Sheep Looking at Me the Card Game? Do I Want It is a hard no. Like this looks like a very bare-bones random game. However, they give you the information you need. There's no rule booklet, but there's a 5-minute how to play. And so, yeah. Do I want it? No, I don't. And I think if you're a gamer, you're probably not there because the how much is it is just terrible. We cannot Like that is the biggest sticky wicket here. I gave it a 2/3 of a point grade bump down. It's a 54-card game. And yeah, you're going to add some cards with the expansion. Then you should mention, you know, that it's improved. And 35 for the coin thing, but then the $10 shipping is just terrible. You're bending your customers over over a barrel because it is dirt cheap to manufacture this game.

Just absolute dirt cheap. It is nothing but cardboard and cards. And hopefully, you at least getting the good cardstock. You're getting your customers 350 GSM plus. You're not just screwing them over with some garbage cardboard. Wouldn't surprise me though. So, do I want it? No. If you're a loyal fan of the show, I don't know. I I Maybe. Maybe. I feel like that price isn't great. But if you don't play a lot of games, I feel like it's fine. You want to support somebody. So, yeah. I'm going to go with meh. And then can you do it? Yeah, I'm not worried about that at all. You have $167,000 to manufacture a 54-card game. And yeah, maybe you're going to add six cards. Oh, it's a 60-card game in a small box with one cardboard insert. They're banking so hard on this.

Good for them. Good for them. But for everyone else, I I just don't feel it on this. A gameplay video, some quotes that actually are real, a rule booklet would have been nice. Um that shipping just feels abysmal. Just just for this game. And I the shipping combined with the price 2/3 of a point grade bump down. Um how much Yeah, final grade is not good. I think it's a uh I will say I feel like the 2/3 of a point grade bump down I took for the price away was it can be put right back on for bringing 2,000 people here. That is truly outstanding. Like we could go look at the most popular projects things that have made millions and millions of dollars and they are not bringing anywhere close to 2,000 new people to here. I imagine you could probably add all six of these up and they're not going to have 2,000 new people joining Kickstarter. That is just absolutely spectacular. Yeah, 11 for Ringyo which has a thousand. Kabuto Sumo much lighter game though so maybe that's a bit No.

Six. That's what I'm saying. 2,000 is incredible. So 2/3 of a point grade bump up there so it washes itself out. But for everything else just no. Just in no way shape or form was I as a gamer interested in this. Like it it At least give me a gameplay video. It's so simple. It's a 10 to 20 minute game. Why can't I have a gameplay video? Like I you have a 5 minute how to play video but it's like Final grade is a D C minus? I think it's a C minus. I think it's a C minus. Cuz at the end of the day if this game were reasonably priced you know, I don't know, 15 to $20 and that shipping were reasonably priced I feel like this would be a much easier sell for a lot of people cuz you do it's a cute little family fun card game. But as soon as you get to that price of $35 I feel like most people are like no I'm out.

So you just priced them out. So I'm going to go with a D-plus. Yeah. Yeah, D-plus.

Progress saved