Greatest Game Designer Fantasy Draft
Transcript
Gentlemen.
Yes, sir.
We are back for another draft. Indeed, we are.
This time we will be drafting a top 10 of the greatest designers of all time.
Yes.
So, we're going to be snake drafting. We'll be starting with Mike, then Nick, then me, then I'll get two picks, then Nick, then Mike, so on and so forth till we have a list of 10
10 each. So, how are we determining the greatest designers?
So, basically what we're going to be doing is we're going to make our list and then I'll we'll come back in another video to go over the results. And the results will be determined based on the top seven games of these designers because we couldn't decide between five and 10. And so like seven sounds like a nice round number. Um and essentially where those fall on BGG will determine who wins this draft
because the people generally think da da da is the best designer based off of like
this amount this being in the top 100 all this giver kind of stuff. And so yeah, we're basically draft not necessarily our favorite designers, but designers we think will be the highest on your cold hard evidence here. You know what I mean? The data doesn't lie.
That's right. It's interesting because this list like I'm fairly confident about the top like five or so, five to 10. And then the rest I'm just like
they have a couple good like couple highly ranked games, but I'm like for the rest I'm like gosh, I'm not even sure. So
we'll see.
Yeah, we'll see. All right, Mike, kick it off.
We shall see. So, uh, what is your guess for my number one?
Number one, I'm not going to say I'm not going to because if I say it, then you might pick it, right?
Maybe workshop this little
I have my guess. I'll tell you after you pick yours.
Okay. My number one pick, number one pick overall in the draft is going to have to be U Rosenberg. That's what I thought. Uh, Uve Rosenberg is famous for uh, you know, A Feast for Odin, uh, Patchwork, many, many other games as well. Uh I you know they I think have so many that are very highly rated. So I feel pretty good about that one at least to start off. Uber Rosenberg
uh maybe my favorite designer one of them certainly that's way up there. So I'm going also with personal personal preference here. But it also is a I think a strategically smart choice. I I think so. Yeah.
There's no way I was making it out of the first round.
Absolutely not.
Yeah. There's just just too many of the games that are that are big uh in there. Um, okay. So, now it's me. So, I would have picked Ube if Mike hadn't in for my second one.
I got a cheeky pick, but I don't think it's my first first pick. So, I'm just going to go Valicera.
The Talisera because things like Conbon,
you know, Conbon's in the top 100. On Mars is in the top 100. Venos used to be in the top 100. I don't think it is anymore, but like a lot of these big old games, Liz Bo, I think, is in the top 100, I'm pretty sure.
So, like a lot of stuff is in in there. I probably would have picked U over
probably three of their sevens in the top 100. That bodess well.
Yeah, that's a good pick.
That's my guess. If you tell us Sarah, big games, very BGG type games.
Fair, fair, fair.
So, my initial my first pick was going to be Uve,
which basically would required me to go first in the draft, but the only way I was going to get
first pick, so I was like, I should probably take it. Yeah, there's no way Ube was going two there.
You're gonna get two picks in a row here.
I am gonna get two picks in a row. And uh with my first pick, I'm gonna go with my heart. I'm gonna pick Simone Luchiani.
I think we'll got Voyage of Marco Polo, Grand Hotel Rotel, Zulken. He's got quite a few games in I think barrage is in the top 100. I think is also um almost always a co-designer with someone. And I'm not saying that they don't deserve the credit for their thing, but it also helps because
they get they got a lot. Yeah, they get to put
grant we're just doing the top seven, but I'm sure he's got at least seven in the top like 500.
There's definitely some where I'm like, "Oh, this person is also on a lot of games." And so
like if not in the top 100 has got to be in the top.
He's in the top 100. Yeah. I was honestly forget he's
was going to be my next pick and also we are big Luchiani fans in this house. So
well done. All right, so that's your uh first overall pick, Jimmy. What was your second?
So for my second pick, do we go with my I feel like I feel like this person will hang around. So I feel like I want to go with somebody who is more likely to get grabbed.
It's fair because it's going to be a little bit for you, right? So
yeah, I'm going to go with Stefan Feld for my second pick.
Sure.
You know, here's the thing. when I was writing out my list cuz I was basically just writing out popular designers that I know and I was like I know I'm missing a big one. Forgot to write them on a list. Not going to lie, forgot to be forgot to write on the list.
Stephan Feld's a great pick. Yeah, Castles of Burgundy. Uh uh American
outside of Castle of Burgundy, I don't think he has that as many high games as we think.
He's got a lot of pretty prolific. I have a lot of games that are in the top 500
for my number two.
Cheeky. Okay, let me let me
Okay, I'm curious what you got.
I'm picking Rob Davio.
Okay,
Rob Davio.
He's got he's got a few in the top 100. He's got Panda.
Basically, every single legacy game is Rob Davio. I believe two of them are still in the top 100, but also Cthulhu Die is in the top 100. Yeah,
there's a whole bunch basically all of
Restoration Games most popular games, many of them have Rob Davio on the as a co-designer. So, it's like he lowkey has done some of the biggest games out there. And I just I feel like he's going to be a lot higher than we think. I don't know if he's right for number two,
but I was like, you know what? I'm going to pick him high just in case. I I Big Rob
pick.
Love that guy.
He was He was right after Stephen Feld on my list. He was in my top 10 picks.
Sure. Yeah, because I was just like I feel like he's gonna be he's got a lot of big games.
I agree.
Yeah.
Uh all right, on that note,
I get two picks in a row here.
You do.
Uh on the other half of the pandemic legacy and pandemic in general, I'm going to go Matt Lee.
Yeah.
Yeah.
The designer of all the pandemic games, um uh or the the originator of the pandemic
right after Davio on my list.
Um the pandemic legacy games and stuff are highly rated. The pandemic games in general are quite highly rated. Uh, so I'm gonna go Matt Le.
Yeah, I think it's fair.
King of the Co-op.
Yeah.
Plus, Fate of the Fellowship is if it's not in the top 100 or it's close to close. Yeah, it's like
they also have like Forbidden Desert and stuff with that, which is a massively popular game. I don't think it's like the top 200, 300.
My next pick I think lowkey maybe should have been number one.
Alexander Fister.
All Western Trails, baby.
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. I don't know how how many I guess are all of those in the top.
At least two of them are in the top.
At least two of them.
Yeah. So, uh yeah, the Great Western Trail series. Um
like Marbo. There's a ton. He lowkey might be the best.
Fister is is a goat. Yeah,
sister is goated
for sure.
It's true.
Uh okay, who did I write down?
So, man, I am stuck now.
Yeah, Fister. Fister was probably my next choice.
Fister. Fister. Alexander Fa never knew how much I missed you.
Man, I'm really stuck here.
I'm God.
It's so hard.
It's tough.
These middle ones get tough cuz you're like, I got a sneaky one.
Well, there's so many am I being like there's like six or seven people looking like any of those could be like the next one really. And I'm like, gosh, that's tough.
I think I'm going to go with
I'll go with Danielle Tashini.
Yeah, good pick. I don't know if that's the right decision. That's like Zulken. I mean, Teayot Wakan,
Jam Marco Polo. Yeah, he's got some overlap with Luchani.
So many of the tea games are Danielle Tashini. Um
I think of the two of them though, I think Luchiani has the
I think the higher
higher ranked.
I would have picked Luchi over Daniel.
Yeah, I think Luchian is a little more prolific.
Sure.
Toshini does more solo designs and I think that means there's a few fewer things although pretty prolific as well. So
yeah, man. And Tashini's uh not a bad pick.
So this is I guess I'll get this out of the way just cuz the fear like I don't think you're going to grab it. So like but I'm going to do it just to take it off the table. And this is my sneaky pick.
You're going to make me mad right now. I can tell
this is Cory Kisca.
He was going to be high for me.
Yeah, he's Twilight Imperium, Star Wars Rebellion, Imperial, Battle Star Galactica, Eldrich Horror. He's basically the FFG like internal designer for like 10 years names on a bunch of
uh designs. No, I I Cory Kitko was going to be very high for me. So I I don't Yeah.
Yeah. Cuz for for all the Twilight Imperium games and then like Star Wars Rebellion alone is like that's a decent amount of high stuff right there. So like
I feel like he's going to be like sneakily one of the highest
designers just at Well, that's what I thought about Rob Davio where I was just like I feel like no one really thinks of him that much in terms of like because he doesn't do a lot of solo designs, but I'm like so many of these massive games he's a part of and I'm like yeah.
Yeah. Like for FFG games I feel like
people just think of them being designed by FFG so they don't associate them so Fantasy Flight. Yeah. Which I think back in the day in, you know, particular it's just like oh it was designed by Fantasy Flight Games was essentially saying it was designed by Curry. So,
so, uh, my next pick,
yeah,
I don't know the I feel like I'd feel more confident about this pick if I if we were doing top five, but I'm going to I'm still going to roll the dice to top seven. We'll see how how it goes. I'm going to pick Paul Denon.
Uh, because he's got the Dune Imperium Games. They're both in the top 100. He's got Clank Legacy, Clank. Um, so there's a lot of
I think Clank and Acquisition Incorporated is also in the top 100. Yeah, that's lowkey. He got him think about I He did right now. I didn't even think about him. Most because I dislike Doom so much.
Sure.
So I don't think about him.
I don't think I heard him.
Yeah. And then Clanken Space I'm sure is. So yeah, he's he's there's a lot of
Yeah.
two games repeats.
That's a low
and then probably like his six or seven would probably be like Wild West and I'm not.
So he might the risk with him is he might be someone where he's like getting whatever.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I'm sure he has a a seventh game. I just don't know what it is.
But it might be ranked very very low. Right. That's interesting. A good call. Yeah. I didn't even think about what that was.
It's probably Lightning Train is probably his
Lightning Train was pro. Yeah. If it's Direwolf, probably.
Direwolf Daddy. Yeah.
Um, okay. I'm gonna go with just because you know what? I got the number one game of all time. I think I'm going to go Martin Wallace.
Yeah.
Wow.
Martin Wallace has hurt your heart.
Yeah. It hurts my heart to do this. Not really. Um,
yeah. Brass, Age of Steam, Railways of the World. He does a lot of training.
Ano 1800.
Australia.
Yeah. There's a whole bunch. I don't know how much how well I feel about that, but we'll see.
Well, again, you at least know one of the things is quite low indeed. So, that's good.
Yeah. You know,
that's true.
Um, okay. So, my numbers fourth fourth and fifth picks here.
Are you going to pick the one that would have hurt your heart or no?
Yeah. Did he pick your one that was gonna hurt?
He did. Based on his response, I did not pick.
That's my guess. Yeah.
All right. Rock with me here. Now,
if you do pick it, you got to let me know what the if it was the hurt your heart pick. Okay, I'm going Shim Phillips.
I almost did it.
I mean, I got Shim Phillips.
I almost did it.
Multiple games in the top 100.
Yeah,
at least
and have more. I don't know. I think he might only have one in the top 100 now, but he had Phillips, you know, Raiders of the North Sea, the the Shem Phillips of Garfield games. Uh, Raiders of the North Sea, uh, the West Kingdom trilogy, the South Tigris trilogy, the ancient anthology series.
The only ones in the top hundreds is Paladins. For a while, Paladins, Vic Counts, and Architects were all They're all going to be really close. I think
I wouldn't be surprised if SHM has seven games in the top 250.
Yeah.
Or so.
Yeah. I I
So thought about him, but I was like, "Ah, let me wait a little longer before."
That's what I thought you were going to steal from.
Sure. Got it. That makes sense.
And And I have the rights to Shem Phillips. I have the rights.
Yeah.
Okay. It's mine. Um, I know there's some people in the chat right now who are mad about certain names not having appeared, but we're out here playing data. All right, data driven. And with that said, should I make this my number five?
I don't think so.
Let's go Cania. Let's go Cania.
Bad choice.
Ryan or Kitia?
Real bad choice. either have a single game or the top 100.
I agree.
Quest for Elderorado.
Quest for El Dorado.
Lost City. Lost Cities. Lost Cities games.
They've made so many classics that
if it was like top 20 games. Yeah.
Oh yeah, for sure. Boy. Yeah. Yeah.
I probably would have picked him. I just would have picked him later in the list. For sure. I just didn't want it to go away because I think he's going to be peppered throughout the top three 400
and we'll overall have a solid score. Even though there's nothing that's a top 50 all time game,
I just feel like it's a safe bet.
It's fair. So, I just wanted to get it
because I know people are like, "Hey, Kenitia." It's because, hey, man, we're trying to win. That's why
we're trying to win.
But Kenitzia is on my board. What?
What? I got a solid top five right here. This is
It's a good top five.
That's pretty good.
All right. Pretty good. So, back to me.
Back to you, Nick. Fifth pick.
Man, I don't know. There's so many. Like, do they have enough? I I'm stuck between like three. It's funny because there are certain designers who were like I would say humongous like five years ago and before.
I feel like I know exactly who you're thinking of just based on that problem.
You know what I mean?
I think so.
And but I don't know. There's multiple people in my opinion in that that bucket
that haven't had the the
but they have huge games.
Sure. Sure.
Those games don't just drop off the face of the earth.
Oh man, this is probably a bad decision. I'm going to go Antoine Baoza.
Antoine Bowser was on my list just for the Seven Wonders name. So he was on there.
Yeah, Antoine Baoza
again has I'm sure they've done stuff recently, but like the Seven Wonders are all such humongous games. They had like 10 years ago they were like on top of the
Seven Wonders D
when we came into the hobby they were definitely one of the biggest.
Duel for Middle Earth are both in the top 100.
That's what I'm saying, right? So like I know these and Seven Wonders, Seven Wonders Architect, all those are going to be up there. And he does other games as well, but like
those alone I'm like I just feel like that's should be on there. Maybe not quite this high, but definitely I think should be on there. I think it's a fair pick.
Yeah.
In honor of that pick, I will take Bruno Cathala. Yeah, that was
like cuz I feel like he's on all the the the games that Bowsa has the most popularity recently with Seven Wars Duel. He's on Splender Duel. All the dual games basically. He's on Five Tribes.
He's a good He's
He's on Sea Salt and Paper, which like also did quite well.
Then also like Five Tribes is highly rated and stuff like that. I That's what the two would have been. Maybe on my next go around I would have had Bruno on there.
Um I took him now because I was like, well, he just said it. Um, I guess
it's trying to think of like the seven number is interesting because there are definitely picks where I would feel more confident about it whenever it's five cuz like I can think of five games that feel like they're ranked quite highly.
Um, and they're a little bit riskier.
Um, yeah, I'll do it. I'm gonna take David Tersy for my
Yeah, that's gonna be my next When I was doing Danielle Tashini, I like maybe I should just do Turti instead.
Yeah. So, he's done an ACRI, he did Nucleium, he did uh Imper the Imperium games,
a bunch of the tea games. I mean, and also a big co-designer a lot of times. So, like
solo modes for a lot of games. So, depending on how cheap you want to be.
I don't think that would I wouldn't I don't know how I guess it depends on how it's counted on BG of
Sure.
but So that would
see. Yeah, David Ters is a solid pick. They have their fingers in everything.
Yeah,
I haven't played a ton of his games and his solos modes are too much for me. But yes, yeah, I feel like he is
weard. I like he would probably been my next pick or very close. My next pick is me again.
Y
man,
I'm going to go with the brands.
Oh,
Marcus and Inca Brand have a lot of a lot of bigger games. They're not the splashes, but like things like Village Rajis. They've done all the exit games. They've been around for a while. They're fairly prolific. Um,
and yeah, marketing a brand. They're a husband wife
duo. Um,
and I'll say also first female on the list. Uh, let's get more
representation in designers. This is something I was going to bring up at the end of the video that one thing you are going to see this is not enough women designers
or non-binary or anyone we need to fix that.
The top pick you could do is Elizabeth Hargrave
and like may maybe she has seven games.
Well, sure I think she has seven games but like it's
the top the top is high because like Wingspan and stuff and I think Wingspan age is also in the top 100. I might choose a little bit harder later honestly. But uh yeah, it's there's hey if you want to design games anybody out there if you want to design games do it. We need everyone.
I can't remember what her name is but like there was a woman who was designing maybe 80s 90s who did like set and like a couple other of those like big like mass market games.
Yeah.
But because they're mass market her name I feel like she should be more famous.
Right. Yeah.
She had like three or four bangers.
Yeah. Huge.
Um okay. Okay. So, my sixth and seventh picks, I feel fairly confident about these two for especially for where we are. Number six, you're talking about designers that really seem to dominate yester year a little bit. I'm going Vlada Chelato.
Yeah, I thought about it.
Through the ages, code names,
Mage Knight,
Mage Knight, uh some all the CG games up until like verified certified bangers. Yeah.
Um,
yeah, Vlad's a good choice.
So, Vlada, you know, I think is a good pick.
Galaxy Trucker.
Galaxy. Yeah, man.
Every CG game really. Yeah.
Really dominated, you know, uh, a while back there. Um, next one is I'm kind of between two here for this wing. I'm going to go Vladimir Suki. Yeah, I've been I've been putting off Vladimir for a while and I like
289 underwater cities last will.
Yeah, I mean lots of stuff. I don't know how highly rated those all are.
I feel like he's got a lot in like the 200.
I think they're going to be I I think um Underwater Cities is probably in the top 200 for sure. Uh and I think they're going to be all around there. So like it's just a middle of the road like solid. I mean you have several games in the top two 300. It's you're a very good designer obviously somebody who can get to seven without hurting you with any
Y. So I'm going Vlada and Vladimir going the V's detail.
Fair. That's my six and seven.
Okay. I think one because they're very often a co-designer but they have their own stuff as well. They've been very very big. I'm going to go with Michael Keesling.
Oh wow.
Cuz Kramer and Keiesling, Wolf Gray Kramer make a lot of games. But then Michael Keing made like Azul. Azul is enormous. There's a whole bunch of different kinds of Azul. I think Michael Keesling also did things like this won't be on on his
top. Yeah, Heaven and Ale, um, Miyabi, there's a he's done a ton. And then all the other stuff with Wolf Gang Kramer, like Cole Baron, all kind of stuff. Kramer and Keesling is a very common design duo, but then there's enough on his own that I'm like I feel like Azul alone is kind of like a
I'd say Keesling's a legendary designer. I think you'd be safe in saying.
So, let's go Michael Keesling. Jimmy seven and eight. Jimmy
trying to think of has this person done seven design.
Let's see if I can name. Get ready gamers. The Omaha Gaming Convention is where games bring people together. Whether you are brand new to board gaming or a longtime hobbyist, OGC is your place to experience the joy of tabletop gaming. We're committed to creating a safe, welcoming space for individuals and families from all walks of life to come together and make lasting memories. So join us July 10th to the 12th. For more information, visit omahagamingcon.com.
So, that was a quick little ad spot made by Grant from Our Family Plays Games, who are putting on the Omaha Gaming Convention. The Omaha Gaming Convention is, of course, in Omaha from July 10th through 12th, and again, it's put on by our Family Plays Games and the Board Game Wagon. It's a really great gaming focused convention that is incredibly welcoming to both newcomers and seasoned gamers. The convention is fun, inclusive, and just lovely. Make sure to check it out again in Omaha July 10th through the 12th. Make sure to check it out down in the description below. H
there's probably there's got to be one. Uh yes. All right. I will take with my seventh pick. I'm going to take Cole Whirly.
As you start counting stuff, I was like, you're going Coleworthy. Yeah, cuz he's got Roots, Arcs, Oath, John Company, and then I was like, "Okay, there's Molly House, then there's like the pack game, and I'm like, "Yep, we got there.
We got there."
Between uh, you know, Leader Games before they broke off recently and and Worly Gay Games. Yeah,
there's a good amount of uh titles there. Root being very well loved, PAX Premiere is very highly rated as well.
Yeah, I feel like I don't know how many of those are in the top 100. I'm sure Root is. Uh, I think probably is is or close. And then Oath is probably in the like 10020 range, I would guess.
Um, yeah.
And then his other I feel like he's got seven under thousand would be my guess, but I don't know for sure. And then I guess for my uh let's see, put that in there. Uh, for my eighth pick,
yep,
I am going to take the person who I thought everybody was going to take every time they kept talking about like this person was really big five 10 years ago, whatever, and like they worked on a lot of stuff. I don't know how high it is. Uh, and I'm going to take Eric Lang.
Oh, yeah. I've always taken Eric Lang because he's like got Rising Sun, he's got Cthulhu, Death May Die, he's got Blood Rage, he's got Marvel United, he's got a bunch of stuff,
especially because when he was at Sean, he was just put on every single box. It seems like I
whether or not how much he did on those games, I don't entirely know, but they definitely put him like Dice Masters. I mean, he was just on every single game for a while. He was like the team, you know, where just he was in every song for a while, you know, and Lil John was the same way, you know,
but yeah, he's like he's a guy who I feel pretty confident like
he's got seven games that are probably under 500.
Yeah. I almost took in the last number like five through seven. I've almost taken Eric Lang every single time that I'm like ah no. when you were talking about people five cuz when you 5 10 years ago were you thinking about him or were you just
him as well but like when I was talking about like Rob when I draft like Antoine Baoza and the brands and Michael Keing each time I kept being like should I take Eric Lang now and then I end up taking something else but should I take Eric because I think the same thing where it's like he's probably low-key we all probably should have taken him higher.
Sure.
Um I'm
glad to get him in number eight. Yeah.
Thanks Eric. This feels like feels like a good deal for you there.
Okay. I was gonna take Eric Lang next. I'm going to take kind of the same way of like Corey Kitka, like Fantasy Flight person who's around a lot. I'm going to take Nikki Valins.
Nikki Valins did like Eldidge Horror, Arkham Horror, a bunch of uh Fantasy Flight stuff. Um I believe Nikki Valins also did like C not Crossroads, um Dead of Winter, I think is Nikki Valins. Like I I if I remember correctly and so like Nikki was on a lot of stuff. Uh she was really all over the place. Again, I don't know how much stuff they Quirky Circuits is Nikki Valins. a lot of stuff that she's done and she was also again in that kind of fantasy fight pipeline where she was in a lot of those big da da da horror games.
Sure.
So I think Arkham War the car game might also be Nikki Valins and so like um I'm going to take Nikki Valance. I don't know if that's the best choice in terms of like the top games but
I feel like that would probably
on a ton of a safe like 10 pick because in that way that like those covert like
Fantasy Flight games like hidden in a list of like five other designers.
Yep. That is an interesting pick, my man. Well done. Uh, I'm going to go since I have the eighth and ninth pick, I'm going to go with a couple of iterative
designers,
and that's the only reason I'm adapting them.
Got to have the literation.
I'm going to hit it with some Freedom and Freeze.
Yeah,
because again, Power Grid, all those famed green games. Freedom Freeze.
I thought with that, I feel like it's Power Grid. And then what's his next highest ranked game?
Maybe Biome. I don't know. I feel like the next one's down like the hundreds and hundreds after.
So, Freeman Freeze is definitely a bad choice, honestly. There's um a high amount of, you know, high uh high output.
Um and Power Grid being, you know, the highest rated and stuff like that. But I think, you know, they have a good strong solid body.
My other illiterative uh designer is going to be Wolf Gang Worsh.
Oh god. Quacks have quit down Wolf Gang
War. That's good.
Um,
yeah.
Yeah, low key because again, he came out like two or three games a year. They were all like huge hits.
Yeah,
that's interesting.
Gangs had some uh some big time bangers. So,
that's pretty clever.
That's going to be my pick.
Interesting. All the
So clever.
Two more, huh?
Heavens of teeth, though.
Yep. I I bet you're wishing that when they came out with Quax that they counted that as a second game rather than bundling it all into the same edition.
Quack.
I'm sure there will be people who are like, "Don't count two editions." Uh, and we'll see.
We'll see. It depends. We'll see what happens. We'll see.
She was like, "How much is fancy pick?"
She's like, "But Alexander Fiser, I was just like, the double editions are definitely useful."
They are,
man. Two more, huh?
Two more.
There's so many that could be on here. Yeah, you got Shottle on there, too. So, it's like through the ages, through the second edition,
depending on how we decide, you would benefit the most, probably.
Yeah,
because some of my favorite designers are still on here, and I'm just like, I don't think they're going to be have that many high ones, but you know, who's got a decent amount of high ones? Is that enough?
That's I'm gonna go with Ryan Lockett.
Yeah,
cuz like Sleeping Gods, if I remember correctly, is the top 100. Above Below, I think, is pretty highly rated and stuff. I don't
got seven games
for sure. Yeah. Yeah. Cuz like Near and Far, uh,
Bound, there's a whole bunch.
Creature Caravan.
Creature Caravan.
There's also smaller ones that he's made. Some of that. I don't know if that's best choice, but I just kept being like, well, Ste God's in the top 100. People really like that game. So,
yeah.
It's hard to get those here. You're like, it could any of these could be it. Like, there might be ones like, oh, that's way higher than I thought. Or maybe they're a co-designer on more things than I remember, yada yada yada. Right. So, it's like
giving me nine 10. My last two pins.
Oh my gosh.
Bring it home.
What do I do?
I mean, maybe it's it feels like a continuation of this just sort of like feels like the Fantasy Flight draft. Uh because I have another pick. Well, actually, I have like two possib uh uh
memory
memory of Fantasy Flight stuff. I didn't write any of those people down. I should have.
That's that's the loophole. Um, like Nicki M was one of the first people I thought of because I was like, "Oh, Nikki's on a bunch of big older games."
Yeah, same with me and Cory Kiska because I'm like, "Oh, there's a ton of stuff that he's on." Um, yeah, I think I'll probably take this one then.
Uh, I'm going to take Nate French, who is a designer on Arkham Horror LCG, Marvel Champions, Lord of the Rings LCG, and a few other fantasy
fight. Yeah. Who's my next pick?
Nate French.
Nate French.
Yeah. I was not gonna pick Nate French Jimmy,
but yeah, he's he's often the guy that they have I feel like for like starting stuff because he was on like the first wave of Marvel Champions and helped design the base game and then they kind
But I think all those games are very highly rated, right? So you're like that could be like four or five games.
I think Arkham and Marvel Champions are 50.
Yeah.
So it's like that's a huge bump.
Fury's probably worked on other Yeah. big fantasy
and there's going to be low-key like a designer that all of us miss that's like super high up because they're just on a bunch of stuff that we didn't realize that was that high or whatever. It's like there's going to be
and then for my last pick has he done I mean yes he has done seven games. How many of them is an interesting thing because there are certain designers who and I feel like these are the people we got early on who did a bunch of different games that are successful.
Right. Sure.
And then there's some people who are like
in a Matt Leot kind of way where I got a I got a thing that I designed and I'm going to iterate on it and these iterations will be successful because people like the base game.
But yes, I'm going to do this mostly
and I guess yeah, since I'm
I'm No one can steal from me. I guess I can just talk through my thought process here.
Do you?
So, but then I you guys are going to pick.
That's true. I think I know what my next pick is. I've got a couple I'm pretty set on for my
I'm picking kind of a a wild my last
I don't know where because I feel like this person probably only has maybe has one game in the top 100, one game in the top 100 to 200 and then probably like a couple other games in the top 500 and then it starts to get further out. So maybe this is the move and just to to double down again on Fantasy Flight Games uh and go with Yeah, I'm going to do it. Sorry audience. It's not the most exciting thing, but I'm going with Christian Peterson the founder of Fantasy Flight Games who created uh Twilight Imperium, Game of Thrones, Star Wars Armati worked on Lord of the Rings the confrontation also.
Um
yeah,
nice. It's just brought to you by
We're not big uh we're not big uh Fantasy Flight.
We don't play, but somehow this is
Yeah. Well, again, they had a collective of people who did a lot of their stuff. Some like Restoration, it's like there's like 20 people listed because like they kind of or like Chip Theory, they just say like designed by Chip Theory Games now because it's like they designed it as a whole company. So, it's like they're just like there's no point in us putting designed by this person on there. There's just no no need for it. Man, I had a I had a choice and then now I started thinking about it harder and I'm like so I'll tell you right now because if Mike takes it I was gonna choose Hisashi Hayashi.
Mhm.
Cuz Hayashi did like Bomb Busters just one of Spiels but has done a bunch of a bunch of games that you forget was theirs and like has a lot of like smaller games. Yokohama a lot of big games.
Interesting.
But you know what I think I'm gonna do?
Um I'm gonna choose sorry if I pronounce this wrong. uh Helgay Oscar tag.
They did
Gaia Project,
Gaia Project, Ter Terrammystica, Age Innovation, all three in the top 100.
Now question is have they done seven games?
Probably.
But those swamp so
I'm sure they've done seven.
So my thing is like those three are big games.
Yeah. you were very highly rated
and so I think I might go Helgate Oscar tag over Hashi Hayashi who was gonna be my
think I think that's a wise decision.
Yeah, I think Hashi is not going to have quite as many high ones as I think but Hashi Hashi makes great games.
Yeah, I don't know if they have any in the top 100.
Is Yokohama not in the top 100 anymore?
Maybe
it was. That would be the one if it was.
But then like Bomb Busters I think is near the top 100. a couple other things. I was like, God, I was like, is I just got enough now where maybe they might pop in, but I was like looking at Hely Oscar Tag and I was just like, we were going to play Guy Project the other day and I was just like thinking of that. We just played Famous Swamp and I was just like,
wow, Age Innovation's in the top 100. Terara miss in the top 100. Guy project top 100. I'm like, maybe I should do that.
That's a a good get a 10.
That's more than Ryan Lockett who was my last choice. So, I'm like, well, I think I probably should choose this one.
So, my 10th pick, huh?
Yeah. We're going to talk after this. We're going to talk about some people who did not want to talk about like some wild cards that you think could have scored quite
well. Three, four, five, six, seven, eight still on my list.
So, yeah,
Nick's been the person picking stuff that wasn't on my list.
Yeah, baby.
Yeah,
you've gone rogue like probably three or four times.
I almost went more rogue.
I'm between like two or three people. I'm not trying
for my 10th pick.
Talk it out. I can't take it. Okay, so who I'm between is John Declair,
who's got some like solid stuff.
Yeah, I don't know if they're high enough. Praise be Phil Walker Harding. I don't think they're high enough. Same thing.
Yeah, that's a thing. But I think for my 10th pick, I'm going to go Jamie Stegmire.
Yeah.
Oh gosh, I forgot to write him down.
I had them on my list, but I was like I was trying to rack my brain if it was like how high outside of like Scythe vidic culture.
I think there's going to be a drop off, but I think still a known and well and well like brand tapestry is going to be up there like between two cities. What's his what's his underground game? I don't think he did. He didn't design between
um who's the His first game was
Euphoria.
Euphoria. Yeah, Euphoria. Vidic Culture.
Uh
has he done
Scythe?
I think so. Okay.
He did explore. He did Advantage. He did uh what's the game called? The one that's like a Scythe universe.
Oh, Expedition. Expeditions.
Yeah.
Um
Red Rising. Red Rising. Red Rising. Yep. So definitely over Phil Garard and John Declare who I love dearly.
I definitely thought about Jamie Stegmire, but it was that question of like I was like, can I get to seven? Am I going to get dinged?
Yeah. For someone like Johnny Declar, I thought I'm like again John makes games that sell very well, but they're not rated super super super high other than like I think Space Base is the highest rated and Phil Harding like I love Phil Harding, but none of his games other than probably Baron Park are rated high really at all. I don't think
I'd be surprised if there's not a bunch in the top like 500. I don't think 500 would be. I don't think it'd be enough to make it.
Should be praise big.
Okay. Tell me a why.
Okay. Well, first of all, real quick,
go through your list real quick. So, go give me give me your one through 10. I'll give my you'll do one or 10 and then we'll talk about the wild card.
My one through 10. U Rosenberg. Yeah. Get goated.
Uh Matt Leok, Alexander Fister, get goated. Shem Phillips, Reiner Canitzia, Vlad Chavat, Vladimir Suki, Freriedman Freeze, Wolf Gang Wars, and Jamie Stegmire. freaking I mean if we're looking at totality of roster
I mean I think
get wrecked boys.
I think your list is definitely like in the minds of people who are going to be like what are 10 of the top designers like off the dome like that would be a lot of them.
I definitely picked ones I think were sneakier and uh probably I think are I'm probably not going to do as well as you do but I picked Fala Serna who I'm very confident of. Rob Davio which I do think is a good choice.
I think that maybe might end up being your best pick. We'll see. Robio.
Yeah, Bob Davio I think is like sneaky best pick where you're like oo good point you know
Danielle Tashini, Martin Wallace, Antoine Baoza, Marcus and Inca Brand who are always designed together. So um Michael Keling, Nikki Valins, Ryan Lockett and Helag.
Okay, mine are
solid list.
Simone Luchiani, Stephan Feld, Cory Kanesca, Paul Denin, Bruno Cthala, David Tersy, Cole Worley, Eric Lang, Nate French, and Christian Peterson.
Interesting. Interesting.
Okay. So, what are some wild cards where you're like
they're gonna low-key have a solid score?
I almost put Sam McDonald because him and Shem,
Yep. They're like,
SJ McDonald, they they co-design a lot. A lot of those games are very highly rated. So, I was like, I'm I'm going to put both of my list here because
they're probably pretty similarly rated. Shem does more solo stuff than Sam does,
but they often, you know, all of the
But I was like, that's a low key a sneaky.
Here's who's still on my list that did not get picked. Uh, the next one I had was Tom Leman,
for the Galaxy, Resana, Roll for the Galaxy. I thought about it and I was like, because those three I think are pretty high, but then I think it probably like fall like when you go off the off the, you know, the drop like how far is that drop?
Yeah, I think he's probably still got a few
late on my list was like Donald Xarinos who's had like
sure
Dominion, Kingdom Builder, now Moon calling, Bloodbath, but kind of nothing else. And so I'm just like, h no, that's not going to be enough.
I had Ignasi Jack Robinson Cruso Bureau Settlers 51 for State Alan Rar Moon all the Ticket to Rides Europe
um and I guess technically Ticket to Ride Legacy I'm sure he's listed as a Der on that.
I'm sure one I didn't say because I'm like I don't know if there's seven games and if there are they're going to be quite low but the two tops the three tops are really high is Isaac Childdress.
Yeah, Gloom Haven. I don't think he has something and then Jaws of the Lion by Speaking of Nikki Valins also was a designer on like Buttons and Bugs which also one of the reason I was I'm going to pick Nikki on here. Yeah, continue. Yeah. Yeah. One I'm like I don't know how far that drop's going to be. Uh, one that I think is lowkey, really solid is Yamahawk. And like I have Yamahawk on here too. They design a lot of things together. They do like Dragon Castle.
Photosynthesis is Yamaha.
Photosynthesis, Evergreen, The Great Split. Like there's a great
Yamahawk.
Yeah, they've done a lot of games.
Put Yamahawk on here cuz I was like Yamahawk might be a lowkey a sneaky sneaky choice.
Yeah. So that's that's one that was gonna be my little
I had Ted Albach on mine just because like Suburbia, Castle, Bugwig, all the the um vamp not vampire werewolf games are on the Wolf Gang Kramer. One of us probably should have chosen just because
probably
Wolf Gang Kramer probably should Well, not to mention there's tons of Wolf Gang Kramer games like Downforce that are just like just his. So like one of us probably should have chose Wolf Gang Kramer. Uh, I had Nick Little who did Aon's End, uh, Terraforming Mars Aries Expedition, Luke Lori. Luke Lori was on my short list.
Dwellings of Eldervil, Andromeda's Edge, Manhattan, Energy Empire, lots of work.
Hit it with some Nigel Buckle, uh, who's done all of the Imperium games and stuff with David Turt.
I'm sure Nigel's done more outside of stuff with David Turtzy. David Turtzy does more stuff on his own or with other people. We we mentioned her earlier but Elizabeth Hargrave that was one that was tough because it's like wingspan so highly related but then the next one's probably the fox experiment it's probably her top rated Mariposas maybe
Mariposas tussy mussy but it was one of the things where like the highs on this one are really really high but there isn't one that's quite as highly um uh rated as that.
I also had Scott Alms who did all the tiny games and bread
one of the most prolific designers for sure. Uh I have Adam Kapinsky uh did the Nemesis games and other things.
A lot of stuff for Boring too.
This I don't know if they've done
one of you take Phil Walker Harding. You just considered
Phil considered Phil Walker Harding.
Um one that I think soon will probably have enough credit. They might have more games than we're aware of is Thomas Hol did like SETI. Yeah.
Tea Gardens. Um and they're they're up and coming. It's like a couple years from now it's like oh that might be a really
Danny Garcia I could see also
Danny Garcia I thought about doing to Danny Garcia. Yeah. Tell I thought I was like g give a couple more years and cuz like high high and the rest aren't nearly as high but I'm like give a couple years I think you're going to be right about that.
Yeah. Matthew Dunston does a lot of stuff. Um, Fabio Lipiano. There's a whole bunch of Duty that I thought
maybe you'd pick just because of your love of one of their games. And this is the last person on my list, which was Xavier George who did Gopoulos and Nick's favorite game to
uh, and I hate that game.
Yeah. I mean, there's there's so many more people we could have named this stuff. So, what we want to know is just off vibes because we don't have the reaction show just yet where we get the actual answers. Who do you feel like has like a
Who do you feel like won all of this? Right. I feel like I did not.
We had one person uh one of our one of our patrons uh basically picked draft picks in the middle as if they were one of the four of us and then told us what it was and that was pretty fun to see.
Very cool. Draft. You want to watch the video again? Insert your
I lowkey think Mikey might have won this one. I do.
I probably won. But then again, we also thought Mike won the last one. Go check out the last draft where we did best games of I won and maybe he did win.
Mike argued until I didn't.
Yeah, Mike arguably picked the best because he picked like the highest games, but then he had a couple real bad picks and that really tanked him.
That's how it goes.
But yeah,
which I feel like that there's definitely
like a mind sweeper like bomb in the mix that we don't realize now that we will realize later where there's just like actually this person.
That's kind of fun about this is that we don't have the answers yet. So, we'll come back later. Uh we'll try to put a card in or certainly in the description of this video a link to the reaction video once it's out. It won't be out for uh you know
the results show
results show. But that is also really fun because it's it's really cool. Like we don't look into all the data and stuff before we do this. We we're going off vibes. So it's fun to see like where you were right and where you were certainly very wrong. So that is our picks uh fantasy draft style for the best all-time game designers. Put your favorite game designers in the comments below. Stay tuned for the results show. Consider being a patron. Get some merch on your body. There should be images.
If you want to know when that comes out, subscribe and then
Yeah.
Get a notification that little bell icon.
Turn that bell on because YouTube be not showing our stuff to people. So, make sure to hit that bell, y'all.
Yeah. So, hit it. We will see you all in the next one. And goodbye.
Bye, everybody.
Thank you for checking out this fantasy draft. Don't forget to tune in next time for the result show. Also, another shout out to our sponsor for this video, the Omaha Gaming Convention running July 10th through July 12th. So, if you're in the Omaha era, CHECK IT OUT. IT'S A FUN DAY. CHECK IT OUT.