Skip to main content
Loading video...

Modern Art Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 15:40

hey everybody today i'm talking about modern art which is a three to five player board game designed by reina kenitzia this one came out in 1992 so nearly 30 years old at this point so i suppose you could consider it a modern classic and there'd be many versions of this game and in particular i'll be looking at the uh one of the newest printings by command however as i said there are many different iterations but i believe that the rules have been consistent throughout so this one is an auction game which is a kind of a genre that reiner canitzia is very synonymous with he's made lots of great auction games that i personally really enjoy such as ra such as high society this one has some similarities to those games and is very much a you know there's many different facets of the auctioning in this game lots of different ways you can accumulate things so the objective of this game is to get as much money as you can by collecting or buying cards in auctions and then selling them off for profit so at the start of the game every player is going to be given a hand of these cards and these cards are going to have different information on them but most of it is um you know just artwork and i'm completely superficial but the important information is at the top here so as you can see there's different artists attributed to these different pieces of art and again that corresponds to the main board here and the idea is that throughout the game the uh the value of the artwork by each particular artist is going to fluctuate

sometimes it's going to be worth a lot sometimes it's going to be worth nothing and it's all about collecting the right artwork and selling it at the right time additionally on top of these cards you've got a symbol here which is going to determine the type of auction that these um that these pieces of arts are going to be sold using and i'll go through those shortly everybody's going to have a museum screen here to hide the money um and you know this is going to be secret throughout the game and you're going to use that to buy your paintings um and the the flow of the game is going to be quite simple simply you're going to choose one of the cards from your hand and you're going to play it in front of you or at least in front of everybody and then an auction is going to commence so the person who plays the card is essentially going to be the auctioneer they're going to take control of the little gavel here at least in this version and an auction is going to start so you've got lots of different versions of auctions here as i mentioned this one here um with this eye symbol is basically your traditional open auction where people are going to be throwing in bids left right and center without any right more reason or any turn order just the highest bidder wins you've got this one here this is kind of a hidden auction where people are going to take a uh an amount of money from their um from behind their screen put it in their hand um secretly and everyone everybody is going to reveal at the same time and whoever bids the highest is going to be the winner of the uh of the piece of art you've got this fixed price auction

where the auctioneer is going to name a price that he is essentially willing to pay and then if or in player order if anybody chooses to um to match that price then they will get the piece of art but if nobody does then the auctioneer will uh pay the cost that he's um that he's chosen and take the piece of art into their hand and the uh the final one here is a one-off auction where starting from the player to the left of the auctioneer somebody can place a single bid and then going around in order you're either going to get a choice to raise that bid or not now there are some special cards as well such as these times two auctions now these ones mean that whenever you play one of these cards you are also going to have to choose another card to play so for example i might say let's choose this one as well and this means that a couple of pieces of art are going to be auctioned at the same time using the method of the second car so in this example is going to be a blind bid and once the bids determined you know who's bid the most you're going to put the card in front of you and um just to show other players what you've accumulated throughout the game or at least throughout the round and then as soon as the fifth card of a certain type of artist is played then scoring is going to commence now something that's really worth mentioning is that when you are the auctioneer and you win your own auction then the money is going to go to the bank but if you are the auctioneer and somebody else wins on your turn they are going to pay the money to you so that's another decision to make there

and something you have to bear in mind when you're buying these lots because not only are you going to get potentially points at the end of the round you're also instantly giving your opponents money to not only use going forward but which is essentially going to help them win the game so let's talk about how scoring works in modern art so as soon as the fifth card of a particular artist is revealed and that means just shown and not actually auctioned then the end of the round is going to be triggered and points or money are going to be distributed so the first thing you're going to do is you're going to decipher which artist appears most amongst all the players so in this example we have four manual carvalho cards we have four blue cards and we have four red cards but the end game the end of the round would have been triggered let's say for example when somebody played that fifth um manual kind of carvalho card um so what you're gonna do then is you're gonna as i said show who's the most numerous amongst all the players and the person who does appear the most is gonna get 30 points uh the second most gonna get 20 points and the third point is going to get 10 points the other two artists which haven't appeared the most amongst the other players are going to be worth nothing in take in case of a tie then the person or the artist furthest to the left is going to break that tie and take the advantage so this would be the particular layout in in this example and now all the players are going to sell their art that they've accumulated at the value each for um depending on

the price they've got here so every piece of manuel carvalho art will be worth 30 coins or 30 money so this player would cost cash these cards in for 90. they would take their red card here and sell it for 10 for 100 coins in total and as you can see they've they've bought two green cards but at the moment that artist is worth nothing so they are not going to get any points for their green cards now the following rounds are going to work in exactly the same way however values are going to be potentially boosted by different rounds so you know going forward sigrid tala could have been worth 50 coins this round but something that's important is that even though in this example manuel carvalho was really successful in the first round he wasn't worth anything in the second round now this doesn't mean that he's still worth 30 it actually means it's worth nothing so the kind of uh the lucrativeness and the the value of these different pieces of art does fluctuate quite drastically and even though one turn it can be worth a lot of money the next round it can be worth absolutely nothing so that's how the scoring works and i find that's quite interesting so let's talk about how i feel about modern art so talking about auction games and rhino kenitsia might be a bit of a mute point at this stage in the kind of board game hobby you know this guy this guy is synonymous with these games is what he does he's had so many

um successful auction games that i've loved and this is another example of that but i suppose the best question is how does this game compare with the other ones so first off what i really like about this game is how simple the rule set is it is extremely simple and a lot of the fun comes from the auction themself and the variety of the auctions because you do have that simple open auctions you have the blind bidding you have the one-off bidding you have the kind of set the price bidding and all this adds a lot of variety and kind of dynamism to the game which keeps things fitting fresh it keeps you on your toes and it just keeps things ticking along nicely always kind of think about what you're going to do next but i also love the uh the mechanism in terms of the way the points are distributed and the way that the money or the economy is spread around the board as well because as i said when you bid on auctions that you've personally set or are hosting then the money is going to go to the bank and it's going to be taking taken out of the economy but when you buy lots of other players that money is going to go to that player which is a big decision to weigh up and something that can't be just done without reason or um without thought going behind it so i love that economic economic feel that vibe just telling up what other people have spent you know is this going to be worth it for me am i going to be collecting this set and selling it for the maximum money here i've got to manage my hand of cards make sure that i've got enough to get these artists past the finish line to get them into that top three rankings

of these artists i also love the way the uh the pricing changes throughout said the you know in the early rounds one might be worth a load of money like this one here but as soon as it gets that third round you might be thinking you know what i'm gonna go all in on blue and um you know get get three cards of them if i can and then the other players pick them to the post by getting four cards of the others out and you could have wasted a lot of money investing in blue when in this round it'll be worth absolutely nothing so i also like the way that things don't actually um lean into from one round to another so in this game as soon as you've tied up your art that you've accumulated for the round the money or all the art is going to be discarded and you're going to essentially start again from scratch the only thing that's going to carry from round to round is the money that you've accumulated and the existing values of those artists but again that doesn't mean that much or it can potentially be completely undermined by somebody or by that artist not being successful in following rounds so all these little elements are extremely interesting and i think they all come together wonderfully in a streamlined experience um which to be honest i wouldn't expect anything less from ronnie canisia that is what this guy does he's very good at cutting the fat off the games um he never includes anything that doesn't need to be there and i think that's his design philosophy and modern art is just a strong example of that and particularly considering this game is as i said 30 years old at this point um just a triumph really just a fantastic designer

in terms of the balance as well i mean yes you are somewhat subject to the cards in your hand and of course you can go around without getting much at all because people are constantly i'm snapping things before you can buy them but by doing that they're going to be spending money and if they're buying the cars that you really want to buy the ones that you've played then you click you're going to be getting money anyway um which ultimately is going to be your points so there is a very well um an interesting balance here and also you know you've got to make weight of that decision of you know if i've got i've got four red cards here if i play the other two and catch the other people off off guard i can really um almost fast track this round and benefit off that so more decisions there which i think is fantastic um uptime as well is great always engaged whether it's your turn somebody else's turn you're always going to be in the picture throwing bids out and deciding which artists are going to be worth the most money replayability i think because this game is so streamlined and elegant it's pretty flexible in his play account as well in terms of working with three four or five players i think it is going to peak better at those higher play accounts you know four or five i'm just being a bit more competition amongst the players um more people getting shafted with buying art that's not worth anything but the three player game does offer a different experience and it does work surprisingly well and because it's a bit more tactical a bit more involved and um you are considering what the other players are buying and could probably keep a better tally or how much money they're spending so probably a more a more involved game when it comes to

that lower play account but maybe a little bit of the fun factor is increased with those higher player accounts aesthetically um you know i like the way this game looks if it's a chord it's called modern arts you'd expect some decent art here and all the different artists are real-life artists and you know i don't know much about these but you've got different styles here um i suppose the art is completely subjective but it works well for the game um you've got some really nice pieces here it's very striking these nice big tarot sized cards add a lot to the game as well um components are really good quality the board is nice and clear and easy to identify what everything's worth uh i suppose what the the main gimmick is the wooden gaba which is a really good quality thing and you know it is a bit of a gimmick but this is an auction game and this adds so much to the theme so much to the player interaction and the immersion and that little things like that do go a long way with a game like this and i don't think that's something to be underestimated so in terms of the components and quality and theme and stuff i think everything comes together wonderfully for an auction game and even the screens are quite good and nice and clean and vibrant as well so no complaints whatsoever from me when it comes to production and the setup and teardown time as well is no issue whatsoever essentially you are just shuffling a big deck of cards and um dealing them out dipping getting some money out and uh pretty much get going from there so no issue whatsoever uh the progression in the game i think is fantastic um i love that i said the market is just

such a big part of this game and it adds a lot to the forward momentum the constant changing values is just a huge pivotal part and i love that and it makes the game feel so much different in the early rounds where you know you're purely speculating and in the end rounds where you know who the big artists you want to get into this top three and um get the uh get loads of paintings of theirs down to get those big bucks um so yeah overall um you know this is a fantastic game uh when a game's been around for 30 years and still remained in print i think you know what what really else can you say this is a game that's always going to get out for me or at least going to hit the table regularly especially when i've got four or five people around on a game tonight something that's going to be easy to teach but still has some gamey mechanisms some really thoughtful decisions to be made the set collection is interesting the auction's interesting and you're gonna that idea of catching people off guard and having to you know discard your artwork that you've paid so much for um and potentially for that to be worth nothing it's gonna create some real fun moments and um just gonna i think it's gonna be memorable it's gonna create some memorable moments and you're going to take a lot away from modern art if you do like your auction games now i know a lot of people do not like auction games and in that case you know i of course wouldn't recommend modern art because that's essentially all this game is but for me personally i'm a big fan of auction games i haven't really played many i don't like um and this one is certainly a top tier one and has stood the test of time for good reason so many good things going on really interesting fun

breezy but still thought provoking that is modern art a modern classic so this one gets my shield of quality no hesitation to give it that whatsoever um certainly going to be a collection mainstay for some time to come that is modern art certainly check this one out if you have enjoyed the review please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved