Skip to main content
Loading video...

BoardGameBollocks Vs. Shut Up And Sit Down

Transcript 5:21

Hello. Welcome back to the channel. This is a channel where we give you reviews. I don't do unboxings and we're not going to do any more play throughs. But imagine my surprise when I got home from work and wake up after 4 hours sleep, someone sends me a link to a video that was posted by one of the behemoths of the board game content creator community where they slag off one of my videos. So when someone criticizes what I do, I reserve the right to defend myself. So let's have a look at what this geezer, Tom Brewster, put out on the internet and uh let's dissect it with a fine tooth comb. Let's crack on.

Ballocks. The other day YouTube served me a mythically bad algorithm pull. A mythically bad algorithm pull, [ __ ] Your secret subscriber ID is on. There's this video called AI in board games, yes or no. And uh it's a bad video. Ah, it's a bad video. You care to tell me why? It's not very good. It's this kind of low effort glazing Low effort glazing, like you spending 9 minutes sat in a stationary position diatribing at the camera. of AI in all of its myriad forms. Uh don't watch it.

Don't watch it. So you watched it, right? [ __ ] it. It's not very interesting.

But it was interesting enough to provoke you into making a [ __ ] video about it, weren't it, Tom? Uh and at the end he says it's all AI generated anyway. Yeah, cuz it really looks like it was AI generated, wasn't it, Tom? [ __ ] it. Epic prank. Well memed, sir. I consider myself trolled. Uh no, actually I consider you a colossal bellend, Tom. My initial thought was to do some kind of response video to this thing. So why didn't you? It would have been nice to have heard your thoughts about why my video was bad, but instead you decided just to say it was bad for no reason whatsoever. But the thing I would be responding to is quite clearly in bad faith. I don't think you really understand what the term bad faith means, Tom. It would be a losing battle. I think the fact that you just say something's bad without actually telling us why means you've already lost the battle, haven't you? So instead, I wanted to make a quick, slightly off-the-cuff, slightly rambly video.

Mate, you're not wrong there, mate. Uh but I feel like having something out there somewhere that clarifies our position on this stuff rather than just getting the kind of vague sense of what we think through our videos and podcasts and the like. So, you bought it. I thought that would be good to have somewhere. Yeah, I'm not surprised cuz you didn't actually put it on your main channel, did you? You stuck it on your like little supporters channel where it's only at 900 views. I also feel as though it's important to give a kind of TLDR at the top of this video before getting into anything else. Uh Shut Up & Sit Down is a staunchly anti-AI channel. We do not use it in any form, and we avoid things that do use it. Behind the scenes, we've had plenty of minor disruptions over the last year or so because we've been dropping products and services that we've used that have made hard pivots to AI.

Hello, everyone. The video he starts talking about blacklisting companies and people that use any kind of AI. And we're quietly blacklisting publishers that are making those same pivots. I mean, what the [ __ ] all that about? It's post-modernist McCarthyism, you know what I mean? You can safely assume that if a publisher is getting into that space, then we've got zero time for them whatsoever. You know, watching this bloke waffle on it. So, going back to the days when the Catholic Church tried to put limitations on the use of the printing press to stop ideas and alternative opinions being bandied around, yeah? Just because a channel has a prominent position in the industry doesn't give them the right to criticize other people's opinions without debate. I mean, obviously, they've got the right to do that, but that's not really how things work. Obviously, Tom went to university, so I would have thought he would learn how to argue and not just shut everything out while he was doing like PPE at Oxford or wherever he went, you know what I mean? So, look, I've got a lot of respect for Sham and Sit Down, you know what I mean? They are sort of pioneers in the whole game content creation, yeah? They're very professional, they're witty, they're very, very popular. They bring something to the table that multitudes of people on YouTube have copied. However, saying somebody's work is [ __ ] without giving any reasons why and telling people not to watch something after you [ __ ] watched it, I think it's a little bit disingenuous, you know what I mean? I've never slagged off another YouTube content creator in this manner, okay?

I've thrown a few jokes out there from time to time, but I'm a little bit disappointed with Tom Brewis here, you know what I mean? I think in saying stuff like this, they've let themselves down hiding behind their like subsidiary channel and not actually given any particular arguments as to why my video was crap. It is just sort of like poor 4 minute, you know what I mean? At the end of the day, you want to watch the video that upset Tom Brewis so much, you can find the link in the description. Just remember, don't let anyone tell you what to think, yeah? Observe the evidence, come to a reasonable conclusion by and make your own mind up. Don't let people who are in power tell you what to think because, as Tom so admirably demonstrates, with great power comes great responsibility. I'll see you in the next one.

Progress saved