Skip to main content
Loading video...

Reviews: Cottage Garden, HMS Dolores, Picassimo, Cash n Guns Expansions, Huh?

Transcript 16:17

Cottage Garden is a game about building flower beds you're planting puzzle shaped flowers onto your board trying to complete them to score points the appeal of this game is in the jigsaw puzzling of finding the right Tetra style piece to fit your needs there's a simple pleasure in finding the piece that slots in perfectly this is a relaxing game the decisions you make aren't overly taxing you can either take one of the pieces available to you that turn or fill a spot with a flower pot which is worth one point there's very little competition between the players it very much feels like trying to complete your own garden whilst everyone else is concerned with theirs sometimes a player might take a piece you were hoping to get but only because they need it not to sabotage you Cottage Garden is a great game to play with your parents it's easy to get into and feel like you're having an impact in the game and it's never aggressive or unsatisfying it's not a game I would generally used to excite people about board games especially with younger people the gaml isn't likely to wow or blow people's minds of the potential of board games and while the theme will attract some it will probably be uninspiring to others there's strategy in the game if you want it you can see the pieces you're going to get later and try to plan ahead and there's a balance between trying to get flower beds finished to score points or taking your time to fill your beds with flower pots and covers which is how you actually get the points Cottage Garden is inspired by the game Patchwork which is a brilliant two-player game from the same designer U Rosenberg which is in my top 10 couples games video ultimately I prefer Patchwork which intensifies the

puzzle building the desperation of trying to fill gaps and complete your board the fastest in Cottage Garden you complete multiple puzzles and there isn't the same level of Jeopardy I also prefer that patwork can take half the time to play of Cottage Garden but Cottage Garden can play with two three or four players whereas Patchwork is only for two it's also less competitive and frustrating than Patchwork which may be some players preference it was a nice game to play with my mom but I won't be racing to play it ahead of other games on game night HMS Dolores is a small card game from season designers Eric Lang and Bruno fi Duty it's their take on the prisoners dilemma the players are pirates splitting the loot of the HMS Dolores each round two players go head-to-head to work out who will get what from the four cards available after a count of three you both make a hand gesture either peace fight or first pick if you both choose peace you split the loot evenly getting two cards each the fairest outcome if one of you chooses fight and the other piece the fighter takes everything the peaceful pirate will regret being so trusting but if you both get greedy and pick fight no one gets anything HMS Dolores differs from normal prisoners dilemma by introducing first pick this allows you to take one card of your choice first even if your opponent chose fight however if you both choose first pick you get nothing and lose one of your existing set of goods it's a game of negotiation bluffing and

outthinking your opponents you can talk it out work out what's best for both of you or claim that you're happy to make peace and steal everything as you get deeper into the game you'll be thinking she knows I want this card so she thinks I'll choose fight so she'll go first pick unless she knows I know she'll do that and actually goes for fight herself it's nice to have a short game that features negotiation and the potential to back stab it's the kind of game that will really sing with people you know well because you'll be better at reading them and more willing to betray them I like that it encourages table talk and I can imagine it being really fun with a few drinks as well what makes the decisions really interesting is the collecting of the loot they come in seven different types and at the end of the game you only score points for your lowest and highest set but if two or more sets are tied for highest or lowest both score it creates a tricky balance of trying to keep all your sets equal so towards the end of the game you desperately don't want certain types of Loot and your opponents know that if all your sets are tied you double your score but it's incredibly hard to pull off it has a nice shoot the moon feel to it and victory is all the sweeter because it's come from clever negotiation or reading of your opponent I like HMS Dolores it's a small box card game that does something very different to my 40 other small box card games but it doesn't quite rank up there with the Classics for a filler card game it's long the joy of the game is in the negotiation but if you get into it every round the game can take an hour it's also not that flexible playing only two to four players and

it's not a game I can comfortably bring out for everyone because of the Betrayal element but I personally enjoy the interaction it encourages and it completely achieves what it's set out to to make a fun prisoners dilemma game it's a keeper for me Picasso makes a simple Twist on classic drawing games in Picasso you draw on these whiteboards that are divided into segments before you reveal your drawing to the other players to guess you have to swap four of the tiles jumbling up the image it works really nicely it makes the challenge of guessing that bit more interesting than simply being the first person to get the words out and you'll be amazed by how often players will guess obscure answers from average drawings let's try it can you get this it's a horse or how about this the answer is Harry Potter I wish Picasso been around when I made my alternatives to Pictionary video because it would have been perfect and it's even closer to Pictionary than any of the games on that list it hits the family game level perfectly because there's no fussy rules the boards do all the work for you it's much better than Pictionary in Pictionary you never get to finish your drawing Picasso Awards good clear drawings rather than speed but there is still a rule to stop Slow Coaches from dragging the game down and imption only one person gets to draw at a time in Picasso everyone's drawing at once and there's no waiting around while the other team has their go they manage this by giving everyone Shields to draw

behind they even have little pockets to keep your word cards in this has the Simplicity and instant appeal of a mass Market game but with a little more effort put in there are hundreds and hundreds of words to play with and in three difficulties that are scaled nicely the hard drawings are hard but we've been Amazed by how often we still guess them correctly the boards are holding up but but since they're made of cardboard I'd worry they'll wear out after swapping them around over and over again and on the downside the pens haven't lasted but are easily replaced we've really enjoyed this game it's perfect for families kids anyone who loves a drawing game we've had a lot of laughs with it it can't quite compete with telestrations on that front but it's a little unfair comparing it to my favorite drawing game Picasso is trying something different and it really works you may wonder how many drawing games a guy can justifiably own that number is now six Picasso is a definite keeper for me huh or Hine as it says on the box is a party game that offers a neat Twist on the Classic Party games like times up in ha you have to describe what's on your card to other players either a film or a famous person but instead of racing to get anyone and everyone to guess the answer the aim of the game is to communicate the answer to as few people as possible it flips the usual Dynamic of frantic shouting on its head and ask you to carefully eek out a cryptic clue hoping that one person will work it out before everyone else let's give it a try so for a film I said hot chocolate the

queue in a post office and hat the answer was the film full monty hopefully only a few of you got it both the clue giver and the correct guesses get the same points the best result is for one person to get it that will get you both the most amount of points if you give too easy a clue and everyone gets it nobody gets any points and if you're too vague and no one gets it right you get no points either it's a fine balance you have to walk and that's the beauty of this game it has that great feeling of games like spyall or fake artist ghost New York where you're having to walk a fine line between giving too big of a clue or too small H is one of those devilishly simple ideas that just works I love that it brings a little bit of thoughtful challenge to the classic guessing party games but without being complicated it's less frenetic than times up you won't get quite so many laugh out loud moments but it's a nice change of pace and there's no waiting for the other team to take their turn because everyone plays at once the designers have done a nice job of balancing the game for different sized groups if you play with five players you get less points for two players getting the answer than if you're playing in a group of 15 players so it's a party game that will work for any number it could use a few more cards in the box and hopefully when it gets reprinted it will get some but it's a breeze to come up with your own words and I love that it comes in a mercifully small box which makes it a lot more likely to take to a party than the Beast that is times up ha is a party game that you could play with anyone and one that will be in my collection for a long

time cash and guns is a game where you point foam guns at each other your gangsters splitting the loot after a heist it's a silly fun game of bluffing and bravery as you don't know whether the gun pointed at you has a bullet in it and if you get shot three times you're out of the game cashing gun's best feet as it spectacle there's a simple joy to pointing toy guns at each other but I haven't always been convinced by the game underneath I found that players get lost in the game with no real idea of who to be pointing their gun at and why after some mediocre experiences with cash and guns I wanted to try the two expansions to see if they could improve the game for me first is more cash and more guns the main thing this expansion does is improve the Godfather role the godfather has a private safe he can take loot from but only if he's part of the loot sharing that round which means The Godfather becomes a much bigger Target trying to get the godfather to lay down so he doesn't get that extra loot it also introduces new loot cards there's fake money which only counts if the Godfather approves it making the final Godfather crucial fake diamonds which count towards trying to get the diamond bonus but are worth nothing on their own and I really like the key and suitcase the owner of each of these cards gets $25,000 but only if the other owner is still alive so this this gives you an incentive to keep a rival player alive I really like all these new cards they mix up the game without adding too many new rules to learn and they all add thematic flavor and give the potential for surprise twists can the player with all

the fake money grab the Godfather at the end and make himself Rich the expansion also comes with four new foam guns to use in the game the big gun dishes out two wounds and these twin guns allow for extra bluffing because only one of them is real unless you accidentally punch out the hole of both guns cuz you're an idiot like me the little gun comes into play when using the surprise cards these are the final part of the expansion and they are one use powers that are kept secret until you reveal it one cards allows you to launch a catar and become The Godfather another allows you to shoot even when lying down I don't especially like these cards they turn an already chaotic game into a laughably chaotic one and a lot of the cards have a real take that feel to them it's not much fun for the recipient when you play the card which allows you to steal the loot they're just about to take more cash and more guns introduces some fun new bits to cash and guns I would definitely recommend it to someone who plays cash and guns regularly but the more fair weather fans should hold on to their money to buy cash and guns team spirit instead cash and guns team spirit completely changes the dynamic of the game by dividing the players into teams of two if you're both alive at the end of the game you count up your points separately then add the totals together and the team with the most wins the game this simple change gives players a focus it's now much easier to decide who to point your gun at and why I like that you have someone you can discuss tactics with across the table of course with others listening you may want to say one thing to your partner and do another cash and guns can often feel like a lonely game for people who are picked on or who get eliminated having a teammate

fixes that even if you die it feels like you took a bullet for your teammate so that they can go on and win the game in your honor there's a trading tile which means instead of taking loot you can opt to swap a card with your teammate this is helpful to tactically Cluster your paintings or diamonds with one player the other major aspect of this expansion is the mercenaries these are four tiles that are laid out at the start of the game to be used at the end of the game just before scoring to be in with a Chance of using a mercenary you have to give money the team who set aside the most money for Mercenaries gets to pick first the powers these tars provide a huge and can really swing the game so it's a really nice challenge deciding how much money you should commit some teams will get over excited and commit way too much money to the blind auction throwing away their chance to win others will stick in $5,000 and get a third pick steal and for good measure they throw in four new gun types that all bring added flavor to proceedings such as the massive desert Sparrow which means if you aim at someone they can't aim back at you these expansions have really turned cash and guns around for me it's gone from a game that I wasn't racing to recommend to people to one that I'm looking forward to playing again each added element brings a little more thought to proceedings the guns make you think twice about who you're pointing at the new loot gives you more passs to Victory and the the teams well I'll probably never play this as a solo game again I feel like cash and guns is just better as a team game I honestly wasn't expecting this outcome when I open these boxes but I've been pleasantly surprised Las Vegas the card game is as

you might guess a card game version of Las Vegas Las Vegas is a fun like dice game from rudig gor where players are placing dice on casinos to try and win money I covered it in my top 10 games to play at Christmas video the card game works in a very similar way but instead of placing dice on the casinos you place tiny cards with dice symbols on them every round you pick one or two cards from your hand of five to play everyone does this at the same time which is the first Improvement on the original Las Vegas which does things in turn order and in the card game you can pick two different numbers on a turn allowing you to hedge your bets a little more once everyone has played their eighth card you work out who gets what the player with the most dice on a casino gets the highest prize but if players tie for the number of dice on a casino they cancel each other out this is a brilliant twist that will have you sneaking in to grab 100 Grand whilst two other players cancel each other out your deck is made up of 30 cards five for each number which means there's a predictability with the numbers you're going to get that can't be said in the dice based original this card game is a tighter more tactical experience there are doubles cards which count for two dice symbols it's always tempting to play them and if you get three or more of a Kind you're allow to put all of them down at once breaking the usual limit of two cards but you'll probably regret putting all your eggs in one Casino later on and if you play your cards right you can end up playing nine or 10 cards instead of eight if you hold back early on as with the original you can be rewarded for being patient seeing how the casinos evolve and snagging some unspoken for cash later on Las Vegas the card game improves on the dice game in a

number of ways it's less luck driven it has simultaneous play in many ways it's a better game but I don't prefer it the dice rolling surprises is what makes the original the joy is in watching other players rooll hoping they won't get the numbers they want and the tiny cards are really annoying it's not something I've had a problem with in other games but trying to line up stacks of them on the Cino the table becomes a complete mess I love the original Las Vegas and I've realized I didn't need a card alternative no matter how good it is but a friend I played it with is attracted to the smaller box and improved gameplay and as isra pero said on Board Game Geek you could always buy some Tiny Dice and turn this into a travel version of normal Las Vegas that sounds like a great idea to me if you're interested in buying any of these games you can support actual by using the links in the description if you like this video please check out my previous videos because you'll probably like them too I'm actual L on Facebook and Twitter I'm John perkus thanks for watching

Progress saved