Skip to main content
Loading video...

The 7 Deadly Sins of Board Game Design

Transcript 30:35

I'm not going to lie to you. Making a good board game is extremely difficult. Somehow you need to meld the theme, the mechanics, the pace of play into this complex system that people willingly engage with in their spare time for leisure. And I've been working on my own board game, Sunlet's Eulogy. And just today, I put up the preview page. You can follow it right now on Gamefound for a $5 discount, which is like 10 lb of potatoes in savings. really think about that. The direct link will be below, so follow it. And as I was designing it, I kept the mental list of things not to do. Things that planted tiny little eggs under the mucous membranes of my soft, fleshy body and caused me to feel deeply uncomfortable.

Those eggs are the sins of game design. I think on some level, we intrinsically know what kind of play resonates with people. Like deep inside of our fidgety little dendrites, we know what makes fun. But of course, there's experimentation and the need to actually be financially viable. And sometimes it just leads to a dark place. Anyways, here we go. Let's dig our way through the seven layers of board game design since thin number one, the lies on the box. Let's start at the surface and work our way down. And what's at the surface? That's right, the box. The way I see it is that every game has its organs. The game has a set of systems that makes it function. We tend to judge that the mechanics, the theme, the art. But there are so many choices on the box itself, the vessel of the organs. And these choices are way more powerful than many might think. When you look at the box, you're really looking at a promise. a promise of adventure, of unique feelings of tranquility, or of esoteric knowledge. And at its most fundamental function, it's meant to convince you to engage with it. There is a certain deal we make with the box itself. It presents itself as a swashbuckling adventure or as a thinky game, and we are convinced for a moment of its promise before we rip it apart and organize its organs.

And there's a whole 2-hour long video that can be made just about boxes, but I want to focus on something more tangible, something more clearcut where the promise of the box and the design are in conflict. The two aspects that I find that really aren't up for any interpretation are player count and time. These are not abstractions that are conveyed in art or semiodics, but instead a simple number meant to represent a real life measurement. Let's talk about time. Board games are notorious for underestimating the time it takes to play them. Take a look at Through the Ages. It says on the box 120 minutes plus. And you know that's technically correct. It will very likely be 120 minutes plus. But that plus sign, that one little thing is doing a ton of work. In a three-player game where everyone is proficient, you're closer to 180 minutes. And in a game where people are trying to actively learn, you're talking about 4 to 5 hours. Over the years, I've generally resigned myself that if the box says 90 minutes, the first play will be at least 180. Any plays afterwards, probably close to 120.

The box time is almost always under perfectly ideal circumstances. And of course, it doesn't include any setup, any real checks, any action paralysis. It's only where each and every move is efficient and players know what they're doing. And I get why designers and publishers do this. The game and its box, it's competing for your time against all possible alternatives. And if you think a game of Through the Ages is approximately the same length of two episodes of Bridgeten, well, you'd be wrong. But you've already fallen into the trap cycle of purchasing cards and assigning translucent cubes that you can't really get out of now. Player count is the second part of the sin. And I even find this one more egregious. Game designs are always centered around a specific player count. My favorite example that I've referenced before is Dune 1979. On the box, it says 2 to six.

But this is a lie. It is an equivocation of possible to play with good to play. And it's not only Dune 1979. So many great games have no shame in using what I would call a functional spectrum of player count, but it tends to miss the reality. The game is almost always designed at a specific unique player count, and the rest of it is kind of adapted to accommodate other player counts. Think about Root. Root is functionally playable at two to four players right out of the box. But would I ever tell anyone to play Root at two? No. No, I wouldn't. Or a game like Vantage, it technically plays one to six players, but no sane group should play it at six. It's just not worth it. I think it works both ways. Some games try really, really hard to get that magical one to four player count to satisfy that grown market of solo board gamers, while other games stretch what is feasibly a two-player game into a four-player game.

It's a financial boon that ultimately contorts what the game design is capable of. into sometimes uncomfortable positions. And you might be thinking, is this really a design sin? Is it really the game's design that leads us to this? And I would say maybe a part of the game's design is its promise to its players. If I go into TI4 and I don't engage with politics or space armies or technology, which is all advertised on the box, I would feel betrayed. In the same way, I do feel a sense of betrayal when the box just flat out misrepresents game length or the player count. And I can see an argument for why it's not necessarily a design sin as much as it is a publishing sin. Hence, it's our level one sin. We need to go deeper. Sin number two, player elimination. Our second layer. I want to disagree with the great great grandson of US President James Garfield for a moment. Player elimination is the classic sin. We all lived and breathe it as children, and we almost develop a Stockholm relationship to it, but it's not right. It's not good design. It's the default because it's the most easy to implement and understand. But think of all those times you got kicked out early in a 10-hour TI4 session because your home planet was invaded round two, and you spent the next 7 hours dreaming what could have been. That is a sin of the game. I'm a magic circle kind of guy. I like having

people involved in the rules and the structure that a game creates. So when you think about all of those classic games, Monopoly, risk, diplomacy, werewolf, these are games of fundamentals. Their function is primarily around encouraging and fanning the internal flame of survival. We play to exist within the game's magic circle, and that's intrinsically motivating. But it's sinful because to fall out, to be pushed out of the magic circle, that is a rejection of your existence in the fantasy. Richard Garfield quotes a few games in his defense. But the one that sticks out to me like a pimple on my eyelid is his defense of Mafia and Werewolf. He argues that the games are excellent for spectators and have a great feel to them, not despite the player elimination, but sometimes in part thanks to it. But I think this argument is just straight up messed up.

Werewolf and other social deduction games are indeed spectator friendly, but you can enjoy being a spectator never having been involved in the game at all. Like literally just watching it from the start. That form of enjoyment is not dependent on having been eliminated from the game. Think about an actual spectator sport like let's say football. If you're invited to play a game and then 5 minutes in you realize the teams were uneven, so you got volunte spectate. The game is still enjoyable to watch. You still have fun, but it's distinctively different than the kind of fun you have while actually playing it. Watching is watching. Play is play. To equate the joy of watching with the joy of playing is a mistake. And let me go one more step further. Blood on the Clock Tower already fixed this problem in Werewolf with near universal approval. All they had to do was allow dead players to still engage with the game's mechanics, but on a slightly lesser level. And guess what? That game also has a huge following of spectators who literally watch hours upon hours of games online without ever having been eliminated. It's a win-win both for the spectators and the players. And the joy of spectating was never dependent on having been eliminated, not even in parts. To which Garfield argues, and look, in Werewolf, you can get killed at the very first night at the first opportunity possible, and you had no information, made no meaningful

choices, and now you're a silent spectator for the rest of the game. The game might go on for 60 minutes, and what are you supposed to do? You just sit there and watch. That's not a game, Mr. Garfield. That's not being rewarded with the gift of spectating when you signed up to actually play the game. Now, I'll be fair. There are games where elimination supposedly works. Coup Skull, Garfield's own King of Tokyo. Games where the rounds are short that elimination is basically a brief delay until the next round. Or even games like Clink where the elimination jumpst starts the endgame process. And you know what? I like these games. I've recommended them before, but I find that the player elimination part is the most sinful element of these games. That sudden ejection from the magic circle, even for a few minutes, is still rejection. And the fact that we have to defend player elimination by saying, "Well, at least it doesn't last very long," tells us it's a sin, but a sin we tolerate. The truth is, a ton of games I love have player elimination, but they're great games in spite of The Sin, not because of it. TI4, Nemesis, Diplomacy, these are iconic games, but when someone is eliminated early, it can truly feel awful. And at the table with your friends, it just feels bad, forcing someone out of the experience. And it's not the good kind of bad, it's just sinful. I think player elimination is a relic of a primitive form of play. It

was the default lose condition because it innately tied our need of survival with the game. It's an easy motivation. Keep survived to keep players engaged. But this was before designers kind of innovated and found ways to keep the magic circle intact for everyone involved. And that just works better in my humble opinion. Sin 3, the rules. Getting a new game is always a moment of bliss. You carefully snip that shrink wrap. You begin to punch the tokens and you feel the satisfying heft of everything you're going to be interacting with. It's a tactile joy that's akin to opening a gift on Christmas morning. But there is a barrier, a knowledge gap between this moment of bliss and the imaginary fun you're going to be having. And that barrier is the rules. Now look, it's not that the rules themselves are a sin.

That's not it at all. Rules are the salt that keep the magic circle intact. We need rules in our games. But many games, even dare I say most games, are not able to communicate their rules clearly. Let me give you a classic example. I think the language game Decrypto is a fantastic game. It's clever. It's snappy. It has that joy of communal mind melding as people find clever ways to communicate. Great game, even fantastic. But it's a truly horrible rule book. And I don't know why. I just don't know why this game was so hard to explain in text and images. I think maybe because rules are rarely considered when designing a game. When you actually sit down and make something, you rarely think about how difficult it will be to understand and operate the game for someone else or even how you're going to explain the order of operations to set up the play.

You're mostly just thinking about the play itself. And the process of understanding rules is tricky because some people really enjoy nibbing away at the rules. They'll watch a YouTube playthrough, watch a guide, read the rule book, check forms, and there is a specific kind of unique joy with that knowledge acquisition process. But even then, I think the core of it is that you need a functional rule book. One great example of a horrible rule book was 2014's Myth. This game was notorious for just having a broken set of rules. Pages upon pages of just half-finished thoughts with terms that had no explanations. It was truly a feverdreamed turned into a dungeon crawler rulebook. Eventually and infamously, community members had to reverse engineer the rules. The publisher actually released a completely rewritten 2.0 rule book. Another terrible rule book that kind of breaks my heart is Dune 1979. I've played this game to death with all the variants and little add-ons, and I think it's perfect in so many ways, but the actual rule book is abhorent. It's scattered. It's hard to grasp and ultimately it isn't a reference I would recommend anyone to use. Much like with Myth, the community has made functional rule books that while are extremely complicated, cover all of those edge cases you will find in a game as complex as Dune. And this is a tragedy. People want to enjoy the experience of a game. But when the game's own mechanism of teaching itself

is too obtuse or too verbose, it leads to this barrier of understanding that just creates unneeded friction. And it isn't that complex games are inherently more prone to this issue. Like I mentioned, the crypto is not a hard game, but for whatever reason, the actual physical rule book makes it seem way more hard than it actually is. Another example off the top of my head is Mysterium. I don't know why, but I could never grasp it just reading the rule book. Even Skull, the Skull rule book, which is one of the easiest games to play, is so hard to understand just from this little pamphlet. And this is a special sin. It's a sin of unneeded suffering. How much does a player actually need to focus and to dive into before they can understand how to play the game? It's the sin of cost and time and effort even to enter into the Magic Circle. And when it's disproportionately difficult or confusing, it's just not good for the player. Sin number four, the overstay. A game should end before the fun ends. I don't know who said it first, but I believe this tenant to be true. There's a moment in every game where it peaks, where the tension is at its highest, where every decision feels critical, where everyone at the table is locked in. Good game design knows when that moment is and then it ends. But there's a special kind of sin where that moment comes and then it passes. and 30, 40, 45 minutes later, people are just waiting for the game to end. Let us consider Munchkin for a moment. This game Munchkin has become the proverbial

punching bag of game design for over two decades. But I think underneath it all, it could be, possibly, it could be fun. The first 10 minutes of Munchkin can hide some fragments of enjoyment. kicking down doors, equipping goofy items, messing with your friends as you all go down this dungeon crawl. This has some charm of early 2000s Newgrounds. But then the sin comes. Once people start hitting level eight or nine, suddenly every single action is dedicated to sabotaging the player who's closest to winning. It's a full unload to just destroy the leader and a take that carousel. And the game just hovers around this endgame but never will cross the finish line. It's just painful. And even worse than that, it's boring. And Munchkin relishes this. It loves it. It It is designed out of spite for one another. You must sabotage the leader in hopes of eventually catching up until everyone runs out of mechanisms to sabotage and then someone will drag their palative bound body across a finish line. It's a miserable experience. And I'm not even against take that mechanics. I'm against this neverending spiral down a drain that never ends. The brief sliver of enjoyment that can be found in Munchkin.

It was a moment that existed 10 minutes into the game. And it should have ended there. And now you're left with this massive tugofwar that the game holds you hostage, bleeding you of any memories that you had of joy. A lot of old school games fall for this trap. Think of games like Talisman, Diplomacy, House Ruled Monopoly. Even some mid200 and 2010 Euro games go on for a touch too long. And it's just horrible because these games have removed joy in favor of testing your patience. It's a frustrating state to be in, and we're only four levels in. Sin number five, the spreadsheet. There's a kind of sin in game design that hides in the beauty of games. The box is a beautiful specimen. The art is worth the price of admission alone, and the theme sounds like this magical moment of self-discovery. But somewhere between opening the box and that first game, that world dissolves into an Excel spreadsheet. This is where that disconnect where mechanics and theme are functionally independent. The theme is a costume and underneath it is something that undeniably feels like work instead of play. Let's get down to Earth. Earth is a game that tries really hard to be transcendent. It has everything you could want to make an ecological masterpiece. 364 unique cards, each one infused with all this nature factoids and pictures. It's got these little stackable pieces that make 3D trees. It has ecosystems and climate types. It has everything you could want for an ecological simulation in board game

form. And when you open up the box, it's practically begging that you'll fall in love with the natural world. It wants you to feel this living, breathing ecosystem that you're actively guiding. But then you actually play it. And within a few turns, the natural world dissolves itself into a deeper form. A new world of mathematics and optimization. The sunflowers, avocado trees, and jalapenos are all cut up to make a point salad. What the game actually is is an efficiency race. You're trying to maximize each moment by using the four actions as efficiently as possible. You compost to get soil to fuel your engine building. You use growth to get extra cards and to add trunks to your flora. Watering adds useful sprouts to your tableau. And of course, planting cards onto the board creates that 4x4 engine. Very quickly you realize that the sacred lotus and the Venus fly trap aren't unique organisms in the living world, but are in fact stat blocks that simply are components of that efficiency machine that you're designing. You care about what happens when it triggers on a blue water in action or how many points it can score or if it helps you achieve this objective on the board. You only care about its various levers and pulleys that it can offer you. And Earth isn't unique in this aspect. There are hundreds of games like this. These games at their core of cores are ones of number crunching, a fiddlin with a very complex Excel spreadsheet. But I did find that this was particularly frustrating with Earth because it felt

antithetical to the chaos and beauty of the natural world. Let me explain. Spreadsheet games are extremely head to the table, solitire-esque games with an intense focus on your own independent play area. Of course, there's some minimal interaction with the act of racing towards objectives or the positive interaction between players, but you're never really able to slow down someone else's machine. What this means is if the game is unbalanced, a dominant pathway can be made that essentially becomes a default way to win the game. An infamous example was the egg strategy in the base of Wingspan, where it just felt like that variant of the machine was a more efficient way to play than any other. And since nobody can really interact in a way to stop you, it becomes the dominant strategy that is now the default way to win the game. But Earth falls for a very unique problem even within spreadsheet games.

Almost any action feels valid in a given moment. The game feels flat because the game feels so incredibly finely tuned. Whatever lever you pull or whatever button you press, the game will find a way to reward you with some form of points. Now, of course, this doesn't mean there's no room for optimization or skill expression. I'll be the first to say it. I'm actually really, really bad at Earth. But the problem was that if I decided to chase objectives or focus on growths or watering or some other variety pack or to rush planting 16 cards, I always saw myself with approximately the same amount of points. What this felt like was that if I put in zero effort and just played without any thought, I would get to like 75%. And if I thought really, really hard, maybe I would hit 90% optimized. Playing it made me feel like my effort and ingenuity was minimized because every pathway led to the number just going up. It never really felt like I made a pivotal mistake or that a move was so brilliant it won me the game. It was flat. It all just feels like data input into a beautiful Excel spreadsheet. And no matter what the data is, it moves the number up. It's satisfying, but ultimately hollow. It's as if the game is protecting you. It's formed a barrier against other players, but also against a failure to engage with the mechanics.

It guarantees that the player will feel satisfied by the end of game night. It will always create an even toned game that never really moves you beyond the sense of that was all right, I guess. These spreadsheet games are beautiful, yes, but they're also hollow. Their theme and mechanics are fully disconnected. These games hope you didn't notice all of the busy work when you're just pushing cubes around. And that's a sin. Sin number six, the illusion of agency. Have you ever played a board game and been like, "Wo, look at all these choices." And then eventually you go down a few of those paths and end up in the same place. It's that cow to the slaughterhouse meme where no matter what you do, the result is always going to be the same. It's all just going through the motions of playing without ever really making a choice. Let's talk about Flux. Flux is interesting because on the surface it feels like a game of pure possibility. The rules change, the wind condition change, the whole game is shifted underneath you every single turn. And that sounds exciting. I thought it was such a cool little concept. It sounds like a game where every decision matters because the landscape is so dramatically altered at a whim. But this freedom, it doesn't feel liberating. When every single rule changes at any single moment, nothing you decide really feels important.

nothing actually matters. You can play a card and the rules change. Then someone else plays a card and the win condition is different. Plans vaporize like your credit score on affirm payments and eventually you lose. And it's not because you made bad choices. No, it's because there was never really a choice to make. When you play Flux, you sit there on your turn looking at your hand and yeah, you got options. You could play time or the moon, any variant of the new rule cards, but there is no real framework to evaluate them. You're just tossing something into the primordial chaos and seeing what happens. It's a random game with random actions and a random outcome. And the sin that makes it feel like it works is that it all pretends to be liberating, but it's all just an illusion that your choices actually matter. And look, you might argue that chaos is good, but it's not the chaos that's the same. A game like Can't Stop is pure chaos. You're rolling dice, pushing your luck, and every single roll, the game asks you to make a real choice. Do you stop or do you push?

It's a chaotic game for sure, but ultimately when you bust, there's a sense of personal responsibility, an acknowledgement of your own greediness. It's a real decision to roll those dice again, even if that dice roll is random. There are so many heavy randomness fun board games that still feel like you have a sense of control. Can't stop, Camelup, Magical Athlete. These are chaotic games that feel like they have a central focus on a mechanic that you can engage with. But more importantly, there is an actual element of decision weight in these games. You can feel like you made a bad choice in a random situation, but in a game like Flux, it doesn't offer a framework to judge decision validity. And that's why the illusion of agency bothers me. Flux gives no mechanism to weigh choices. It's a functionally strategically void game where every decision is meaningless.

It's almost like you have an activity that you watch happen rather than a game engage with you. And there are other games that suffer from this to a lesser extent. Games with extreme rubber banded mechanics or games that are focused on a single possible method of correct play. But that topic likely deserves its own video, so stay tuned. Sin number seven, whale bait. Let's talk about zombicide. Actually, hold that thought. Let's talk about the Kickstarter page for Zombide because that's where the real game is. It lives on your screen at 3:00 a.m. where you have to think if you're going to drop an extra $15 for Danny Tjo. Zombide is mechanically an acceptable game. It's a cooperative zombie game where you move through tiles, pick up weapons, and kill an increasingly large horde of the undead. The rules are approachable, and the game is varied enough to justify a few playthroughs. I even had a moderate amount of fun playing it, but I do think it was mostly due to the company I was with rather than the game itself. But that's not the tagline Seimon puts on these campaigns.

What Sean sells you is a dozen boxes with an endless hoorde of miniatures and just more plastic. Selling this illusion of a great game. And all of that volume of content exists for one reason, to make back in that Kickstarter feel like you're getting away with a steal. And look at all this value. Look at all these exclusives. Where else can you get this much plastic for this price? And you might be thinking, well, is that really a sin of the game design? That sounds more like a marketing sin. But my dear friend, we need to dig one layer deeper. The sin isn't the Kickstarter page itself. It's the fact that the game was specifically designed to cater to the crowdfunding hype machine. Games like this prioritize making the design as irresistible as possible to encourage creating a collection of zombicide products to feast on our FOMO. It's a sin because the game and its designs are specifically crafted to allow for this kind of marketing. If you want the characters, the cameos, the scenarios, the plastic, the minis, the upgrades, the premium features, the extra weapons, the game has to be designed in a way to allow for these things to exist. Think about it. Some games are made with a finely toolled scalpel. If anything is removed or added, it will affect the game in a significant way. You can't just add 12 new characters to PAX Premiere and expect the game to carry it without any faults. But these crowdfunded hype machine games are specifically designed to be as sterile as possible so that the optional

features can rest without jostling the rest of the mechanics. And that's the sin. The sin is that the game is designed to maximize FOMO. nothing else. The core gameplay is purely a necessity to allow for marketing. And it's not just zombicide. Game after game have been engineered to make the crowdfunding page as irresistible as possible. It's a proven strategy that just feeds off our primal desire of want. Stretch goals unlock. The comment section become this echo hype chamber where everyone reassures each other that this is going to be amazing. There's a countdown timer. There's going to be exclusives that you're never going to be able to buy again. These games are designed to make this form of hype possible. And look, I love crowdfunding. I'm literally crowdfunding my own game. When it works, it's the best thing in the industry. It finds those weird games, those dream scenarios that couldn't otherwise exist.

But when the campaign is more engaging than the box itself, something has fundamentally gone wrong. When my most vivid memory is watching the game get more stretch goals unlocked, that's just sad. You know that I was the whale and I fell for the bait. And that's why this is the seventh layer of game design sins. Now, you might be thinking, Mr. Pasti, you talked about some bad games for sure, but you also talked about a ton of great games. And you're right. Every one of these sins exist because someone out there in the industry made a choice. Sometimes that choice was poor game design. Sometimes it was money. Sometimes it was a necessary trade-off that strengthened something else in the game. A game like Through the Ages is way off on player time to potentially convince people to play it. The Crypto just couldn't translate its gameplay into text all that easily. Coup has player elimination, but all of these games are ones that I would still recommend. They're still great games.

Other games like Flux or Zombicide kind of do the more obvious sins. They're the ones that make us feel unfulfilled while playing or focus more on the purchasing rather than the actual game itself. And then somewhere in the middle are the more abstract game design problems. Problems of not knowing when to end your game or games that feel disconnected from the theme and become more of an abstract game than someone might have imagined. These can still be good games, but they have blemishes that well make them feel a bit dirty and hollow. So, I suppose committing a sin of game design isn't a death sentence necessarily. I think it's more akin to a deal with the devil. You'll probably gain something from the sin, but it's not always worth the cost. Anyways, that's all for today. I hope you enjoyed. Leave a comment below for what you think is a game design sin. And don't forget to follow my own game on Gamefound for a $5 discount. That way, when it's released, you can tell me all about the sins I personally committed. As always, thank you for watching and bye.

Progress saved