Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 10:48

Have you ever been to Carnimal? You know, where everyone's wearing those masks? Well, today we're going to be trying to find out who you are, what mask you're wearing, and what secret you have. Today, we're taking a look at Carnimal. This is a two-player deduction game that takes 10 to 15 minutes tops to play. It is designed by my favorite tag team design duo, Bruno Cathala Ludovic Maublanc of Mr. Jack and Cyclades and you name it. They've done a ton of things together. So, let me show you how it works and I'll see you on the other side.

Before I get to the moment you've been waiting for, I wanted to tell you about finding your grail game at Noble Knight Games. Grail games are games that you've always wanted but are no longer in print and very hard to find, hence finding the holy grail. Noble Knight buys and sells pre-owned games and developed a condition grading system from 30 years of experience from buying and selling games so you know exactly what you're getting. Maybe it's the top 100 game Mechs vs. Minions and you don't want to wait a year for the next printing. Or maybe the slipcase version of the classic game Acquire from the 1960s. So, go on your holy grail quest at Noble Knight Games by clicking the link in the description of this video or on the eye up there in the upper right. In Carnimal, randomly you are going to be assigned one of many different characters and they're all animals.

Both of you will also have a mask that is helping try to hide your identity. And you'll both have a secret that you're trying to keep from everybody. That's what you're trying to find from the other person, do that first and you win. That's the beginning of the game, you're going to get one of each of those, character, mask, and secret, and you'll know what you are. Now, the rest of them are ones that you're not. And there are color deduction sheets that come with the game. So, in this game, I was this character, I was wearing this mask, and I had this secret, and you're making notes trying to figure out the other person's three things. Very important, there is a misprint in the English rule set. Uh the new rules online fix this, but the first player is going to take uh two of any single categories. So, they might take two of these and they know which two that the other player is not. The other player will take one of each of the others. So, first player might take two of these, the other player takes one of these and one of these. It just gives them some information to seed what they know is not true.

Now, here's how the board's laid out. It is a random and there's going to be three tiles in this row all the way up to seven in this row. This is going to have two and then this. This helps you cuz you're going to be moving things around. You want to make sure that the board stays the same. Now, simply on your turn, you're going to take this question tile and you're going to swap it with any other tile. This is an abstract movement portion of the deduction game. So, maybe I want to learn a lot about masks and this column has a lot of masks. So, I'm going to swap this with this bottom one and I can either keep it like this or like this. Now, the other player has to say, "Going in here, how many of these things now remember it's a character, a mask, and a secret. So, three is the most. How many of these things are you know, tells me about you?" So, if they were were one of these masks and that's it, they would just say one. If they were this character and this mask, they would say two. And but you don't know which ones they are. You have to deduce that over the course of the game. Then it's the other player's turn. Now, the other way to swap is when you're swapping that, you could put it on this side and this will tell you that they have to tell you this piece, this piece, this piece, and this piece. How many of those is true to their identity? So, different ways that you can try to formulate things in an abstract manner. And as you get closer, you're going to be trying to really narrow things down. Like, this is only pointing to two that might not seem good, but you are really trying to narrow things down really closely at the end of the game.

Now, if you get an answer that says zero, there's no information there. You should take one of any single card from the pile giving you more information and bring the game to sort of do a quick end, if you will. That's pretty much it. At the end of your turn, you can guess. If you're right, you win. If you're wrong, you lose. Before I get to the moment you've been waiting for, I wanted to let you know that Game Toppers is known for their high-quality game mats with over 38 styles and 12 sizes from some of the top artists in the industry like Vincent Dutrait and Ryan Laukat. They have the perfect storage solutions for all your mats like mat bags and mat racks. They just launched the Mats Game Bazaar crowdfunding campaign, which highlights the greatest mats on Earth, including the new Victorian Steampunk mat and many others. Visit gametoppersllc.com or search Kickstarter for Game Toppers Mat Bazaar to learn more. Now, as I alluded to in the overview, uh I just need to come in with my biases here that uh look, this design team, Bruno Cathala Ludovic Maublanc, is my favorite tag team duo. Uh they do amazing things.

They've made all the Mr. Jack games. They've done Cyclades. They've done a a a gazillion other games together, and all a lot of them are very highly rated, and they I just love the games they do. I love I just I just have a knack for what I want in a game. And I love deduction games. And I love two-player short trick short games uh that that are quick like this. And so, wow. Let Let's first tell you uh what I liked about this. Uh this is a simple, quick deduction game. I've got a I've got a ton of deduction games in my collection, but a lot of them are deep, and a lot of them are longer, and and I do have a handful of them that are quick. I don't think I have any games that are this quick, has this much depth, and just has me coming back for more like this. This game is absolutely fantastic. Simp Simple, quick deduction game. Uh now, the other aspect, the reason why I love this so much, is because it is essentially an abstract game with deduction. And you know, uh I'm I don't know exactly who designed which part of this game, uh but I do know that part of the reasons why I love Bruno's designs is a lot of his designs tend to have abstraction and abstract games mini games built into them. Um and I'm not saying he's the only one that had that idea and this Ludovic probably had some as well, but the the fact that you have this sort of abstract thing where you're moving tiles around and then either pointing uh or doing the cross gives you two different ways to ask questions, gives you different ways to swap things.

Uh it's just really clever. I love that when you're getting info, if you get a zero, you get to pick one of the cards that you that that that you want to learn of. And usually you're going to want to pick the one you know the least of because the more things you know, the more apt you're going to be pulling a card and go crap, I already knew that, right? So you it definitely does give you some information. And again, there is some randomness in this game because of that. So just cuz you're great at deduction, you might still lose at this, which is cool, I think. Uh I love that flexibility of choosing the arrow or that adjacent on that thing because it really allows deeper ways to mess with things and deeper ways to to cut things up. And then when you're swapping, I'm just flabbergasted at how simple this good this game is. But yeah, how good it is. There's also a deeper level uh that you can play this game at. You can not only take notes for what you're doing, but you can also take notes as to what the other player knows.

Um and knowing that, you can actually manipulate the solution to obscure things to the opponent. For example, if you know that they have your if you know that they have masks narrowed down to two of them, and maybe you know, they might have some cards. You might not know exactly what they know, but based on what you know that they know, you might be like, oh, he's got me narrowed down to these two masks. Well, when I swap something, I might purposely swap one of those masks to to to stay close to and around the other mask, so it makes it harder for them to sort of like uh you know, split them up and things like that. So there is like a a deeper level that you can play this with, uh which I think is also very interesting. You could just even just playing it just normally, the game has a it's a good it's it's simple, but it's just so good. And then you can take it to a deeper level I think is awesome. So, I just think it's fantastic. Um and again, I have a lot of two-player deduction games, and I have a lot of quick ones, you know?

Uh but man, none of them really hit me the way this hit me. You know, there's there's Orphem Mine, and there's Orphem Space, and um you know, there's a lot of little ones. There's There's Telepathy, which is awesome. Uh but there's just something special about this one with the abstract movement as well. Now, note sheets. So, here's here's a couple of negative things. Um the note sheets, there's enough to play I believe there's 25 games worth in there. Um they are colored, they're nice, but I kind of wish they were double-sided. Um because then it would have been like, "Hey, twice as many games you can play with." Now, granted, because I like this game as much as I do, I am going to go through all these note sheets. But typically, what I'll do with these deduction games is I'll put them through my laminator. I have a little lamination machine. And I'll just laminate them, and then I'll just use my dry-erase markers. I get like the little pens that like you don't really wipe off very easily, but you can erase them off.

Typically, I do that with deduction games anyway, so for me it's not that big a deal, but you might want to know, "Hey, you're going to get 25 games before you have to print off more on your own or laminate it." I kind of wish they just double-sided it, but it is what it is. Um mini shields would have been great. Fold-up little paper mini shields would have been awesome. We end up just using the box. We take the box on both sides and just use the boxes as a as as a shield, and that works. Um but you're going to want to hide your your things. Uh now, in most deduction games, if someone gives you a wrong answer, it will break the game. And in this game, it does that. And in this game, it's probably even a little bit more fragile, cuz there's no way to like back up and go, "Hey, at one point, uh I put it somewhere over here. I have no idea where that was. I don't remember which ones I was pointing to, but I wrote down that you had one of these two." And like there's no way to figure out who messed up. Because the the nature of the board is constantly changing. And when you ask something and you make notes, you're not necessarily saying, "Hey, here's the eight possible things that it could have been." And they said two. You know, you're not really doing all that. Um but so this game is a little more fragile in that regard. If you just double-check your answer, it It's not a problem, but it can do it. And again, if it does, it's a 10-minute game, play it again.

Uh the other thing is that I mentioned it in the overview. Uh there is a misprint in the physical rules for the English edition. Um they have fixed those rules online. I showed it in the overview, go back and look at that. It's a little, you know, They have fixed the rules, but if you're if you're getting this and you're just looking off, it's a pretty important setup balancing thing. So, check that out there in the overview if you didn't see it. The other thing is it's not yet available in the US. It's coming out at Essen through Pixie Games. Uh they are currently looking for a a publisher that can help them bring it to you to North America. Um so, if you're interested, you know, this would be a great one to bring over. For all those reasons, this game's fantastic. Obviously, it's getting a Sax on Saturday, my highest honor. Here we go.

Woo!

Progress saved