Underwater Cities Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about underwater cities which is a 2018 release board game by designer vladimir suki this one is published by delicious games which i believe is vladimir's own company accommodates one to four players and takes probably around that two hour mark to play the box does say it takes 40 minutes per player but i would argue that that's a little bit shy of what it actually does play so the idea of this game is that the earth is starting to be overpopulated meaning that the human population has to start building underwater cities to be able to provide and look after them so the game is going to take place on this main board here and also on your individual player boards which will look like this now this is at the end of a game so uh naturally the bald state isn't going to quite look like this at the start of the game this is very much as the game is developed and so on so fundamentally the game is pretty simply um in terms of its mechanics you have got a bit of worker placement here you've got some hand management and card play but the main aspect of the game is your tableau building as you're building up an engine of cards um and creating synergies and combinations as you put more and more combinations together so what you do on your turn and i should say the game plays out over 10 rounds um at the end of every fourth at the end of the first four rounds there's going to be a um a kind of income kind of phase and then there's gonna be three more turns another income phase and then the final three turns and a final income
phase and at the end of those all those turns the person with the rope most uh victory points is going to be the winner so what you're going to do on your actual terms so first off everybody is going to start off with three of these different tokens and you are going to choose to allocate them onto one of these worker placement spots um dotted around the map here so you can see you've got these different colors you've got the orange ones you've got the red ones and you've got the greeny ones here now forgive me if i'm not quite right because i'm colorblind um but also whenever you take one of those spots not only are you going to get the bonus associated associated with those spots but you're also going to always have a hand of cards and if you end up matching the color of the cards and the worker placement spot then you are going to get an additional bonus and get different different rewards for doing so now generally speaking the these slots here are slightly weaker actions but have corresponding cards that are slightly more powerful the red ones here are a bit more kind of well balanced and the orange ones here are really powerful um work replacement spots but the cards are generally a bit less less impactful so let's talk about what a lot of these slots do so first off this one here lets you draw cards so you've got a bit more flexibility in your hand let you upgrade your buildings or gain kelp now your resources that you've got here you've got science which lets you upgrade your buildings you've got kelp which is used to not only build buildings but also used to feed your feed your
population because you need to feed them at the end of every um every income phase you've got all your different buildings and things represented by these discs you've got your money you've got your kind of metal you've got this um kind of i don't know what it's called in terms of its proper name but it's like a flexible resource which can be used for food and as metal you've got your little tunnels here and um and so on so yeah that this one's going to be used for upgrading your buildings this one's going to be used for climbing up this track here now this track is useful because it lets you break um first player order so whoever is higher up in this track is not only going to get rewards for going up it but also going to be first in the in the next round which can be quite important you've got this one here that lets you build buildings this one here lets you build these desalination plants this one here that lets you draw special cards from this deck here um either paying one or two from these this set or buying or spending three coins to get one of these cards we can give you end game bonuses you've got this one here that gets you just resources this one here that lets you activate your act action cards which i'll explain shortly or build tunnels this one here lets you build farms or um or laboratories uh this one here again lets you build buildings or and build one of these um structures upgrade your buildings or gain science build two tunnels and get any of the combination of those resources so that's going to be the basic action so as you can see they're pretty they're pretty straightforward but when you start combining them with cards it becomes a little bit more involved so
why are you doing all this so the reason you're doing this is obviously to get points and the way you're going to get points is pretty much illustrated by your state of your board here so every board is going to start off or every player is going to start off with a board with just a single city on like this and as you go on you're going to start building more cities by cashing in resources building tunnels by again cashing resources these structures on the side if you connect up to these um these metropolises you get additional bonuses or potentially end game bonuses for doing so and the the reason you're doing this is because if you have or the more cities you have first off is you're going to get more points but if you have a number of different buildings or different building types in each city you're going to get more points but sometimes that's not always going to be to your advantage because you might want to upgrade buildings and have the same couple together because they become a lot more productive for doing so so for example if i use my little player sheet here as an aid so for every kind of farm i use if it's just a single farm you're going to produce a a kelp which is useful because it feeds your workers but if you have the upgraded ones you get to get a kelp and a point but if you have two or if you have a pair of upgraded farms then you're gonna get three food and three points so they're a lot more efficient if there are a couple of upgraded buildings together and the other buildings work in a similar fashion um again you can build the basic buildings here or you can build these very fancy symbiotic buildings which will give you more points when it comes to the income phase and so on so yeah you want to be
constantly building and expanding and becoming more productive as the game goes on now let's talk about how the cards actually come into play because there are so many different things that the cards can do in terms of being giving instant abilities giving permanent abilities because you've got these ones here with this kind of infinite sign on them where no matter what you do these are always going to be active so for example here you know once per turn i could have built a tunnel at a minus one one credit discount or at the end of my turn i can spend one credit to convert a kelp into metal or vice versa this one here means that if i don't ever match a color and uh work a placement spot on a card together then i get to get a goal sorry a metal and a coin or whenever i build a city i get to go to up this track here so there are a lot of things that combine come combine together and can give you bonuses for now no matter what you do but that's only one aspect of what your tableau can achieve so you've also got these action cards which correlate to the certain action spots on the board like this where if you use an action space that does that you can tap one of these abilities or one of these buildings and get a bonus and these can do some really nice things you start off with a very basic one like this which just gets you a metal or a or a credit but eventually you can start you know spending credits to build tunnels um or you know upgrading um one of your laboratories just by spending a credit or science and so on and there are lots of buildings and things you can do you've got endgame scoring ones as well like this which is i've invested in which means at the end of the game i'm going to get two points for every upgraded lab i have
and you've also got as i said instant abilities and and so on so there are a lot of different things you can do and a lot of different routes you can take and focus on you've also got some public objectives available for all the players which are kind of a race aspect where the first person to achieve a certain criteria is going to get a bonus so in this example here the first person to build six tunnels is going to get two points one metal and two science and obviously that creates a bit of a tension between the players and gives you a bit of an incentive to go towards so that's pretty much how the game is going to play it's just a matter of you know keep placing your placing your worker tiles out and get getting resources upgrading your buildings using your actions and building tunnels and building this network up making sure that you can feed your people and basically building up an infrastructure where you can sustain yourself so let's talk about how i actually feel about the game so first off mechanically i think while on the face of it it's a pretty straightforward worker placement game you know these spots are pretty clear and clean there's not too much fluff or fuss about them but combined with that hand management i think works really well because you know you do really want to bear in mind about when and where you're going to play these cards and which order you're going to play them in because not only do you get you have the choice to do that but you also have to bear in mind that do you want to play your card first and get the ability or do you want to take the action from the worker placement spot first and that can be really important and create some interesting decisions sometimes damn
right brain wracking decisions because doing things in a certain order it's really important to be as efficient as you can not only that there aren't too many worker placement spots so you know doing these in the right order and making sure that somebody isn't going to snatch the spot you want before you need to do what you need to do is of the utmost importance i really do like that meshing of the hand management and card play with the tablet building and the um and the pure worker placement it really does come together really nicely of course there's some other kind of standard euro tropes you know the initiative track the public objectives um you've got some really nice cars here that you can invest in which give you a bit more of a kick and give you a bit more bang for your buck but bearing in mind that you know money is a tight resource and you have to bear that in mind at all times so yeah there's some really cool decisions here and um trying to play everything as efficient as you can and get that motor running as early and as efficiently as you can it's just so satisfying when it does pay off so i really do like the fact that there are a lot of routes you can do loads of engines you can cater towards and um you know end game goals that you can try and tailor yourself to achieve at the end of the game and so on so that's all really nice um the balance of the game as well it goes hand in hand with that really your engine really does um you know you can tailor make your engine to do what you want it to do you know do you want to have a real um productive system where you can keep getting your buildings out do you want to um you know give yourself lots of passive abilities so that you could just generally be or just have the edge of your
opponents as you go through the game and so on so there are loads of different routes you can do all the cards are well balanced and i love the fact that you know if you want to play the more powerful cards then you're going to have to go to the weakest spots and that works really well the um mechanically again clean simple and crisp and in terms of rules overhead there really isn't much it's pretty clean worker placement but all the depth lies in the cards and i really do like that so in terms of you know having to communicate the rules to someone it's very straightforward but they can really kind of sink their teeth into it as they actually see the cards um develop throughout the game and start to see the different strategies formulate without having to explain it all beforehand which is really nice the time investment while 10 rounds it seems seems quite long and it is slightly on that higher end of those or of my sweet spot of euro games i never felt that this one outstanding is welcome i think it's a really satisfying puzzle lots of things to try and explore and you're always engaged there's never a point where you think you know this is going on too long despite it being quite a long game so i think long games and games outstay their welcome are very different things and you know as long as i'm engaged from start to finish then i'm happy with the game being on that longer end of the time spectrum and i think underwater cities falls on under that category really the replayability is excellent in this game not only because of all the different engines you can
build um you've got all the different um end game cards here that can come out and these aren't in every game so there's a bit of variability there you're not going to see all these special cards each game whenever it comes to a scoring phase you're going to have to change the deck of cards so you've got your era three cards here you've got your era two cards your era one cards so there's a loads of replayability and you're never going to see the same cards in every single game and um so that's always good you're always seeing new things and new combinations and i love that the um interaction there's a lot of things i usually say about working placement games about these spots being scarce i really do feel like you need that in a worker placement game and underwater cities does a great job of that these worker placement spots are really valuable you know you do have to weigh up what you're going to prioritize and bear in mind what your opponents are going to take because um because you know that they are really scarce and doing it in order is going to be important and always prioritizing is great the public objectives as well add a add a race element and a bit of attention in the game and also these um these powerful cards at the end as well that you always want to make sure that you're getting there before your opponents do to make sure you're getting as many points as you possibly can so i do like that terms of player interaction the aesthetics of the game is something i'm not overly keen on i think the game has some issues in terms of the art it's not for me personally i think all the all the artwork looks a bit soulless and just doesn't look quite i don't know it just doesn't look quite right to me
it always has a underdeveloped feel which is a bit of a shame but that being said this kind of theme doesn't quite do it for me either but i understand the route they're going for in terms of you know a different approach these underwater cities there's not a it's not a overly used theme in fact it's not used at all whereas if this was probably a medieval theme of having you know nights and building castles and things i'll probably be a lot more keen for it but that being said it's not something i dislike it's just not something i am particularly invested in either so in terms of the actual components themselves and it does have a a bit of a cheap feel to it and i don't know if i have a better way to say it than that the cards are okay but all these different building parts which i've just knocked my board over um these will just feel a little bit a little bit tacky really they're they're quite light um and just just feel like they cut some production corners so you know these are just basic standard discs all these different um tunnels they're a bit small and a bit thin all the tokens don't look great they're functional but they could have been improved considering this isn't a cheap game um and it could have been a little bit more deluxified considering the price but you do get a lot in the box you know there's loads of cards loads of components so in that respect i suppose i can't complain too much the setup and teardown time is not too much of an issue really of course you've got all the different components you need to lay out on the
table different card stacks and things like that but i think most of the um most of the kind of playing things on the table and things happens during the game so it kind of maybe the pack up time is a bit more than the setup time but it's not too much of an issue and i certainly don't see it as an obstacle to get this one to the table and in sense of progression i think this is one of the best examples of a game ramping up as you go on throughout it so for example in turn one yeah you've got very basic um just placing your um workers out putting some initial cards out but by the time you get to you know after the second um production phase you've really got loads of cards down as i've got here which all working at the same time and um you really do have that ramping up effect and feel like you're achieving way more than you was at the beginning of the game learning just remembering all the different things you can do taking different routes than your opponents can you know there's a lot of lots of progression here and it really does ramp up incredibly well and leaves you having really satisfying turns which combo together well and things like that uh scalability as well i would i would hesitate to play this one probably more than two players to be honest i would play three you know with three players under the right circumstances but i think four players is not something i'll be looking at doing um it actually works incredibly well as a solo game as well because the not only is the solo autonomous are really simple in terms of just blocking a few spots and you can actually foresee
the spots that they're doing so you can plan that accordingly but it's just a matter of trying to beat your high score already and exceed a hundred points of building seven cities but although that sounds pretty boring on the face of it it actually works really well because not only do you get to play the game a lot quicker you can really just get your head down and focus on your own engine and it's still um you get the full kind of feel of the game without having to worry about what other people are doing but i said at two players as well it works equally as well and um i i think that's my sweet spot for this one uh comparisons yeah there are a lot of worker placement games out there and in the face of it these spots aren't incredibly interesting but as i said matched or meshed with that card play just takes us way beyond a lot of the work placement games out there and um i really do like the way that those two simple things do come together and add or and added with the engine building and the tableau building and all those um kind of crunchy bits just comes together extremely well and um takes it into the kind of next bracket of um a satisfying gameplay um so yeah that pretty much concludes my thoughts um at least in the gameplay of underwater cities so let's just go into some of my final thoughts so first off i wasn't quite sure what to expect about this one because although i really enjoyed um prague kaput renyi which really did kind of um you know wet my appetite for vladimir suki games um and i absolutely loved that game it had the kind of theme i like it had a lot of
mechanisms i like this one i don't know what it was like stop me getting this to the table a lot quicker than it did because i knew it was so highly praised i think it might be in the aesthetics because i generally don't like this almost pandemic look it's bit a bit too a bit too shiny for me and a bit too bright and garish but that being said i completely ignore that when i'm playing the game because the gameplay is so strong so satisfying and engaging i was left massively impressed with this one i really do love the engine building one of the best examples of an engine building game i've played and i've played a lot of them as well um so many different cars they can do different things loads of combinations you're never going to play the same game twice there's some a good amount of player interaction without without it being over burdening towns are engaging um it's just absolutely fantastic one of the well one of the best kind of card management games and engine building games that i've ever played i'm absolutely fantastic um i would have liked it to be a better theme or a different theme but that's my personal tastes and i appreciate that they've gone for something a bit different but hey i don't mind i'll happily play this one anytime because it is so much fun so that pretty much concludes my thoughts on underwater cities it is definitely as good as they say it is it's um it's got everything you want really so if you enjoy these kind of ramping up games where you like to have your own little thing going um this is definitely one to check out and you know if you're looking for a solo game with that kind of gameplay then um i would definitely recommend giving underwater cities a go
this one is strong enough to get my elite seal which i rarely give out i was that impressed with underwater cities and that pretty much concludes my thoughts you know the highest praise for this one and i'm really looking forward to digging in deeper to more vladimir suka games and um certainly i will be checking out anything he brings out in the future so i hope you've enjoyed this review if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye