Skip to main content
Loading video...

Deception: Murder in Hong Kong - Discussion

Transcript 18:04

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Online. Dev and I are doing a discussion over Deception: Murder in Hong Kong. Uh, which I'm pretty sure I have no review over. Um, and this game is relatively old. I don't know who was going out to look up Deception Murder in Hong Kong reviews, but we had played this recently and I'm like, h, why the hell not? Um, cuz this was actually a game that we I don't remember how many times we we ended up playing it that night. Couple more. Um, but this was surprisingly one that I was feeling like most people weren't that into, but you you were like, "Oh, I wish we played that a little bit more." Um, I'm like, "Oh, yeah." Because you can because it's super easy to set up. I mean, there's a million uh like this is like two full things of of red cards of items and then one full thing of the uh um method I guess. But so years ago there was this game called the resistance and uh the resistance had this kind of very simple everyone has a hidden role and you're either part of the alliance or you're part of not and then you kind of have a person who picks the team to go out on this mission and it's either pass fail.

Um, and this game comes out to add a little bit more uh I don't know to the to that kind of genre of gaming where there's a person who's trying to give hints and there's still a traitor in the midst. And this one like blew up whenever it came out. And I want to see God did this this come out 2017. ancient um deception murder in Hong Kong. Wow. 2014 is whenever this came out. This is 11 years old. That is insane. But it was huge because it was so simple to teach and it worked so well with large groups.

Mhm. Um, like this is one that it's like I rarely get it played, but I never wanted to remove it from my collection because it's like when that group number does come about, it's like this is a really awesome one to come in and teach cuz everyone is engaged. Mhm. And I think that's what makes this game a lot of fun is from the get- go, even the forensic scientist has the role of trying to give clues, very vague clues, and the trader is the one who gets to pick his combination of cards, but then everyone is look, everyone's a suspect the entire time. And if you have a really good trader who can spin things uh on anyone for whatever reason, I think that's whenever this game really shines. So, with that being said, Devin, what did you think of Deception: Murder in Hong Kong? I enjoyed this. Yeah, very, very straightforward. And like you said, it was easy to teach, snappy, great. Um, see here, the roles weren't too bad.

It's like it wasn't a horrific trader game. You know, in some games it's like it's a little overwhelming. You're kind of worried being the traitor if I you sus me out too quick and then like, oh, I'm just a fool the rest of the game, right? Um, but this one nice snappy rounds. Um, I'm all I always enjoy a good speedy game. Um, but yeah. So, what is it like? So, four people or however many people that play the game. You play up to 10 and everybody and like only the trader picks like their series of um instruments, but then everybody has eight cards in front of them. Yeah. Besides the forensic scientists, the everyone has four red and four blue, which is thematically supposed to be the item and the method of killing. Mhm. Um, and so you're trying to associate something that would be difficult or could be linked to say another person on the table. So that way we're all getting thrown off on who the actual murderer is. Yeah. So I remember the last time I played this besides with uh the group we just had and the person who was the traitor, I whenever he was looking at me, I was like, "Okay, you know, pick whatever one." And he started looking around and I was like, "Oh [ __ ] he he thinks he can pick any combination." But what he was doing was looking around to see what other people had so he could pick the the the combination in front of him that was mostly associated with everyone else. And I was like, "Oh, that's genius." So So it's like if I'm looking around and a lot of people have bladed weapons and I don't know, paper, then I would pick box cutter and ID card because now that blends me in with

everyone else. And someone's like, "Oh, well you have a box cutter." It's like, "Dude, you have a sword." He picked sabbing. M like no one's really stabbing someone with a box cutter. And so it it allows for so much uh I don't know like player agency without an external factor of the game hiding you like the traps or you know the the chaos deck in Unfathomable. This one is purely off of how well of can I mask myself and how well of a trader can I be Mhm. versus everyone else, right? Which could be a flaw of the game if someone is a traitor and they just don't like to lie or they can't. But in in that turn, I mean, these rounds are super quick and you can set this up two or three times in the span of a normal time that you play a more another more uh complex board game. Yeah, that's true. You could also, I mean, normally what people like to do is just take new cards, but really you could just take all the four, you know, the the red cards that are already out and just shuffle those and you're going to have a different combination. Yeah. Because you're also going to get cuz the game is extremely quick. Like Devin said, it is three rounds of the forensic scientist getting, you know, these uh clue tiles.

Um, and all they do is just, okay, well, clearly they're stuck on like how the hell do you do? Like, if I did box cutter and ID card, what the hell does day of crime? How the [ __ ] does that help me in any way? So, but you have to give a clue by putting these I mean, I always like the touch of putting the bullets on there. Mhm. But it's like, okay, people travel the most on a weekend, right? If I was doing ID card, which is where you might need it. And what's what I've also found with certain groups is people will do their hints by telling a story um of like how the person was killed using an ID card and the box cutter. Um now obviously I do not give hints that way, but I've seen people run with that as the their um their hint giving. But yeah, it's like every new round. Okay, I drew a new tile. Now it's victim's clothes. Okay, that would be that might be a little bit helpful. Getting rid of day of crime because that was a [ __ ] hint.

Um, but you could also just get rid of one that it's like, okay, well, don't forget about that. That was still important, but I have to get rid of it with something. It's such a clean game. Um, but I also found that most the time no one's giving their clue, their guess until round three. Yeah. Why would you? Unless you're just Yeah. Like there's Unless you're so sure of what it is and you're like, "Let's just call this. It's clearly uh that's why I always throw it on route one, right? Make sure I just so that way one of these days I'll get the shocking immediately and ruin the game for everybody." Well, it was amazing cuz last time we played um I had injection and uh dart frog and every clue was leading to dart frog and I was like and I picked injection and I'm like man you guys are really hung up on this frog.

Frog, man. Yeah, you knew it was me. Uh but because whenever you make your one guess of the game, you have to get both. It's not like, oh nope, you got one. It's like if you if it's box cutter and ID card and you say perfume and box cutter, the scientist has to say no. So that doesn't really absolve you of of them. People could be like, well, it's either not him or maybe we just got the combination wrong. I don't know. I feel like this game could go south for some people because it's like if I'm being accused the entire game and it's not me, there's this game does lead to the fact of there's nothing I can say to change your mind. Yeah. Um and so but I mean it's also so quick that I'm like you're not really going to get hung up on it. Yeah, that is very true. I'm just stating that's not a problem with me. I think this game is great. Um, I'm just saying that that could be a problem if you're trying to get you if you're trying to get a semblance of discussion going. Uh, or if people are just always going to meta you where it's like you were the traitor last time, it's going to be you this time and it's like, okay, like let's just not even let's just not even set this up. You have any negatives on the game? Oh man. I mean, ants are a little vague. I mean, but they're also kind of fun in their vagueness. I love the vagueness of these because it'd be boring if it was like if if they were so hyper specific.

No, for sure. And they have to be vague because you have so many cards. But in some instances, it might like I felt like whenever it was um uh what was it? Faulty parachute and whatever the other one was. I was like, "Oh, cookies." And it was like food and I was like uh or like smell in the air and I was like food and no one no one ran with that and I was like like well I went with the plums. It's just that they had cookies and plums. Cookies, plums and something else and I was like you smell fresh baked cookies. You guys knew I mean I again it's like these are are good done in such a way that but that was also the round I wasn't reading the tops. Oh, right. Yeah, that's true. You were like, "Oh, those are words." Just I destroyed the words and you're like, "Oh, there's a top." Yeah, you're right.

Um, but that's what makes this game fun for like everyone involved. Like the murderer is trying to, you know, sew Discord. The forensic scientist had to has to sit there seething that no one is picking up on this hint because if we then mention the scientist is the person giving the clues and he also can't talk. Like in all these kind of hidden trader games, there's like a person who can't talk. So, he has to just sit there and be like, "I don't even know how you got that." Like, what? Okay, sure. Sure. Just Yep. That's That's where you guys are running. Okay. How do I get you away from that? Um, but yeah, if these were like very very specific. Um, and because they're going to be either really bad for some clues or really good. Like if I picked box cutter and ID card and I happened to get victim's build which ranges large, thin, tall, short, disfigured or fit. What what am I supposed to do with that?

Besides maybe ID card, I can look at the picture on it and be like, well, he looks thin. But if it's a dumbbell, if that's true, if it's dumbbell, then you would do fit. Uh, and that would which again like you said if it's like oh I got the perfect string of you know clues to give out and that just immediately to you then yeah then this is like okay it's handkerchief and dumbbell. Yep, that was it. And then you just reset. Damn jerking it while lifting. Hard to do. Hard to do. Hard to do. Well that is true. It is. You are hard while you're doing it. Very. Um and this game did come with an expansion which we didn't play. Well, it came with um you know more more cards, but it actually came with new roles um which I never get to play because you kind of need six, seven or eight. So, there is a lab technician that needs it's recommended for games with seven or more players. The lab technician may check one card and play to determine if it is part of the solution to the crime.

The lab technician wins if the investigator team wins. And then the inside man uh spreads rumors is in optional games for eight or more players. During the allies phase, the inside man causes one other player to lose their batch token before making a guess. N they can choose themselves. The inside man wins if the murderer team wins. And then also added events which I've also not played with. Um yeah, the perfect crime. It's uh so there's just or actually I think that's is that base game? Oh, there is. Yeah, event tiles. Play with the event tiles. Forensic scientist shuffles them into the deck of scene tiles. And basically, if you draw an event, it will do something. Like I said, I've never played with them. Hell, I don't even know where the hell they're at. Here they are. Boom. Countdown. The Fing Scientist draws two scene tiles and substitutes them for any two scene tiles in the display. The game ends after the following presentation is finished.

Okay, so you get like one last ditch effort. Uh, and then I think I thought there were new roles to the uh Oh, there is. Yes, there are cuz we have forensic scientist murder investigators. There are two roles. The accomplice, six or more players. The accomplice knows who the murderer is as well as the or sorry, who the murderer is as well as a solution to the crime. The accomplice and murderer both win if the murderer gets away. So, they they're also equally trying to do what the murderer did. And then the witness um is an optional role when playing with the accomplice. Witness is an investigator who has witnessed the culprits leaving the crime scene. They have no way of knowing which is the murder and which is the accomplice. And they do not know how the crime was committed. If the murderer is arrested but can identify the witness, the witness is considered to be killed, allowing the murderer and the accomplice to get away with the murder and win the game. So, if someone's the witness and it's like, okay, like I know you're the murderer and I'm going to guess and I guess dumbbell and handkerchief and that's correct. If you can say you're the witness and that your correct murderer team wins. But those are all for really large player counts that I never have. You're the witness. We killed you. So, yeah, this game, you know, [ __ ] 11 years later, still fantastic. Yeah. No, solid. I would definitely agree with best party game there. Seal of Excellence.

in 2015. Yeah. Best party game. This blew up, man. Yeah, it was huge. Um, so on a scale of 1 to 10, what do you give in uh Deception Murder? It's fun and snappy. I seem to favor the snappy games. I give a solo nine. Nine. Mhm. Yeah. No, I uh like I could hit the I could keep playing this one. I mean, I game night out of this one. I have a great time with it. Yeah. I I'm gonna go a little bit lower. I'm at an eight only because it does require a large group of people and I never get that. So, it's like, well, um, well, this is how you gateway them into your more intense games. I mean, we were able to schedule a game day and everyone who was there actually was is pretty adamant about wanting to, you know, do more of those. So, it's like, oh, maybe it could be a regular thing. And then this game gets played more. But yeah, even then I still always kept it in my collection just in case cuz I remember the first time I played this, it was like a 10player game and it's just it's so much fun.

Especially if you can figure weed out who it is and you're the person that's just like I don't know PlayStation and exercise bike and it's like and that's it. It's like yeah. Um although what you got to do and I have no way I have really no fix for this is you got to everyone has to either scream or I guess you could have everyone leave whenever the trader is picking like normally it's quiet. Yeah. And then whenever I was a trader like I was like I like was really quiet and I didn't move but then whenever I like touched my cards and I picked like I moved my hands I picked up the cards. I'm like, [ __ ] it was so loud somehow. So, play music or have everyone leave. Or you could just go, I would play music. Yeah, I would play loud. Yeah, that would be a good idea.

You could theoretically do how Obscurio does it whenever it's like you're showing the the cards and they go like, you know, eight and two. You could have 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 and you could go like and then that leads perfume and box cutter. Um, but I mean that is just one thing that can be slightly annoying because the game is completely trash if you know immediately like, "Okay, I heard you move." Well, yeah. Any of those concepts I feels cheap to me and defeats the purpose of the game if that's if you're that kind of player who's just like hunting for the sound. I'm like, I don't want to play like Heads Up Seven Up whenever you had your eyes open looking for their shoes. I don't want I don't want to talk to that person. I want to hang out with them. Yeah. So, it's a fantastic game. still holds up after all these years. Um, and probably super cheap to find. Oh, yeah. Um, so yeah, that's our thoughts on Deception: Murder in Hong Kong. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching, and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon. and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other runthroughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved