Skip to main content
Loading video...

Bier Pioniere (Beer Pioneer) First Impressions

Transcript 20:03

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this episode I go over my first thoughts and impressions of beer Pioneer this is a game that was developed in 2023 by uh or designed by Thomas Spitzer rather published by Spiel Fable art by Harold lek and this game was if I'm not mistaken one of the games that was recommended for the Kenner Spiel this year so that's what originally put this game on my radar and as I read the description it seemed interesting to me because it had a lot of similarities to viticulture a very popular game and a game that I enjoy very much so let's go through a quick rundown and I'm trying something different here I wanted to show you my finished play of beer Pioneer at a two-player game and in this version the cards and and rule book are all in English and more on the Lang anguage uh plans I suppose for what this game is supposed to have in the future uh right now it's physically available in German only but there might be some chances where in the future it will be available in other languages but as a quick overview in this game you are using work replacement and uh multi-use cards to be able to grow your brewery as a brew master uh in in the form of this Tableau that you have in front of you and over the course of multiple rounds

uh it takes as many rounds as you need to be able to Traverse 20 points on the victory track here once you do so then the game ends and whoever has the most points wins so that is a a very quick overview but let's get into some of the highlights and starting with the mechanism of worker placement so as you can see from some of these workers on the board each worker starts with a strength or you know quote unquote number or strength on them and you place them onto open worker placement spots and block them from other players from playing there and there are a couple of reasons why this is important one the sum of the worker that you place onto a spot and the number next to it if that equals six or more you get to place a small bonus worker on the uh bonus action board here and so depending on some circumstances you can play it for one of these bonus actions that you can take and choose from Once you make that certain requirement happen along and and you don't start as you can see the numbers are different among these players these workers uh starting at the game you start with a a worker uh strengths of one and two and during the game you can take an action to upgrade your workers and when you do so at the end of the round after you have played place them the worker retires and you place it next to your uh

Tableau here and when you do so you get to take off a certain uh space that is seen on the board here for an additional bonus that you can choose from but you'll also get some space to be able to place uh barrels from your uh barrel uh thing here as well as uh bruise that you make in your Brewery section here so that is another function of these workers and when you do so uh you place the worker down and you get to upgrade to one that is bigger and better then there's some other ways to take actions in this game you have the administration action here that you can take on your turn for one of these bonuses and actions you have the uh truck here that you can place on certain worker placement spots mostly to fulfill orders but also to accomplish different things as you can see here uh in part particular trading in resources here for points or coin and you also have a worker up here that you can take and place onto any one of these spots at the end of the round the worker that is furthest to the left will become the first player and so on and so forth and so if the round ended that would happen so a couple different ways to use the those workers next are the multi-use cards zooming in on some of these as an example you have different areas of the card that have different effects one the white spot um

either has some ongoing effects that are tied to some famous figures from uh German Brewing history or some of them have one time effects like this one you have the top beige portion of the card that you end up stacking on top of each other like so in front of your Tableau uh when you take certain worker placement actions you get to activate one of these uh the you know Cascades of U actions that you can take based off of how many of these cards and columns are showing that particular action that you take and then you also have the purple section here which include the orders that you're trying to fulfill when you place your truck into that certain work rep placement spot for a lot of points next is the actual brewing beer so as you could see here when you brew beer you actually start with a lot of these spaces here's an unused board uh you can Brew one beer at first but then you during the course of the game remove these uh blocking tiles as well as these uh additional blocking spots on top of the Coupes to be able to finally choose a beer that is represented here and you place it down onto your dial and for using this track as well you determine how far away the Brew is ready uh from from being ready and it usually at the beginning game starts here at 6 and uh but as you upgrade this track and and do

things you could start brewing at a sooner number and by taking actions to brew uh such as depicted here you can accelerate the rate of Brewing as well as at the end of each round uh you can also take a free rotation until it gets to zero and once it does you remove that dial and take a beer from the um General Supply and you place it into your Tableau so that is how it works and it you know it takes time and part of the game is trying to be as efficient as possible to brew as many beers as you can and as fast as you can to be able to fulfill orders before anyone else does so with that in mind comparing this game to others the first one that I mentioned before was viticulture so both games end have many similarities in the way that they end the game at 20 you're crossing the threshold I think it's I think it's 20 in viticulture if not it's 25 but you you that same game and Trigger is found in both games the way that turn order is determined is also very similar in choosing different bonuses that get better the farther down you move but and you know you sacrifice your turn order uh for that as well having bonus workers is more of a a unique feature of um of beer Pioneer but in both games you do

have worker placement that can be pretty cut throughout and the the strategy behind this game is very similar to viticulture where uh Brewing beers and fulfilling orders is not always the top priority or the top way to score points very much so in viticulture where you can you know do a Tasting Room or a tour of your Vineyard for points uh like a steady stream of points to get throughout the game you always have this spot where you can uh dedicate barrels that you acquire or beers uh for one point and sometimes if you pay extra money you can uh pay pay that for an extra point as you take this action and you could potentially take it twice on a turn if you have a uh worker placement that you place here first before anyone else as well as your truck and there are other ways to score points such as in the turn order the uh different um ongoing effects as well and onetime effects have ways to score points uh and in this bonus section right here can also get you a point as well so there are a lot of different ways that you can score points in this game it does not always have to come down to the big orders that you're trying to fulfill and that is very reminiscent of VI culture as well other games that share more uh minor similarities in terms of the mechanisms and how the game plays include Lin and te teoton where both games offer worker placement or dice placement strategies

but include a bigger emphasis on the Pips or the strength of these workers they you know deal a lot with the fact that you know the stronger the worker the better the action will be and and you know in this game it comes down to being able to take bonus action but in those games uh it's has a myriad of different consequences that may happen and in addition to teot wakan and villagers as well as another game that is compared the aspect that you retire these workers to allow for Tableau building and further advancement in your game is also seen and so there's always a progression of trying to get uh bigger and better workers and upkeep the quality of workers that you have in each game the card play and the multi-use card uh that cards that you see in this game are very reminiscent of L granha in my opinion and you know it's it's not like a typical deck builder where you're playing multiple cards each turn you perhaps get to play maybe one or two of those these cards and draw into probably you know five or six depending on how long the game goes maybe more and uh and so you're only playing a handful of those cards you have a deck of about 60 cards or so um if I count these correctly L uh maybe 50 to 60 cards and so there's plenty of variability among these cards and it has the same feel for the most part as the card selection in lagranha less so comparison in

comparison to vulture in my op opinion but those are the closest uh comparisons that I can make and there aren't a lot of you know peer reviews available on Board Game Geek but there are some comments of people who have played this game a lot of them are very positive a lot of people praise this game for its puzzly nature and work replacement aspects uh it feels thematic to uh brewing beer having uh your tbla development resemble your Brewery and the um you know the the spinning of the the beer dials seems very thematic to you know allowing time for your uh beers to brew and and a lot of people really enjoyed that uh if you are familiar with worker placement this game is fairly easy to pick up and people once again about the thematics really enjoy seeing a lot of these famous folks like in my Tableau down here for example I've got Adolf Kors um playing a role for me which was pretty interesting to see and so you get to learn a few things along the way there are some concerns that people have made about this game and that include first the rule book uh it originally was made for you know German speakers and uh so perhaps there are some translation uh mixups you know in the process of translating it to the English one that I have used here uh but the order of things was I admit a little daunting from for myself to learn from Strictly from the rule book and needed a

video to help me along and people also talk about the first player Advantage particularly being able to uh take the upgrade worker action first uh by spending this coin and being able to upgrade your worker the the fact of the matter is that only one or in a uh larger game with three or four players uh two people per round would be able to upgrade their worker and so there is a lot of competition for this space and to be able to create more efficient workers down the road and so you might have to you know sacrifice a couple of turns with some less efficient uh you know worker placement to um to add to your you know Strate your strategic decisions that you make each turn but if you're first you have this option available to you and so so there is that and in addition to that to like you know being able to upgrade your workers first might be able to Cascade to better actions later on that may give you a jump start that is hard to catch up from but that is the opinion of some and I would only have to I I would only comment on it I would have to play the game more to really uh uh find that out for myself finally some people did have an issue with the overall strategy of the game uh some of them disparaged the idea that you can strictly uh you know acquire you know any kind of beer or any any number of barrels or money and just trade them in for points um I guess it

does work out in case the cards don't add up for you so there is a somewhat of a luck of the draw aspect to this game based off of what cards you have and what orders you can try to fulfill but um some people don't like the simplistic strategy of just going for the space every turn to give you that steady stream of points uh to gain at you know throughout the game and uh it's very similar to the situation that many people find Dominion in with the coin strategy being uh you know predom predominantly strong and U uneventful for some you know it kind of takes away from the thematics of brewing beer and fulfilling orders in this game and so some people had some issues with that but my first impressions of this game were very positive I really enjoyed the mechanisms and how they all synergize together in this game I like the fact that and I'm going to make a lot of comparisons actually to agria because while both games Feature work replacement and Tableau building uh I mean and this game also obviously shares a lot with viticulture as well I think I would rather play this game over viticulture although I probably would rate them about the same because um anyway I might be getting ahead of myself I I I you know comparing it to Agricola the work replacement feels very tight and and very competitive as it is in both games the Tableau development feels very similar as well trying to build out the best part and and focus in on you know you know a couple of beers

or uh you know trying to expand your spaces to include as many barrels as possible as you can see like uh these extensions that you have also play a big role in how your game might go some of them reveal the extra beer spots that you're trying to go for uh some of them allow you to turn beer faster whereas others allow you to uh be able to take more bonus actions Etc and so there are a lot of different ways your game can end up which is very intriguing uh I mean you're It ultimately you're trying to you know accomplish the same thing but the journey might feel a little bit different each time which is very reminiscent of how each game of agrica feels uh I will say that the card play is a lot more varied in agrica which makes the game feel more variable and replayable compared to this one but in my opinion I felt like this game was more deterministic than viticulture is I think in viticulture despite the fact that you can uh utilize a a vast amount of uh ways to be able to gain points whether it's strictly through order fulfillment or through you know wine tasting and touring or through uh different combin ations of cards you do have a lot of viable strategies there but I do feel like the card play is a little bit more variable in vulture and if you rely too heavily on the the cards to be able to get points uh the luck may get you down and not provide the methods that you need to be able to score well in that game because the ultimately it's

the cards that determine what kind of orders you have available to fulfill as well as other ways to score points and in this game it is very similar as well but the card uh pool is I think you know smaller than it is in comparison to viticulture and you know there isn't a lot of variation among the uh different cards in a sense that there are um different ways to be able to gain some extra money or points based off of these um orders but I I feel like they're you know it's I don't know I I felt like it was easier to kind of strategize around these cards than it was compared to VI culture um so yeah so I I really enjoyed how tight this game was another thing that people had a hard time with was how long this game could take since it does not have a determined set of rounds that you have from the beginning to the end of the game but it's very similar to vulture where it starts to ramp up really quick it it does have a slower start very similar to agria where you have to take care of all of this uh um you know these chores of cleaning up and and refining your Tableau to make it ready to to uh start your engine essentially like I you know it took me three or four rounds to be able to set you know all of these beers up and finally to get them going in a few extra rounds to be able to um get them to a point where I could sell them uh in this particular game I was able to sell twice to two different orders and uh in addition to other ways to you know

getting points throughout the game that's what got me to 22 here but uh it it didn't take me too you know too long for a one player or two-player game it probably took about an hour to an hour and a half to play and uh yeah I I think if you're very familiar with worker placement games and have played viticulture and Agricola and some of the other games that I have mentioned before then this game I think will come a little bit more naturally to you it's a tight worker placement game with a interesting Tableau building thematic approaches to cards as well as to brewing beer and if you're a fan of that then I think this game might be right for you now once again the language barrier for the physical game as of right now is limited to German I think there are files online where you can get an English rule book as well as the cards in English as well um but I I there might be plans for it to be to be coming out uh in a physical version with you know in English or in different languages uh potentially in the future there isn't nothing there is nothing set in stone as far as I'm aware at the time of this recording ing but uh you know you could always try it out here on tabletop simulator and see if this game is right for you but those are my thoughts and and feelings first impressions of beer Pioneers uh thanks for sticking around with this new format that I'm trying out uh let me know what you think and uh because because I wanted to show you the game you know instead of just having PowerPoint slides

uh you know depicting parts of the game but uh thank you for Consulting with me today and hope that you schedule an appointment with your board gaming doctor real soon take care

Progress saved