Skip to main content
Loading video...

Underwater Cities Review | Tactical Construction Under the Sea

Transcript 20:39

hey I'm Ryan this is my brother Dango and this is rolls in the family and today we are reviewing underwater cities a medium tohey strategy game about most effectively building up a human habitable underwater civilization and if you enjoy engine building and worker placement and you enjoy adapting and making lots of tactical decisions then you'll want to hear more about why we enjoy this game so much and as with every review we've got a link to under water cities down below if you want to check it out for yourself after watching this review but Ryan let's jump into it in underwater cities players will manage resources and take actions to expand their network of underwater cities as Humanity attempts to combat overpopulation by making the sea habitable you will take three actions each round each consisting of selecting an available action on the board while also playing a card from your hand as long as the color of the card matches the color of the action you also gain the card rewards every few rounds you will gain resources in a production phase preparing you to further push your underwater network of cities and buildings forward after the final production round the player that gains the most victory points from their cities and endgame scoring cards added to all the points they scored throughout the game will be the winner the decision-making in underwater cities feels incredibly tactical as you strive to optimize your actions while always playing a matching card with only three cards in hand unless unless you have special abilities you often find your choices limited even if you have cards

of each color you'll typically find a couple that catch your interest more than others balancing which cards to play with the actions available on the board creates a fascinating puzzle at the end of each turn you draw a new card forcing you to re-evaluate your priorities you might acquire a color you didn't have unlocking new board actions or draw a card ability that's perfect for immediate play this Dynam means you can't simply plan your three actions every round each new card reshapes the puzzle you're trying to solve however the game still offers plenty of long-term strategy you'll consider how to build your personal board deciding which tunnels to construct and which connection bonuses to pursue do you stack multiple buildings of the same type for better resource production or diversify for optimal endgame scoring planning your resource use also plays a big role as you strategize what you can accomplish before the next production phase but running through all these strategic considerations is this core thread of tactical adaptability as you strive for efficiency with your cards and actions we have found two to three players to be the sweet spot for underwater cities simply because there can be a lot of downtime with four players there is also a solo mode but we haven't tried it ourselves on one hand the theme of using technology to make underwater areas habitable comes through strong and influences a lot of the game design on the other hand the entire experience revolves around a color

matching mechanism that is completely arbitrary and the Tactical decisions feel more mechanical than thematic this balance puts underwater cities somewhere in the middle between abstract and thematic this is a heavier strategy game that rewards optimal action efficiency and Resource Management so while the card draw introduces a lot of Randomness the outcome is still largely determined by players skill most of your time is spent thinking about your own puzzle and not worrying about what other players are doing but there is still interaction in the competition for work rep placement spots and sprinkles of other elements such as competing for special cards with endgame scoring or racing to achieve specific goals when using the government contracts module for a big strategic experience there isn't much setup required outside of getting out all of the different supplies and shuffling decks still the number of components here will still take a bit to get in their right places While most of the systems in underwater cities are intuitive with good iconography this is still a complex strategy game that takes a little while to explain everything in a way that will set new players up for success in their first game almost all the setup variability is going to come from the randomized hands of cards which certainly make a big impact as well as the randomly drawn special cards that said a lot of the variability feels similar and is more about directing small Tactical decisions than really changing the trajectory of your strategy from game to game we will note that the excellent new discoveries expansion does

a great job of increasing this variability with more asymmetrical player boards unique personal assistance and varied sets of starting resources the most fun part of underwater cities is navigating the decisions that emerge from trying to match cards to action spaces of the same color it is a great example of how a mechanical design Choice without any thematic justif ification can elevate a game simply because it is such a fun mechanism it takes everything that is interesting about worker placement planning out your actions prioritizing based on which are likely to get blocked first and injects a layer of nuance as you try to optimize your cards every turn ends with the exciting moment of drawing a new card and seeing if it changes what you think you should do next there's even a bit of push your luck as you can try to keep your colors balanced for more flexibility or take the risk that you might draw the same color you already have and be really Limited in the actions you can take underwater cities like many card-based engine building games offers a satisfying sense of progression as you enhance your production and abilities with only three production rounds your advancement is very clear as you notice significant increases in output there's also a cool mechanism with action cards that trigger When selecting board spaces with the matching icon playing More Action cards is like creating your own worker placement spot as those places will let you choose any of your action cards to activate additionally if you exceed the action card limit of four you are forced

to discard one but are allowed to trigger it one final time this is just a fun design decision is and can even lead to strategies where you turn action cards for extra activations all of this optimization and card play feeds into the actual construction of your underwater network of cities and this core system does a good good job of providing interesting tradeoffs independent of the Tactical action selection you want to consider which placement bonuses to prioritize and choices you make on building construction have implications on both resource production and final scoring other systems such as the Federation track that provides bonuses and determines player order or the special cards that can only be acquired through a single action slot add to the foundation that really allows the variety and tactics of the cards to shine it is really satisfying to see how much your production scales as the game progresses but the actual execution of collecting those resources can start to get really tedious as each player slowly walks through every aspect of their production engine since every player typically handles their own production simultaneously unless you really want the game to run long there is just a lot of room for error without anyone double-checking the calculations it is a kind of upkeep that would be really nice to leave to a computer but us mere humans just have to accept that there are probably going to be errors that are going to go unnoticed almost every time you play there are many games where you build something up throughout the game

and then get the satisfaction of looking at the unique thing you've built at the end of the game and while underwater cities fits into this category it also doesn't have much variation in its end State as your network of cities and buildings will feel roughly the same each game it's a small thing but just don't expect to go wow look at the really unique way I built up my board this game and now let's get to our personal ratings for underwater cities so I will always remember underwater cities as the game that I bought right before everything went into lockdown in 2020 I remember I got it and I was going to plan a game day and then uh you know there weren't a lot of inperson game days for a long time after that yes it was was a little sad in fact our first plays of it if you remember was actually on tabletop simulator we actually cuz I learned IED toy and so we tried it on there um and man this is a game that like when I researched it it felt like it was you know kind of in a crowd of these types of games it's like is there really something that's going to have it stand out and having now played it quite a bit I think it really does and I'm actually going to be coming in at a 9 out of 10 um it's just just a really fun if fun game and I think so much of it is driven by that core card Action System um you know it's such we've talked about it in

the review that it's just kind of this arbitrary thing of like well you know the colors of the cards that they match the colors of the places but the decisions that come out of that like if I'm sitting with two red cards and a yellow card okay it's like I really don't want to go to the green actions unless like I need to cuz you're going to basically just not get to play a card right and then it's like okay well I could go to a yellow action but I have two Reds if I draw another red I'm only going to have Reds at that point like is it better to maybe try to use a red and maybe balance my hand but then you're weighing that all on top of the normal like worker placement considerations it's tight yeah of like where are other people going go tight and there's a lot of things that like there's only one place to do it like um there's like only the one space where you can play the science to upgrade things and there's only you know the one place to get special cards which I find often the mistake we all make is there's those endgame special cards that are all like endgame scoring of like you can you know turn all your kelp into points at the end of the game and everybody in their mind's like oh yeah I'll get that in like the last or second to last round and then it's like well there's only one spot everyone everyone can't go there right yeah so there is we realized more like oh it is probably good to like think ahead and like uh you know take that action potentially earlier um but yeah and then the fact that then at the end of the turn you get to draw a card and you've just refreshed that puzzle like it just is so satisfying to always

you know right when you're going into what's going to be the downtime and this game does have downtime depending on who you're playing with and how many players but you get to start it out with this new piece of information that's really impactful and then on top of that other people are starting to take space is and so you're kind of you know figuring out how what's the best way for me to approach this um and so honestly that's like most of my what I think SE like elevates this game to where it's a keeper for me is just how fun that that core system is now we have gotten since the the new discoveries expansion which is a big it comes in a box like as big I think it's like almost as expensive as I was say but it is a mega expansion and has tons of great stuff and especially for uh people like us that you know maybe wanted a little bit more variability out out of the game the fact that it adds the uh unique personal assistance so you don't just all have the exact which the personal assistant I don't think we really talked about but it's basically your starting action card and then you can get more action cards yeah it's got the triple layer boards everything slots in and you know we we now use usually the set that's like the most asymmetrical boards with different um and some different types of bonuses for connecting to the cities um so really great expansion I think that has has kind of solidified it as one that I want to keep coming back to um but yeah like when I try to like think of like why is this getting up to a nine it really does feel like most of it is coming from that

that core Action System um and another thing the expansion had is more cards and like it's fun to see them kind of like getting some more creative cards you know there's some fun cards that have abilities like oh that uh how don't know I picture the guy like snorkeling out of the water or whatever that's like the now if you don't match the card like if you go to an action that doesn't match the card you actually get like a little bonus which can kind of be an interesting strategy especially if you get a couple of those so it's fun to get some of the like ongoing ability things and I think the expansion pushed that even further with kind of just more options to kind of make that feel unique right um but yeah it's it's just a really solid game with a a just a killer core action selection mechanism in my opinion yes I uh I will agree with you Ryan so much so that I am also coming in at a nine out of 10 for underwater cities um man like you were mentioning that that course it's you know I I love when games just have such a simple mechanic that just makes the game incredible and that really is that um cuz not only is the I mean it's it's a whole um system of just optimizing likey trying to you know with these cards and these limited actions like you're always trying to match colors cuz otherwise you're you know you're uh you know missing out on potential of of what you can do and so every turn is so satisfying to like okay I could play

this card that lets me get this and then go here to get this you know figuring out how to kind of match those things up you know one of the things that you know you didn't mention was the fact that you're you know you're you have a small hand of cards and so it's you know one of the things that's driving also where you go the current turn is how you want to set yourself up for right future turns of like okay maybe I really want to do this but man I've got two other you know red cards in my hand and if I draw you know another uh red card like I'm going to be in real a really tough situation you know so there's even like not only what are you trying to do currently but setting yourself up in future turns um man that just all around in such a tight worker placement uh we love tight worker placement Where It's just tough decisions um but man when you're able to optimize and and and and every turn's a you know a combination of of two things happening uh you just get a lot of um a lot of fun kind of interaction between playing those I think also just as the game progresses I mean you you just feel your engine growing um you know between building the little uh uh are the cities that are are buildings you know um around obviously that's in you know increasing your production but then it's fun because if you can get you know part of one of the tensions you have in this game is uh at the end of the game a big way you score points is unique buildings

around your city is worth cities more if it has more different buildings so you so you know pointwise you would get maybe all three unique buildings around a city but on the other hand production-wise if you can have two buildings that are upgraded to their level two thing you get like a production level that is bigger than better than just the two individual things and so that's even a tension you're facing but uh of of wrestling you know do I go for the two do I uh spread it out um but but man as the game goes on and on you're just producing more and more and that's just all feeding into the tight work how do I take all of these resources but now run it through such a tight worker placement and and just it's so there's there's not a t is not a game of a ton of options you know instead it's very just like a few cards and limited actions out on the board and everyone is jockeying over that and I don't know I think for both of us we've um we've found that incredibly satisfying this a last thing I'll say is it is weird cuz for some reason this this game when I think about playing it it doesn't like it's not the first game that I think of of like I get really excited wanting to play and I was thinking about that more I think the the theme for me like like it's not a bad theme but I don't know for some reason it it doesn't get whereas like I don't

know maybe a terraforming Mars and AG grica like uh I feel more and I know we mentioned this earlier more satisfied kind of in like the progression of the the bo State and whatnot um I find this one for some reason doesn't the the theme doesn't get me going wow like you know this is uh like it's it's a fine I think it's not bad it's fine um maybe it's my I hate the the little pieces that you play your workers essentially yeah this is D biggest complaint in the game My biggest what even is that I don't even know just like such a and I mean I'll be honest like board game you know pieces uh influence how you know the the presentation influences experience for me yeah and and for some reason that just placing that little rectangle I'm like there's a million other pieces I would have rather uh rather placed than that I don't know why that just just does not does I mean I I don't know for me if it's so much the theme but I've always been a little underwhelmed by just the player board like I'm never when I'm playing this game that excited about like what I'm build I don't know it's like yeah it's like I'm putting cities and tunnels out and I'm trying to hit the bonuses but it's kind of just like right most of my enjoyment is coming from like the ways that I'm making that happen right um and

so and again you know this is in a weight and category that our favorite games are in like this is and so that's maybe some of the reason why it's like it's a nine but there's also games in this category that we rate 9.5 or 10 um and so it it does for me it's it's like tier two but it's like good enough that I'm going to you know continue to own it and want to play and it's different enough that it's not like cuz there's some games in this weight that might fall into the thing of I would always rather play my favorites but this one it offers enough of a different feel and experience that there's I want to experience this too um and so it has found a home in my collection I totally agree and it's one that despite me not thinking about you know despite Me Maybe not getting super excited before like when I'm thinking about playing it every single time once I start playing it I'm like oh my gosh this game is so much more fun than when I think about it you know I wonder if that's because like when we think about games we tend to think more about like the Strategic parts of it and like underwater city so much of the satisfaction is coming from the in the moment tactical and that's like harder to remember how fun those little things are yeah um but yeah it's just like constant the whole game you're just like o got another card oo what do how do I do good it's so good so those are our uh thoughts on underwater cities

but Ryan the real question is is underwater cities a game for you our listener if you prefer long-term strategy to constantly changing tactics are put off by tedious upkeep or want to avoid a game with downtime between turns then underwater cities may not be for you but if you want a heavier thematic strategy game that is filled with interesting decisions and a satisfying progression then we have found underwater cities to be an excellent choice hey we got a link to underwater cities in the description below hopefully this review was helpful to see if maybe it's a game you would like to check out we've also got lots of other videos here on the channel we got two of them here um suggested for you maybe check those out and we will see you in the next one

Progress saved