Ex Libris Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to John gates games today I'll be reviewing ex libris this game was designed by Adam McIver and it is a worker placement style game that has players competing to build the best library in front of themselves that they can they're gonna do this by visiting a wide variety of worker placement spots that are gonna change drastically from one turn to the next they will also be activating their drastically different asymmetric player powers all in the goal of building the most well-rounded stable library that avoids as many banned books as possible and has the most of those premium books that people are really looking for first I'll explain how the game plays and then I'll jump in in my review at its core ex-libris is a tableau building game and you'll be doing set collection trying to acquire the correct cards to put down into your tableau and before I talk about the main mechanics of the game I want to show you how you actually build this library that's gonna win you the game now at the beginning of the game you start with six cards in your hand and you'll see the letter which is the starting letter for every one of the books that is on this card they all have fun bunny names like yes we can trip and yetis and their love of spaghetti but also along the top of the card we see icons which tell you what type of each book is so in this case this is spells and potions and this one over here is a monsters manual whenever the game tells you that you can shell the card that means you're gonna take the card either from your hand or from a location and you put it down in front of you if it's the first card it can go anywhere but any future Scheldt cards need to go next to an orthogonal way one of your previously placed cards and you are never allowed to have a library that is more than three tall now as you're putting these down there is another very important restriction and
that is that you will only score cards that are in alphabetical order at the end of the game and this is where these numbers come into play if we look right over here we see that on the T we have two out of ten and five out of ten that means evented there are ten cards in the game that start with T and this one with a two out of ten is actually going to be before the five out of ten card so once we pull up the central player board we can now see the variety of ways in which our library will actually score us points now right here we see alphabetical order is first so this means at the end of the game we are all going to check to make sure we have actually built out in the alphabetical library in front of us so if we were to have these T's down here and the five was in front of the two then at the end of the game you actually be forced to flip this one over leaving that spot in your shelf but not scoring at those options on the card so next up let's take go ahead and build our library like this and that let's shift this over to see the next scoring thing for our library and that is going to be shelf stability we're gonna find it the largest rectangle of cards that is at least two by two large and is associated with the bottom level and we're gonna get one point for each this means right now our shelf stability gives us zero points but if we had this s right here we would now get four points for these four cards it also means if we had something that was oriented a bit more like this we would get zero points because we have an unstable shelf with this gap right here on the bottom in addition to shelf stability all the libraries are also gonna be judged on their prominent works and at the beginning of the game we are gonna shuffle up all of these cards one if each aren't associated with the
different types of books and one of these is going to be a prominent work so in this case when the game is over the player who has the most of these reference text cards in their area and as you can see right now we have 1 2 3 4 5 so in a pretty good spot then the leading player is going to get 15 points and then 9 and 4 points for the players who have less but as you play you also have to make sure to avoid as many banned books as possible this is also going to be randomly selected at the beginning of the game that means that the player will lose at one point for every one of these spells and potions books in this particular play so looking out here they are currently losing one point but often times it actually makes sense to maybe have this card down because it's gonna do better for winning you lots of points and you only lose one point for the ban spells the second to last way that your library is going to be judged is categorical variety and in this case you're actually trying to have the most balanced library possible as far as all of the different types of books not including the banned books so you're going to look out and find it the type that you have the least of and if we look out here we have let's see two of the black books we have two of the red books there are two green books we have 1 2 3 4 5 of the blue books but only one yellow book which means right now our categorical variety is only scoring on yellow because that's the least and we get 3 points for that so that would be 3 times 1 or just 3 points which goes to show that's very important to try and bolster up and have an even amount of all of these different types of books the final way that your library is going to get judged is library focus and all of the type cards that we're not used for prominent works are banned are going to be given out to
each of the players as a hidden goal throughout the game and when the game is over each player will reveal their goal and then they will score two points for every book of that chosen type so again in this case that's probably not too great for us just two points but now you should have a good idea of how you're actually going to want to build your library and let's now take a look and see how the worker placement phase works to actually grab these cards and build it out at the start of the game players need to decide if they're going to be playing a fully symmetric characters or if they're gonna go with asymmetries and if they do the asymmetries you will draw out twice as many of these as there are players and they will draft them in Reverse player order when they do this they will take two pawns of their color and then the one pond that is associated with their specific character and the rest of these won't be used in that game at the beginning of every round we have to deal out one worker placement location for each of the players and in the first start of the game you always have to have the diviners Hut down so in this case we would draw two more cards from the stack and you'll see this number in the top corner we're gonna go ahead and put them in order according to that and we now have all of the worker placement locations available to us for this first turn of the game when you look closer at some of these worker placement spots you'll see a section that has a deal number and that means we actually deal this number of cards face-up on top of that section and those worker placement actions are likely going to interact with those specific cards that are over there play always starts with the start player as denoted by this token right here in under turn you simply take one of your workers which could be a generic one or your special one and you will activate one spot that has one of these work replacement locations on it including
the three that are on your own player board that only you can activate now when you actually put the pond down it's going to depend on what happens based on the location and for instance you see this is a lightning ball here and then this little clock there when you go to a lightning bolt spot like this you get to evaluate it immediately and in this case The Bookseller just lets you take one of the cards that are is currently on top of this location and you pull it into your hand or you can immediately shelve it putting it out onto the table versus we have the auction house if we were to go right here then we would actually be bidding at the end of the round that this clock means it happens once everybody's placed everything to discard 3 cards in order to take all three of these cards and put the into our hand or to immediately shell them out there but there are special rules for many of these locations for instance if I went here then one of my opponents could take their pond and go to the four and specifically for the auction house that would kick this one out and now they have a better bid but other locations like the bookseller multiple people can live on that spot in harmony but this is where some of the asymmetries come in because if for instance this player over here and put their snowman these special ability for this is that no other players can activate any slots on that location so this would be a very powerful one to put down here in order to win the auction for not that much using their ability another option would be this gelatinous cube when you put that down and when anybody whenever anybody else goes to that spots they either have to give you a donated card or allow you to do a bonus action so in this way you could see the asymmetries can really come into play the last one I really want to talk about is the diviners Hut because it is in every single game and if you look at to these
specifics on the card it says you draw one card for every assistant that you have placed and then you take the first player token this is the only way that the first player token moves and it means that in the first round if you were to go on to the spot you would just draw one card but if you were to wait a couple rounds and you have a couple of your workers out already and then go there you would be able to draw several of these cards and then take the starting player token for yourself for the next round when we look closer at some of these locations you'll see a three plus and 4 plus on some of these slots this has to do with player count that means in this three player game only three of these workers would be able to go there and this last one will be blocked out and only usable in a four player game the last thing to cover as far as worker placement locations go are these home actions they are the same for every single player board and there is no asymmetry here and whenever you put a worker onto one of these spots you simply get to draw a card or shelve one card so they are relatively weak actions but they are always available to you once every player has put all of their workers down the round is over and we're going to go ahead and activate and clear all of the worker placement spots so if they had a lightning bolt then all that happens is you clear the token back but if it has the clock then this would be the moment when you actually do that spot so in this case the player over here would have to discard one card for winning the auction and then they would gather all three of these and potentially shelve them right away once they have all been evaluated we now get to take a look and see the numbers we have one three and ten and we always take the lowest value location and we then put it up on to this player board we discard all these remaining ones and then we go to this gigantic stack of
other locations we draw an equal number to the number of players we put these out in order so we have six 13 and 18 and then we play the next round and we of course seed these locations so as you can see as the game goes on you're going to have more and more worker placement locations once this round is over these six would actually come up here you would discard these two and draw three more so there are going to be more and more spots to choose from the game will keep playing in this way round after round gaining more and more worker placement spots until a round ends where a player has 16 14 or 12 cards in front of them shelved in their library based on the player count once that happens the game is over and we can go into an game scoring the game comes with the official library inspection form b7c as well as a dry erase pen and this is just a good way for us to write everything down that we did to figure out our final scores now we go ahead and put our name up at the top and before we check for our alphabetization of our library we can optionally flip over any books we want to and now we're just gonna go ahead and fill everything in including all of the numbers of these different types of books and this is gonna help us figure out our categorical bonus to see which one we have the fewest of it also tells us if we won the majority for the prominent books and we can also log things like our shell stability and our private personal goal as well once we sum up those scores we figure out who has it the most points and that person is going to be the winner let's now begin the review for ex libris by starting with a few positive points and the first of these has to do with the shelving puzzle - this game gives you realistically this is what the game is
all about it's the library you're trying to build it in front of you and there are several different things you are thinking about while you're trying to put these cards down if it was just put these cards in alphabetical order that wouldn't obviously not be very interesting but instead the game presents you with some pretty interesting decisions of when do you actually commit to put these books down in front of you and also when is it good enough to stop hoping to find that next perfect book that's gonna fit right alongside that one set of books that you already have like you will have moments of good luck where you'll pull the perfect card that matches up just well but more often than not you're gonna be sitting there and you're like well do I jump from R to W or something like that or even bigger once we're like from high all the way to Q and you might be looking at your handing like that's actually probably what I'm gonna do because at the end of the day the game is gonna end once somebody has at least 12 14 or 16 cards in their tableau based on the player size but with 26 letters in the alphabet that means that you are obviously going to be avoiding a lot of these letters in the alphabet so you really just need to try and make these decisions of when you're going to say enough is enough I'm just gonna put these two cards down together even though there's like 30 or 40 cards in between the two that I could end up grabbing that could be really good to me because the game clock is going like you need to know the right moment to just start putting shelves down putting books down into your shelves because if somebody else gets reasonably far ahead of you in actually getting these books down you might not be able to race back and catch up to where they are you definitely have to be present looking on the table and seeing where everybody else is because at a certain moment it feels like there is a sprint if people just now throwing books down like crazy
and you want to make sure you're not behind so all of those great decisions come together to try to figure out when do I go and when do I just sit here and try to build it up a bigger hand of cards because there is no hand limit in this game realistically you could just keep drawing cards like crazy but at a certain point that is going to do you wrong because you get no points for the cards you have it in your hand at the end it's just the cards that are shelved in your library for positive number two I want to talk about the interesting tweak this game brings to the worker placement John rrah in this game you will be randomly dealing out a number of worker placement locations equal to the number of players every single turn and you'll be discarding all of those but one every single turn as well so that means that from one turn to the next you're gonna have a significant difference in the variety of options you have available to you to actually grab these cards and put them down in front of you but I also love it that idea that you grab the lowest value worker placement spot and bring it up to the top as a permanent location because not only do you have a sense of escalation as the game goes on you have you start with very few worker placement spots and you end with a whole bunch of them but it also means that one game is going to play pretty differently from the next based off of a shuffle of those tiles because you will oftentimes have the like the low values like one two and three end up being permanent locations because they will are more often than not the lowest version of the locations that come out on a turn but every now and then you'll have a situation where it's like 12 15 17 and that means the 12 is now gonna be a permanent spot and odds are relatively high that you haven't played a game with the 12 as a permanent spot before so that means that in one game you might have a pool drafting session every single turn for lush so the game based off of how those talis came out and in
another game you have people gambling like crazy you turn after turn and that third game you have an auction that keeps going every single round it's really cool to have these things come and go in brief stints but it's also cool to see the variants of having a variety of different ones lock up to the top from one game to the next now I will admit that based on the player account you can have some kind of weird slow starts because of this specifically at the two-player count you start with the diviners Hut which just allows you to pass the first player token around and you draw one more and in the two-player game I played we have the diviner side and then the garbage dump come out which meant that you could dig through the discard pile that was currently non-existent so in the first of all round of the game one person did the diviner side and then we pretty much just did a little home actions and then went to the next round and it seemed like it's definitely possible in the first couple rounds of the game for it to feel slow and for them to not feel like there is a huge variety of worker placement spots I feel like maybe you should have drawn +1 to the player count or something like that I don't think it's necessarily a problem but once you get to the later stages of the game it really opens up and you have tons of options but based on the shuffle of those those locations it is possible to have kind of a weird slow start it doesn't slow the game down but it might be slow as far as the number of interesting actions available to you because you just pulled out a tile of it's not particularly good for you at the beginning of the game for positive number three let's discuss the asymmetric characters you can play in the game now I was expecting them to add a nice bit of variety to the game and in general I really enjoy asymmetry in board games in general but I was not expecting them to be as different from
each other as they actually are you have a big variety of actions you have a flame in for instance they can go into places and burn up all of the books on the spot so that nobody else has access to them and then they get some bonuses for that you have a mummy who can actually in tune with cards underneath previously shelled cards so that they can and they get a couple points for doing that you have a character that can actually pull cards off of the board as they get to started and pull them into your hand there's just this wide variety of different strong actions that you can do and based off of which character you choose you're gonna be playing a different game each time we sit down because there's gonna be different pacings to how they all work like some of them will just naturally have a much bigger hand of cards so you're gonna be more oriented towards trying to get your shelving going faster whereas others like the mummy for instance he's going to have a harder time having a big shelf at the end of the game but they're gonna get a bunch of bonus points for having entombed all these cards underneath now there's an obvious thing that comes up when you have asymmetries especially strong asymmetry Seng games and that is do they feel balanced at the end of the day and this is a tricky thing to answer I have not played the game enough times to have an authoritative stance on this I haven't seen every single one of them played just yet but it does seem like the scores at the end of the games have been relatively tight and I have a hard time feeling that they are totally balanced just because there are 12 of them and they do such a wide variety of things I do think some of them feel like they are more flexible in a larger set of circumstances whereas others are only good in a finite set of circumstances and they're the theme of them is fun and I like the variety but I do feel like
some of them are just a little bit more fun to play than others but that is probably going to vary on people's personal preferences for how they like to play games for instance if you don't like being really interactive maybe you don't take the fire imp so you're not blowing things up and maybe if you like having control you trying to draft it in a sense right it's a symmetric character that lets you draw a bunch of cards for instance for positive number four I just want to briefly talk about the great theming of this game and specifically how it integrates over to the mechanics in the game you have a wonderful art all over the place and it really feels like you are building a library in front of you from a mechanical and thematic perspective because you're putting all of these cards full of books down in front of you and the books have hilarious names every single time we've played we are constantly quoting the various names of books that we're seeing on them there are great puns and it's just really great to see that stuff down in front of you but then you also have the actual work replacement spots you go to they feel like what they're supposed to be if it's a community center then you're gonna take a card and then donate a card to somebody else if it's a mystery shack then you're going to be guessing a card and then digging in there and see if you found the right stuff if it's then you are going to be doing gambling between you and your opponents is just all this great mechanical somatic integration going on there's even a draft house like a brewery but then you do a pool draft in the middle of the table you also have this with the asymmetric player powers if you're a flame if it makes sense that you're gonna burn up all these books and if you are a mummy it makes sense that you're gonna be entombing all these cards down below it just I like I love the theme in general and I love how it actually plays over to the mechanics as you're playing
the game it it feels like a great integration to me it's now time to move over into a few neutral points and the first of these has to do with symbol management now there are six different types of books and as you are playing these books down into your shelf you are going to need to keep track of the amount of symbols you have not only how many do you have of the prominent work so that you can make sure to try and be in contention to have the most of those at the end of the game but more importantly you need to have a well-rounded bookshelf because you're gonna score three points for every book you have of the least of all the books you have so you're constantly trying to figure out how many books you have in the five non banned categories and that could be a bit tedious especially near the end of the game when you might have 10 plus cards out in front of you you will oftentimes be sitting there being like okay how many greens do I have how many yellows do I have how many residue I have okay I need green and then you get maybe a green in the next turn you're like wait which one was I low on okay how many greens do I have how many else do I have how many reds and then you go through all three okay okay now I need Reds and this is important because you can get a lot of points for making sure you have a balanced library but it could be just a little bit of a headache it's not really just looking at the different books you have in front of you but also then looking out to your opponents and trying to count over and over again how many books they have of the prominent works I almost wish there was some sort of tracker in the game that you could just have this be public knowledge because you are oftentimes looking over you like one two three your count like okay thirteen yeah maybe I missed one I'm gonna recount and that can definitely eat up a little bit of time which is not the end of the world doesn't take up a 2monkeys amount of time but it can be a bit annoying and it is important to do this and this is why
it is a neutral point because it's not to the worst thing in the world and I like the mechanics that come from this kind of tedious task that you need to do I enjoy the act of actually trying to balance all these books out I think mechanically that is quite interesting so I deal with it but it is a it frustrating for neutral number two let's talk about the role of luck in this game now there is a massive one hundred fifty-two card deck of books that you're gonna be dealing from in a wide variety of ways throughout the game now most of the locations get dealt out face-up and that's fine you know that's one way to deal with luck of the draw is well you see what the options are and he trying to go in there and draft that card or buy the card in one way or another but there are lots of times where you are doing blind draws for instance with your home actions you just draw a card from the top there are also many locations that have you doing something that can have quite a bit of luck variants like with the gambling den you go there and then you just say okay I call blue and then you deal out you've drawn these four cards and maybe your opponent calls yellow and they might have just been lucky that you they happened to draw more yellow than blue and then they get stuff and you didn't get anything for that turn or there are other cards where you just are mining deep into that deck you maybe draw three or four cards and they may or may not work for you and look at the drawings gonna become present in all of these situations you have the mysterious attic or shed or something like that that has facedown cards and you have to call a specific color and you get all the cards of that color but you could just whiff entirely and so all these things are luck based and this is a game that you just need to go into it understanding that like you might get frustrated if
you seem to have a run of bad luck and that can't happen but you will also have great moments of pulling the perfect card from the top of the deck and I think in general this they outweigh each other or they balance out so that I don't think that luck of the draw is necessarily a problem especially considering how many of the locations draw cards face up into the middle so that you have some control over when you're gonna grab those cards based off of the player order but it's definitely something to know that this is a tactical game where you are constantly dealing with how luck happens to you and trying to do the best you can versus having long-term strategic tendrils going all over the place you need to be quite quick footed jumping around and dealing with the good luck that comes your way as well as the bad luck because both are going to happen to you for neutral number three let's now discuss the role of player order in this game and it is no surprise that this is a work placement game which means that going earlier in player order is a good thing because you get first dibs at those worker placement spots but the tweak that this game has on that general feeling is that there is variance in how important it is to go first from one round to the next and you're not gonna know until the next round when you deal out those new worker placement spots because you will have situations where you might be going forth and you're like you know what I'm just as my first act I'm gonna go to that diviner side I'm gonna take the start player token just gonna draw one card which is unfortunate but I'll be start player for the next round and you get to the next round and you deal out the car the locations and you're like oh it doesn't matter but like they get based off of what came out it might not be that important to actually go first but you could have other situations where you decided to
actually hedge your bets well not hide your bets I guess and just risk it and do other things with your actions and not take start player and then the perfect locations come out too and that is just one more variance that comes to the game it's one more luck of the draw that you really can't account for and you just have to go into the game understanding that there you're gonna have situations like this and I've seen people get a little bit frustrated with it it has not been a big deal and I don't think there's necessarily a flaw with the way that player order works in this game but it it's just one more luck of the draw thing to keep in mind and I do as one last thing when I mentioned that I do think the diviners Hut is a interesting idea because when you go to that spot you take cards equal you drag you to draw cards for the top of the deck equal to the number of assistants that you have already placed which means it's an incentivized location like in the early part of the round you're less likely to want to go there because the longer you wait the more cards you get to draw from the top of the deck but the longer you wait the more likely it is for somebody else to jump in on that spot but the thing is that I found it's more often than not better for you to actually just go there as the your first action if you are in the very end of the play order because well if you wait for that second round well the start player they've also already placed down a worker so if they have become incentivized to go there before you and they're gonna get to draw two cards in that moment they kind of have still have first dibs so like I like the idea the way it becomes a growing incentive but I think it does not actually help out people and the lower ends of the player order as I first thought but anyway that's pretty much everything I had to say about that it's it's not a problem with the game it's just a little bit of a rough point
that has come up a couple times we've now reached the negative points section and I only have one to cover but it's pretty important to the overall gameplay experience and that is a form over function issue with this game specifically it seems like they have prioritized the beautiful art and seaming of the game slightly too much and it starts to impede on the actual play of the game in two primary ways the first has to do with the hand of cards that you have in front of you these are going to be all of the book cards and they have the letter that they're supposed to be in the top left which is fine it shows you the number it is within that letter which is also fine the issue is the icons for the different types of books now I understand why those icons are along the top of the book from a thematic perspective because they kind of line up with the books that are graphically underneath them and the books are hilarious and I really like the way all those look out on the table but what this means is when you try to hold a hand of these cards it can be kind of frustrating for you to figure out not only what symbols you have but also how they match up to the various letters you almost need to stack them vertically in your hand which is very odd to do we've been using card holders at home and I kind of lay them at a diagonal so I can see all of them and see all the relevant information I feel like they should have put these icons on the left hand side of the card as well or just done that instead and I know that that wouldn't look as good because they would not directly correlate to the books that they are out on the card but it'd be so much easier to just hold this hand of cards and see exactly all the information you need to have it's just an issue with that important information being obscured by the way most people
hold cards so the other issue I have has to do with the worker placement locations they have a beautiful artwork on them but they also have the text for the location and a very tiny font that is written on top of the the art itself which means it's very busy it's hard to read it's almost impossible to read it upside down I found which happens often times when you're playing games everybody's sitting around a table and this means that it's just difficult also there is a lot of text on some of these because they're complicated actions and you oftentimes need to look back to the rulebook and make sure that you're not missing a key interaction that was omitted from the actual card itself and I feel like the design of these locations should have been half of the location is beautiful art and the other half is everything you need to know to actually have that spot in larger text that would be I mean even if the text was the same size it'd be way easier to read if it was on a constant steady background in the back as opposed to being on top of all this beautiful artwork so both of these have definitely impeded the overall gameplay experience it is not to derailed the overall game but I do think that they could have been done a lot better let's now discuss the variability for ex libris and I think it is definitely more than I expected for a worker placement game of this wait this comes from two main spots - the first is the asymmetric player abilities you could draft at the beginning of the game there are 12 of them to choose from which is a large variety right there also they play pretty differently from one another based off of how you are the pacing of your putting books into your shelves as well as how you're gonna be interacting
with the worker placement spots in the middle of the board but the other thing has to do with that really interesting worker placement location shuffling mechanic the fact that you have random ones come out at the beginning of every single turn is gonna keep the game fresh from one term to the next but also from one game to the next the way that you're actually gonna pull up to the permanent ones is gonna be different based off of the shuffle of the location cards and I think both of these come together to be a really great amount of variability in this game xle pers plays two to four players and I've played all of those player accounts and I'm happy to say that I think it's good at all of them but I do think the game is better with more players around the table which means that four player is best and two players probably worst although I did enjoy my two-player game the reason for this is twofold the first has to do with the number of action work placement spots that come out in the beginning of the game the less people you have the more likely it is you have weird starts where you can't actually really use the cards that come out in a two-player game you always will in all player accounts you start with the diviners head but in a two-player game you're gonna draw just one more location and it might have no impact on the game at that moment it might interact with the cards you have Shelby already but you haven't shelled anything or it might let you dig through the discard but you don't have a discard pile yet which means for that first turn one person is probably gonna go to the diner hut and then every other action is just plunk down onto your home actions and they these terms go quickly because well in the beginning of the game these home actions are probably gonna be you just drawing cards to the top of the deck to try and fill out and see how you're actually going to be shelving stuff but from an interesting decision perspective that can be kind of low for those first
couple turns now this is not gonna happen every time it's just gonna be luck of the draw and the more players you have around the table the more likely the little more action spaces you're gonna have and the more likely you're gonna have interesting spots to go to right from the beginning of the game the other thing is that the game ends when you have 16 cards in your bookshelf at the end of the game with a two-player game and only twelve cards for a four player game and as I mentioned in the neutral points this game can be a bit of a headache with managing all those symbols so in a two-player game that is a much bigger tableau of cards and symbols that you're managing and counting and recounting to make sure that you are balancing everything correctly I think ending the game where somebody has 12 or more cards is better because you just have less to kind of shuffle around in your head and of course this does mean that you are counting out the prominent works for three different opponents as opposed to two or one opponent but yeah in the end I like the way it felt the best at four but I enjoyed all three of those platter counts in conclusion I've played ex-libris three times at this point and I've enjoyed all three of those plays the game has exceeded my expectations because when I went into this game after reading the rules I was expecting it to be okay I was a little worried about the fiddle enos of trying to deal with all of those different symbols and that did end up being a little bit of a headache that I mentioned before but what I wasn't expecting was the great semantic integration of the mechanics to what you're actually doing on the table also just the fun of the art and a style and all the different puns on the books and also the asymmetric player powers making the game feel pretty different from one game to the next all of these things
really seemed to work well together despite the fact that I have some graphical design issues with not only how to actually hold these cards to see the relevant information but also to actually read out the specifics of what the locations do in the middle of a table I think those could have been done better but what I actually have is a game where I enjoy the decisions in it I like trying to figure out the moment to actually start putting these books down into my shelves I like the puzzle of figuring out how I'm gonna actually do that am I gonna go for a long and skinny just to rochelle for am I gonna go nice and tall with three different rows and you know what point in the alphabet am I going to commit to putting this one here or this one there to grow the different things out in different directions I like all of these decisions in many tableau building style games like you have Arboretum where you are placing all of these trees down into various patterns trying to score that one also has a feeling of when do I commit to actually putting the cards down and I like that feeling here as well I also like well it almost has like a keltus feel like this kind of game where you have to decide when is a gap between cards too big to actually play with you know you look at this this D card and then you look at this P card and you're like am I really gonna put them next to each other I might because of the other cards I have in my hand I have a whole bunch of WS and x's and maybe this is just a game where I'm gonna go really low and I like those decisions I'm trying to figure out how big to jump versus trying to dig and wait out to find the right cards that fill in that those gaps because at the end of the game you're probably gonna only have between 12 and 17 cards or so in your
tableau based off of the player count I also really like the wide variety of worker placement spots that are in this game there are eight different 18 different locations and they do everything I've pretty much ever seen and where her placement games do my wife Jessica brought up that it had a fabled fruit vibe to it because this is a game of sight collection with a bunch of wacky worker placement spots that you know one creates a pool draught situation and another one lets you put cards in the table for people to buy them from you but then you get to draw cards like there are definitely some similarities there but I think that is probably because fabled fruit as well as leaked ex libris are games that are playing off of other work of placement games and looking to for inspiration from a wide variety of other worker placement games because these are both the type of game where you just put all these actions into a stack and then you reveal them at certain times I guess and fabled fruit there's a specific order but in ex libris you're gonna be randomizing it and putting Mountain little the table and I love the variety of different spots and I know that this is not gonna be great for everyone in fact one person in particular I played with felt like it was a bit too much having the worker placement spots change that drastically from one round to the next and so I think this is gonna be personal preference my preference is I enjoy that variety I think it's neat seeing what the new ones are gonna be in singing those are other ones go away and you know that you discard those locations you're not going to be getting back to those it's like I've I've played one game where we went through every single location in the deck usually we almost went through the whole deck we've never recycled those locations and
put them back out there so the ones that go away their one and done locations for this game and I think that's just a neat idea so at the end of the day I recommend this game I think it is a fun time I think the pacing is good most of the games have played around an hour which is maybe a little bit faster than I expected and I just like all the decisions I'm doing even though I am a little bit annoyed at some of the graphical design decisions so yeah I recommend ex-libris you should definitely give this one a shot if any of this multitude of great things in the game appeal to you as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting my channel through patreon including all of these producer level pledges if you two would like to support the channel you could do so at patreon.com slash strong it's games and I'd really appreciate it also if you'd like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching