Garum Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at garum which is a 2-4 player board game designed by ricardo jorge gomez and published by pythagoras this game accommodates two to four players and takes 30 to 40 minutes to play so despite this amazingly compelling cover here and the theme about making fish sauce this game is actually an abstract strategy game with tile placement area control so the board is going to look like this we have all these different bowls here divided into four different sections and some of these sections also have little symbols on which um i'll kind of explain the the reasoning behind that later um you've also got all these different notches around the bowls here on the vertical and horizontal axes each player is going to have their own bunch of pieces which is going to consist of a stack of tiles you're going to have four of those tiles in your hand at any time you've got a little scoring reference here and you've got a bunch of meeples one of which is slightly bigger than the others which can affect scoring um quite significantly so this game is ultra straightforward so the first thing you're going to do is you are going to draw a coin off the top of the stack here which is going to show which which bowl is going to be in play this round so this one says 16 on it therefore we'll be playing uh we'll be playing tiles in the 16th bowl so the first player is going to take one of the tiles from their hand and then they're going to place it into um into that bowl and any of the four sections so let's just say for example i played this one here i could put it in any of these bowls in any orientation that i like and if i ever cover one of these symbols then i'm
going to get an additional point and if i ever can cover one of these symbols precisely so let's say i did that one in a future on with five came up i would get two points but we're we're playing in this bowl at the moment so let's just say i do this like so and now after i place a tile i'll have the option to place a worker on to any any kind of orientation that affects this tile so i could put it here i could put it here or i could put it here or here because they cross through this tile and the reason i want to do that is because at the end of the game wherever i have a worker i'm going to score a number of points depending on how many of my tiles or how many of my symbols are in that row or columns so at the moment in this vertical axis i've only got two of my symbols therefore i'd refer to my sheet here and have a look at what that's going to score me so at the moment that's not going to score me anything and in fact it's going to score me negative points um but if i ever get above four symbols in a row or column then i'm going to start gaining points and these do work kind of in the future as well so if i place one now i can i can actually think about building more and more symbols in that row or column which is going to affect my scoring because all scoring is done at the end of the game you don't score immediately so claiming these spots is kind of a push your luck style mechanism where you want to claim and kind of bet on yourself of getting loads of symbols in that row or column but of course you want to get there before the other people do because they can actually block you out and once once i place my tile i'm going
to have to draw up back up to four tiles to replenish my hand and then i'll go into the next player so let's just say the the blue player goes next and they're trying to do the same thing as me i'm obviously trying not to help me because as you can see all the tiles here will often affect other players so if i was to put this tile like this then i'm just going to help the other player in this row whereas i might try to try and stop doing that so let's just say the blue player played like that and then the red player would go let's just draw one out at random here there you they just just not think about too much they put it like this and then the green player will finally put their tile again not only trying to help themselves but trying not to help other people as well so that's literally going to be what a round is going to consist of in a four player game i mean you're going to keep doing that again and again until you go through all these tiles and all the regions will be filled up so once all the tiles have been placed on the board it's going to go into end game scoring and the ball is going to look something like this where all the tiles and all the bowls are put on the board and filled up and you're going to have a bunch of the meeples on the outside areas here and ready to claim those points so then you're going to calculate points depending on how many symbols of your color in your in or in your rows and columns um depending on where your meeples are so let's just use some for example scoring here so um let's just say this uh this column here for the blue player is quite a good one so you've got one two three four five six symbols and the little meeple so you'd be having a look at your little little track here
so you've got six and it's a small meeple therefore you'd only get two points so you can probably tell you want to get as many symbols as you can because the points do jump up by quite a bit so for example the green player here has done quite well in this particular row where they've got one two three four five six seven eight eight symbols down and they've actually managed to place their big meeple there therefore they would get a massive 14 points so the points do jump up quite significantly but of course as the game developed people were trying to kind of nullify your ability to do that and make sure they put different symbols in your rows and columns where you've already placed your meeples so it's a very straightforward game um but everything does affect what each player does and it's quite puzzly in that respect so i do like the way this game is broken down into three very simple phases of course the first of which just putting the tile on the board and the second of which is is the option of putting one of these meeples on the outside and i do like that mechanism of you know do you want to go in early and try and claim where you're looking good early but be aware that the other people are going to start gunning for you and then start trying to sabotage that line or column or do you want to wait until it's a bit more of a safe bet where you've got loads of loads of symbols in that row or column and then claim it to make sure you back those points but of course people may be trying to block you from doing that additionally you can't actually place a meeple in a row or column where once the third of a row or columns bowls are filled up so you are under a bit of pressure to get your meeples down which does of course increase the
probability of you suffering negative points by not reaching that four uh or above four threshold so i do like that system i think it's really cool and you just replenish up and always have a hand of four tiles so i do like the fact that this does have a good amount of kind of hand management um you are that does somewhat tunnel vision on what you can do because you can't just pick and choose the tiles you want to place on the board and of course some of these tiles are really really good so for example here you've got these like um these ones where the whole the whole tile is all made up of your symbols and you you only have one of those to play throughout the game so you really need no need to know when to place that one and of course you want to place it where you're affecting as many of your meeples as possible i'm at those crosshairs so i think it's quite a clever game it's ultra simple and you can probably tell that this almost has a throwback style feel to it where it doesn't have any bloke to the game it really is trimmed back very streamlined without any fiddliness or any any confusing rules minutiae this game has a tremendous flow to it and it does it does accurately play in about 30 to 40 minutes which i think is fantastic i think the the ratio to decisions here and the fun factor do you know are really amplified because it does play so quickly um i was remarkably surprised about how quickly this one did um just did pass by and you know before you know it the whole board is filled up um which is which is really quite exciting so i do like the fact that this is i'm really funnelled into a nice tight time frame um to keep players engaged from start to finish i mean on top of that as well the actual player's
turns aren't too confusing you know you are just restricted to one bowl at a time therefore you are really kind of well the whole uh maybe potential of getting analysis process is completely nullified so i do like that and you are constantly involved in this game and thinking about what other people do and even on other people's turns they might be you know inadvertently helping you which you're kind of excited about so i really do uh like that and that kind of ties hands with the player interaction this one i do love the way that each of the players pieces has other players symbols on as well so you know whether it's deliberately or in deliberate or indirectly you are affecting other people's rows and columns and that's really fascinating and i love the way that works and it's just completely unavoidable um additionally the aesthetics of the game is nice and clear you know the symbology you know you can't get the confused at all i'm colorblind i can see what all the different symbols are i like the fact that all the colors really do pop there's no confusion about which rows and columns your things go on and i just think all together it's a nice production package and um yeah i've got no complaints about the production whatsoever i mean even the components themselves are nice high quality the tiles are really good and strong uh the meeples are your basic meeples but you know nice wooden maples are great um yeah so i've got no complaints whatsoever and you know there's not too many components in this game just the you know just the tiles each your meeples and a scoring board each but you know that's just perfectly fine for me i think it's really well produced um theme of course this has has no theme whatsoever this is an abstract strategy
game um the actual choice of the of the theming and setting is a bit strange but i don't dislike it you know it's a it's got quite a catchy name i suppose garum and the the whole fish sauce thing is it's just completely um not even skinny but it really is a veneer on this game and it doesn't have any kind of tangible um connections to the mechanisms or anything which is which is perfectly fine for me i do really like the progression of this game and it does um really ramp up in its excitement as the more and more these bowls are filling up and you can really see the opportunity and potential of getting those higher player scores or the higher scores of getting more symbols in the rows and when you start hitting that nine and then you smash your big worker down it's absolutely great so um yeah i do like the the scoring amplifying here as well and you're not going to just do it you're not going to get loads and loads of points each time sometimes you are really going to cut it close to potentially losing points because um you know because the competition is so tight for these outer notches so yeah it's got a great kind of balancing and a great pacing and that tension of getting your workers down and knowing when to put them down is um is really good something that needs to be talked about is the scalability of this game so four players you can imagine how this will play everyone's got their own color however regardless of the player count you do play with all the tiles so whether if you play a two-player game then you take control of two colors each and if you play a three-player game then the first player whoever's first player for the round will draw a tile off the unused players and place it in that bowl which i think is actually quite a nice
way to scale the game and it does work well and you can use that to your advantage and try to hinder other players as well however there is a bit of a bit of swinginess to that when if you draw a particularly good tile that will help you then that can actually make quite a big difference to the outcome but i do think it's a nice streamlined way to scale the game but optimally you want to be playing this game at four to get the most out of it so overall for me garen was a nice pleasant surprise um i wasn't expecting lows and lows out of this game you know it's pretty simple about what this was going to achieve and what it was going for um however you know despite being a 2019 game this does have a nice throwback feel to it it's clean in its mechanisms i mean it does have a lot of fun to be had you know it does offer a lot of fun um because again you whatever you do you are either helping or hindering other people and it all goes back to that tension on when you're going to claim these rows and columns and i think just how clean it is in terms of just you know placing a towel and potentially claiming a spot and then drawing a tile you can really play this one with absolutely anybody i like the fact you are always limited to a hand of four tiles yes sometimes you're not left with the best tiles at the best times and other people might you know might fall into the favor of other people but for me that's not really an issue it does suit the game it suits the flow of the game and it just feels right and it ticks along so so quickly and on top of that i really do love the fact that these these bowls do come out in a random order and that can really change the uh the feel of the game you know sometimes the
bow will be up here then it'll be down here where and then when they start linking together and you start realizing how lucrative some of these rows and columns are to you that's when the real satisfaction starts coming into the game and i love that uh it's it's really enjoyable and you know is it going to stand up in in years and years to come am i going to still be um you know urging to play this one maybe not but for now i'm enjoying it i think this is a certainly above average game in fact way above average game and i'm actually pleasantly surprised by it and i'm certainly going to play it more and more and i think a lot of people are going to get a lot of fun out of this game so um despite its dry and bland appearance and this is a game that i'd recommend and i think this is a bit of a hidden gem so that is garum thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time