Skip to main content
Loading video...

Earthborne Trailblazer - Apparently It's a Spinoff? - Kickstarter Critique Review

Transcript 27:57

Ahoy there, YouTube. I'm back here today for another Kickstarter critique where I take a look at a different Kickstarter tabletop game project every weekday 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time giving my honest thoughts on how that project is being ran. And today, we're checking out the 22nd most popular project in all of games. Also, my Kickstarter is about to be done. If you want to support that, $30, you can sponsor your own Kickstarter critique. We're shooting 105 videos at Gen Con and Origins bringing the hottest game coverage to YouTube for use and also helping uh foot the bill for that. So, check out that link down below. It's a no bare-bones no-frills Kickstarter. That's enough said. Earthborn Trailblazer, however, the 22nd most popular project in all of Kickstarter games right now, 12 days left to go, 256% funded. Explore the wilderness of the far future, this cooperative adventure board game for one to five players. Now, I apparently Earthborn Trailblazer or Earthborn is fantastic. I've heard nothing but very, very good things about this game in quite a few times, actually. So, I'm very excited to try this game out. That being said, apparently this is a spin-off. And I want to know right from the jump, do spin-off games disappoint you when you find out a game is a spin-off game as much as it does for me?

When I find out something is like not an expansion or a stand-alone expansion, but it's a a spin-off game, most of the time I'm like, "Oh, okay. Cool. Like, I wasn't here for the world of space base, you know, or what whatever it may be." But hopefully this game is deeply thematic enough. One to five players, two hours, co-op, that excites me. As always with the video, I'm thinking three things. Do I want it? Can you do it? How much is it? Let's see how you convince 2,514 backers to give you $383,000. Oh, ex- the description, I feel like it could have more meat. I do like the fact that you mentioned it's cooperative one to five players, but you did a great job on that in the main image as well. But particularly, the mechanisms would be nice here. Is this tableau building? Is this, you know, my my engine, my bag building, am I my tile placement, you know, something else? Cuz you're not telling me anything in the description and you're not telling me anything in the main image aside from your art which by the way, I didn't talk about the main image but I think it's very not great. Like just not a great main image at all. Aside from this, I think the bottom right's great showing me two hours, one to five players, co-op, age 14 plus, that's fantastic. But just showcasing artwork here and hoping that people know what Earthborn is. Hate the main image. I just think it's objectively not good. But that, that's fantastic. I would make that bold.

One minute, wow, solid. For the creators of Earthborn Rangers. So right there, we're five seconds in. So the can you do it is slightly done here. But I would put some awards there, right? You're you're wasting your time here. Like that was five seconds right there of just that. Why not slap some awards here, slap some rankings, something like that I think would be nice there to bring me into the Earthborn universe. But either way, I like it being there. Can you do it? Yes. Oh, it's art. Animated art for a board game, cool. Ooh, that was a nice seamless transition. Uh looking good on the cards, decent amount of text, decent amount of Ooh, a nice me- And I go back to the main image and how much I don't like the main image. Like this I think is, you know, not a great main image but I think it's a much better main image. Just okay, here's some artwork, here's some cards, here's some cool looking meeples, especially if you zoomed in a little bit.

We like this panning shot. Hey, it's art. Moving art. Oh, transition to the board. Explore the wilderness of the future. Okay, now we're talking gameplay. Man, that panning shot's getting old. Mhm. There's art. Oh, oh, hey, it's it's a card. Uh spend a trail marker in the region with a latrine hole to let Scamp play with his family. Gain two XP and soothe all your fatigue. So take a kitty to go play with the other kitties. That sounds fun. Okay, there's artwork down there. Okay, that's nice. I do like that scrolling that that whoop. Oh, that's the whole thing. Uh this little guy has been following you ever since you bumped into him. Again, it seems like he's being separated from the rest of his rump. He seems happy enough to follow you for the time being, but maybe you should bring him home. Oh, so now it's like oh, I can have this card or I can bring him home and I have a choice and something's going to happen ala Robinson Crusoe, which means like like ah and then I'm looking at these player boards here. It looks like they're dual layer player boards where I'm sliding tokens into various different spots and it looks like there's a good deal of text underneath this, which is just the very tip top of the player board. Fantastic stuff that I'd love to see more of.

Instead of this. Like hey, they're they're climbing. Neat. I don't care. More art. Yippee. Now we're talking. There we go. All the components, all the animals. Look at all those cards. How many cards is that? 300? You got a huge chunk of cards there. That shot. So much better than everything in the main image. Unless you're just here for artwork, which is not most people. Earth Board Games creates breathtaking so you did one thing. You did Earth Board Rangers. It was a big success? Question mark? I do believe from what I understand. Let's find out in the comments. People are saying they love it. Hello guys, since almost a year there's no update. What's the status? So far the answer was always update is coming soon or something like that. Please give us an update. It feels like we are completely forgotten. So that's not the greatest first message that we love to see when we're doing the can you do it aspect. Uh hi Jan, we plan to have an update very soon. As for my last comment. So let's see it make sure they did. I'm sure they did if they launched this. Yeah, so they announced Air Trailblazers.

Uh oh hey, German edition of Legacy of the Ancestors update. So I'm going to guess that is specifically probably So it looks like it's a international shipping issue. Could you complete an update for the German version, please? Today I finally received the Legacy of the Ancestors expansion in Australia to complete the game. Oddly, like the original box the packaging is at least twice the size it needs to be with two of the four compartments completely empty. Yuck. Everything fits easily in the original box as expected. The campaign is extensive filling a fairly thick A5 booklet in the box and map art are great as usual. The tokens are printed on good quality thick cardboard. My only issue being that they need some care to punch out. Uh so it looks like great custom great components here. Awesome. That that game sounds fun. Can you please tell us the update we expect for the German version? So yeah. Cool.

So can you do it? Yes, looks like they had a snafu with shipping to Germany which, you know, first time game publishers international shipping it sucks. I did a 500 print run once. That's my extent of my knowledge and it sucked whenever I had to do the international shipping which was not much. So yeah, international shipping never fun, but if you want to make your game worldwide, then obviously very necessary. So can you do it? Yeah, I'm going to go with the yeah on that. Wow, we got a lot of woo 1 2 3 4 5 6 7. We got a lot of too many drivers too many drivers behind the wheel. It's good let me smooth music. Earthborn trailblazer funk that's funk I think or blues that's blues not funk it's blues. Earthborn trailblazer so it's a square box. Okay, reasonably sized box does that mean a reasonably sized price?

Am I getting this for 80 bucks? 60 bucks honestly would be the reasonable price, but I just assume it's 80 cuz you showed me the dual layer board and you showcased how fancy your art was. You had to pay somebody to do the art probably. Okay, that player board those look hot. I want to play that player board. I want to customize this thing. All right, a game crafted to nourish your mad love. 80 bucks. Okay, feels reasonable 20 bucks off MSRP sure. I don't feel that, but hey I feel like 80. So the deluxe is $70 price jump. So first and foremost, if you don't have an expansion for this deluxe, I feel like you have done an atrocious job selling me this deluxe because I, at first glance, after watching that video, cannot tell you what I think is going to be in the deluxe aside from card sleeves and probably some stupid dice roller. Play mat? Is it just that?

I don't know. Let's see if they got you on the extra 70 bucks. Oh, why why isn't this in the video? Uh deluxe component Oh, why isn't that on the main image? Like it's a cool-looking tree and then there's an expansion there as well. Yeah, I feel like this should probably be the main image. So, we got an expansion, we got a cool dice roller, we got the deluxe components. We don't even have the We don't even have the the card sleeves. So, 150 That one feels it feels fine. Right? Cuz you're essentially asking me to put a value on that and it's like I mean it's yeah. It feels It doesn't feel great, but it feels fine. Kickstarter reasonable. Moving on. You're going to get me the extra 120? I don't think so. I just I don't. At this point, I think it's just going to be Oh, it's a book. It's an art book.

Uh oh, is that No! Icky! So, if I pay 150 bucks, I don't actually get all the content for your game? No, that's the thing for Earthborn Rangers. Oh, that's for the the original one. Okay. So, deluxe component upgrade kit here. 70 bucks. Book, don't care. Limited edition art prints, don't care. Exclusive all in Ranger badge, don't care. So, collecting dust, three things. What's that though? What's the Earthborn Rangers? That's the one thing that I care about. Oh, Visitors from Afar expansion. Yeah, cuz that's not for this game, that's for the other game. It just feels like it's kind of plopped in there. Hopefully, that's also an add-on cuz I can't imagine most people are going to want to do the 120 price jump for your art book {slash} art {slash} knickknack that's going to collect dust.

Uh four limited edition art prints uh for 50 bucks? What size are these? That'd be nice to know. If you're going to If you're going to gouge me 12.50 for a picture, at least I I'd like to know the size of the picture. Good for the artists. I mean, good for them. They are They are banking on those. Yeah. Gameplay overview. Hey, yeah. Why not mention that? That'd be fun. Uh step one, prepare. Cool. Step two, explore. Step three, travel. How to play? Excellent. Love seeing that. Love that way higher. Gameplay preview. Okay, so here we go. 380 card library. Why is this so far down? You were trying to get me to do the price earlier and I felt like your price wasn't great. But it felt fine. I think this would help.

380 cards. Great. Does that saying 380 cards total? I think that's what they're saying. Which is what I wanted to know. 40 predator meeples, 40 prey meeples, 20 ranger meeples. So we got 140 meeples. So once again, I'm going back to that $80 value. How you going to sell me it's an $80 value? It's got 380 cards. It's got 140 fancy-looking meeples and counting. It's got five dual-layer player boards. 10 royal courts, 145. So we got five extra player meeples there. Cool. Add-on, 40 bucks. So this is All this you're telling me is 40 bucks. Fine. It's fine. Doesn't feel great. Feels Kickstarter reasonable. Visitors from afar expansion, you tell me this one's 30 bucks. How many cards is it?

Love to know that number. Thanks for not telling me. Uh I'm going to guess 100. That's a lot of cards. I want that. I need that. Done. I'm immediately the 150. I think most people are totally going to get there and I imagine that's going to be the most popular pledge level. And the Earthborne Rangers. Wow. Is it Are these at least tarot cards or is this literally just a tuck box of cards for $25? I I I sincerely hope that these are at least slightly larger than normal cards and you are not just gouging your customers for $25 for a tuck box of cards. And then not just not just $25 but saying hey hey hey hey you're getting a deal. You're getting a deal cuz it's going to be 30 bucks with the MSRP.

All right? Which by the way, that is 50 cents per card. We're We're doing some math here. Yeah, that one's roughly So, 26 bucks. It doesn't feel great. A new mission path set but I guess it is it's gameplay but it's uh yeah. And they're trying to convince me that I need to do that $120 price jump by bumping that up but at the end of the day it's just like yeah yeah no thanks. But that being said if I'm a fan I do want that. Yeah, I bet there's going to be some people complaining about the price of that. Uh the lore book 45 bucks yikes and beyond the things we made the first game is cool people liked it. Returning backers um Wow, that is a you you know what I got to read a lot for returning backers. Okay, let's get into it. If you're a returning backer if you purchased it before in Rangers at retail you may be wondering how Earthborn Trailblazers relate to EBR and whether or not it's right for you. Hopefully this section will help answer the question. Video would have been nice for that too, you know, instead of just panning over components followed by panning over moving artwork followed by panning over components followed by panning over moving artwork. You know, this would be a great thing to do.

Earthborn Trailblazers a brand new game system that has a more zoomed out fast play experience. For example, it's played in single sessions as opposed to the things stuff cool. Earthborn Trailblazer is a game under development. There's that is we're still working on it. When you see on the project page it's a fair representation of our vision but it's not the final product. Holy golly. Oh, so that's that's that's the entire vision with the expansions and everything. Okay. For example, the core design is complete, but we still have a lot of individual cards still to develop. Hmm. Similarly, we've estimated the look of the board, but only about completed around 20% of the illustrations. When is this thing coming out? When is that coming out? This is coming out August 2027. Okay. Next year Gen Con. Uh what do we got? United States. Where am I? Where am I? Where am I? I'm the Come on, people. Why is this Why do I have to go searching for the place that's going to have Lower 48? You even called it the Lower 48.

Why would you lead with Hawaii and Alaska then just Lower 4 I just Okay. Whatever. They're from Minnesota, too. Like it's so confusing. It's not like they're from Taiwan or something. Like I don't know. This is supposed to be Lower 48. Whatever. Whatever. All right. So, uh yeah, it doesn't feel great. So, 442 people access to the pledge manager. So, that sounds to me like 442 people were like, "Yeah, I just want to buy that thing for that game that I like." Okay. $50.

[sighs]

Oh, hey, you actually told me the size of the art print. That's nice at least. Four people took your art prints, including that meeple. Okay. $80. Once again, it feels fine. Once we get to the shipping, it's up to $100, which doesn't feel great. But it doesn't feel terrible. I also I also want to check out cuz I feel like they mentioned their game a lot, but I don't think they put necessarily enough respect on their game's name, I think. Cuz like yeah, here we go. Like boom. Best solo board game nominee. Best cooperative board game nominee. You know, like it's like best gift from a small publisher. But you like this is what the kind of thing you should spotlight be like, "All right, so this is I just it seems like an odd oversight to just assume that people know what Earthborn is and not like just showcase like, "Hey, we won a bunch of awards and stuff. Like people really love this." It helps with the can you do it, it helps with the do I want it, and it helps uh I think a little bit with the how much is it cuz that's a combination of everything. But let's check out these pledges once again. So 390 people said, "I need the core box, just the base game." That number feels pretty high from what we normally see, which makes me wonder if this Oh, why am I zoomed in so much? Uh if this is going to be a rough cuz this is going to be the most popular pledge level. And I think that next one is going to be a little bit of a wet fart.

1218. Oh, boy. Wasn't it Okay, and then this one is 438. So good for them. Like good for them. That's still a 500 print run. But yeah, good for them. They're They're making so much cash off their art. Right? This game could be just

[snorts]

this game could end up rating 17,000 on BGG, but the amount of money they made for their art is going to like can you do it? Yeah. Yeah, because they undoubtedly want to make What is this? I don't know. 500 print run of these these posters? Thou- like minimum, right? A thousand print run cuz how much are these things probably going to cost once you start jumping those numbers? Uh also, you know, a 500 print run of that generic-looking badge, right? Like, "Oh, hey." And And you're like, "What Who cares? Who cares if they have an extra 500 of those things laying around?" Like, who's going to want those? And I And I say it like that's just a little extra sweetener so that selling things after the fact, right? Or when they launch a campaign in the future and they need to have something that they can add a value to some a campaign like cuz this is a Yeah. What is this thing called? The exclusive all in Ranger but I don't even know.

It's just good for them. Good for them. They are making a lot of money off their art, so I'm going to give them a third of a point grade bump up for cuz this this whole show is about how I feel like the publishers are running the project and the amount of money they're making off their art. I am begrudgingly giving them a third of a point grade bump up even though I I'm not an art guy. Just not. I hate how many people purchase board games and art is one of the main reasons they do it because I think it just leads to very bad habits in the crowdfunding sector where people feel like they can get away with launching half-baked games just because they have delightful art and delightful components. And I am in no way saying that is what Earthborne doing. I haven't played the first game, haven't played this game, but we've all played those games where you're like, oh, I see why this got made. Uh does the Earthborne book contain new information not contained in the world book from previous Earthborne campaigns? Yeah, I think that's what we're all asking. Yes, this expanded world book will contain all the information, cool. Let's check out the updates, comments, give this one a grade. Hi everyone, we have a very special update for you today. If you haven't already come across the video on the project page, Andrew Fisher, Evan Schmetz, and I drove down to Tulsa last month to spend time with Team Covenant and show off the vertical slice of Earthborne Trailblazer. It was a powerful trip and all because we were able to spend our time with Zach and his team. Uh so this is the what? Uh the our company's mention this so this is about how our company's uh helping

people, cool. I've seen two Earthborne Rangers people defending Aboriginal land in Brisbane, Australia. This game brings people together, reminds them of cooperative power, and imagines a positive future for those who care for the land. Okay, that's neat. That's awesome. I mean cool. Okay, it's amazing to see it's Haley who wrote the amazing climate scientist BGG review. Great video that resonates a lot about what makes this game so special. Which Andrew is this? Uh okay. It's like plant. Sometimes I just Sometimes I suspect like are these real people? Uh I've never seen a game in the same universe as another where people's minds are so blown at the fact that it's not expansion or re-implementation. It's like people have never played board games before and completely flabbergasted at the concept of a Pandemic Legacy type game existing alongside an LCG type game.

Um I don't know if it's blowing their mind, but they're probably just like me disappointed, right? Like I love this thing. I want more of this thing. They're like, "Oh, here's a different thing that we like there's another thing we're doing." And it's just yeah. They're disappointed probably. I asked some specific questions at the beginning of the campaign, but it was either ignored or not seen. Here we go. Get some juicy stuff. If someone can answer it, it might be able to make a decision. I'm currently experiencing fatigue and don't really want to watch videos about this topic. I just want my question answered. Maybe later I'll be in a better headspace to sit and watch things, which is why it's important that you let me know everything without making you sit through videos. Like it's great when you have videos down there, but do you want to sit through a 30-40 minute video, especially if they don't put quotes from it? Here's my question. Is this a sequel or a prequel to the original game? Does this game act as an expansion to the original or is it a quicker, easier access version of it?

What makes it better or different than its predecessor? I'll check the FAQ, but if you have a quick answer, perhaps you could share it with me. Thanks. And this is from 23 hours ago. So this is like they're a week into this campaign, and this is a big question. Kind of wild to not just read anything about the campaign before jumping into the comments sections. It says after the events of Rangers, but supposedly we won't spoil much of the plot. Rangers is a cooperative campaign card-based. This is a single-session exploration game. Well, they did bury that section at the bottom instead of, you know, putting it at the top where people need it. Period, right? Like if I'm an Earthborn fan, I need that piece of information. If I'm not an Earthborn fan, well I don't need that information. It's still nice information to know. Right? Because I honestly, when I created this, thought, "Oh, cool. It's an expansion.

So, now I can learn all about the base game." And it was like, "Oh, no. Disappointment. It's just a stand-alone. It's the founding What is it? The Foundations of Gloomhaven. Hooray!" The story is set a year after the things of the events Thanks, James and Luke for joining in. The game will continue with 10 roles to the five roles upgrade with XP. Cool. They're doing a good customer service here. Looks good. And I That doesn't surprise me, right? This is their second game. I I can't imagine they're going to sleep behind the wheel. So, do I want it? Um no. Not really. I don't feel like you did a particularly great job of selling me on it. Actually, that video like there's Yeah. I'll I'll go with I'll go with a begrudging kind of.

I don't feel like they did a great job. But, I think if you look at their pedigree, if you look at their track record, they don't have a rule booklet? Where's the gameplay video? So, this is this is a how to play video. It is not the same as a rule booklet, but it is fantastic. Okay. This is a gameplay preview. So, awesome. Why is it

like this comes up

Okay, so it's kind of like And these are both you. Got it. But, you're showing them to people. Whatever. Rule booklet would still be nice. So, do I want it? Can you do it? Yeah, I'm not worried about that at all. The end of the day, they're banking so obnoxiously hard on those stupid art prints. And it's just good for them. Good for them. Good for them.

They're doing And And I hope I hope they just squeeze the pennies out of this one. They're like, "Yeah, we're going to do a 486 like the bare minimum print run of these and just cash out on those. Just cash out on that art. They're not going to though, because you know, they could they could make a massive more print run and they could probably sell these in the back end cuz they just look like generic looking artwork from one of their games and they could sell them later on. So, good for them. Good for them. That is how that is a smart business decision. I still So, so can you do it? Yeah. I'm not worried about that. They also have pretty much said, "Hey, hey everybody. We're not really super close on getting this game done." Now, they dropped it all the way down at the bottom in like a little section you actually had to read.

But, they did warn you. Right? So, can you do it? Yes. And then how much is it? It feels It just feels eh. The expansion to your original game at $25 and slapping me in the face and saying, "Oh, but you should be happy it's $30." Not a fan. $50 for your art prints when you're not even going to tell me the size over here. You did over here, so kudos on that. I'll take that. But still, just that's Oh, hey, look, you can draw pictures. And it's great, but it's just This is your second game and you don't have like a famous artist. Like you're not Vincent Dutrait here. It just I don't know, but from a business perspective, I get it. They're banking. They have a 500 print run of their art at $12.50 a pop. Then we get to the base game at $80. I didn't feel the value of it and I think that's because you did a poor job showcasing your gameplay, right? Like your video was not helpful.

It like teased it like vaguely what was going to be in the game and then you're just like, "Hey, 80 bucks." I'm like, "Hey, that's $20 more than MSRP." And then you're just like, "Hey, but now you got to have this stupid looking tree in the expansions." I say, "Well, I don't need that, but I want it. And I don't need those, but I want them. And I do need that. So, I say, "All right, $70, fine. I will make that jump with you and 1,200 people, which is the majority? Question mark. That's 800. Uh that's 12:38. So, yeah, it's pretty much one-to-one this pledge to all the other pledges combined. And that's counting the 443 people who are just like, "All right, fine. I'll pay $25 freaking for the expansion of this game I love, even though these cards I'm never going to see because they probably already pulled all the cards." But, whatever. That plays to the completionist, and they are playing to those people, so good for them.

[sighs]

And then we get to the stupid obnoxiously $270, $150 price jump that I don't feel like they sold very well at all. But, if I want that, and if I like I yeah, good for them. Good for them. Good for them. Final grade, main image, not a fan. Video, eh, go either way. But, at the end of the day, like they're making a lot of money on stupid stuff. Stupid non-gameplay stuff. And from a company perspective, that's fantastic, right? Uh I I I can think of, you know, I've helped uh over Grey Fox Games from time to time. Like I said, I I helped tear down their booth one year. Uh and and I'm friends with Lance there, and and I've seen they had like this this this binder that's full of just cards, and they're just promo cards. It's like a big binder, it's just full of promo cards. You just flip through it, like and you go, "All right, all promo cards." And people just come, and they will buy those promo cards all the livelong day. And there's going to be people, when they have conventions, they're going to come, and they're going to buy those art prints all the livelong day, and they're going to buy those promo cards all the livelong day. So, as much as I hate it, and as much as I think it's not the best thing for the hobby in general, for them as a publisher, it's smart, and I'm giving them the third of a point good bump up.

That being said, the grade is still not not not good, I don't think. I mean if the biggest takeaway from this is, "Man, I'd really like to try out Earthborn." Um yeah, I'm going to go with C minus. I think that's fair. No rule booklet. Weird shippings like just some weird stuff. Yeah, C minus. Let me know in your comments below what your final grade for Earthborn Trailblazer Also, if you're enjoying the content, please be sure to click on that subscribe button down below. And if you happen to see this in the next few days, be sure to check out my Kickstarter down below. It's very bare-bones. Next year's is going to be, dare I say it, right? I think I rated it a D minus. Next year's is going to be C minus to C plus. That's the range. Actually, it'll depend on my daughter's in school or not. Let's be quite frank. If she's still if I'm still stay-at-home dadding, it might be a D. But let me know in the comments below what your final grade for Earthborn Trailblazer. Have yourself a good one. Bye-bye. Uh this is this is the exit. There's the exit. That's not what What That was a long time ago. Why is it still showing that? That's weird.

That was so long ago.

Progress saved