There Are No Toxic Gaming Communities!
Transcript
you've all heard the statements before your favorite thing be it wargaming board gaming or whatever other geeky thing you're into and more importantly the community that surrounds that thing is deeply toxic and problematic you know maybe that information came from a video from a known content creator or a scolly journal article or news Outlet or maybe it just came from some Forum post you remember reading in any event the premise is always exactly the same because a select few people say something or do something that the writer disagrees with the entire Community has a toxicity problem that you that you specifically have to deal with and call out if you want to be a proper Ally and fan I'm focusing primarily here on tabletop gaming both board gaming and War gaming but but really my feelings on this issue can be applied to any sort of hobby or fandom I mean if I went through every article suggesting that that Gamers Star Wars fans or Marvel fans or whatever fans were toxic I would spend my entire lifetime just buried in hacky Pros overly dramatic personal stories hell if you're a Warhammer fan you've experienced this type of content for decades I'm focusing on this issue because I recently watched a video from a YouTuber called tabletop minions who I'm still subscribed to and who I I still think makes really solid content his video was primarily about the concept of of hobby tourism and how it doesn't exist that's a whole different issue that requires a discussion because I I don't think he really engages with it honestly but in the video he does mention a few reoccurring bigger Concepts like like gatekeeping and just
general toxicity within the community that I really wanted to reply to and so I'm really only using that video as a springboard for a broader topic that has bothered me for years I mean pretty much ever since I got into this Hobby and it seems to come up every few months in some form or another basically just lambasting the communities and the hobbies that I love my last video had me ranking miniature war games and and man there was a ton of push back in the comment section hell I had to delete like four or five comments because instead of the usual disagreement which is totally fine some of them were just like attacks on me as a human being I could sit here and pretend like the Warhammer Community has this like deep-seated toxicity problem because they mostly came from Warhammer fans but that's that's I I I love that people get passionate enough about something to act as though you know I've just told them their child has a funny-shaped head and smells bad I respect that I think it's cool and and in a little disagreement there's nothing wrong with that at all but there's an important question you should always ask when presented with the argument that the Community is toxic compared to what so you think the board game Community is toxic because you think you overheard some players uh saying something bad about someone or or or some group or maybe you think they were mean or or dismissive to you directly okay okay that's fair that's fair I'm not discounting your experience but what is the community we are using as comparison to be the sort of Pinnacle of cooperation and positivity that that that all other communities should aspire to be there's none there's none no no Community will be free of Bad actors
hell I I play a lot of stardew Valley and I can point you to some pretty Dreadful interactions between people on the forums in that game and that's a damn game about cute little farm animals okay the fact is that none of these outlets and individuals making this argument will ever State the gold standard because no Community is perfect and that's not their goal in making the claim that a miniature gaming or or board Gaming Community is toxic well while some may have good intentions I I would argue that many don't they create the concept to generate clicks and Views because what happens is they'll get people who strongly disagree to watch and then angrily reply and they'll get the select few individuals who have had bad experiences to agree and express their views all of this all of this Fe feeds that like algorithmic Beast and elevates the notion that these communities are toxic to a level they they shouldn't occupy it has been and always will be a gross exaggeration of the truth and if you ever ask for evidence to support this this claim of toxicity you'll get the odd Forum post by by someone you don't know saying something that's either bad or being dishonestly construed as bad imagine if we applied that same level of evidence to anything else imagine if I said an entire uh uh racial group or gender or or religion has a toxicity problem because a select few individuals do bad things that are in no way tied to the tenants or or beliefs of that group or culture it would be an awful thing for me to do and for whatever reason we seem to accept it when the same criticism is
levied against the Hobbies we love more importantly the community that we love we say oh you think the Warhammer Community is toxic because because some people are upset by the inclusion of the female Space Marines well I I guess I can just ignore any other arguments or or or why they're upset and just focus on the abundance of Rage bait content by creators trying to get clicks that those people are represented of the entire Community or or what they believe is somehow intrinsically evil but that belief whether that you agree with it or not has no impact on the game or the community as if any man or woman who is curious and friendly couldn't go down to their local gamar to view a game and have a Warhammer fan just freaking pounce on them in seconds asking if they wanted to play or learn the game with such like an overwhelming abundance of excitement that it would be absolutely frightening naturally not everyone who has a conversation of toxicity within the community is is condemning the entirety of the community as a whole you I get that I get that and I'm sure most of those individuals are just trying to highlight Behavior they find unacceptable you know you you've heard it many times before such and such Community needs to do better do just do better it's a never-ending platitude at this point just do better you've got to do better Senator you've got to step up but I would argue most of the discourse surrounding toxicity within the community does attempt to malign the community itself and suggest that there is some problem inherent to the community or else why use the community as a foundation for your argument yes any given hobby given enough time and
growth will reach a point where bad people are attracted to the space board gaming is pretty huge right now right so it's totally understandable that if you go to any given public board gaming night you're going to encounter some sore losers and you know just just otherwise dicks at the table now and then like myself I'm one of those dicks who will attack you in every game I can until you hate me can you imagine if my hand was this you guys hear that you feel the Thunder the bigger the community is the more likely it is to draw in the crazies that's true of every Hobby and so it doesn't really stand as a proper uh indictment of gaming specifically and if anything it's a detriment to your own personal enjoyment of the community if you approach any Community with the belief that there is an element of toxicity within it you're priming yourself to find things that that that may not actually be there you know this sort of like confirmation bias on overload and so these articles calling the community toxic could could actively dissuade individuals from joining in the first place like imagine if you and I are buddies okay and you're going to go to some board game group and I that I've been to a few times and I told you before just before you went I said look out there may be some there board gamers they could be creeps now I've planted in your head this overly negative attitude that well it certainly could be true is in no way indicative of the group as a whole you know I I'm not helping you by saying that I'm actually setting your your expectations up for
failure and these people who harp on sort of like cherry-picked experiences I think they do more harm than good too I mean seriously do do you think legitimate Bad actors read the articles and that you wrote or the form post that you wrote about how bad the community is and then while reading say to themselves you know what I think they're talking about me I'm an I got to do better no no it's not happening like okay my first experience with board gaming at at least in regards to dealing with people uh who were not my friends within the hobby was incredibly shitty super shitty like okay story time we have a local gaming store here okay uh it's located downtown I won't give you the name of it for obvious reasons that people seem to either really love or just absolutely despise I went to the store almost two decades ago when I first started board gaming pretty seriously I wanted this new game people were all talking about called The Ticket to Ride you know maybe you maybe you've heard of it I tried to find it and I I couldn't for the life of me locate it in the store and the store was kind of a mess you know there was there was just everywhere I figure I'll ask a sales Associated right so I get to the counter and the guy is talking to some other dude about about magic The Gather you could tell they're like super passionate enthusiastic so so why give it a couple minutes right like I'm I'm Canadian so I'm trying to be polite here and not interrupt but eventually I have to jump in right I got places to be so I ask them nicely if they have it right the dude looks at me if the Dude Looks at me and says uh we're talking about a real game here and it was rude of you to
interrupt and just goes right back to talking to the other guy who admittedly looked a little surprised himself by that response leads to say I I I bounced I left the store and I never went back because I found out that that that person it wasn't an employee that was the owner of the freaking store I had another bad experience when I went to my first gaming convention that that same year at uh Canen games I encountered two dudes okay who were they were kind of dicks but that's a whole other story and and harping on the past here it's not the point now I could bemoan these encounters and pretend like they represent the average tabletop gamer and or that I was being Gaye kept from the hobby or whatever and that gaming is obviously toxic in the community is a toxic but I didn't do any of that I found a different store I decided to go back to can games the next year and both the store that I went to and the the convention that I went to were amazing experiences and 99% of the people people I encountered were some of them are my friends today they were awesome people in truth tabletop hobbyists be they be board gamers or W gamers are some of the nicest people I've ever encountered I've gone to dozens and dozens of stores and whenever I ask to VI someone playing a tabletop game you can damn well bet that not only will they say yes they will ask if I want to play and and and learn within like a few minutes of watching when I went to some local group to check out the miniature game uh infinity I came with nothing with nothing no miniatures by the end of the night people were letting me play their armies and teaching me all all the damn rules they
can shove into my head one of them even gave me half of his Kit Kat bar half of his Kit Kat bar if I go to any random board game convention and I ask if I can join in on a game unless they're full they will almost never say no that is true at Origins that is true at Gen Con hell I bet I can show up to some random person's house who I know is having a game night because because I I I I watched them through their window at night and I see them in their living room playing and I I go knock on their door and I asked to play I would bet they say yes I would bet they say yet they say come on in have a beer play a game with us board gaming and War gaming has always been inclusive we want everyone playing the games we love there isn't an ounce of toxicity Within These communities the truth of the matter is is that in any hobby you're going to find an abundance of of a passionate people the more passion those people have for the cultural products they love the the more fervently they're going to defend them from criticism and and you know what I I don't think that's toxic I don't think that's toxic either it it's not toxic to tell people they're wrong when they say a game is bad my comment section like I said my comment section in my miniature game tier list was filled with people telling me I'm wrong or or how I have bad tastes do I view that behavior as toxic fellow to me it's all in the realm of discussion and disagreement and I don't want people watching my videos and just just agreeing with whatever whatever crap crap comes up out of my mouth right like this this video included so if you're new to gaming and this is one of the First videos you've ever seen on the hobby for some strange reason you know
don't be afraid okay of all the crap out there telling you you know the Warhammer fans are toxic or board gaming people are toxic it's all nonsense if you're not comfortable dealing with strangers you buy a starter set whatever board game tickles your fancy and you just force your friends to play with you if you're a little more extroverted or you know you're trying to be extroverted you find your local game store check their page for events because I guarantee you they'll have some war games or or board game events during the week and if you you know if you bring your butt down there without knowing a damn thing you will be greeted with some of the warmest most passionate and helpful people you will ever meet who will be absolutely begging you to play because they want you in this hobby you know I want you in this hobby so that's the end of my rant you know this is just a reply to a lot of the comments that I've seen over the years saying you know this community is toxic and that Community is toxic and it's just bothered me has bothered me for so long and they crop up all the freaking time and I understand you know I understand they mean well but it I don't see it doing more good than it does harm so but if you disagree with me let me know in the comment section that is all for today later