Star Wars X-Wing: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for x-wing the the miniatures game star wars x-wing the miniatures game brad doesn't have the box anymore because this game is a nightmare to store now this has been a long time since i have played this i used to own i went crazy whenever i was first playing it and then it was basically one of those games where i didn't want to play competitively because it made me mad and i had no one to play you know casually so i just ended up selling everything this is all first when first edition before they did even though i think before they even did the force awakens pack yeah oh yeah i was out of it before that and forced weapons i wasn't even second edition right that was just the first it was still first yeah that's what i thought so then uh brad got a hold of a bunch of stuff for second edition and i gotta say my feelings haven't changed whatsoever on this game it is still a fiddly mess that i don't really want to play casually not because it's really bad or anything but these the amount of setup time the amount of uh work you're gonna have to put into it uh storage solution is just all over the place that it's it's almost a chore this is a a chore of a game it's a lifestyle game i mean if you're into it that's you know yeah i mean we now granted we did a a quick build which
is the only way i would ever want to play it because i don't want to sit here through every single card through every single ship because each ship oh the thai advanced has a stack of you know people that you can use oh and then you have to pick your you know your your builds for it like you mentioned it's a lifestyle game i just there's a reason why i don't play magic anymore it's just one of those things that you keep sinking money into it and this is just a game that you play all the time so definitely not a game for me uh but let's talk about some negatives well before we get into that um the i like i prefer i mean today with the time sure what it is and stuff using the quick setup is fine but this game rewards knowing your ships oh yeah you know just like anything yeah but um so throwing together stuff mm-hmm you know i know for a fact i misplayed the hell out of the millennium falcon on this right because there was some sort of synergy that they had picked that i wasn't seeing something um and everything so it was just it was just one of those things it seemed this energy with that one was you constantly had ways to get shields and get extra evade while also being able to still do your 360 by five ships that was right i mean it's kind of a one of those things you you know your deal and i i prefer building my ship um because this is something like we had talked all the way until down here is it's all app-based when the app works
yeah um and so you put together your points on the app and you get to pick your cards and do there's a lot of free wielding right stuff so you can make the ships as complex as you want to um but yeah i mean it is what it is on on this right now yeah it's it's one of those things that i mean it's still kind of a gripe even with like magic for example is you can you can have the perfect build you can have the perfect deck but you can still get hosed by mana screw or by dice um in this case because i don't think i built any particular way the only synergy i even had was between one of my valin rudor which just helped him do extra actions if the peons that i had near him uh were being attacked but you never attacked him so i was like well he's useless now uh it's just vader was just so good uh this is one of those games that it it always it sounds for me it sounds better than what it ends up being like it sounds like it's gonna be super fun maneuvering these these ships uh you know doing the dog fighting like kind of like but it's so it it ends up being slower than what you think it to be and then it's also extremely fiddly right just because you have oh is is that base touching well i don't know because your miniature got in the way so i don't know what i mean yeah i guess not right and if you're playing competitively um um actually no no you would have hit
so we can't shoot like you just have those salty toxic people well and i will say that the way we played now it it wasn't a good representation necessarily because this game's best when it's like two ships against two ships oh sure i mean when you start having a lot of ships out there it starts getting extra fiddly you know and all this different stuff and it's harder to maneuver on a three by three deal right that's one reason why that thing said to do eight eight points instead of ten points you know because that would have lowered it down to you having probably four shifts yeah instead of five and i probably only had two right so it would it gives you more space to mess with because we were jumbled into a big [ __ ] map yeah we also didn't really do much to move out of the way uh granted you had the millennium falcon so the entire time i was trying to stay swarmed on you uh to get him out of the way because i i it went exactly as i thought it was if i can get the millennium falcon out of the way but i mean that also kind of defeats the purpose it's like you have this an armada and it's like well i want to do x-men because the dog fighting ah uh you only get two ships it's like well then why don't i just do armada and just have the big bombastic massive two ships and then the because they have like they have like the little x-wings in armada if you remember that represented some dog fighting it's like why don't i just do that instead because you want to have oh i want to have a huge swarm if it allows me to but you're right it then just lends itself to be extremely fiddly uh not only not only
just maneuvering because that's just kind of a miniatures game um it it which does reward if you if you can see the trajectory of your how you how they're gonna lay it like how they're gonna land how they're gonna move predicting your opponent how they're gonna move and then it's just like it's like oh man okay i think if he if he does this and i can maneuver and he's and i'll be out of his line of sight and i'll be able to get him and that's where the true uh theme and the dogfighting comes in but it's one of those games if you are not fully experienced with it you're not going to get that right and it's a reason why i got out of it because the guy i was playing it with against regularly that's all he played so he was able to just completely eat my ass whenever it came to he's like i don't know you're gonna do that now i'm gonna you know flank both of them and then just i'm gonna use all these abilities i'm just like dude you uh i what why am i playing against you so it took the fun out of it and i don't know so i mean a few negatives for me obviously are are those dice it's just it's not fun whenever you put all that effort into trying to out thank your opponent and then it's like okay so i did this i i made it i did precision guessing i'm right up on you i get nine dice and they're all blanks all right that's pretty cool i will never get another shot like that again and that's just not not fun for me yeah that was what kind of hat that's because i was going in with those big
five dice rolls with the falcon and i whiffed yeah and then i got surrounded i was going in that way to destroy a ship or two before that way it reduced it right so my plan was going to move that in there take out a ship or two that he'd get surrounded by other ones where behind it would like to start picking off those yeah but i just whiffed on those two rolls then i was just [ __ ] exactly because it's like oh well i'm here now uh because yeah once once your shields went down then it was like oh i'm only rolling one evade and so that could have worked though if your dice had gone great you would have just blown all these up and then it's like well i have vader and then vader would eventually got picked off so i mean it and that's what bugs me about especially competitive like 1v1 games when it's like well i didn't play better than you the dice just went in my favor and for a game that's so tedious and set up and storage and moving it over to hey i'm going to a friend's house better load up the truck uh with all these different tokens and and just to have it really come down to because i don't think it was a bad matchup oh no no it was equal i mean i'd like to i'd be interested if my app was working to see what the points oh oh yeah just to see what the point actually was because we wouldn't normally set a 200 point army i bet this was probably closer to 300. okay oh well because we went up to ten threats right yeah but i was just curious like how if they were similar yeah technically yours was illegal
well right no no i know and that's another problem with the right just the quick setup because you don't pay attention with that that's just the casual just set up exactly yeah and i just kind of wanted to get the the run through up just to have have it on on the channel i mean it's the game is fine it's it's not a game that you know whenever you and i haven't played the game in a while that it's like revolutionary that i'm getting back into this or something right no absolutely not i have no i don't love star wars enough to just have the minis even though the minis are really nice especially when these were coming out i remember how they came out they were painted and it was like oh you know you never saw like a you know a high publisher actually come with pre-painted minis that represented the the ship so and and at this point now they have rebels empire first order scum and villainy seven there's seven facts in fact i can choose from that's why when i went into the second edition because i just wanted to get a decent sized collection but i stuck with the original three from first dish and i have the scum ability the imperial yeah the rebel because there's the rebel there's the revolution yeah this is that's the force awakens right so you have a lot of the rebellion right yeah you have a lot of like those people yeah poe dameron and stuff like that right and um oh what's his nuts you know evo dude kylo ren i was obviously i went to finn like i remember him being
but it's like they they went with all these there's that robot faction you know that's just all the droids oh that's cool hunters or the ig they're uh made of um i can't think of the name right now but they're the separatist alliance um but they have all these different vaccines down yeah i just have a good collection of those three sure to have which is which is something to keep in mind if if you're looking at this and you're like oh should i get into it if you love star wars and they they have everyone you can make any scenario happen that you want which is a huge positive uh because there's a lot of games out there that are ip related and it's like kind of like a what-if kind of scenario and you can get that here you can have like what we did with chewbacca uh han and leia and luke versus you know fighting darth vader and all these nameless other people that i had i don't know knight beast and van valen ruler val kilmer well they do have a expansions out for this that are scenarios oh that's right you know because you can do stuff there's the snares where you're trying to rescue the you transgender that's right yeah dual add-ons forgot they they had that they did the uh yeah the scenarios which is something that if you don't have a lot of people to play with it's like well if you have one other person you can do the scenarios together well and at the conventions you know a lot of the like gen con stuff they'll do the reenacting of the trench run
oh and these and they have all that stuff where you play a huge game of that where they have like the that stuff but the one thing that's cool about this is fantasy flight about a year it was during the it was probably about march or april during the pandemic when i was years when they came out with the beta that they're working on for the solo play for this game have you tried that yet um i've messed with the beta a little bit i mean they're still tweaking it it's just trying to do ai stuff and they roll nice and there's different stuff it's it's pretty intuitive right now but i'm waiting to see how they that's that's probably if they can pull it off that's that's a rough that's a rough solo variant i would almost assume man yeah that would be hard to to try and ai right you know a miniatures game if they can pull it off then it's got like charts and this yeah if this you know and it's just it's almost sounds like it'd be too much work it's a lot better like i'm giving it because it's the bait it's yeah like it's very early they just had to print files on so people could be playing at home and play testing while they're at home on pandemic and then i don't know where it's at now but yeah that's the main reason i'm keeping it because of that plus if if i ever get so sick of the game i don't ever want to play it i have a lot of cool models to yeah i mean places exactly like i'm not it's it's not this isn't really a negative discussion um and obviously the the run-through is one scenario of many that there's probably rules that we must that we miss because the game is pretty technical um with a lot of
different things and especially if you do a quick build it's it it's like you mentioned it's a lifestyle game if you know the ships well then you could probably do a quick build but we had to quick build and then also learn yeah oh [ __ ] what does vader do right okay i have all this stuff it's not that it's like complex but it is a lot especially if you have one six level threat card and it has eight things and it's like okay now i have to try and figure out the synergy while also trying to read my opponent and what they're going to do well that's the one reason why i chose the rebels scum because i played scum that was my deal i played competitively i did everything yeah so like you gave me boba fett and some headhunters i'm good to go so i wanted to do something new oh yeah and that's the other thing is i mean a potential negative is one of those things that you can't you might not be able to casually play because if you it's like well well i i've played this all the time let me just get someone else to play you know you're you don't know what's going on well i'm just going to annihilate you well and as and this is was a casual game but because i've played this competitively i can you we can sit here and say it's as casual as ever but that's why i got hurt because i'm still competitive yeah i'm trying not to you know so it's just like oh that's it's over yeah because you just know i mean yeah you know this is one of those things where there's almost i mean you could have potentially if you had destroyed any maybe one or two of my ships you probably could have uh but once they were still five once your main ship went down it's
like okay yeah let's just call it you were just gonna have luke fly off the map just to die anyway that's my plan that's why sabine was going that way oh and vader actually was one who blew actually no i think one of my peon ships did destroy the falcon from a three distance away just because i rolled well yeah and i don't know it the game the game is oh the game is good it is just not a game for me uh it's pretty much and usually whenever i talk about discussions that i i am hard won or hard on the other uh of whether it's good or bad this isn't a bad game but i do think that it's a niche market and there are flaws in it but it is an improvement over first edition oh yes yes absolutely especially just just in production quality uh you don't have tiny ass cards with like a paragraph of text that you can barely read and keep track of yeah it's all very easily organized and uh it does seem a lot more streamlined with uh things that were busted from first edition like the millennium falcon like i didn't think that was gross at all um it was definitely it had its its advantages because you constantly had ways to either get extra maneuvers or get extra shields back first edition william falcon was very strong yeah okay the 360 fire yard where you could worry about turrets you could just shoot in any direction you wanted to yeah and they were probably going for like a similar name falcon as a state
iconic ship we have to make an op and you could also do multiple attacks there was card there was upgrades oh yes direction so you you can just get like if you if i was in the same situation i went with you i could go in there if i had the upgrade i could do a full-on i would have been able to do that free attack at seven yeah i've been able to do a 360 attack and then i'd be able to use that upgrade to another yeah 360 attack yeah and it's like okay and that's actually one of the issues with this game and with many others that are competitive and and have a lot of stuff is there is a meta there i mean i don't i don't there was a method in first edition for sure um and i'm sure there's a meta for second edition albeit maybe not as powerful and usually with those kinds of games that can be frustrating because you see the same thing every time especially in competitive where it's like man i want to try this build that sounds cool oh you don't want to do that because that's [ __ ] because here's what everyone else is going to do it's like ah so i don't get to play the way i want no i mean yeah it's it's it's a game i'm i'm amazed that it has stayed around as long as it has especially it's still one of the biggest sellers yeah for them it's people doing that still right it's crazy all right uh oh one thing that is i think new in this uh versus the first edition is the use of force yes i actually like that i thought that was pretty cool it made uh because you had iconic characters who had the force that you got to utilize uh in completely different ways like luke didn't have much
he actually had less force in darth vader but he had ways of generating it quicker and basically the force can be used either for special abilities or to mitigate guy roles and then like with darth vader he was able to uh do double actions and and with his specific ship so i thought that was pretty neat having force users but that's it scale of one to ten let me go first sure um i i want to give it a lower score to now after this experience but i'm not it's just one game um this is a game that's in my top 100 um but i just haven't played it a ton yeah so we'll have to see where it falls this next time i'll probably say seven point five maybe i mean right seven point five burning yeah just just because i i love playing it and it's just when you have those bad experiences yeah it gets you a little bit salty yeah i know where i know where you're at uh this would not make my top 100 it wouldn't even come anywhere close uh if if you were to be like oh do you want to play i'd say sure um but i i want to do another quick build which is not what you want to do because i don't want to stay here and take the time to do a build list now what i would do which would probably make my experience a little bit better is if you made the builds well and you're like oh here's here's one and that's what i was going to say that i don't know if it's because i have that connection with it or what but that app
that they made it was one of probably the biggest things they did with this game because the reason i made the second edition is because first edition their power creep got really crazy like vader was really good and first and then they couldn't go past it like everybody started playing the same thing yeah whatever what they've done with the second edition there's no point values on the courts at all that you go in um and they can update it on their app so that if there's something that they're wanting if they want to change the meta or if there's something that's overpowered they can make the points higher so it takes up more of your 200 team points so that you have to alter your stuff around a little that's smart that's very very smart that they did that and then likewise going back to what maybe start talking about that is you can build your steels here and save them on the app oh so so you could have like i could go through and spend some time and build a good deck you know or whatever and have it there so like and i could build one for you yeah you could be like okay here we go so that app is is really cool for that and that's one of the things that i that was a really good decision that is that is really always adjusted you know just to make it more that's true uh um man i think i'm not as high as you uh just because i would only ever play this if if like you specifically asked me i don't think i would i would request it again it's not a bad game i'm kind of sitting at a six like still above average uh but
it's not like it's not amazing and i remember i was like wowed by it whenever i first got it then it's just it's just one of those games that i'll forget about i mean i won't because obviously it's a huge thing but it's just it's around it's it's fine and i mean but i'm also not that big into star wars yeah so if i was if i was huge into star wars i'd probably bump it up another point kind of like what i did with bloodborne like bloodborne as a game was an eight but it's a nine because i love it it'd be the same here it'd say seven if i'm if i'm geeking out over star wars but it's a six for me personally the and the scum is fun i mean yeah that's a fun group because they're like cheating and right all kinds of stuff that's right they're kind of cool too these guys are the one we played the ones that we know i mean like yeah exactly you know i mean
oh i know right all right so that's our thoughts on x-wing star wars x-wing the miniatures game let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day of this video hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you