Skip to main content
Loading video...

President Maker Review: Vote Early and Often

Transcript 27:25

Hey there everybody. I'm Mike Delisio

and I'm Chris Yay.

Today we're going to be taking a look at a game called President Maker. This is coming from publisher Pluto games and designer Bong Wanhu. I hope I am close on the pronunciation there. If not, I apologize. So, this is a game with a theme, and I'm just going to read off the back of the box, Chris, because I think that I should let the publisher do the heavy lifting here. You've crashlanded in a parallel version of 21st century South Korea. In this world, you're a leading presidential candidate. With the national election just around the corner, there's no time to unravel the mystery of how you ended up there. Your only goal now is to survive the schemes and sabotage of rival candidates and win the election. Now look, I know what you're thinking.

When four people land in a rocket out of nowhere,

put them up for put them up for election.

Correct. And another game with this theme. Look, I get it. But let's not head on to the table. I'll show you how it plays and then we can come back here and let you know what we think. Okay, here we see President Maker as it would be set up for a fourplayer game. Uh what you see here is you've got the five different regions of South Korea with Seoul, the um capital region right here in the middle. These other four boards are going to just be randomly placed around the outside. And these political support cards are also randomly placed on the corresponding spots. What these really do is they show where the candidates start, where their starting place is based upon what card is there. Also, at the beginning of the game, players are going to be randomly choosing one of these candidate cards.

It's going to show you which political party you're affiliated with. Um, you have an independent candidate, centrist candidate, a progressive candidate, and a conservative candidate. So depending upon which card you end up with, you're going to take the associated components uh for that, your deck of political cards, your region cards, your vote tokens, etc. And some of them have some additional setup like the independent candidate has to determine what their area of expertise is. So they would just simply draw the top card from their political deck, look at the bottom, and that's going to determine what their area of expertise is. In this case, they are experts in environmental policy. Okay? And there are other setups. First real big thing you need to do is figure out which is the ruling party and which is the opposition party. That's going to be determined between the progressive candidate and the conservative candidate. You can do that in any fashion. I tend to like to take one of the vote tokens from each one. Maybe let the independent candidate or the centrist candidate randomly choose one and whichever one was pulled would then be the ruling party. They're going to gain this token. The other candidate will be uh the opposition party and whichever is the ruling party is going to start with certain things. They're going to gain one support in the sole region and you can see that star is represented right there. So you'd move them up one on these support tracks.

They would also gain one additional vote on the vote track. So you'd move them up there. This vote count track is going to be what determines the eventual winner at the end of the game. Whoever has the most votes will win the game. And also they are going to gain one risk card. And those risk cards are right here. Uh those risks are represented by bonds. You would not look at the front of this card when you gain them. You never look at them when you gain them. There's a phase in the game where everyone flips them all over simultaneously. But this contains between one to three bombs and more bombs is more risky and more potentially dangerous to you. Once all that initial setup is out of the way, you can begin the game. The general idea is that you want to gain support in each of the five regions of South Korea so that when a um eventual uh election takes place, you're going to have the biggest support in all of the regions and thus gain the most votes to win the game. In each on each of these region boards, there's a couple of uh things you really need to be paying attention to. One along the top is the engagement track. This is going to tell you how many total tokens are pulled from the bag during that final count to determine the number of votes you get. So they all start on the left hand side. These are the support tracks for each of the four candidates in each region. What this is going to do is along the top it's going to tell you how many of the vote tokens are going to be placed for each candidate within the bag

for that vinyl final coat uh count. So ideally, you want to have a lot of vote tokens in the bag so that when you're pulling the number that it tells you here, you will have the most votes. There are two rounds in the game, and when it within each round, there are three phases. Between rounds one and two, there's a presidential poll. After round two's final rally, that's where you're going to have the final vote count where you determine the winner. So, let's talk briefly about these different phases. First is the rally phase, and you see times two there. That means that each player is simultaneously going to be choosing two cards from this deck of cards. Everyone has the same little deck of cards. They just outline the five regions that are out here on the board. You'll choose two of the regions, place them face down, and once everyone has done that, you reveal them face up. The way it works is that you just go through region by region. If only one candidate went to that region, they're going to move their support cube up two spaces. If however multiple players went to that uh region, every player that's there will move their uh cube up one space and they'll also move the engagement track up. So you do that for all five of these and make any adjustments necessary. The next part of the game is the political action phase.

And this is where really the meat of what you're doing is going to entail. You see times three under that. That means that each player is going to be playing three political action cards. Those are in these decks. So, every player at the beginning would draw five cards to begin their hand. And during this phase, they're going to be looking through their cards and they're going to be choosing one of them to play. Now, there is an order of operations here. In this uh phase, the leading party or the ruling party will play first. So in this case, the conservatives, then the opposition party, which would be the progressive candidate, then the centrist candidate, and then finally the independent candidate. Everyone will be playing three cards, but one at a time going in that order. When you're looking at these cards, there's a few things to look at. Number one is the cost of the card. So if I want to lobby a business tycoon, that entails two risk cards. So I would immediately take those. Again, you do not look at them yet. You just put them face down in front of you. Then you're looking at what regions this card is going to affect. This is saying any region except the central region of soul. And that's that uh symbol that it does not want to. There we go. That's that symbol right there saying you can go to any one of the other four regions.

And then it tells you what you're going to do in whatever region you pick. In this case, you will move your support cube up two spaces. So let's say for example the purple player decided I'm going to go to gang gang one here. I will choose that as my region. I will bump my support cube up twice there. The final thing you do is you look at the policy symbol at the bottom. This represents foreign policy. And what you can do is looking at where that card is placed on the table. You can go and move your support cube up one in each of the two adjacent regions. So in this case here's the foreign policy card. Yong and Chong Chong. I'm doing probably terrible with pronunciation, apologies. You can move up one each in those. So, I can go do this and this. The other option you always have instead of moving up one in adjacent regions is to just move up one in soul. And so, that is how that would work. They would play their card, do the things, they would actually that card would be out for the rest of the game.

They would draw back up to five. So, you'll always have five cards you're choosing from when you play your cards. Then this player would play, this player would play, and this player would play. You do that three times. The last phase is the media phase. And in this phase, what you're going to be doing is you're going to be looking at how many popular candidates there are in each region. So let's just for the sake of argument here, say that we had some movement amongst players and things looked maybe like this. So, you're going to look in each region and there's a dotted line in each region and any candidate who is to the right of the dotted line is considered a popular candidate in that region. What you do is for every candidate to the right of the line, you move the engagement meter up one. So, in this case, that would move up one. We have one popular candidate here, one popular candidate here, two here, and none here. So, that would not move at all. Finally, during the media phase, you're going to then have everyone reveal all the risk cards they have. And whoever has the most risk cards are going to uh face a bit of a penalty. So, in this case, this player had five.

Let's say that they were the one with the most risk cards. What would happen there is that they would move back one on the vote count track. Round one and round two will work exactly the same. So, you're going to be doing that process I showed twice. In between the first and second rounds, you're going to be having a presidential poll, just checking who is the most popular at this point in time between round one and round two. The way you do that is you place a vote token from every one of the candidates into the bag. You're going to place an additional token for each region, whoever is the most popular candidate there, draw five, and whoever has the majority there, whoever has the most first place will gain one vote. But they're also going to gain gain a risk. With popularity comes risk. Then you would do round two. Same thing. You'd have one final rally where you would only be picking one of your region cards and moving cubes accordingly. And that would take you to the final vote count.

And the way that final vote count works is, as I said at the beginning, you're going to go through every region starting uh from the top left in clockwise order, ending in soul, always ending in soul. And you're going to be placing the number of vote cubes for each candidate or vote tokens I should say for each candidate based upon where their number is here. And then the total number you're going to pull is going to be the number that it says here. And during that final count, every vote that gets pulled out of the bag is going to move you up the track one. And so this is going to be a kind of a dramatic thing where you're pulling out and moving up these votes. After you have done uh the count in soul, which would be the last of the five regions, whoever has the most votes on the vote count will win the game. That's the general idea of the game. There's a couple of things that I have that I've left out like this minor candidate. There's a card that will allow you to unite with a minor candidate. It will give you potentially an extra vote in the regions, but it comes with some risk.

Um, there are other little kind of special things like the centrist candidate here. If they don't have the most risk during those two checks, they're going to gain some uh support because they're not trying to be as risky. Things along those lines. If you're playing with a player count other than four, then you're going to include some non-player uh candidates. In a three-player game, the independent candidate would become a non-player candidate. In a two-player game, the centrist candidate would also be a non-player candidate, and you would really only have the progressive and conservative parties with some, you know, interaction of moving cubes by based on those NP MPCs. But that's a general idea of President Maker. All right, let's head back up and we'll let you know what we think.

Okay, so there you go. That is President Maker, a game with uh the theme. Now, now joking aside about this the theme uh because there is a humorous element to that for sure. I kind of understand why they went alternate reality because politics, you know, it's a theme that could be very fraught with um meaning and and

baggage. Baggage 100% feelings.

Right. Exactly. And so, um, I appreciate that they put a level of abstraction there, you know, besides the game that is already abstracted in in a pretty good sense, but, um, I think unfortunately the theme is something that is going to work against the game,

I suppose. Yes. I for some people it will.

Yeah.

Uh, I think for most people it wouldn't really be an issue. what if you if you actually kind of get past the the name on the box and the cover and stuff when you really play it, it is just kind of this nice very bird's eyee view of what it takes to run a few different campaigns,

right? And you know, um it's not like this theme has not been done before. There have been, you know, political themed games, you know, as long as there have been games, quite honestly. And so, uh, I'm just saying that because I would hate the theme alone to keep you from trying this because I'm not going to bury the lead too much, but I think this game does have some things to offer. Um, so, moving past the theme, just briefly, uh, talk about the the components and the art. It's a very Spartan art style. I would say it is very almost not art in the game. There's just little bits of icons, but what it lacks in maybe flashy and splashy art, it makes up for with I think extreme usability.

I Yeah, there's never a card that I really have any question what it does. I appreciate that it's spelled out in both Korean and in English. So, yeah, wherever you find a copy, if you speak one of those two languages, you're set. And yeah, the the cards are so simple. Every card has a cost, it does a thing, and then it and then you just move up. uh you know based on this symbol on the bottom. Every card does one simple thing that I never have any question about. I can look at it extremely briefly and just based on the icons even before reading the words I have a good idea if there's words on the card even.

Right. Right. Right. Exactly. Yep.

Um and so the the quality of the components, the cardboard, the wood, it's all nice. It it's, you know, especially for a game in a box size like this, I don't really have any complaints about the components at all. I don't have any complaints. Some people will say it's too bland for them, right? It's not going to win any awards for best artwork of the year. Sure. But I think it all is in service of the fact that you then get to kind of play this game that's

a little bit above the table, so to speak, where you're kind of you're playing effects that are going to affect other people. You're messing up with with uh someone else's track over here. And not in a mean-spirited way, but in a very logical, I would like to win more votes than you, so I'm going to move up my cube here and move the leading competitor back a space,

right?

You know, and you're kind of looking people in the eye as you're doing it for the tracks are pretty pretty minimal. Yeah.

Yeah. And I do think that's an important thing to mention is that I would not consider this a game that is particularly aggressive or take that oriented. There are some cards where you can directly affect an opponent, but much more often you're trying to bolster your position and to some extent by doing so you're you're you know uh indirectly kind of affecting your opponent but there's not a lot of direct you know I take a vote from you, I take a you know a support from you although there that's in there. It's not a huge part of the game but it doesn't feel bad. No either. Yeah, it's you're never uh losing headway on on progress, I think, is kind of the neat thing about this. The way that there's blatant interaction.

I like the I like the asymmetry amongst the four factions as well, where where each player when you're playing the independent or when you're playing that kind of

uh um what is the the

centrists. Yeah,

you you do play very in little ways differently. Yeah. which is impressive because to go to that earlier point, every card is so simple, it almost feels like, okay, is there that much play space with it and you realize just little things like the independent party

doesn't have to worry about regions,

right?

Every one of their cards says you can do this effect in any of the five regions you want,

right?

That's really cool. That's a small little lever to move and all of a sudden makes that player feel different

and no costs.

Yeah.

Right. Yeah. So, there is those decks. I believe I mentioned this in the overview, but those decks are different. Um, they all have the card that'll allow them to unite with a a minor candidate if they're the first one to play it. But otherwise, they're slightly asymmetric decks, but as you said, they're all so simple to understand um that you're not playing a different game from the other players. You just have certain things that are maybe more to your strategy than it would be in a different uh if you were a different candidate. So, um I just the couple of things I wanted to kind of focus on I think with this is that um the game itself is relatively simple. Okay. But I will say that um before I played it for the first time after reading the rules I did not have a good handle at that point on what I how what what I was doing was really going to affect the endgame.

Absolutely. And I will say don't despair if that's your um experience after reading the rule book too

or watching the overview if you say like that seemed kind of funky.

Yes, exactly. Um the game is short enough. It says what 45 minutes on the box for a four-player game. I would say that's true for your first game.

Maybe even true for later games, but it may be shorter than that too if you've played the game a couple of times.

After your first game, you'll be like, "Okay." And I will tell you right after I played the first game of this, I did want to play it again right away. Um, but so that I think is a good thing. So just be aware that it's a little obtuse from reading just from the rule book on how things work. But once you get the concept, which is not a complex one,

everything else falls into place. The cards that you're playing and why you might play them fall into place. Things along those lines. So it's a simple game. the round structure is a little bit unorthodox. So, you just have to kind of wrap your head around those things.

I think that this game does something that I often have a big complaint about actually where it is so thematic that there are funky rules simply they exist to uh to accommodate the theme. Yeah.

And that's something that I actually feel like most times you should just abstract those those little weird finicky rules away. Why do you halfway through the game do a a presidential poll and then at the end of the second half of the game you do the actual election, right?

But it's because this game is so thematic. Why does it have weird finicky rules about the independent party has this extra special card they reveal at the start of the game?

Well, because they're the independent party and they kind of have to uh you they theyatically have to align to a particular point of view. This is the party that cares about national defense. That's the very big thing they stand for. So everything has a very nice thematic explanation.

Sounds obtuse at first

and as soon as you play around or two, you go,

everything makes sense now.

Yeah,

everything clicks because it hangs its hat on that nice little hook of that theme very well.

Yeah, I agree. So things that you may want to look out for if you're trying to decide whether this is a game for you. Um, it has a lot of luck.

Big old dollop. Okay, you have to know that going in is that essentially it's a bag pulling game, right? You're pulling chits out of not chits, but the essentially uh wooden chips out of a bag and there are going to be times where you've got the most chips in that bag. You've got maybe three or four more than any other person out there and yet at the end yours were the fewest pulled out of the bag. You have to be aware of that. So luck is a part of the game. Now, I think the flip side of that is that you get excitement out of every bag pull. And I will take that trade-off in a game this short every time. Yeah, look, sometimes you're going to get hosed. Sometimes you're going to have seven in there and two come out. That's just the bottom line. But because of that, it's very rare that you have no interest in what's going to be pulled out of the bag.

I I have seen uh well, yes. Okay. I have seen players who have two or three chips in that bag, get both of them pulled out, and I've been the person absolutely hosed where maybe one of mine came out and I lost the election because of that. But I will tell you, and especially I'm sure some people grab out a handful, kind of, you know, spllay them and okay, three more. I love just one at a time.

I mean, just like waiting for actual poll results, you said they're agonizing and it fits that theme once again so well. And it's just this this dread as you're watching your candidate fall behind and then this sublime enjoyment as you see your guy catch up like that's what I thought.

It's amazing what it pulls off with this huge dollop of luck that only would work because of how lucky it is.

Yeah, very much so. So, I mentioned that because there are some people that are just very uh resistant to playing a game with with luck. And if that's you, you probably do want to steer clear of this because it is very uh has a large element of luck into it. But for me,

you could play this game perfectly and get annihilated by that bag pull. You have to know that this is that type of game. It reminds me a little bit of the game thieves game

where you pull stuff out of the bag, you dig into the desert, you might just draw terribly.

You might get a lot of dirt, right? Yeah. Um and and that is but but again I want to emphasize that the game is they would bother me a lot more if it was a two-hour game.

It would be unplayable.

Right. Right. But it's such a short game um that all of those polls just become exciting to me more than anything else. I've never become seriously frustrated. I've always been like, "Oh my gosh, are you kidding me?" And there's almost this shared kind of thing around the table of like, "Yeah, you're getting, you know, there's just no two ways about it. It happens, right? It could happen to me on the next poll." So remember how you were the the leading candidate, you were the incumbent,

right?

Not anymore.

The other thing I would mention just on a thematic edge because we've been talking about the thematic element of the game is that I highly recommend that you say what your card is when you play it out. You know what I mean? It's like I am whistleblowing a corrupt policy, you know, because it just adds something to the fun there. So um yeah, I I think that this game is um Should I just go in should we go into final thoughts or

Yeah, let's do it. Okay. So, this is a game that has surprised me. It surprised me with how much I am charmed by it. Um, I was intrigued. You know, I I heard about this game and I sought it out specifically because I was intrigued. So, I'm not saying I came into it with, you know, no interest. I came into it with some interest, but I was still surprised by how much this game charmed me. The luck doesn't bother me because it's such a short game and it e kind of feels thematic in that sense, too. Um, this is one that I cannot wait to introduce other people to. And that to me is a sign of a game that I hold in high esteem. If I just am wanting to show this to almost everybody I know, that means it's a game that uh I hold in high esteem and I do. I'm giving it an 8.5, a seal of excellence. Um, I have not even begun, I think, to begin my journey into this game. Like, I really want to keep playing it. When I'm not playing it, I want to be playing it.

Why isn't it higher? Well, because it does have some limitations. I know that I have to be careful about who I even ask because some people are going to want to just be polite and say, "Okay, and maybe not be interested." Now, the one time that's happened so far, they ended up loving the game. So, I'll just point that out there. But, but that, you know, I do take that into account. And there is a heavy amount of luck. So, uh that's where I'm coming down.

I am just ever so slightly lower. I'm at an eight. I think that this I highly highly recommend this game still. I really enjoy it and I think that it it surprisingly scales well.

Uh it is better at four players because one yeah I yes I absolutely best at four because one person

is each of the candidates and and so it is funny that in a three or two player game you can lose to a dummy player. Uh but it's more exciting when you're sitting there going like how's the Independent Party winning the election? What's happening here?

And second place is the Green Party. they're coming up, you know, it's so it's great. I I love all of that. I think that the game is very small in scope. It is surprisingly small in scope and yet packs a good punch and it has just it's going to it's going to favor funnier moments, I think, rather than like strategic gameplay, per se. The every time you do risky moves, you grab those bomb cards. You might have two bomb cards and they're both threes. You might get hosed as opposed to the person who has uh, you know, has five cards over there, right? So, there are those those moments that aren't going to feel great, but none of those things are actually that punishing.

Yeah.

And so, I agree that that bag pull, the trade-off of the amount of luck

for how exciting and how like genuinely I'm sitting there like, am I going to win this thing and am I going to win this election or not?

Yeah,

it's such a cool payoff. So, yeah, one absolutely you should check out.

And I'm glad you mentioned the player count. Um, we have played at all the player counts. It would not be an 8.5 as a two-player game.

No,

I'll put that up. But as a four-player game, that's where that would definitely land. And I think that's the way that the game is really meant to be played. So,

all right. Well, there you go. That is President Maker. Until next time, I'm Mike Delisio.

And I'm Chris G.

And get out to the polls.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved