Hall of Fame: Diamant
Transcript
push your luck in a diamond-encrusted mine flip a card distribute treasures and then there's just one decision are you staying in or banking your treasure and heading home a simple tense card game for three to eight players from the Superstar design Duo of Bruno for Duty and Alan Moon that's the hook I'm Adam Porter I design games and I review them on this channel with a focus on product design if you like what I do please subscribe comment and share the video in my game design Hall of Fame series I pick out games I love which have undeniably proven themselves as Titans in the industry Sushi go viticulture King Domino carcazon everdale and today I'm adding dearmont to the family dear monk was first released in 2005. designer Alan moon was flying high after winning the prestigious spielder's award the previous year for Ticket ride his second win elfinland won the award in 1998 and frankly the amount should have been his third Diamond was recommended by the Spiel desiares jury other recommendations and nominations that year included Torsten gimlers no thanks freedom and Freeze's power grid and Kramer and kiss things were flexed strong competition from an incredible lineup of games but I think diamond is the best of the bunch and I have no hesitation in recommending diamont over the award winner Niagara which fell a little flat for me Alan Moon partnered with his frequent collaborator the prolific designer Bruno feduti to create
Diamond initially published by Schmidt spieler the game was renamed Lincoln gold in its subsequent Edition from Eagle Griffin and then reverted to Diamond in 2016 with a gorgeous graphic overhaul from yellow and the bunny Kingdom artist Paul mafeon dearmont has never had an expansion or a sequel though two new modules are due for release in a mini expansion this year there's considerably less material for me to cover with diamond than some of the other games in my hall of fame Series so I won't be taking a deep dive of the same scale as my enormous Carcassonne or King Domino or everdel overviews I was inspired to Showcase this unassuming little title after a recent game with family which reminded me why after all these years it's still among the best games in my collection and why it remains permanently in print it may not be as prominent as Ticket to Ride Katan or pandemic but diamond is a true Evergreen and it deserves more Acclaim throughout the game a group of three to eight explorers will venture into five treasure-laden mine shafts risking hazards and trying to keep the most treasure for themselves a card is revealed and the number on the card determines how many gems are available and they're distributed evenly to each of the players with any leftover gems remaining on the card all players then simultaneously reveal whether they intend to stay in the mine or return to the camp and if players return to Camp they split any gems sitting on the cards again leaving leftovers behind and place
their collected gems into their chest where they'll be safe until game end of course if you're the only player to leave you'll get to keep all the gems from the cards for yourself Thursday remained in the mine turn over another card and once again split the gems and so the game continues but not so fast some of the cards are hazards and there are five different types with three of each in the deck one Hazard of a specific type is fine but if a second emerges all players who are still in the dungeon are eliminated losing all of the gems they've gathered that round a third card type is the artifact these are worth five or ten points but the only way you can claim them is if you leave the mine and no other players come with you if multiple players leave the mine the artifact remains for another Adventurer to collect later over five rounds the players gather a horde of treasure into their chests and the player with the most treasure at game end wins so we'll start as ever with onboarding the cover uses a color palette lifted straight out of Scooby-Doo with a title font reminiscent of Indiana Jones these are subtle references but they set expectations of peril Adventure backstabbing and camaraderie it's an appealing image which tells you exactly what you're going to be doing and exactly what you're going to feel I can't fault it the rules are crystal clear and the game is a breeze to teach this is a perfect introductory game short enough for an after dinner session or a quick intermission between longer games now I
rate games using my own ladder engagement system games are scored between zero and three in five categories and each point scored climbs the game one rung up the ladder score of 10 or above tops the ladder and indicates a real favorite with me the Thematic immersion Diamond scores two the theme makes a lot of sense and you do feel the Peril that the imagery invokes now I've stopped short of awarding full marks because the traps lack any personality they all function identically so you don't really notice whether you're being consumed by a snake squashed by a boulder or overrun with spiders for interaction it's a three the game is packed full of interactive moments trying to read your opponent's intentions it's hugely satisfying to see your opponents perish in a hideous trap the very turn after you headed back to Camp with an enormous stash of gems it's exciting watching that one foolish player pushing on through a perilous series of cards defying all the odds you find yourself willing them on even when they're stealing Victory before your very eyes you can't help but get caught up in it this is a game full of stand-up moments invoking cheers or groans the artifacts offer another intriguing decision now you really don't want to leave unless you're heading out alone but what are my opponents planning now these cards didn't feature in the original game they were introduced in the income gold editions but they remained in yellows beautiful Edition making it the definitive version of the game the stress and tension in the game
couldn't be greater pushed your luck titles are always strong in this aspect and it may not be to everyone's taste but if you have a gambling spirit this one will be right up your street and for feedback again this game excels your in-game choices are rewarded or punished with immediate and dramatic effect the game itself comes to life and offers up just as much personality and interaction as the other players do sometimes it feels like the game is on your side but more often it's mocking you and for Meaningful choices it's a two the game is not full of deep decisions but they are genuine sincere impactful decisions you know the odds and you choose to take the risk or play it safe win or lose it's on you the overall score of 13 tops the ladder now I sometimes make deductions for incoherent rule books and fiddly or unintuitive gameplay but no such problem here Diamond sits proudly at the top of my ladder it's a true classic but there must be some drawbacks right you can't all be positive well yeah the biggest issue with the game is the blowout rounds it's not uncommon for a pair of matching hazards to be drawn in quick succession potentially even before any players have gathered a single gem these occasional wipeouts are amusing in the context of many games played but they can be off-putting and in my experience for whatever reason they seem to happen every time they introduce the game to new players diamond is like an unruly child never showing its best side until you get to know it a bit I feel like I'm
always apologizing for it I promise you'll grow to love it if you just give it a chance in an industry completely saturated with new games which are a bit more rigid but offer a predictable Pleasant sanitized first experience dearmont does stand out a little Bruno for Duty has made a name for himself with slightly chaotic antagonistic titles like this one Animo crazy is a totally unique wild unfair party game where players pose new rules and then vote on which ones are instigated as the game progresses in Dragon's gold players work together to defeat dragons then bicker and argue over the distribution of the rewards if the time runs out before an agreement is made no one gets anything even when reigned in by Alan Moon the ordered designer of ticket ride and Airlines Europe for Duty's mischievous side can't help but break through in diamont so on to my product design checklist is the game Innovative well I think so there are actually relatively few pure push your luck games in the Hobby in comparison to other mechanisms and this is one of the the preeminent and early examples cracks of quedlinburg is a massive title right now but that was released 13 years after Diamond Port Royal Deep Sea Adventure and Captain carcass are all excellent games but not as universally acclaimed as Diamond my personal favorite zoc verlag's alph toy Volcom Rouse never seems to get a look in and that's not to mention my own
twist on the genre compromat co-designed with Rob Fisher which offers up a tense head-to-head Jewel for two players but can't compete with a massive player count of diamond which brings me on to my next question does this game solve a problem or fill a gap in the market well categorically yes this game scales incredibly well if you're looking for an engaging interactive game for large groups without an extended duration there are very few viable options diamond is among the best of them but it also plays really well with three or four players too it's a very versatile package as side note the game can technically be played with two people but it advertises itself as three to eight and rightly so playing with two is serviceable but it doesn't give the full experience will the Game grow with its user well this is perhaps where the product is lacking there's no variety between games or even rounds of the game aside from the order in which the cards emerge from the deck and the metagame created by the players and their interactions it's unusual for such a successful game to find itself approaching its 20th anniversary without a single expansion or sequel nothing to refresh the experience now that's not to say that you'll Tire up the game quickly it's too much fun for that but I've found it's a game I return to every once in a while rather than a permanent fixture that I come back to week after week that said I've been playing sporadically for over a decade and I'd still never turn down a game of diamont it's interesting to reflect on the
possible reasons why Diamond has remained a second run Evergreen title not reach teaching the enormous Heights of moons ticket ride or pandemic or wingspan now I'm splitting hairs here of course not every game can sit on the Winner's Podium and remaining in print for the best part of two decades is not to be scoffed at but diamond is not a brand to rival Katan or carcasson or Dominion so why is that I think there's a timing issue Katan carcass on a ticket to ride all captured a moment while Innovative Diamond doesn't have the obvious Prestige of being the first deck builder like Dominion or leading the Vanguard of Cooperative games like pandemic but I think it's worth noting how Anodyne the top run Evergreen titles are there's nothing mischievous about Carcassonne or wingspan or pandemic Diamond feels a tadmor anarchic and perhaps the mass Market isn't looking for that that said we can't Overlook the enormous success of munchkin or exploding kittens there's a market for chaos and combative take that mechanisms perhaps the problem is that diamond is not anarchic enough maybe it falls between two stools as I said this is splitting hairs it's an incredible idea and it's executed exceptionally well by designers and publisher alike and hence sitting in the orange section of my idea execution Matrix indicating a hugely successful product and a commercial hit in this industry older titles can
sometimes get lost among the shiny new titles so perhaps you haven't yet had the chance to give diamont a try I'd suggest you Rectify that I don't think you'll regret it in if you enjoyed this retrospective you might enjoy one of my other Hall of Fame videos so follow the link