Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 15:08

welcome to John gets games today I'll be reviewing trombon this is a two-player only card game where players are going to use creative hand Management in order to build a bunch of trains to move the most passengers around and to ultimately get the most points first I'll go over how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review here's the starting setup for a game of trombon it's a two-player only game so we have the starting player down here they have a hand of six cards and 12 money and the second player has six cards and 15 money you'll notice that the money is simply the same cards as the ones in hand they're just worth a thousand dollars each when they are in this money pile the first thing a player does is they must take one or two of the cards from their hand and place them out as passengers in this communal area here the card you choose must go down on the terminal that matches its color so I could put this card right here and I've now satisfied that requirement in the second phase of a turn a player can put as many cards as they want face up in columns in front of them now for instance they could take this right here the only restriction is they must go in ascending order so I have to go two four six seven it's also important to know that you can have multiple uh Columns of the same color once a player has played as many cards as they want to into these columns they can optionally take as many cards as they want from their hand and put them down into their money pile here but let's say that this first player doesn't want to do that they keep this card and now the player can optionally purchase one of these trains they all cost five thousand dollars and have a 2X modifier at the beginning of the game so the player would simply take 5000 from here they would discard these cards they

would still have this money in their Bank and they would take one of these trains and Associate it with this stack of cards or any real stack of cards they want to but the important thing is at the end of a turn if you have a column of cards without a train associated with them that column is discarded and lastly we would reveal a new train to come out it's important to know that there are a few of these two axes at the beginning of the game but pretty quickly you get to three X's that cost ten thousand dollars each and in the very end of the game they cost fifteen thousand each and they have a 4X I'll explain what that 4X 3x and 2x means in just a minute and at the end of a player's turn they draw cards from the top of the deck until they have six in their hand again now that the opposing player is gone I'm going to show you one more turn before wrapping everything else up so if we look at this hand we have here we got three more blues and blue is good because we already have a big blue uh train going on here however this two and three are too low in order to get added onto this train because you always have to go from low to high you can always create a new train but I think in this case it's much better for this player to put both of these down into the Blue terminal remember you must put at least one card down as passengers but you can put as many as two and the reason they would put two down will become evident in just a minute fortunately for us this 10 is definitely higher than seven so that could go down here and that actually completes this train because all the cards go from value 1 to 10 so you can't put anything higher than 10 down onto this train uh the player could also take both of these cards and create a new train here that may or may not be a good idea since it's a really big jump but it's something that they have the

option to do so they would take five dollars from their money they would discard that and they could take one of these here slide it there and they have one card left so they would draw five more cards so they'd have six cards at the end of their turn so now let's discuss scoring these different trains as soon as one of these stations reaches four passengers for instance if this happened like that then all trains of that specific color will score and when you score you simply add up the central number on all these cards and multiply that by the modifier of the train so this would be three four five six seven eight times two or 16 points the opponent however simply has two times two or four at this point we get out the pad of paper we write down the amount of points that we got we write down the amount of points that the opponent got and that is the end of the first tour this is actually the game clock as soon as 10 scoring rounds happen the game is going to end and of course after scoring all of these passengers will get discarded you may have noticed that I have this Joker in my hand also called a conductor now the way they work they can go down on any train as long as it's not finished like this 10 here so let's pretend I hadn't put that 10 there I put the Joker down instead and let's also pretend I had this eight in my hand that could go there we now have seven cards in this specific train if we put this 10 down that would be the eighth card and this is the reason Jokers are important they make it easy to get to eight cars in a train because the moment you get to eight cars you get an extra bonus scoring for only that train so you would add everything up that'd be one two three four five six seven eight nine ten times two or 20 points and that's what this little Zone down here is for you would write the 20 down here it gives

you points but it also does not push the end game clock also your opponent does not score their blue trains it's just that train they hit eight cards it is important to note that as soon as the main draw deck is depleted each player is going to lose half of their stored income so the right hand player over here is going to lose five of their 10 bucks and this left-hand player is only going to lose two of their five because you round down those cards go into the discard pile you Shuffle up the discard pile a whole bunch and then that becomes your new draw deck and once you've completed 10 standard scorings you add up all the points including any from these extra tours and the person with the most points wins so now let's move into the review portion of the video and we'll begin with the Positive points the first of these has to do with that great card play mechanic that you have coming out of your hand where you have very simple decisions realistically like you either play as many cars down as you want or you can play cards into your income pile that you don't want in order to have enough money to buy trains or you could save cards in your hand you're going to draw less cards but you can try to match up a really good card you got earlier with another card that works for you later I just enjoy that decision process where you think how badly do I want to play this card now versus holding on to it later if I hold on to it I've seen less cards and this game is definitely about seeing lots of cards so that you can kind of adjust your gameplay based off of the cards that come out of the deck but you also need to put a lot of Cards into that income pile and unfortunately you only get one money per car that you discard so I found that it's just fun to think about how many cards do you hold in your hand that you

always draw back up to six seems like you really really want to save more than one or two cards that you can see a bunch of new cards and try to make more interesting things happen with the trains as you're trying to build them if you hold all your cards you're not going to be drawing much else and you're not gonna be able to build up your little train engines that you want the second positive Point Compares trombone to other games of his ilk like celtus and lost cities where you have this card game where you're playing cards down in a row of ascending or descending order now the other games of this kind always lock you down to one stack Pursuit and so that means as the game goes on you can draw cards that you have no way of playing it's might be like a four of green and you're already at the seven or eight of green going up you can't play that anywhere but in trombone you can build multiple trains or multiple stacks of specific suits of cards and I really enjoy that that at no point will you ever draw a card that is completely dead to you that you cannot use at all you can always make a second train or a third train of a specific color if that makes sense with the current game state where you're playing and I suppose you can always turn that card into money as well which is not a bad constellation prize but you just know that you're never going to draw a complete done of a card you might draw cards that you don't really want but they will always have the option of doing something because you could just have many trains in front of you as you want and I really like that design decision so now let's move on to my one neutral point and that involves the number of turns where you don't feel like you did very much interesting at all I call it like treading water turns you drew a bunch of cards at the end of your turn

and then it's your next turn and you don't like any of these cards and maybe you play one of them down and you jump the rest of your hand into your income pile and you didn't really do anything interesting and then you drop a bunch of new cards and maybe those don't really work for you as well and so it comes back around to you and you don't come into your income again or maybe you like these cards but you have no money and you need to get money in order to buy those um train cars and they get more and more expensive near the end of the game they cost 10 to 15 uh cards in order to discard and you only draw up to six in your hand at a time to get to 15 cards that way you have to spend many turns ditching most of your hand as money to be able to afford that train car and you might say well don't go for that train card just try to do the try to get points for the things you have in front of you and I understand that but you also have this hand of cards that you want to play out in order to score more stuff with those specific colors so I don't like how often you just have a very uninteresting turn it seems like at least three out of four turns I don't feel terribly engaged with what just happened and on that fourth term I'm like ah awesome and I plunk three cards down and then I happen to like score on the next round I draw the right cards those that definitely happens but not often enough for my taste and now let's jump into my only negative point but it's a big one it really feels like this game is far too dependent on luck of the draw as far as how well you do in the game you have all these things that you can do to try and put yourself ahead like creatively and strategically hold cards back and put cards out in specific situations and then Reserve this card to put it down to score those passengers But ultimately it just feels

like the person who wins is the person who drew better cards who drew the um maybe a nice set early in the game maybe that first hand of cards they can play three of those cards down right away into a train and then also get lucky to keep getting those cards in order to score them they're definitely going to take a lead out of just having to grab the right cards off the top of the deck and you might say well that's a lot of ifs but what I've seen is that does kind of happen uh somebody can be playing the game and feel like they're doing the best they can they're making lots of really good decisions they're dumping their hand when they're not getting anything they need but they've dump their hand three or four turns in a row they cannot get any cards that work with anything else it's just not syncing up versus the other player might be getting all the stuff they really need and they're doing some pretty cool stuff but they're not necessarily winning because they're outplaying their opponent they're winning because the correct cards are coming into their hand there is not a runaway leader problem with this game but I found that even a small ish gap between the two players can just be maintained throughout the whole game if the other player doesn't happen to get something going for themselves I really feel like there's two uh strong of a potential for somebody to get a better early game setup and just stay ahead through the whole game I've witnessed it happen and it's not particularly fun for either player the person who just cannot hit the right cards for the life of them well that's frustrating because you're like well next turn maybe you need to dump all your cards and drop a hand of cards and none of these work for you again versus the other player it's not a satisfying winning because you had the right cards fall into your hand that's not what

you're really looking for when you're playing these games and I'm not saying this is a game of war or just rolling Dice and the person who rolls highest wins there's definitely room for interesting strategic and tactical decisions in this game but it seems there is way too much of an influence of that card draw because of this like I said there isn't really a runaway leader I haven't seen one person blow another person out but it seems like one person just the person who gets in a lead early stays in the lead for the whole game and part of that also is because if one person gets a little bit lucky or early and the other person at the end of the game has drawn enough cards for the luck to even out and they have a really good engine and a bunch of uh trains and stuff in front of them the game is pretty much over because the game clock is how many times you score so if you have this great thing going for you near the end of the game it can be really hard to catch up at that point because your opponent is also doing the same thing and they're playing off of you if you finally get a really nice setup for one specific color and the other person can kind of match you then you're not gonna be able to jump ahead now I'm sure that people have come from behind in this game in the past but at the end of the day I don't like how much the card draw seems to swing the situation it takes a lot of the fun out of the decision you're making when you feel like you're making good decisions but it's not really getting you to where you want to be so now let's discuss the replayability of trombone and I think it's somewhat average just for board games in general it's not particularly good or particularly bad every time you play the game the only difference is how that big deck of cards is shuffled and the cards that are going to come into your hand maybe one game you'll have one or two trains that are going to be really big and that's all you do the whole game or another game you might have five or six

trains in front of you and you're just playing the cards that you get and you're trying to make interesting decisions as you're going through the game so if you play this game like 10 times the 11th time you're going to find yourself not exact not doing something exactly that you did in Prior games and so that's a reasonably good thing of course you need to enjoy the game enough to play it that many times but I think from a raw replayability perspective on the mechanics it's okay the next section is player count discussion but there's not a whole lot to say here because trombone is a two player only game so that's the only way you're gonna play it you're always gonna have an opponent playing against you and it seems to be designed well for that player count uh specifically how players can try to play off of what their opponent's doing if they have a really big suit that they're going for maybe you try to get a train down with some of that color as well so that when they do a big score you also score on the gap between you is a lot less I think that works really well in two player perspective um so yeah there's really not a whole lot else to say about that in conclusion I've been pretty disappointed by trombone I've really enjoyed celtus and lost cities in the past so I'm predisposed to enjoy this type of game in fact I really thought that I would enjoy Tron Bond more because it adds so much more on top of the mechanical decisions that you're doing on a turn and Celtics in Lost Cities you're playing a single card each chart and that's pretty much your whole decision structure and that could be a really interesting decision but in trombon you could play your whole hand you could play multiple cards down in front of you into trains you could discard cards that don't really work for you into money and then use that later to make those trains better and all those decisions are really great but ultimately I can't get over how much

card draw luck seems to dictate who wins the game and who loses I think maybe it has something to do with the fact that you draw so many cards at the end of your turn in peltics and lost cities you're always drawing a single card at the end of each turn and of course luck of the draw can be swaying in those games as well but in this one where it seems like you should usually only be saving one or two cards at the end of each turn you're drawing four to five cards at the end of every turn and that that's quite a bit of Sway and influx for somebody to draw several cards that all work really well for them and play them all down on the next turn versus somebody who gets several cards that just don't work very well together at all and the person who gets luckier earlier in the game they just seem to consistently stay ahead throughout the whole game and it's very difficult to get rid of that lead it's not a runaway leader situation it seems like the Gap usually stays relatively similar but you just really can't chew into it and I think it's going to be relatively rare that somebody comes from behind and has a really big win with some large scores at the end and if they do that they probably got really lucky with their card draw so ultimately I just have an issue with how much the card draw affects the game in general I really wanted to love it and I don't think I can necessarily recommend it it's not a terrible game it's just really mired by that randomness if you'd like to see more in-depth reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel also you can directly support the channel at patreon.com John getsgames thanks for watching

Progress saved