Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 18:17

welcome to junk it's games with 43 votes in and winning by five today I'm gonna be reviewing compounded this is a chemistry themed game of trading elements creating compounds and exploding laboratories first I'll go over the rules then I'll do my review and I'll end with three more games you can vote on for my next review alright so how do we play compounded the first thing to note is there is a four by four grid of potential compounds the players will have access to create throughout the game each player also has a player board which not only shows them the current level of their four areas of study but also is a nice area to hold the elements that they currently have available each turn has four different phases and you evaluate all players in each phase separately so we would have all players do phase one and then all fair's plate do phase two all players to Phase three etc etc so let's explain those phases now the first is discovery where each player is going to grab elements out of the bag equal to their current discovery level which at the beginning of the game is - once all players have grabbed their elements but before we go to the next phase there is a free-for-all trading session the first thing that can be traded are these elements themselves you can trade two for one one two one but as you can see there are varying numbers of them in this bag so some are rarer than others you can also trade these bonus kits which are acquired through completing certain compounds out here and trading non-binding verbal agreements once all trading has been done we have to discard down to our holding desk size which at the beginning of the game is 4 that's indicated by our lab statistic over here

so we discard down to 4 and now we can move on to the next phase when we study we take unused claim tokens and we put them out onto an empty compound that does not have one already so I can put this one here for instance if I had more than one I would place one and then other players would each place one around the table and then I would have a chance to place another unused claim token once all unused tokens have been placed players also the ability to move one token that was already out on the board to a different compound now we research and researching is where we take the elements from our desk and we put them out onto the player area we can put them on compounds and we can also put them on this fire extinguisher here once it gets to oxygen and a carbon it flips over into a the fire extinguisher which I'll explain its use in just a little bit so if we look over here and we see that a research level is currently at three that means I can take three elements from my desk and put them out onto the board like so remember I could have split them up if I wanted to but let's just say I put them over here and I can also trade three of one element for one of a different element one time during my research phase once all players have put their elements out we shift into the next phase which is the lab and this is essentially the cleanup phase we go in player order taking our compounds that have been completed we take the elements off of them we get our claim token back we'd score victory points and then we good to go up a area of study which is associated with that compound so this is a liquid so we could either go up once on discovery because that's associated with liquid or we can go up once in our

laboratory which is not associated with liquids solids or gases any of those three can bump up the lab instead now when you go up the lab it gets you this little chit here which goes there and now you can store five elements per turn instead of four which is quite nice the other bonuses that you get from the liquids is you could go up discovery and now you can draw three elements out of the bag instead of the original two at the beginning of your turn if we had completed a solid then we would go up on the solid track and this would unlock a new claim token so we could have a greater presence out on the board to claim various good compounds so that other players won't be able to get them and finally as we go up our research which is associated with gas we get to place more compounds from a board out onto the playing area quicker on each term once all compounds have been acquired and let's pretend like several more have we are going to start drawing them from the compound deck and at a certain point we are going to get a lab fire when we get the lab fire card we are going to set it off to the side and continue to fill in all of the holes in our playing area only after we've finished fill all of them in do we evaluate this lab fire and that just means that every element that has a little flame token on it is going to our flame icon on it is going to get a flame token as you can see some compounds have two flames and some have one so in this instance the ones that had two they're fine one more flame token and they will explode however hydrogen sulphide over here only

has a single so it is going to explode now now let's pretend like it had already had a couple of different elements on it and maybe a claim token when it exploded it the claim token is going to come back to the player Sanu had it and then the elements that were on it have to scatter out to an adjacent compound which is orthogonal or diagonal so I if I'm red I could take this hydrogen and move it say over here let's just pretend like I had a clay marker over here so that would help me out I could push this over here and then the sulfur has no legal place to go so it actually goes back to the bag this hydrogen sulphide is going to get go out of the game and we would draw a new card now let's rewind just a little bit and pretend like we were already here as we were before and I had completed my fire extinguisher this would be the perfect time to use it if it had been completed I would discard from the game and prevent the placement of this one flame token now my hydrogen sulfide is safe and I'm going to be able to probably complete it on my next turn and get lots of victory points you may have noticed that there are these icons in the bottom right hand corner of some of these compounds as I mentioned before these can give you little bonus chips which can be one-time use or permanent effects you can trade these I'm not going to go through the specifics of what all of those do they can like light fires or steel the first player token but what I do want to specifically mention is this right here this is the journal and you acquire it when you get to the second layer of solid study you take this little chit here you put it down here and this is a really nice ability this

lets you when you complete a compound as you take the elements off before you put them in the bag you can take a single one of those elements from the completed compound and put it back into your desk and then put the rest away so that's a really powerful ability that's inherent to the study vial the game is going to end from one of three different conditions the first is if a player gets to the top spot on three out of their four areas of study the second is if a player gets 250 victory points in either of those two cases there will be one more term played the third case is if we go through all of the compound cards and we are not able to fill out this 4x4 then the game is going to end immediately there aren't really many endgame victory points in this game there's really only two the first is if you've completed a fire extinguisher but you didn't actually use it to put out a fire then that's gonna be worth for extra victory points and lastly is this wild element marker which I didn't explain before it's worth two victory points if you haven't used it at the end of the game but during the research phase you can spend this to grab any element besides sulfur the player with the most victory points Oh atomic points wins the game before I jump into my review I do want to show you the atomic point tracker for the game our victory points and it's a periodic table you start at 0 you when you have one victory point you're at hydrogen when you have 5 victory points you're at boron and you just keep cycling through the periodic table which is pretty cool it can occasionally be a little hard to tell who's ahead of who but who cares it's a periodic table for a matter of you've compounded I'm gonna start with three positive points then three neutral one negative some player count discussion

and finally my conclusion so let's start with the positive the first thing is I love this chemistry scientific theme that goes along with this game it feels so fresh and different you know we're not building castles in Europe we're not flying spaceships through space we are constructing compounds with fundamental elements it's scientifically accurate and interesting we're chemists and a laboratory performing experiments and I just I have nothing like that in my collection and I love the way that makes me feel as I'm actually playing these game this game and pulling out these elements this theme is what initially drew me to the game looking at the Kickstarter I was just an instant backer that looked so interesting to me to be playing a chemistry based game that also looked like it had some interesting mechanics going on the second positive is I really like those for experimentation tracks on your player board the ones that tell you how many elements to pull out of the bag or how many claim tokens you have to put out on the board I really like that mechanic of specifically increasing the effectiveness of various actions inside a game I actually created a prototype game about four years ago that even had that just looked almost exactly the same with the four different tracks and yeah so that shows you how much I like it it's really an interesting mechanic of wanting to get too far ahead on any of these specific tracks if you pull fistfuls of elements out of the bag but can only put two of them down then that's not really going to increase the effectiveness and you're not really going to get ahead in that way you would much rather have be

pulling less elements out of the bag but be able to put more on the board and have more claim tokens also maybe being able to keep more of them on your player board so you really want it to stay even but then again you are limited by the compound options that are out in front of you which are which ones are taken which ones aren't taken and it's just a very interesting decision to think well I really need a gas so I'm gonna claim that one even though it's really hard to get to and I'll I'll figure that out I'll make it work the third thing that I really like about this game is the art and component quality I love the fact that we have a periodic table for our score track I know that occasionally it can be a little hard to tell who's in front of who but it's a periodic table who cares you have to have this in a chemistry game we've got all these compounds in the game and the way the cards look like this is the way that these elements actually line up in real life they are scientifically accurate many of them show you the positive and negative ends of these compounds and that has no in-game effect but it's just cool because it's accurate we've even got these test tubes to hold the player color tokens in the box they spend their entire lives in the box that you don't use them in the game at all but the publisher decided to go the extra step and put test tubes in a game about science and experimentation I just think that is super cool moving on to the neutral points the first one is potentially a groupthink problem and that is that I found that there is a lot less trading to happen in this game than I thought

you know potentially you can trade elements you can trade these bonus chips you could trade anything you'd say I'll scratch your back if you give me one carbon but in actuality I found that very little trading actually happens when we played the game and I think the main reason for that is it is a 100% open knowledge game there is nothing hidden you know exactly what elements your opponent has you know what compounds they might be going for what they can complete and that definitely stifles the amount of potential trades that happen because you're not they're thinking and if I give them a calcium will they be able to get that I'm not sure you know for a fact that they'll get be able to get that and now you're thinking how much is it worth it to me to allow them to do that and usually what ends up happening is the training phase starts and we collectively agree that no one is trading and then we move on I'd say in a typical game trades happen like maybe three or four times and that's a lot less than I was expecting in this game I really wanted more out of the trading mechanic but I can't necessarily follow the game for that that really might just be my and my friends problem the second neutral point is the way the lab fire mechanic mixes with the relatively high amount of flammable compounds in the game to create a slightly more chaotic game that I was expecting and maybe wanted to come out of the box you know mid mid to late game when several compounds have been claimed and you're putting new compounds out and then there's a lab fire and so you put some more out and you put the flame tokens down and then a couple compounds explode and then you put any more cards out the the game state can change quite rapidly and those flammable cards those flammable compounds are quite a big risk

to go in on and it seems like in general you get more victory points and more bonuses for doing flammable ones so there's risk versus reward but especially with the compounds that only have one flame token what ends up happening is people just never take those unless they have the option to grab it in one turn and that's just not very interesting because often times you have to have a very high research amount and the exact perfect elements to grab it in that one go so usually those single flame token elements they just they just get exploded pretty much immediately and they never really get into circulation with the game so I like the fire mechanic I like the exploding mechanic I think that's cool the way the elements scatter around but maybe just a little bit too much exploding and a little bit too much chaos for my taste the third neutral point is the potential to have a runaway leader situation in this game there was a big discussion on BoardGameGeek where the designer weighed in and said essentially that trading is the main way that players can really gang up and hurt a runaway leader they can trade amongst themselves and not trade with the leader and I get that and I can kind of see that happening but I mentioned before that trading doesn't really happen that much in our game and if the leader the person who has the victory points who has that really great experimentation levels to be doing really powerful actions they're more likely to be drawing the correct elements and there have the ability to place more elements out in the field because it's a bit rich gets richer you get more compounds which increase your abilities which allow you to get more compounds and rarely do people actually

get to stop that person there's no way to stick a wrench in the spokes of someone who's really doing very well that being said it's not been a plague on this game it's happened once or twice and it was a little bit of a bummer but I could see it potentially being an ongoing issue but it's it's not that big of a deal and now for my single negative with this game and that has to do with the fact that player order is really important in this game and there is almost nothing that you could do to change it there are a couple compounds which will let you steal the first player token but they're pretty rare in general the first player type can just move clockwise around the table but going first or being near the beginning of player order is really important to claim specific compounds that you really need for your engine that you might be lacking and I feel like this was a definite missed opportunity to potentially stop runaway leaders or more importantly help fall behind losers in this game if maybe the people who are doing the worst least victory points or maybe the worst experimentation track setting maybe those people got to go first because they now have the ability to get back into the game potentially and that person who has an amazing engine well they are now going to be a little bit hampered by the fact that they're not getting the potentially first dibs you know they might be getting last dibs they might be getting first dibs it depends on where that turn order token happens to be so sometimes when you're playing the game you're thinking about okay I'll be first player

in two turns and that's oh I'm gonna want to do this not but the game state like I said can change so fast that it's hard to plan for that as well so I really wish there was a better more integrated mechanic for changing the player turn order and I just think that was a missed opportunity so now let's talk about player count the box says it plays two to five players and I've played it in most those settings so let's start with two players in a two-player game there is actually a dummy player who is controlled by whoever is the start player on that turn the dummy player generates elements and can put elements out on the board and it actually works pretty well trading is almost non-existent between the two players because it's pretty zero-sum but you can trade one element with that dummy player which is a pretty interesting mechanic so two player worked three and four player games also worked pretty well that it feel like that's kind of where the game was built to be at the game progressed well and the there was definitely some chaos but not too much and shifting into five player I played one five player game and oh my gosh too chaotic for me I mean I would play it again five player if someone twisted my arm but I don't think it's a sweet spot for this game there are so many people buying for these compounds and so many compounds being completed that it's just it's very chaotic it exacerbates those chaos potential neutral issues that I had earlier so you could do five if you want but I think four is probably best and two worked better than I was expecting in conclusion I've played compounded 4 times now and I like it but

I don't love it I was expecting to stay more excited about continuing to play it then what actually ended up happening when the Kickstarter first came out I was so excited had this awesome chemistry theme where you're trading elements and you're doing engine building and compounds are exploding and I just was so excited I had to have it I got it my expectations were really high and I got my friends together and we played it and I enjoyed it but I remember feeling like not as excited as I thought it was gonna be and that's probably my fault I've just I had to high expectations and every time I played it subsequently I have enjoyed myself but I never really had that blood pumping excitement excited to hold your breath moment in the game and many other games give that to me so I think it's been a little bit overshadowed by other stuff that I've been playing instead that does not mean that this game is bad I will continue to own it I will continue to play it my girlfriend Jess really enjoys it and I think that people who think that scientists cool will also be very attractive to this game and especially maybe teenagers or / children I think it would very much work in that kind of setting where you've got great mechanics and you awesome integration with lots of highly scientifically accurate stuff to just really get people into that sciency mood if this sounds interesting to you then I recommend you give this game a shot it's time to find out which game you want me to review next I've got Valley of the Kings Mundus Novus and splendor if you look right below the video there's a quick link it'll take 10 seconds to vote and if you want please subscribe to my channel and you'll get to see which one of these games wins thanks for watching

Progress saved