Skip to main content
Loading video...

Not for me - A Wyrmspan Review

Transcript 17:18

beauty is an enigmatic trait it lies somewhere between objective truth and subjective opinion but it does indeed exist for example sweeping Landscapes profound Artistry shapes and even numbers can often be considered beautiful and in a way warm span joins as one of the most beautiful board games around from the moment you open up the box every card token and even the smell of the cardboard all has a certain charm a familiar friendliness in a way that is to say there is no room for anger frustration or bitterness in this 30 cm x 30 cm box and much like how you play as an amateur drist entic and Dragons warms span invites you to be captivated yet the question remains is it more than just a beautiful game does the intricacy of its design elevated to something truly extraordinary or is it just a paper dragon a quick admission I've never played wingspan so diving into worms span was going in completely blind so please note I won't make any comparison between between the two games but instead discuss worms span as a standalone game worms span is a tableau based engine builder which means that each player has their own little board to build out their caverns and fill them with Dragons which culminates in scoring as many points as possible within the four rounds and what many people may call multiplayer solitire the game has minimal interaction with other players yes of course interaction does exist resources like the cave and Dragon cards are mutually shared in a shop and yes

some other actions will allow players to join in as well or will let you compare your Tableau for a brief moment and there is the over Aran competition to score as many points as possible more than every other player but that's really where the interaction ends instead of focusing on other players the design of the game has you hyperfocus on your own Tableau like a cardboard succubus the game is selfish wanting you to indulge in the artwork the mechanics and to be in awe of your own Ingenuity through the designing of the highest scoring table unlike in a more confrontational game where a beefy chunk of strategy might involve making suboptimal moves to block someone else from a game-winning moment in warm span almost everyone I played with focused on achieving the most points for themselves not sabotaging other players large swings in points do not have a detrimental impact on other players so people are motivated to focus on their own tables without much concern for other players the game even explicitly States how you can never directly interact with another player's board to put this differently the entire Vibe is incredibly chill between players almost celebratory like a Fantastical hunter gatherer themed birthday party sure competition exists but if someone makes an engine that really cranks out points the resultant engine is celebrated and is more of a Fascination for other players rather than a failure to intervene in the creation of a Juiced up Point machine

put simply there are three main actions in warms span Excavating is to build out your cave to allow for more potential areas for dragons to nest in so what's the point well the worms span Tableau has three unique caverns and each Cavern can house up to four dragons that said you need to dig out some space to make room for each one so you pay a coin maybe an egg or two and start digging this lets you play a cave card which has an immediate onplay effect some of these onplay effects May trigger for other players but in general you make a cave and you get some kind of effect the thing about Excavating is it's kind of making the board into a layered cake you need to make the physical Space by paying a resource and then you can Place Your Dragon on top of the cave card this works for the most part and I think the goal was to increase some decision variety instead of just picking what dragon card you might want you also need to think about what cave card is most conducive to Big combos in other words the cave cards expand the board and allow for more decision making from the player because selecting the best cave card is necessary for sick combos that said opening up a new cave space is more akin to clearing space for the combo and not really the combo itself en tyon is put in that Dragon you have in your hand onto the board by paying a coin in resources what this means is you got to figure out which Cavern that dragon can live in based on the color it has access to as well as

what it needs to become enticed chunky meat shiny crystals and buttered gold are the most common but sometimes you'll have to pay that dragon with an extra coin or give it an egg or feed it that sweet sweet Dragon Milk this dragon card goes on top of the excavated cave and then hangs out there so what's in Tyson about in Tyson in warm span the dopamine button is hit when you get those big payoffs Gathering the resources you need Excavating the right cave on the board and having that key dragon in your hand all lead to enticing physically putting a dragon card on the board is satisfying and completes a critical step in the engine of your making which all feels good and a lot of dragons have effects whether they are immediate explore round end or game end as well as various traits and victory points tied to them of course some dragons encourage certain play styles for example the subass of the cute little hatch Lins that really crank up the cash in play style if you decide to go that route the Dragon cards are a focal point of each game and discovering their interactions with the other dragons makes for a very satisfying puzzle I also have to give note to the Stellar artwork which adds a glossy Sheen to a numberb based game which is needed to create the illusion that you really are ad drist and not an accountant that said making an effective functional machine is aely satisfying and en tyon a dragon is constructing a big chunk of that machine through

careful planning en Tyson is ultimately the pivotal step in creating a point machine you have the resources you dug the right spots you have that friendly dragon ready to go and placing It Down results in an immensely satisfying payoff exploring is pulling the lever on your engine thematically you're exploring the cavern you built and visiting all the dragons you've enticed each step along the cavern provides certain benefits where those are printed onto the Tableau itself or from the unique abilities of the Dragons you've played the more dragons you have nestled in your Cavern the more you can explore and reaching the end of the cave grants the maximum amount of benefits exploring also has a cost starting with a coin and progressively becoming more expensive in each round through the means of paying eggs exploring is a reward of all your hard work it's actively engaging with your machine for the benefit the more planning and the more work you put into that machine the greater the reward will be resulting in a slew of resources benefits and ultimately sweet sweet victory points it's a very friendly concept you make little holes you entice little animals and then you get to visit them for loads of gifts and the entirety of the game play is extremely satisfying in a number crunching way and yet you'll feel surprisingly ingenious when you've created a really clever mechanism to score points and exploring is the key mechanic to really demonstrate the viability of your machinery in a tangible way you can feel your dragon machine working through exploring and

you can really stack up those caching or tucking points or gather a ton of resources to further convert into victory points the game's Pac is balanced by these glossy Dragon Coins as they act as a method to resolve a turn the three e Excavating enticing and exploring all take a base cost of a coin to complete so when you're planning out your round it's easy to figure out how many moves you can do this also means that the coins are valuable and for example a dragon that costs an extra coin needs to have a big impact on your Tableau since it reduces the potential number of turns you can have and I like these coins because there's a certain decision weight to them having to pay an extra coin or receiving an extra coin does feel meaningful but if you're really thinking long term you can even save some of your coins for the next round and pull your Explorer lever like mad another neat thing is that worms span actually gives the same amount of coins each round which is enough to set up your dragon machinery and to utilize it fully in other words worms span gives enough turns to set up that point machine and to use it multiple times to score big points there's also a strict rule making sure you have an upper limit of coins and other resources at the end of each turn which actually incentivizes using your coins instead of finding methods to hoard them in general I felt like the game pace is quick at the start typically Excavating a few times maybe placeing a few dragons and a quick explore or two and since the turns are

rather simple it moves by at a Brisk Pace but by the endgame there is a Cascade of interactions that make you able to relish that machine you built the dragon Guild is another novel idea while there isn't much direct interaction between players there is a bit of a race through the dragon Guild whenever you activate a shield icon you can move your Shield through the guild gaining certain benefits along the way that said the most interesting part is either reaching the top or bottom of the guild these have unique and rather powerful abilities that can only be used by so many players for this reason sometimes a player may make a suboptimal play to quickly reach the desired benefit on the guild before someone else will take it this is quite light player interaction and it is nice to have but it doesn't change the game into a Cutthroat race around the track it's fun to hit those Shields take a juicy benefit and then curve around the track to the other side for another one end of round objectives round off the game with some points for certain requirements in most of the games I played people saw these more as an optional side quest than an active goal to accomplish which I think makes sense since a lot of these objectives are restrictive to building the machine you want it can feel like accomplishing many of these objectives is happen stance rather than intentional in other words objectives like who has the large dragons or who has the most playful dragons might be fun to achieve but can throw a wrench into an otherwise wellth thought out machine a common situation I

encountered is if a player is deciding between two dragons but one happens to be large and other medium the decision might be swayed by what objectives exist but it's not so much a critical reason to pick one over another another weird thing about these objectives though and a little bit of a blemish that you'll hyperfocus on is these weird scratch marks these x's and these kind of squiggly lines of course it's purely aesthetic but I honestly couldn't believe how an otherwise very beautifully designed game used this on these cards it felt a little off and now that I mention it you'll never not see it I think if someone came up to me and said I love worms span it's my favorite game I wouldn't have much to really dispute with them worms span is clearly well thought out beautifully designed and latly satisfying and has a Vibe like hanging out with a good amiable friend there is a lot of thinking planning and Beauty in this game and I think from an objective standpoint this game is extremely solid there is a problem though and it's not you it's me I'm really not meant for this game some things that are positive about it just can't fit my palet and while I can appreciate the game I can't say I really like the game there are a couple of me problems and I'll start with the big one I think the lack of meaningful interaction makes the game very boring there's interaction with the shop Sur cards and with the dragon Guild and with the end stage objectives but it never

truly feels meaningful denial of cards or of objectives doesn't have a powerful sense of interaction as much as it has a restrictive feeling for other players and sure I would argue restriction is a form of interaction but is it meaningful am I actively thinking about my opponent's next move am I analyzing their Tableau and find out how many times they want to hit the dragon Guild next turn do I really care about what cave they're digging I I don't and that's because the game doesn't really seem to want me to care I care about my board my dragons my mechanism and I want to make the best board that I can not steal away plans from other players and like I said it's a selfish game that wants to hyperfocus on the player and their creation and their Tableau with only momentary glances towards what's happening across the table and yes I know this game is UN active by Design and I'm not really bash in the game but I just don't feel compelled to have people play this with me because not much changes depend on who I play with worms span doesn't care about forming any interaction between players but instead wants all the attention on its gorgeous art on the satisfaction of his Machinery playing a game of worms span elicits the same feelings I had for a few weeks in 2022 when everyone would compare their wle streaks it's fun to compare your results your methodology and your thought process about a given puzzle and that's great that's something a lot of people will truly enjoy but that's not for me related to this oh my God playing this game with four or five

people feels agonizing turns move briskly at first just due to the Simplicity of the star and rounds but at round three and four the game turns into a crawl and this is from someone who loves longer games but it's hard to remain invested in someone else's turn when has minimal impact on your own space multiple times people zone out during other people's turns and I can tell because when the rare act does occur when other people can act during other people's turns aone almost wakes up from a days at four or five players the pace is more slug than dragon and this goes back to the selfishness of the game since the game draws all its attention to itself it's a challenge to remain invested in other players which is kind of sad I can recommend the game at 1 2 three player count but four or five it's just not worth the time and effort and quick pivoted into the single player modes they both work that said I don't find the single player modes particularly enticing either as the game is practically the same as playing with other people just with some rule adjustments to mitigate some cards not being applicable overall it's fine it's even great at moments but the single player mode doesn't enhance the game the game at its core is a series of dials and levers a machine dressed up as an experience don't get me wrong a lot of games are like this but I find it more and more frustratingly apparent after each game of worms span since I didn't immediately bond to the theme I find myself more and more invested in the Machinery of the game and how to plan each turn and how to optimize and often

people compare these games to an Excel spreadsheet and I can feel it in my bones it feels like I'm crunching numbers and creating functions the satisfaction I gain from exploring my Cavern is more akin to a quarterly report than exploring neighbor and caves and Dragons once you melt away all the art The Lovable dragons and the tokens into just numbers the game becomes almost entirely an optimization puzzle and again I don't think this is inherently bad interaction with numbers and mechanisms can be extremely fulfilling but I find it all so inorganic the game lacks surprise and it lacks the adventure of what it tries to sell worm span's Gameplay at its core is unemotional and mechanical and I recognize this is a me problem but it's a problem I have avoided through player interaction the closest player Crea tension is simply when some races around the guill track ahead of you or grabs a card that you were looking at and this might be enough for some players but it's not really enough for me some people truly fell in love with the theme other people really love the fine tuning of the machinery and I can appreciate these aspects the beauty of the game but I can't love it so what does this all mean where does worms span fall in my season list of greats I'm going to give worm span a 6 out of 10 and I know it's going to be a lot of people n or 10 out of 10 but I have a problem and I don't Vibe with it and I doesn't hait hit what I need a game to hit to have a great time I have to admit there is a certain magic to it it's beautiful and the theme can be captivated I can see why players get thrilled when they get that one Dragon they're looking at in the guide

book which actually comes with the game but it's a selfish game it wants all your butter all your crystals and all your attention there isn't enough room in these Caverns for four or five players and the engine building while enjoyable is more akin to a tax return than it is to an adventurous experience players may see brief moments of each other while they venture outside of their caves but a wave across the dragon Guild isn't enough to create a meanful moment ultimately the engine you make can be marveled at can score the highest points and the game will smile at you and wink because it captivated you

Progress saved