Skip to main content
Loading video...

Obsession 2nd edition with Stephanie

Transcript 22:42

kyoto koto welcome to three minute board games it is stephanie here for a very special episode that is not gonna be three minutes long because today i am bringing you my thoughts on obsession second edition and the upstairs downstairs expansion she's such a chunky girl i love her it's no secret obsession first edition is one of my favorite games it was top of the tv 25 last year and um spoiler alert probably top of the teepee 25 this year the most significant to me changed between first edition and second edition is

right here on the back of this thick boy it's the three minute board games gold medal logo on a real game on a real box which wasn't intimidating at all in fact when dan halligan asked if he could have the files to uh put the gold medal on the game i spent an evening redesigning it because the original image was kind of janky and only fit for online purposes and yeah i needed it to be perfect it's probably not but it's nice and small but it is there so it's still great second edition and upstairs downstairs did obviously go to kickstarter but they are now available retail so if you did not get in on the kickstarter get in on it now now dan also has a large number of highly informative videos on his own youtube channel about setting up a game of obsession both with and without the expansions and also how to integrate upstairs downstairs into the core game so i'm not going to repeat any of that information if you want to learn how to set up a game of obsession or if you want to figure out how to get all of those pieces from upstairs downstairs into the box which is thicker let's see balancing act can i get oh bump to the table there we go comparison super-sized game love it if you're trying to figure out don't knock the table stephanie not to the table how to get all of those upstairs downstairs pieces into the big box

then go check out dan's video because i cannot do it as perfectly as him for the somewhat obvious reason of not having designed the game instead i am going to finally open these shrink-wrapped copies of the game and all the expansions which may or may not have sat in our games room for some weeks because i may or may not have been again thoroughly intimidated by the question of how to do this justice in a video and may have procrastinated just a little bit but today is the day we tear off the shrink wrap and we see what's inside we do not eat the silica gel desiccant because it says do not eat and i always do what i'm told and i will give you some of my random thoughts as we go through i should note that i have already played 2nd edition and upstairs downstairs we know a couple who have very similar senses of humor to us and we often do double date board game nights it's quite cute really and we have played at their place because they did the kickstarter and actually there's got delivered before us which not impressed let's be honest what this means is i already have a good real-world sense of how some of the changes actually work in play which is good because unlike some other ridiculously talented board game videographers i can't just read a rule book and tell you what impact rule changes are going to have in the real world i am only mortal first out of the box and no surprise to experienced gamers is the rule book which contains jay's single favorite thing in the entirety of gaming

the victory points distribution pie chart which i have to agree is pretty useful one really irritating thing often in games where there are multiple paths to victory is when you don't know at least the first time you play how much value there actually is in pursuing say objectives over tech points over pure victory points over hoarding gold my single favorite thing about second edition that's probably a lie i have plenty of favorite things but one of my favorite things is the storage boxes so we not only have these square purple boxes for all of your components just to make sure they're packed away neatly and stack at a nice level but you also have these boxes for the individual families where you can put all of your starting cards your starting bonuses so you're not scrabbling around going wait who gets 300 pounds who gets to start with the cook more on the cook later these are just no box inset has ever made me as happy as these boxes make me our wonderful little turn board is back and there has been some change to the extended play version where the holidays right at the end have been rejigged the national holiday which is when you can invite guests of any prestige ranking to an event and they have to say yes because it's a public holiday what else are they doing is now a lot earlier because it can be a real bummer if you get it in front of that second or third to last round and you just don't have the people or the events ready because you've already been burning all your resources i really like it when new editions of

things just make little quality of life improvements and one that is really great is the family board previously and these are still in the second edition because you can choose which one you like you had your family board and you had to have this little extra tile to slot underneath it to create your tableau of improvements this is still really useful because it gives you the name so you don't have to remember like which color is essentials which color is sport but now you can play with the other side of the family board that just has the colors built in i don't know why this pleases me so much but it just feels very elegant changes have now been made to the builders market probably need to fold that in half so you can see the actual relevant side now once you get to the end of season one when you are restocking the builders market all service tiles go into this 300 pound square which means they're not clogging up the builders market when you're trying to get the more high value improvements out after season two you do the same thing with all prestige one tiles once again meaning that you're actually managing to cycle through at a point when people may not want to be picking up service tiles or prestige one because you're trying to save your money for those awesome monuments one rule change i love is the difference in objective cards in second edition instead of getting two at the beginning of the game and then slowly accruing more at different turns you start with five and you discard down there are also other ways of getting more objective cards but what it means

fundamentally is that you're not stuck hoping you get a good objective card late in the game when maybe you pick one that's perfect you've already got two of the three improvements you need to complete it or it's completely broken because someone's already got two of the three properties you need or there's never enough time to hire enough servants to get all of the victory points starting big means you can quickly rule out which ones are probably not going to work but you still have them in your back pocket if you need them and you can adapt your strategy more organically i guess and rounding things out we have our purple obsession bag if you are from new zealand and i think the broader commonwealth you strongly associate this particular shade of purple with cadbury chocolate which just makes the game seem more decadent even though cadbury's not that good these days we also have a purple d20 because this is a real board game i joke and finally a plastic bag full of plastic bags full of servants make your own inappropriate joke here now let's not forget now rush to get to upstairs downstairs that we do also have the wessex expansion which provided the fifth family and also rules for solo play but i think it's only fair i leave that one to jay and we have the 18 promotional tiles from the kickstarter 20 were actually developed by backers two were picked for incorporation into the game that was the parish church and the babbling brook which seemed very suitable and these are the rest and they're super

fun and completely unbalanced because they haven't been properly play tested i'm sorry dan i'm just gonna throw them all in and see what happens but this is what we're really here for the upstairs downstairs expansion and before i crack the seal on this beauty i just need to check that y'all know why it's called upstairs downstairs because if you don't you are missing out on a great cultural touchstone the tv show upstairs downstairs the closest thing you may know to it is uh downton abbey it's that kind of english manor house there's the nobility and then there's the people doing the actual work supporting their lifestyle the upstairs and the downstairs now downton abbey was not based on upstairs downstairs because downton abbey was based on gosford park which was based on upstairs downstairs and you can tell because one of the main actresses from upstairs downstairs is in gosford park and now we need to talk about gosford park kids this is called a dvd case ask your parents gosford park is a perfect film it is one of my favorite in the universe it requires frequent re-watching because there's definitely details you have forgotten it has the most ridiculous cast of a-list british actors playing the nobles

and a-list british actors playing the servants richard e grant is in this and he is literally just a footman like he has maybe three lines of dialogue richard e grant but he's in this everyone's in this helen mirren is in this clive owen is in this kelly mcdonald is in this there's even americans in this ryan philippe is in this and i have to say when i first saw it i was like wow you exist outside of teen heartthrob films i'm really accurately dating my own age there it is a murder mystery dumbledore dies spoilers um in a english manor house where everyone is disillusioned charles dance is in this kristin scott thomas is in this i just jeremy northam sings i'm fine it's a great great film i highly recommend tracking it down and even if you don't like it once you've seen it you will understand why obsession is forever and always game of the year as far as i'm concerned and dame maggie smith is in it because of course dame maggie smith is in it so what do we have inside the box so many wonderful things what a shock the first thing is the rule book which includes unique rules for five to six player games explanations of what the new servants do and all the other information you need

as well as a card detailing the promotional cards and their special rules just in case it's not clear from the text on the card itself which sometimes happens family cards guest cards and player guides as you would expect but amongst the 16 promotional guests also included we have the canonical first lady of color in the obsession universe which i highly endorse um i don't want to get all political here but basically we frequently erase the fact that there were plenty of people of color walking around england like right back to hadrian's freaking wall so having a game like obsession just be wall-to-wall white people especially when you've also got americans hopping the freaking atlantic nearly said pacific that's portraying my geographic origins just didn't feel entirely right to me so i like this uh she is sarah forbes benetta a former west african princess rescued from slavery and defended befriended by the court of the queen told you to keep an eye on those victory point tiles didn't i here they are they're bigger now the same size as the objective cards which is very pleasing and just a little easier to keep track of once markers and coins and servants are flying all over the table because dan halligan is an awesome person and unlike apple doesn't expect you to buy entirely new sets of peripherals every time he upgrades his product he has included an upstairs down says this little board which has the builders market reserves which is a

change from second edition but it means if you've got first edition you just slap this on your side of the derbyshire board and you're good to go brilliant there are of course tiles one has immediately popped off and is currently balanced on my arm so i can only do this in one take um there are sets of the basics for the sixth family there are new uh monuments there are these interesting ones the babbling brook is over there it actually changes color when you use it so it's not just about using it to get increased victory points you may want it to be a sports ground for the season that the fairchilds are really into sports and then flip it back to an essentials i think uh in any case tiles love them all the components are just so nice to touch and that's a really important thing to me in games and that tile's slipping so oh god i need to catch it tiny little purple bag and finally the fun new servants so we have four new servant meeples confession time i am a complete sucker for custom meeples any kind of game i'm a wizard my meeple has a little wizard hat i am in i'm a seamstress my meeple has knitting needles there was a pratchett joke to be made there and i didn't make it i'm sorry for that i'm in uh i'm an old school accountant and my meeple has an abacus i'm in these are some of the best

i just love them the original game already came with great meeples these are just a whole step up i love them let's go through them one by one just in case you're not across what they do the head house made in pink she allows you to screen for guests if you add her to an event which allows you to take new guests or she can stand in for the housekeeper but not screened guests if she's doing that because you know she's only one woman the whole boy in baby blue can stand in for the butler on any butler task can stand in for a footman on the carriage house task and if a monetary favor is being awarded by an event or a guest if you add him additional to the other staff that are required you increase that favor by a hundred pounds let's not ask why the cook in orange look at her she's got a little wooden spoon little wooden spoon uh there is a renovated kitchen which she is required staff for whether she is used on that or additionally on any other event that doesn't require her she increases the family's reputation alternatively she can be used on any event other than the renovated kitchen to allow prestige rank one or two higher guests to attend who wouldn't normally be able to kind of if you think of it in a role play way normally i wouldn't be seen dead lady ponsonby's morning tea but don't you know she's just hired a french cook and finally in brown the useful man

so useful i'm just going to read from the rulebook for the things he does because i need to remember placed on the private study he increases your income from village fares place them on the builders market to decrease the cost of the tile by a hundred place on any improvement tile temporarily decreasing its prestige rating by one or he has two one-time uses removed from the game to refresh the builders market or remove from the game to search the tile bag for a specific tile not including monuments and place it in the 800 pound space in the builders market he's gonna be very strategic to play and that's probably why i'm never going to recruit one so that is my probably not very quick at all tour through obsession second edition and the upstairs downstairs expansion and it's probably just about time for me to babble a little about why i love this game so much but before i do that i'm putting it down because my shoulder is already hurting and i haven't even packed the expansions into this yet so junk so why do i like obsession obviously the theme was a really powerful attractor to me i love any game where i can be really silly but also feel really challenged and i should note that i play obsession and everyone i play obsession with plays obsession as a bit of a role-playing experience if you're not lamenting every time you draw a cad or

feeling somewhat scandalized that two young gentlemen and three of the footmen have been down in the gazebo all afternoon or feeling slightly worried that your son might be about to take up with an american heiress to me you're not really enjoying the spirit of the game the balancing of the needs of the gentry with the people actually doing the work to support their lifestyle as represented by meeples is one of my favorite expressions of the worker placement game the components and the design and art style are just delightful and the icons and player guides make everything pretty easy while there's also a huge amount of additional information if you really want to dig deeper into it now even to this day sharing a house with this collection of games i'm still not entirely comfortable anytime i'm learning a game that has more than like three or four different ways to score victory points and obsession has seven based on the little score sheets you get but they all feel really earned did you manage to hook one of the fair childs did you build the biggest house do you have the most money do you have the most servants and there are the objective cards which in second edition because you start with five and you winnow them down you can be really strategic about how you're pursuing those points so it all works for me in a way that oh but by the way were you collecting these

matching artifact sets that we never actually mentioned and don't thematically tie into anything i'm not a fan finally in classic 3-minute board game style some recommendations of other games you might like to try if obsession doesn't seem like quite your cup of tea and i'll try not to be offended by that obviously thematically i have to recommend marrying mr darcy as a much simpler mechanically game but with all the same scope for hilarity and role-playing and cut-throat female socialization in the regency era love it it also reminds me every time i play of the old tv ad for the sweet valley high board game which just included the line jessica you're still my boyfriend why do i remember that why is that using space in my brain another if you want that kind of dynastic building experience is legacy the testament of duke declassi now mechanically if the theme doesn't grab you even after you've done your homework and watched gosford park a couple of times it's really hard to pick one i just did a little brainstorm off-screen with jay and we couldn't really think of anything that has the same level of the the tableau building which is really reminiscent of uh castles of mad king ludwig the really specialized meeple placement but also the card management

and in a way the resource management of your events and your deck of guests and your servants so um you just stuck playing obsession can't say i'm mad at that conclusion all right team that's about all from me i hope you enjoyed the slightly rambly long video let me know in the comments if you'd like to see more of this face on the channel i'm hoping to have a proper three minute review out before the tiffy 25 which maybe before or after jay's top 100 we'll just have to see how the timing goes and before i go just allow me to be a bit of a board game mum and give you a bit of a public service announcement i'm recording this before the new zealand general election that's next saturday for us this video will be out after that guaranteed um advanced voting is taking place now and over a million people have already voted and that's pretty cool this video will probably be out before other people's big national elections so i just want to say wherever you are in the world if you live in a democracy and you have the opportunity to participate in that democracy do it register to vote get out to vote get young people you know out to vote because building that habit early for young people is so crucial to making sure they continue it throughout their lives that's just all i wanted to say at what

is quite a pivotal time for new zealand democracy and democracy around the world this has been obsession second edition and the upstairs downstairs until next time i am stephanie and this has been a longer than three minute three minute board games video and i'll catch you all next time kakitayano if you enjoyed this review make sure to like it subscribe to the channel and support us on patreon

Progress saved