Wondrous Creatures - 3 Things I LOVE, 3 Pieces of Feedback
Transcript
hi my name is Ben this is board game dad and today we're talking about the two to four player game by bad comic games wondrous creatures now this is a review so I will be telling you my opinion on the game however this is a prototype copy provided by bad comet and as such I won't give you my final thoughts on the game because the game is not final but instead I'm going to be focusing on whether or not this is the kind of game that you would like to back on Kickstarter which is now open and you can find links in the description but with that purpose in mind I'm going to be talking about three things about this game that I'm very excited about as well as three pieces of feedback that I gave the Publishers but first let's talk about how to play wondrous
creatures so here we have wondrous creatures set up for two players and in order to fit the frame of the video video I've turned the board sideways this is actually the top and this is the bottom and each player is going to have their own player board now if you're familiar with the game everdell as you're looking at this you could be helpful to to think about this like everdell because we do have a market of cards that are available for players to pick up and put into their hand they're going to be building those in a tableau along their player board during the game and then here is a map which is also where players are going to be putting their workers or what they call the crew in this game in order to collect resources and then we also have a section of the board that is for uh objectives or achievements that can be earned during the game and then finally on the board there's spaces printed for the supply so we have all of that now in addition to elements that would be familiar to players of everdell we also have these trophies these trophies signify the immediate end of the game or rather when the last trophy is taken every player gets one more turn and that's going to happen no matter how far you've moved on the time track here however if a player does get to the end of the time track it immediately removes the last Trophy and the end of the game can be triggered
that way as well I'd like to also point out how this game can vary from game to game uh first we have these objective cards so there are three types of objectives and there are several other cards that can be dealt into these areas for objectives in the game that's always different also the eggs that you see on the board these are going to be in different spaces each time you play the game and then the player boards there's some variability here so this card can be added to a player board and it can be swapped out with any of the other captains over here which I've put on display and when you take a captain it also modifies one of your game pieces so I've got Samuel here on my piece but this could be exchanged with any other Captain let's now talk about game play so a game of Wonders creatures is going to be played with players taking turns to perform one of four basic actions so the first basic action is going to be placing a crew onto the board here we're going to talk about that more in depth in a little bit the second basic action is to play from your hand up to two cards the third action is to claim one of these achievements and then finally the fourth action is to use your turn to recharge so let's go over those four actions one at a time so let's talk
about placing a crew you'll notice that every play players crew pieces are large enough that they cover two spaces when placed on the board two hex's now there are several different types of hex's all players have access to these clearings here but some players have a special ability on their player board to place their crew on another terrain type so I have the ability to place my crew on Islands so I could place mine right here now when I do that if I cover any eggs I can pick those up and put them on my player board the spaces on my player board are numbered so I have to start with one and add them in increasing order we're going to talk about the significance of eggs later when we talk about achievements but for now let's talk about the effects of placing This Crew I am going to be able to pick up resources from all of the adjacent habitats to the space is where my crew is so I'm adjacent to this purple area this yellow area and this green area now there are two types of resources there are the food that come from those areas so let's see I might want to take the green food and the yellow food but then for the purple habitat instead of taking the food maybe instead
I'll take the other type of resource which is cards all of the creature cards are associated with a specific habitat so if I was interested in this card I could take it because it comes from the the purple habitat um the other ones on here we have the blue habitat and a yellow habitat but I'll take this card and I'm going to add it to my hand that's it for the basic action of placing a crew that would be the end of my turn you might still be wondering about the captain we're going to talk about that a little later when we talk about free actions the next action is playing up to two cards those cards are going to be coming from your hand and there are many different cards in this game in fact the entire deck is full of distinct cards so we're not going to go over what all of the cards do but we will go over the basic card Anatomy so we take a look at this card and it has the habitat that it comes from it has the type of creature that it is it has its cost along the side here it has an effect which could be of many different types this is an instantaneous effect and then finally it has Victory point value or at least it often does you can see this car doesn't have any victory points but it's an end of game card that will give me points if I SA
safy this condition it also has two animal types we're going to be talking about these animal types when we get to achievements anyway I can play up to two cards on my turn and I want to make sure that I can afford it so if I look at these two it's going to cost me two green one blue and a total of two purple in order to take both of these cards and add them to my Tableau that would be the turn for playing up to two cards the next basic action is claiming one of these achievements if I wanted to claim let's say this achievement it's looking for creatures that have at least seven fish and reptiles so that can be any combination so I've got 1 2 3 4 five six and I almost have enough for that seven so that's where the eggs come in I can get that extra fish from the egg on my player board but whereas these I'm always going to have once I've used the egg I have to flip it over so I flip over this egg that will be my seventh creature of this type and what I can do is I can claim that trophy it means I'm going to choose one of my player markers and any player marker that I use is going to give me a special benefit so I can be strategic about this to get the
benefit that I really want in any case I would take that and put it up here and I will get my award for my player board so I guess I'll take some blue and then the trophy is going to be added down here that also gets us one trophy closer to the end of the game The Last basic action is to recharge so for this I had to jump ahead again I now have all of my crew on the board and what I want to do is bring them all back then you're going to advance on the time track up here and that's going to release a few new refresh tokens so this tells me where additional eggs are going to go it's saying that I'm going to put a new egg drawn from the bag on all spaces with a square so there's going to be three spaces that match now I also have two new tokens which are going to create new actions on the board uh any of these spaces that have an icon on them have a special action which we haven't talked about yet but I can go ahead and upgrade one so that it becomes a little bit more powerful that's it for the four basic actions however there are still a few more game elements that I've been saving until now these are the free actions so one free action uses one of these net tokens that you begin the game with and which you you can pick up as you
continue to score ingame points by spending a net I can in addition to picking up my normal resources collect an adjacent egg normally you can only take eggs that you're directly on top of I could take an egg or if I didn't want the egg I could also perform one of the the additional actions on some of these spaces so for example this one allows me to take one more uh purple Resource One More mushroom I could use that for the cost of a net and that's for free I can do that with any of my workers on the board and it's very useful for when you have a card that you really want to play but you're only missing one more resource so we've got the net the next thing is concerning special cards like this some cards are going to let you put energy tokens on them and as a free action during your turn you can discard one of the energy to perform the special effect for that card that's a free action and then lastly there's upgrading your player board so this also concerns the captain crew member during the game if I've once I've placed my second creature I can slide this up to show that I've finished that
task and I now gain a special ability this is going to be a different ability for each Captain but now it says that as an example whenever I place my captain I'm going to get one in-game point for every trophy that I've earned so far so if I was to place this on the board even from my example because I have one trophy I would immediately earn one Victory point okay the second one on here is going to be achievable once you've placed two of your markers I've actually already placed two markers so I've achieved that and this is what gives you the ability to place on Islands so that's it for the rules but there is so much more to unlock in the game as so much more is included in all of these unique cards you have cards that give you special abilities all sorts of onetime effects um we've got the energy effects there's just a lot to do and really it's going to depend on what cards you pick up during the course of the game that's how wondrous creatures is played but is this the kind of game that you'll want to back on Kickstarter well to describe how a game feels I usually use the perfect board game formula which is five attributes that describe a game's profile these aren't my opinion on how much I
like the game but rather my analysis on the game's dominant characteristics on its theme mechanics components strategy and complexity if you'd like to learn more about that you can check out my links in the description below where I also have the perfect board game quiz where you can find out your perfect board game formula using the games that you like as examples anyway for wondrous creatures what stands out about this game more than anything else is definitely its wondrous creatures the Fantastic artwork and imaginative creatures and names the game is simply beautiful but not only that it also has a fun and engaging mechanic which is medium weight in its complexity so for that reason the game would have very high mechanics and component scores whereas it would have an average or even low complexity strategy and theme score now that being said there are three things about this game that I am very excited about and three pieces of feedback that I have for bad comment things I'm excited about number one you heard in my rules teach that I made a reference to everdell well one thing that this game does differently and that I love about it is that in in wondrous creatures the game terminates for everyone all at the same time but the thing with a game like this is that because of the card kind of engine
building mechanic it's very difficult to stop you know it's the kind of game where you're hoping that the game doesn't end now sometimes what designers do is they have like a game in condition that somebody can just surprise you you know they they come from out of nowhere and suddenly the game is over for everyone and everyone goes oh no I wasn't ready right but by using this trophy thing it it it puts a end at the game so that it doesn't go too long but it gives everybody a fair warning so that they can prepare their strategy for the inevitable end of the game and I really really like how that's done here not only that but if players don't go for trophies you also have the round counter which will remove the trophies so in either case the game is going to end and it's going to end for everyone second thing I always get excited when I find a unique new mechanic something that I've never seen before and this worker placement in a map where the worker covers two spaces is a brilliant new idea it creates so much flexibility and so many options for players because rather than have a space that you know always gives you the same resources you're going to be able to find something or you can try to find something that satisfies exactly what you need I think that that's that offers a lot of creativity for players and I really like that I've never seen it before maybe it exists I haven't played every game but this this seemed new to me and it really stood out I like it a
lot and then finally but of little surprise is The Game's wonderful artwork now for me I'm often very skeptical of games with great components because it makes me question does the game actually have any substance is the game actually fun and I think that wondrous creatures is very fun I think it's very engaging and because it is the components are that much more satisfying and I think what adds to it is the the five types of cards you've got the instant effects The Continuous effects in game the cards that are active during the recharge phase and the energy uh type cards now those card types I've seen cards like that in other games before nothing extremely unique there but it really enables players to enjoy finding how they're going to get uh Synergy between all of their cards it's always a lot of fun the game is well designed in that regard and I'm excited about it I do have three pieces of feedback however and the first concerns those magnetic Captain pieces those are up front and center for all of the photographs of this game but when it comes to gameplay that feature is purely aesthetic at least in the Prototype and I'd really like to see those magnets being used in gameplay I think there's a lot of potential to have them be more
than just decorations for your meeples for example it'd be cool if at some point during the game the magnetic piece would have to come off that would actually give necessity to the magnet or the game as it is right now all of the player boards are identical so the only variation among players is the captain that varies from player to player and that magnetic piece it would be very cool if the player boards were also distinct so that you could have combinations of player board and Captain working together I would love to see that I'm not sure if they're going to do that or not but I do think that there is a lot of potential from there and I have been assured that there are going to be changes being made especially to the player Powers the next thing has to do with the pacing of the game I've played this game both two-player and four player and I found that the pacing of a two-player game was very thrilling it was a great pace and I think the reason is is in a two-player game as you're refreshing the map with more eggs there are fewer players for all of those eggs to be passed around and as a result players have more chances to use eggs to satisfy objectives and earn trophies that that makes the pace of the game a little quicker whereas in a four-player game there's more people to share those eggs and as a result players use fewer eggs to claim objectives and it slows the game down a little bit now I think
of all of my feedback this is the easiest one to fix you just simply add more eggs in a four player game and and that would only just be one suggestion there's lots of things they could do there but I did notice a a a difference in the game's pacing and I thought it was much better two-player than four player at least as it is right now my last piece of feedback is that I wish the game was a little bit more thematically cohesive in the cards effects now give you an example of what I mean I would compare the game to something that most people are familiar with you look at wingspan in wingspan you have all of these different bird cards but then among Birds of Prey they all have a very similar card Effect you're drawing cards you're looking for birds with a smaller wingspan and you're you're getting them for victory points but in one creatures of course all of the creatures are fantastic so you don't go into the game with any expectation for how these creatures should behave but there's no noticeable Trend among creatures of the same species I wish the designers would consider the game's lore and add to it a little bit more story about what each type of creature is and what their card effects are so that you could have Trends among how they how those cards perform when you get them I don't think if you said okay my strategy is going to be collect mammals that there would be anything that would be different about how your game goes than
if your strategy was to collect reptiles and I don't think that should be the case I think that the different animal species should lead you down a different strategic path and if there is a theme among animals of the same type it wasn't apparent to me playing the Prototype um I've told a little bit of my concern and I've told you about my profile whether or not this is a game for you I now leave that decision in your hands but I hope you found this review helpful thank you very much for watching and a special thank you for everyone who is supporting me on patreon you guys enable me to release my honest reviews on board games thank you so much for your support again thanks for watching and I'll see you next time bye-bye