Spring Meadow: Review by All You Can Board
Transcript
hey there it's Carlo from all you can board and today I'm gonna be reviewing spring meadow which is ubi Rosenberg's final game in his polyomino trilogy the first two were cottage garden and Indian summer whether you've played any of those before or patchwork which is a two-player game II made in the same style either way there's a lot to like here about spring meadow it's not a perfect game but there's a lot of interesting stuff that set it apart from some of the other games let me tell you a bit more about it the first thing you'll notice in terms of the presentation of the game is it's not quite as colorful as cottage garden or especially Indian summer which is I would say arguably the nicest looking one of the trilogy it has a little more of a simple subtle look to the artwork but I think it fits the game well you know the theme involves the snow melting away as winter ends and spring begins so obviously there's a lot of white just from the snow as you're filling your boards with tiles it kind of heralds the arrival of spring so you're kind of adding more color to it but overall you look at the components they're all they'll fit the game super well it's nothing spectacular you're not going to be you know showing off the components to your friends it might not be one of the absolute nicest games in your collection but I don't really have anything to negative to say about the artwork you know the little marmots are pretty nice-looking the signpost is a neat little thing the compass kind of
works you know not only well as a placeholder but like just the theme of a compass works well when you're kind of finding your way on a hike I suppose the idolized hiking pins the rocks everything kind of fits together well going back to theme for a moment though if you're the type of person who really needs a thought a strong thematic presence in your games this might not be the game for you I got to be honest while I'm playing it's I can't say I've ever really thought about hiking or applied anything relating to hiking to the game the theme is really just more of a backdrop to the game it's kind of similar to cottage garden an Indian summer in that way but I maybe felt like the theme was integrated a little more especially in cottage garden but but even in an Indian summer as well here it's definitely kind of just a loose thing again doesn't really take away from the game if you don't mind that I don't personally come to spring meadow for the theme and the sort of lack of cohesion between the theme and the gameplay hasn't really affected my enjoyment of it at all so what you're probably wondering is is the game design different enough from cottage garden and Indian summer to warrant you know playing another one of these games or owning owning a spring meadow as well I would say the answer is yes there is a lot different in this game that sets it apart from the other ones while sharing some of familiar mechanics for starters I really like the 5x5 board the central board the grid here I like how as the signpost goes around you might be taking something from a row or column here and that might have been a tile that someone else could have
taken as the signpost swung around the other side later so that kind of makes there's potentially a little bit of player interaction in that in that sense another thing would be the marmots and the burros on the boards the fact that everyone has their own personal board and you're trying to kind of build around these burros but you've got the holes and the tiles that your again you can use the the holes over the burrows themselves to clear them but the fact that you can you know you also have to you can only cover a borough with a part of the tile it doesn't have a hole if you already have a cleared borough it's a nice little restriction that makes you have to work around it but it also rewards you for playing around it properly because if you're clearing those burrows and lining up your holes properly there's opportunities for a lot of extra points so I really like that aspect the fact that your points at the end of the game don't really matter like you're you're scoring throughout so you basically you get one point for winning the round right your your points don't matter at the end of the game so much as they do at the timing of the scoring rounds I really like that I like the fact that you can kind of see in advance when a scoring around may or may not be happening sometimes you're taking a tile that you know you don't want as much but it might lead to scoring happening sooner or later so if you feel like you've got a really good lead on the other players you might want to do something that you think will speed up the scoring round whereas if you feel like you're falling behind you might take a different tile that makes it you know delay the scoring for a few more rounds I really like that
another thing I really like about this is the strategy of lining up those tiles with holes to get those rocks so again because everything on the board I think the smallest piece here has two covers two spaces and it has two holes the biggest ones like these ones that have six spaces don't tend to have holes so it's like the more coverage you're getting from the bigger space you're not getting those the the holes that allow you to combo and get the rocks but if you're taking those smaller pieces or even the bigger ones and you're just doing a great job lining up all those holes long-term I find most often the player who wins the game is the player who had the most extra coverage from these rock tiles I always say at the end of the game when we determine who the winner is I always ask everyone you know take your other the the main tiles put them back in the box but set aside your rocks just so we can compare and see who had how many rocks it's not an indication that that person's always gonna win but it definitely makes a big big difference in getting that extra coverage each turn it's also worth noting that although the game does have a certain element of luck in terms of you know if you land on a row or column where none of the tiles there work for you in any particular way you could feel like it's unlucky but for the most part if you're not doing well or if you come up short you can usually look back and realize oh I should have done this differently or I should have put this in a different spot so I like that there's a certain element of luck so you know if you play with the same player it's not like there's you know the better player is gonna win 100 out of 100 times sort
of thing but I like that little you know slight infusion of luck but for the most part it's about your long-term planning and how you carry out that that planning and the decisions you make throughout the game another thing I really like about the design is the solo mode I have to say most games I play where there's a solo mode sometimes it can feel like it might be just tacked on or even though it might be alright you might think I'm never gonna pull that game off the shelf specifically to play the solo mode the solo mode the spring meadow not only is quite different from the regular game in the way it plays but it's also really challenging but also really rewarding but there's a target score and the rules that says you know if you get this many points you had a good game you can aim for this many points so in the solo mode it actually keeps track of your points using a different system on the other side of the board and then there's even a campaign mode where it suggests basically playing four games in a row where you use a different set of twenty-five tiles each game and then you're adding up your score to see if you can beat a target of I believe it's six hundred points on their campaign so I tried it a bunch of times it took me a while to even get their target good score what they say in the rules is probably my tenth to tenth or so at the solo game I tried the campaign mode once or twice I was not able to reach the 600 points I had a blast playing it each time I did so even though I you know prefer playing the game with two three or four players it's definitely one that I'll get back to the table in solo mode just because I got to get that campaign score so I mentioned before that there can be a little bit of player interaction when
you might take a tile that is also in a row or column that someone else would be able to take from later so you know that that tends to come up every once in a while but there isn't really a whole lot of take that you can't really do things intentionally to hamper your opponent's and that sort of thing so the player interaction overall is pretty low I have to be honest this is one of those games that even at a four player count you could technically play the entire game start to finish in complete silence without saying a single word because you just take a tile place it move the signpost as long as everyone knows it's their turn technically communication doesn't have to even come into play with this so if you're someone who really relies on high player interaction to have fun in your games this probably isn't the one for you you'll be honest even though I had a lot of fun playing this and I still do I don't know if I'd use the word fun to describe the game think of the way you do like a I mean I know we're using puzzle tiles but think of actually doing a puzzle you're putting two words you're you know you're using your spatial awareness you're it's it's kind of a relaxing thing though and that's kind of what I think of spring meadow eyes it's a pretty laid-back relaxing game you're not gonna feel really like stressed out about your decisions even if it's your turn you're not like everyone's watching me what am I gonna do here sort of thing it tends to be a pretty relaxed experience at the same time there can be a decent amount of strategy so it kind of depends on who
you're playing with if you're playing with someone else who is just kind of like once that lazy Sunday afternoon game you can just play it while you're talking and going back and forth and you know it could just be kind of a relaxing gaming experience whereas if you're playing with people who might prefer you know high strategy games and that sort of thing there is room for a lot of strategy in here and yeah it kind of depends on who you're playing with on in terms of you know how serious people get how much you're thinking about your long-term strategy versus kind of just placing these tiles and trying to fit them around so I think there's a good variety in that sense in terms of you know you can take it really seriously and be competitive or you can also just like play with your significant other and you're kind of just both taking it easy enjoying a relaxing game part of what really makes me enjoy the game though is it's short play time honestly playing with two players I don't know if I've ever had a game take longer than half an hour sometimes that can include set up 2025 minutes is not abnormal for this game for a two-player game even playing with four I think I've maybe one set of game go over an hour and that was a particularly you know slow game but because it's so quick to teach like you can teach this to anyone it's super easy to learn can make for a good gateway game so you can get it to the table kind of anytime and because of how quickly the turns move even though I said the player interaction is really low you never really tend to get bored when it's not your turn because you can already look ahead at oh one my next turn I already know what column are wrong gonna be picking from so you can already start strategizing looking ahead especially if there's only one or two tiles on that row you know and you're
also interested in what other players are doing because you kind of I mean you don't have to but it definitely helps to have an idea of how well other players are doing to see if you think they want to or don't want to trigger the scoring round or if you want to have an idea of whether you're going to be in the lead or not and with I think maybe not all but most great games you have that feeling at the end of I want to try again because I know I can do better right so there's a bit of that addictive quality because it's such a quick game to get going again you always think I just want to try again and maybe I'll prioritize you know lining up a bigger chain of holes early to get more of those rock pieces for coverage or maybe you're gonna try a different strategy where you know you're just kind of racing to get the highest score each scoring round without thinking about the long-term holes right so um yeah it's got that quality we're just want to keep coming back and playing it if you like these style of games this is definitely one worth owning I've probably played it about 20 times so far I haven't gotten tired of it yet it's still a blast every time I play it I have to say as I mentioned before the solo mode is quite good and really adds to the replay value if you're into the solo mode because not only is it different and interesting it's really challenging so I found it helped me improve a lot at the game but it also just because you can do the campaign mode and there's target scores to get you can always best your your old high score that definitely adds to some of the value the fact that it works as on multiple levels too like you can use this really as a gateway game I've taught this game to people who don't
really play many games or haven't played many games no one has found it overwhelming and across all my gaming groups whether it's someone who has very little experience with games or has only played like little card games to my friends who enjoy the most kind of you know heavier longer complex strategy games everyone is always surprised by how much they like this game and I think it's because when you see it on the shelf I mean first off the name spring meadow and then it's not the most colorful game I don't see this on a shelf and think what's this spring meadow a bow right but I think it still definitely deserves a place in many collections just based on how often you'll get it to the table the variety of player counts I have to mention truly that this is one game where I wouldn't specifically recommend it to people at a specific player count there's a lot of other games where I'd say oh yeah it plays up to four but you really want to just play with two or three or yeah the four Player versions best it's not as good honestly spring meadow is I would say equally good whether you have two three or four players and again the solo mode is awesome too so that adds a lot to it although I can't really say which you'll like more between spring meadow Indians summer and cottage garden it's important to note that this is the one where the player turns probably move the quickest it's probably the easiest to teach people and has probably the best replayability across all player counts of any of the three in the trilogy overall I'd say the best thing about this game is the same case with a lot of Ruby Rosenberg games where it's got a surprising amount of strategy for a
relatively simple rule set it's one of those games that's super easy to learn but very difficult to master and that's what will keep you coming back to play it again and again hope you enjoyed watching this if you wanted to see any more of our thoughts about spring meadow or any other games check out our youtube channel or visit all you can board comm thanks for watching