Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Shadow Planet in under 3 minutes

Transcript 2:06

This here is a game I won in a math trade. It's The Shadow Planet. Now, I'm terrible at math trades. I tend to give away very good games and get very bad ones in return. I should probably stop doing them. And in fact, I have stopped doing them because I used to think, "Oh, I'm getting rid of 10 games." But then you're getting 10 games in return and you're getting probably worse ones. And in the case of the Shadow Planet, we played this once and it was a very confusing time and I feel I would have been better just selling the previous game instead of trading for this. It's a game of three to five players and it's a moderately complex game. You are a member of a crew on a rescue mission to find a lost ship. What happened to it and which one of you is now possessed by an alien being intent on destruction? Each player at the table will have a secret goal and while there are six characters in the game, your control of them shifts each turn. Ideally, you will use those characters and maneuver them into positions to complete your hidden goals. Sounds like fun. In fact, it sounds a little bit like Station. The art style is quite interesting, and I like the retro comic book feel of the game's visuals. It's a pity then that it's a complete mess. With drafting the hidden identities each turn, you end up somewhat randomly reallocating things on the board each turn, hoping that every step you took forward with the character you want to last turn doesn't get undone by someone taking two steps backwards with them. I get that hidden goals can be hard to implement and make work well, but this game in particular seemed more waffly than normal. So, the gameplay loop here feels a little bit rudderless, a little bit directionless, and instead of feeling tense at the table, most of my players just felt confused. Uh, the

Shadow Planet. This is a solid me. No, no, it's bad enough to fire it into the sun. I'm sorry. This it's just a bit of a convoluted mess. The way the hidden characters are implemented is just so chaotic and nonsensical that I I never want to play this game again and I never want to see it again. Um, yeah, I'm going to definitely sell this one on. Hopefully someone picks it up. Hopefully someone likes the the comic book and the art style. I think there's a good game here if it just got developed slightly differently. They just tried to be way way way too clever and it ended up being quite dumb.

Progress saved