Skip to main content
Loading video...

I Changed the Perfect Boardgame Formula!

Transcript 9:13

for about a year now i've been making videos raiding board games according to the perfect board game formula now the perfect board game formula is something that i devised about two years ago when i first programmed my web app theperfectboardgame.com with the purpose of organizing games according to criteria that was important for people when they bought board games so somebody could sort and rank games by their themes or by how much strategy or complexity was involved but since i've started my youtube channel and been sharing this organization strategy with viewers i've received a lot of feedback and a lot of comments and i've been considering for a while now adapting the perfect board game formula slightly in this video i'd like to announce the changes that i think i'm about to make and really invite more my viewers to share their take on what's important about ranking board games the original perfect board game formula had five attributes theme mechanics luck strategy and complexity now very briefly theme is how well the gameplay embodies its theme it's not about artwork it's not about whether or not the theme is cool even a game with a crummy theme can have a high theme score if the game does a good job of making the players feel like they're actually playing that idea

mechanics is about how well the mechanics stand out and whether or not they are exciting to players some games can be very tedious there can be a lot of upkeep mostly in support of a theme and some games just have a certain brilliant elegance about them which people really find addictive in itself so when you see that that's a high mechanic score now luck hardly requires an explanation a game that has a lot of randomness has a high luck score strategy is about the degree to which the players can devise plans and backup plans and how far in advance they can plan their moves and what they can do if other players try to interfere so the deeper you can get into strategy the higher the score but if a game is just very tactical where you're only planning for the current move then strategy is a low score complexity is a rating on how difficult it is to understand and properly execute the rulebook so games can be very intuitive even if they have complex rules sometimes they just make sense and gameplay is smooth other times games can be so complex there are many things to keep track of and players are constantly consulting the rule book in order to keep track of what they're supposed to be doing and this is considered in the complexity score now there is an overarching principle and that is all five of the attributes has to be subjective it really depends on the people playing the

game that's why their ratings not absolute scores for example you can say a rule book is 13 pages long and that's a fact but complexity really kind of depends one person can say i don't think it's that complex i think it's actually really intuitive and easy to understand and sure there's a lot going on but if you think about it it's really quite simple right with that overworking principle in mind one of the attributes doesn't really belong i don't think luck should be one of the five attributes and here's why luck is a degree of randomness rolling dice drawing cards you can't argue like oh yeah it involves rolling dice but i don't think that's luck i think that doesn't make sense you can't make an argument that says rolling a dice to move is not luck either it has elements of luck or it doesn't really the way that i think i can rank luck is on four levels the lowest level is there's absolutely no luck at all it's pure strategy it's chess right the next level of luck is some degree of random setup where you know no one can control the way that the game was set up but we have to play the environment that the game gives us the next degree of luck is a degree that you can mitigate for like okay well you know this is bad and it happened i'm just going to change my strategy in order to adapt to it and then finally there's a degree of luck that there's so

much luck that even a terrible player can beat an excellent player just because they were lucky so luck that can determine the game luck that you have to work around luck that's like it's present and then like no luck no four degrees of luck so suppose for a moment i take luck off of the five attributes what would i replace it with well i've had two requests from people who watch this channel the first is a rating for the games components and the second is a rating for the game's level of interaction so which of these should i consider to replace luck i would say that the game's level of interaction is very similar to luck like luck i think there are four degrees of interaction you can have no interaction like everyone is just playing their own individual solitaire this is like mariposas you can have some degree of interaction where somebody can take something that you are planning on taking or they can get on your way or you can benefit from a move that somebody else takes this is like wingspan or something but largely it feels like you can pretty much do your own thing uninterrupted then you have level of interaction where you really have to watch out what other players are doing you have to bid off of what other players are doing and it's a large part of the game so for example playing a game like agricola where some of the moves you take are deliberately to block other players and there's high competition for first player and then finally you have a level of interaction where the entire game is focused on interaction this is like

avalon where you know secret identity the everything everyone's accusing everybody else of lying and about who they are in betrayal and all of this the whole game's interaction but components components is something that i think is entirely up for ratings somebody can look at one game like for example rococo deluxe this is all like artwork and painting for a certain era and somebody can say i think this game is beautiful and somebody else can say it's so like outdated and silly looking right like or somebody can say oh gosh i'm so excited about everdell and the evertree like when you put this thing together get so excited and somebody else can say no no that's so unnecessary it has nothing to do with gameplay it blocks players from being able to see some of the cards you don't everdel's poorly designed right it's debatable so i'm proposing that the five new attributes become theme mechanics components strategy and complexity but to the app i want to add two more separate attributes that are ways to organize games but not attributes that people can rate luck and interaction you'd be able to sort games by interaction but you wouldn't be able to argue the level of interaction that's involved that's the idea i'd like to know what you think now as

of right now i've already started to implement some of these changes if you go to the perfect boardgame.com and you look up any game you'll see that there's now a components rating and interaction rating and there will be more development on this page in the very near future if this is something that's very interesting to you there is an opportunity to help build the site as an editor um rather than go into the specifics about that check the description for details about how you can participate and then lastly if i'm on the right track let me know be like yeah dude you've done it like wow get rid of luck replace it with components that sounds great see the thing but here by the way why was components never in the original ranking system let me tell you that really quick the reason components was never in the original ranking system was because originally me and my like pure gaming mindset i was like no i'm only ranking the game components is just you know physical i'm only ranking like the theoretical pure game theory of the gameplay not like the physical thing it can be played with anything it can be played with sticks and stones and dirt like you don't need components but here's the thing we know that despite what i might feel about components not being important some people will buy a game strictly because the components are so highly rated so if it's a factor that is important other people then it should belong in the rating system whereas i really do think that luck is not so subjective love to hear your thoughts thank you so

much for watching and i will see you next time bye

Progress saved