Skip to main content
Loading video...

Isofarian Guard: Discussion 2.0

Transcript 1:00:55

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and Keith and I are doing our final discussion on Isopharian Guard. Um, we I know like I didn't mention it in the latest video, but we uh

Seth came back from a poop and we just we decided

I had some self-reflection.

Some time to reflect in the waters

cuz here's uh here's like So Brad and I did a discussion. We were doing a series for Agamonia and we called that series because we just weren't having a good time with it. Um like so I was thinking well why am I suffering through ice suffering guard? That was a stretch but I made it work. I you know I I respect it. It's

through Isoparian Guard when I like everything less about this one and I called Agamonia because I have so many other campaign games and that was the major reason. It's like I can do other series that I theoretically would enjoy a lot more.

Um and all we do every campaign

it's a it is a recycle

is Yeah. is and we just [ __ ] the entire I know I I specifically am bitching about everything except the story.

Yeah.

And even in the story whenever it gets to the fights it's like oh man here comes a boss fight. I got to do two repeat

two to six fights beforehand. And I've given them so many chances, so many hours in this game, so many home rules, and then they do tweaks of a second edition update, and then and then a cinematic mode, uh cinematic mode,

and it's like, I'm tired of being in an abusive relationship.

This game is toxic to us.

This game, this game is painful to play. Um, there are so many things about it that I it like on paper I feel work and it is just too it it sounds weird to say, but it's almost too big, too ambitious of a game that you have this story that is written exceedingly well and the voice acting is done so well, but everything about everything else is just awful.

Mhm.

Um, and I want to make it very clear that like cuz to some people, I mean, I feel like a lot of people would agree with us. Um, especially cuz I've done so many side videos on the cinematic mode, on the grind.

Um, and I've I know people who other reviewers who just could not, you know, stand through this game. Um, I want to make it very clear that if you love this game and this is the only game you own and you are you are all about it, that is perfectly fine.

I I think that this is a great game if you have the time to spread it out.

Yeah.

If you sit but like you got to keep in mind, guys, we play this game in like 8 to 10 hour segments.

Yes.

Where we sit down and we back to back to back to back it. Y

and whenever we fight the Brian Marauders four times in a session

um

it gets kind of repetitive and boring.

Oh my god.

Especially whenever you know we have a a should be fast character who can't, you know, create AP. Yeah.

Um and like it's just there's only one way to do it, you know, over and over.

So it's a slog to try and get luck. So, it's like, oh, I see the abilities I can get that would make my burst stuff go off, and I, oh, I'm doing the this multi-shot, then I burst two other things, and now I'm a badass. I see that. Except to get to that cool ability that feels locked behind

not necessarily a payw wall, but it's like a a skill tree.

And I think there is a way to make her better. Like if you were to add a yellow cube for every chip cost,

right?

That would make her probably 100%.

The one thing that would make her better is swap her [ __ ] with Catherine.

Uh to where I start with three AP that lets me do a quick shot and lets me do two another thing. So I'm putting bursts out, but it's like

I mean you you pretty much are doomed to only being able to use one card a turn

unless you burst.

Yes. Yep. So every one combat I get to do another burst. And it's so

unless we luckily come across an adventurine,

right? And I mean, and Catherine was the same way. Catherine was more of like, okay, I'm roped into this exact same way of playing every single combat. And there's

the same the same fights every single time. The only thing that changes from campaign to campaign is the narrative.

Yes.

Like,

and this was the I mean, going into this narrative, this was our favorite narrative.

Yeah. So far,

this one was great.

The voice acting, I was super into it. I'm I'm invested in the story.

The six plane striders in a row

cuz I had to do a fetch quest for the first time and

Yeah.

and like get basically nothing out of it. Yeah.

Um because everything is clearly designed around the grind. And I know that's what it's like the I suffering grind is what this game should be called

because

that was better than the first one.

Yeah, I know. I I Yeah, it rolled off the tongue a little bit easier.

Um that it's just disgusting.

Yeah.

To play through. It's like playing I mean any video game like Assassin's Creed Odyssey is a perfect example of like oh to level up you have to do so much [ __ ] to gain so much XP. And then what that company did, Ubisoft was like, "Oh, well, you can pay us money to get an XP booster."

I mean, to be fair, they didn't make you pay extra money, but they're like, "Well, what about a cinem cinematic mode to reduce the grind?" When you know they [ __ ] up when they come out with two additional ways to reduce that because it's such a common complaint.

Yeah.

And for some reason, cuz I thought the cinematic mode was going to help. That one almost seems like a middle finger to the people. They're like, "Oh, you don't you complain about the grind." Well, here's your cinematic mode. And then they just like

they didn't really get rid of the grind.

Not even a little bit.

They give you

and it and it punishes you for getting rid of the grind,

right? It's like, well, I don't want to fight the same thing over and over. Oh, yeah, sure. You can do that.

And then you're going to take a break and you're going to take a week and you're also going to take a bunch of other [ __ ]

You take a bunch of other stuff and and no matter what, if you skip it, you just take damage.

Yeah.

Uh so it's like, okay, well, I guess I'll just do the fight. So it's like do you value your time or do you value uh you know mechanisms

if you can if you can keep this running like a risk which is personally this is how I play it. Um and I I will continue playing this. Um don't don't get it twisted Eric. I think you have a good concept here. Um but I'm able to spread it out. I'm Yeah, it it this this game feels like it has to be something that's just always there that you can run to and you can play it for an hour or two and then whenever that hour or two is done, you take a week break um so you can you can refresh yourself from from doing some fights.

And even just saying that is bizarre to me.

I know. Like that is literally like, okay, if your significant other doesn't hit you all the time and they space out their their Yeah, they space it out

so you can go back and forget.

So the bruises heal and then they hit you again. Um that's exactly what that sounds like to me because someone I heard someone in the Discord say that this was a lifestyle game and I'm like no it shouldn't be. No, it's it's not. Um but its design is exactly what you're saying. You keep this out on the table. So you basically have a gaming table just dedicated to this and you sit down for an hour, you move one space, do a fight, there's your session, and then it's like it takes you a lifestyle to even finish

to progress. I mean, it's taken me almost a year to finish campaign one,

right?

Yeah.

Um, and if this game came out years ago and it was like the only kind of game of its kind,

it's like, yeah, you just kind of would do that. But since campaign games are everywhere,

Yeah. Every 5 seconds there's a new crowdfunding campaign.

I got I have like three on the back burner right now.

Yeah, dude. I have even more

Exactly.

that are that are way more interesting to play and take less time um and are better if not just as good um narrative wise. Mhm.

So like cuz the other campaign I'm doing which actually after this one is going to just be a on trespass

is so much better and I'm invested every single time. And theoretically you kind of do the same thing there. You you know you move a space and then you might have an event and you might have something and then you have a uh a boss fight that you fought over you know tons of times just to get resources.

Yeah. Um, but what what used to keep me coming back to this besides the narrative was I like the the backb building

and Catherine was rough. Even Yuri was like, "Okay, yeah, we're doing the same thing every single time." And then Vera was just gut-wrenching.

It was the the straw that broke the the camel's back.

It No, exactly. It was like, "Oh, man. I wonder what I'm going to do." Oh, piercing shot. Mhm.

Okay. I am curious uh once I get to Vera if like I don't know my brain works differently than yours. So maybe I'll I'll look at her and be like oh well I'll play her this way and maybe that'll change it but I don't know.

Maybe I was looking I was like maybe what maybe you were in playing burst wrong like maybe something like did I was looking through her stats. I'm like did we mess up? Nope.

I don't think so either. Um because like I mean all of them have like a key word uh around them so they're not that complex

to to play. Everyone else just worked a little bit better. Hell, even Catherine had innate ways to do her harmonize.

Yeah.

Like why is tracking my starting one? I don't need a bunch of extra [ __ ] chips when I can't use them.

Mhm.

Like inner fire should have been the one I start with.

If you don't have the AP to utilize the [ __ ] that you're drawing, then there's just no point in having

and you don't have any way to use extra chips,

right?

Like I can I can flood your bag with greens, but it doesn't matter if you just draw them and discard them.

Exactly. Um, I mean really the only greens that kind of mattered to you by by the point that we were was me giving you plus attacks and plus defenses.

Um, I'd throw you some swords and shields every once in a while and they'd come in handy, but

only to guarantee you would get the stuff that you need.

Yeah, exactly. And the only cool thing about her abilities were, oh, I can just keep doing multi-shot.

Mhm.

Because it only flips whenever it bursts.

Burst. Yeah. But that's now even more boring. All I'm doing is multi-shot. There's no change.

Yeah.

So, it's not deep. It's not innovative. It's not thoughtful to actually play.

Um,

and when you do that,

you know, 15 times in a row because you did a caravan quest that took you from 61 to 20 back to 61 and there's 1 2 3 4 5. Mhm.

Um, so that's that's I mean the way that it's actually meant to be played, that's 10 fights that it has potentially 10 fights.

Mhm.

For you to sit through and it could just be like, "Oh, here's a random encounter of a three skull."

Mhm.

I mean, it's in the chapter 2 book, so we should be equipped to do that. Oh, we're not. So, we lost

on a random chip draw.

Yep. and remind you

we have to go back to where we rested last and

yeah and lose all of our [ __ ]

That was the all the original stuff.

Yeah.

Was you lose all your stuff and it's like but now they do it to where you're technically supposed to drop it all but now you can go pick it back up.

Pick up your bag. Yeah.

Um but it was still last save and then you're like okay we made it through that two skull fight or three skull. Like luckily by the skin of our teeth we we survived. All right let's go rest at an end. Oh, it's

25 silver.

25 fighting animals. So, I have bones.

So, we have no money. Yeah. All Let's go back to Fortra and rest at the barracks if we survive on the way to Forra. Oh, it costs

bucks. Yeah.

Uh, so I guess we're not leveling up.

Yeah,

it is mindboggling of a big [ __ ] you to any type of player who wants to enjoy this game.

I just It's like I don't know who hurt the the designer, but it is it's too much. And I've tried so hard to look past it and homebrew it. And

we made a lot of alterations to try and make this game more fun.

Like I And you c and the problem is is you can't it's not even like, oh, we'll just ignore all the stuff. Ignore the caravan. Ignore the side quests. You still can't even do that.

Yeah. Like if you don't have cinematic mode to give you your the appropriate star level stuff, you can't even just do the campaign

where it's like, I just kind of want to see what the story is about.

Yeah.

It does not let you.

Mhm.

Um because you go against things that are in the same star level, but you have to but they're buffed for some reason.

Mhm.

And that's even worse. Like if if if everything was optional besides like Oh, no. like what you like what you get is perfectly fine to finish out the campaign. It's like I just want to play the story and maybe do a side quest here and there,

but it's like nope. Nope. The it does not let you.

Mhm.

And I don't understand why this game gets a pass.

Yeah.

When other games don't. That's that's what really really blows my mind is I feel like anyone who is really raving about this game are did not make it far.

It seems like they probably stopped around Gregory and Alec.

Yeah.

Um cuz Gregory and Alec were I mean I don't know. I didn't have a ton of fun playing Alec but I could see where it was going.

Yeah.

Um the only thing with Alec is he was just he was a slow build.

Yeah. Um, Yuri was fine. Honestly, Carzan is who I've had the most fun playing.

Yeah.

Um,

and Guru is one I had the most fun playing.

Exactly. And they're the big fighters.

Yeah, that's true. They're the ones who got to consistently do stuff.

Yeah. Um, Yuri was fine. Yeah.

But I don't like I don't I I probably liked Alec more than Yuri.

Okay.

And I like Carson more than both of them.

Yeah.

Um, Yuri was was very much a one-trick pony, right? And I could have been playing him wrong. Um because I know he had a bunch of stuff to deal with like red chips and all that and I didn't

he wanted to like draw red chips and Yeah.

But I don't know. I mean maybe Mason will play Yuri different and he'll his brain will figure it out cuz he's smarter than me.

Maybe. Or he'll just run to the same issue cuz I mean Mason seems to kind of align with like the issues that we have that he might just be like this. I don't [ __ ] like this. It It's like and it seems it seems like with Veil Word,

there's a reason why they just went to two guards.

Yeah.

Because

I agree.

It seems like they had they were like, "Oh, let's do, you know, eight guards to do the two pair system and then they had a solid idea for one of them

and then they're like, "Ah [ __ ] what do we do for the other one? How do we make them synergize?" Uh, this kind of works. or the designers are so in to like their the the like their own mess that they know the nuance.

Yeah.

They know the exact steps you have to take. Like, oh, to make this to make the grind not happen, you need to get this specific item. You need to Okay. So,

well, that's what it see every time I go into a forum or into the Discord, it's like, oh, I'm complaining about this. It's like, oh, well, you need to go do this and that.

You need to get the boots and you need to get this and you need to get these gloves. It's like, so say you developed a problem, you you game.

Yeah.

But you put it behind a wall of the problem,

right? Yeah.

Um

I guess it makes you it makes you feel grateful when you have them,

I guess. But like it's like you designed a meta.

Yeah,

that's exactly it. And so you that's that's bad game design

just inherently. Especially in an open-ended RPG, it should be

I mean, you should feel rewarded for branching,

right?

And not going with the this is what everyone else is doing because it makes it playable.

Yeah. It's like I want to play Vera this way. Oh, no. You shouldn't do that. Oh, you mean I can't customize? No, you can. It's just bad.

It's just she's not going to work as good as she can.

Yeah. This is how she has to be played. Or if you want to do be successful in any way, you need to go out and get these items. It's like, okay, well, how do I get those? Oh, you need to still grind a whole

You got You're going to spend like three or four sessions grinding.

Yeah, that's all you're doing. Isn't that fun? Isn't that fun for a board game? It's perfectly fine in a video game cuz I can do all that in a a few hours.

Yeah.

Um

and

I don't have to set up every fight in a video game.

No, exactly. And hell, even I had these 3D printed things that significantly helped at least on table space.

Um

I love those. Love them so much.

And they're yours.

Thanks.

They're yours because I will not be keeping this game.

Yeah.

And I will not be getting Veil Word.

Yeah.

Like I do not trust

because this company also had another game, Dungeons of Infinity, that was also very bad. To be fair, it wasn't their design.

Yeah.

Um

but no, I I just don't trust the trust the design anymore. it. Veilward I was like I've been keeping up with their updates and I'm like okay with the two guards like only

they have to make them way more in-depth. So maybe it won't be like oh you just have eight characters and four of them are good.

Yeah.

So maybe two of them are good. But if it's probably just this just in a different setting.

Yeah.

We will we will see.

I won't.

Yeah. Well, I mean there's still reviews and stuff.

Uh that's true. Yeah. And who knows, maybe it'll come out and it'll be great.

Maybe.

But

or maybe I'll just keep paying for it and and then just so I can test it for myself. Um cuz my plan is before I get rid of this, I'm just going to listen to the story.

Yeah.

Like that's all I'm here for.

I don't really give I'll even I'll listen to the caravan quests. I'll listen to the side quests. And uh whenever I if I ever see these guys again, I just want to talk to the writer because um it's like, "Dude, can you just write a book?"

Mhm.

Like could

turn turn this into a book.

Yeah. Can I would just rather like like just read your stuff?

You guys want to sit down and like get with a development team, make a video game.

Yeah, that's really the route they should have taken. This would have been

this would have been a great game.

This would have been much much better as as a video game.

Even like I mean even with the separate guards like I mean a Grand Theft Auto type thing, Grand Theft Auto 5 where you switch between three different characters

like you can follow their narratives and they all happen simultaneously.

So like there's no reason I this would be I mean

in this design this would be a dope video game. Hell, even if they did it as like a gloom haven, you know, gloom except, you know, not busted to be have you draw negatives the entire time, but like a Steam version of this

of this would be fun because I don't I don't have to set [ __ ] up all the time.

Yeah, you wouldn't like you can just hop in. You could probably with difficulty settings just scale it way the [ __ ] down.

Honestly, I'd probably be interested in doing this true to form in video game form.

Yeah. um

just because I mean

it's just a little more approachable.

You wouldn't have to it it would be so less fiddly. Everything would be automatic

and

I don't have to figure out specific rules for the puzzle quiz because I touch this chip and these chips shoot out from it. But sometimes they don't.

Yeah. Yeah. And that was the other thing where it's like you the things that they introduced um all sounded good on paper every single time. I was like random vagueness like

they'll be hyper specific on how some stuff works and then some stuff they'll be like this is how it is and it's like okay but what about in this situation

right

yeah well cuz if you think about all the stuff they added after the initial game came out commissions

uh okay those things

to get to get stuff so you don't have to go

so you don't have to run all the way up to up to like two to get crystals um that actually didn't work out in reality because it took way too long for them to come back and by the time they came back you're like what did I

I've already moved on.

Yeah, I've already moved on. I don't even remember what I set them out for.

Uh they you don't get enough of them to have them come back and be like, "Oh, now I can craft this item."

It's like, "Well, I still have to go out and do [ __ ] myself, so what's the point?"

You just have to do less [ __ ] A little less.

A little bit less. So commission sucked. Uh the prestige um

doesn't carry

doesn't carry from campaign to camp.

There's no there's no incentive to I mean it's only going to last with you for four chapters which if you're playing this game the way I feel like it's intended to be played I guess you're getting a year out of each prestige but you know yeah a puzzle one puzzle quest to get a prestige one actually like holds out and actually matters. But whenever we're doing this, you know, whenever we're bumrushing this game, it's like I had prestige for like six sessions, but now we're in a new campaign and it's over.

Exactly.

So,

so, and whenever you go and do a puzzle, you're like, "Okay, well, I did the puzzle. Now, how do I get to the second level of prestige? Oh, you have to do this bounty you're not ready for."

Yeah. This bounty that is honestly inaccessible unless you're in the next chapter, which I see I can see why they would rationalize that. But there's no way you're getting full prestige until you're chapter 4. And by the time you're chapter four, you're [ __ ] done.

Yeah. I mean, by the Yeah, exactly. Cuz chapter 3 or chapter 4 lock you into combat. So it's likeap you never really get to explore and reap the benefits. It would be it would be understandable if again it carried over. So then you're like, "Oh man, now I

I've earned this thing."

Yeah.

I mean I like I mean apply the same stuff to that you do for Fort Easter. I unlock all the buildings in Fort Eastra with Gregory and Alec so I have them for everyone. Why why does my my guards lose prestige because they're wandering?

Yeah. I mean, if you think of it thematically like you're saying, okay, if Gregory and Alec get prestige one and we come in with Yuri and Catherine and they're like, we don't know who you are. Okay, that I get that, but it's like but we got a field event that had some people go to Fort Eastra

and they're still there

and they're there and it's like, wait a minute, but at the same time, they shouldn't be there yet because in the last section,

they didn't come till later. Yeah. So, it's like the prestige sounds like again like a good concept. Oh, sweet. I don't need as much sill to stay in. Things are cheaper. Um, I get a sweet benefit of whatever. I get the master angler thing or or whatever.

Oh, wait.

And then I have to redo that. I have to redo all of that stuff again.

Yep. And then even the bounties cuz by the time you are ready to do it, you are done.

Yeah.

Um, even we're I was looking at the training. I know what you were saying like it like it sounds crazy for me to say cuz we just started chapter 2 and I was like we can't even [ __ ] do any of this and it's like well we just started chapter 2. It's like I do I understand that

but we need it. We've already gotten used to something

exactly or it's outdated. We even when we were at a higher level with Catherine and Yuri,

we looked at just like all of our stuff is better.

Yeah. It's like I don't see any reason to get any of this except to just get it

to unlock it. to have it for what campaign five or something.

So it it's completely insane that the things that are slated for your chapter is not actually your chapter. Yeah.

It is always like, oh, we need to be in chapter 3 to do chapter 2 stuff.

Mhm.

What? Like that is just mindboggling to me of like it'd be different if that that's like if you're playing any video game, The Witcher for example, and you see the red skull of an enemy and you're just like why can't I beat this? It's like well clearly it's a higher level than you. But that that'd be that makes sense if we were trying to do a a fourstar

quest.

It's like yeah clearly we're underleveled for this so we can't do it

here. It's like well what about the same level we are? Oh, no. You still can't do it. You need to be overlevelled to go back, but by that time that stuff is [ __ ]

Mhm.

Um cuz in the way Madara does it,

um it it has specific sections like, oh, you get to this city city phase

and now you have this new tier of loot and that new tier of loot is immediately accessible. It's all expensive.

I think that's how they should have done prestige is it unlocks as you progress. Oh yeah.

Um it like you know

like you hit chapter two you have this level of prestige in all the cities.

Yeah. Maybe not even like maybe not even you hit chapter like you hit campaign two may and you can do this. I think I think it should be like you know your campaign one you're Alec and Grigory you can baseline get prestige one in every city.

Yeah.

And then maybe you know

Catherine and Yuri their big focus was mostly north.

Yeah. Yeah.

So maybe whenever you play them, they're getting prestige in Vulno and Stro or Seln.

Um so far with um Card Cartson and Vera, they've been mostly here. So maybe they get prestige too in Razdor and Stroa

and Reeba. Um well maybe Reb who whatever semantics u maybe they have that ability and then whenever you get to campaign five that's when you can unlock camp

prestige three for everyone.

Yeah

or for everything but it but it carries.

Yeah.

You know I I got it. I got I took the time to get prestige one with Alec and Grigory. I should get to continue to have that. I'm taking the time with each individual pair to do the areas that make sense so I can keep having that. And now that I'm culminating everything into campaign 5, I'm getting prestige 3 everywhere, right? And it it is there. Yeah. Instead of, oh, I got all the way up to prestige 3 with every character. It took me 130 hours and now that I'm done with this c this campaign, I'm going to go to campaign 3 and it's all gone.

It's all gone. Yeah,

it was all four. Not it made it a little bit easier on these characters, but by the time I got it, I finished the campaign.

No, exactly. No, that's that's a very good point. I think what is this game's biggest appeal to a lot of people again on paper but is its significant weakness is it is a openw world board game and there's a reason why there's no openw world board games

got to have a path

you have yeah you have to have it so curated so I have two great examples a on trespass odyssey is so meticulously balanced that to some people they really like it but then there's kingdom death monster that is you have swings of whatever like am character's busted as [ __ ] I crit on twos to tens, whatever, and you're just a disgusting god. Or you get none of the luck and you're trash for a long time.

But then there's atto which is like so, okay, you're going to get this tech at this point and boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. So, you're always going to be at the right level that we want you to be.

Like I said with Madara, it's like, hey, now you're on tier. I don't remember how it's called, but it's like now you're on tier three items. So that immediately you can if you have a bunch of money, you can buy all that stuff. Maybe not for everyone, but that is immediately better than your current gear.

Well, and they cap you on those resources. Like you you can only have 99 lux. You can only have 99 cell.

Yeah.

And [ __ ] is not cheap.

It is insanely expensive.

I mean, if you want to upgrade your stuff into tier four, you're paying 70 plus sill

just to do that upgrade, not including resource cost. So for both of us to do that, we have to acquire 140 sill, which we cannot do in one go.

Um we have to stop, do it for one of us, and then go finish it and do it again.

And it's not like there's even a dedicated spot to for certain enemies. It's not like, oh, if we know 23 is always going to have brigen marauders or something. It's like, yeah, I know brigen marauders are in the 30s, but it's still dependent on a random draw. So, you can't even guarantee drops.

Yeah.

Um to afford that.

Well, and there I don't know. The drops aren't consistent,

right?

By star level.

No. Yeah. Exactly.

You can I mean, you can fight a brigen marauder at star level two and it'll get you some lux and some sill. And at star level four, it might get you two completely different items.

Yeah. Because a brigen marauder at one um gives you three sill. A brig marauder 2 gives you five sill. And a brigam marauder at uh three which is isos gives you 10 sil.

Yeah.

And then it's like so

well it's specifically so the bergam marauders might be a bad example because they always give you sillex

right.

But if you look at the I think it's either the clay horns or the plainest striders their like actual enemy drop changes which each star level. Sometimes it's leather sometimes it's cloth sometimes

curious. Yeah. rough leather and then Oh, yeah. Rough leather at two and then plain strider at three is spines.

Yeah. Like, and that's just I mean, unless you Which, as if you guys have watched up to this point, you've probably realized that I'm a I'm a little odd for some of these things

for some reason. Highly you've memorized.

Yeah, I So, I have a lot of these memorized, but I mean, I'm playing it twice, guys.

Yeah, that's true. I I have I have done all the way up to here with Seth. Um this

So um and then I'm playing it again with another friend. Yeah.

Um so like I I know all this because I've done it a ton of times,

right? Well, you have to. I mean,

and that's like that's why I'm successful is like I can I can kind of sit there and you know, you pull out a guard, it's like, "Oh, you're going to get two swords out of that. That will be useful for this situation." And I only know that because I've been doing this for hundreds of hours.

No. Yeah. Exactly. And it's it's like for the loot drops it should I mean why isn't it like a table like why isn't it like playing like roll a d10? I mean there's no dice in the game.

Well here's the thing is this game a lot of RPGs and this game specifically could take a note from D&D's book um which is having D and D does a very good job of space progression.

Yeah. you know, you get you get these specific benefits at these specific levels and those are consistent through all classes. But then if you go into your subclass or you go into your your class a little further, you will have your specific things that you get individually. Like I know I'm always going to get an ability score improvement or a feat every other level,

right? Um, but I know I don't know if I'm gonna, you know, if I play sorcerer, I'm gonna get metamagic at level three, but if I play uh fighter, I'm gonna get uh a fighting type, like a fighting style, right? That those those differences need to exist in games like this for it to work. Like you have to have a consistency and you have to have something to make it feel individual.

Yeah, exactly.

And this

it has the individuality for each character kind of.

Yeah. Um, if you're going Marshall to Marshall, it's not super individual. The only individuality is their special.

Um, you know, chain and

Oh, yeah. Key word. Yeah.

Uh, combine all of that. That that is great individuality. There's no consistency.

No. Yeah. Exactly. It's so all over the place that But I mean, what's weird is it's not it's not all over the place in randomness. It's not like, oh, our fights are successful or not successful because I mean, it's random of the bag pulling and all and all that, but like you're consistently able to almost do everything that you want to do, but the way an actual campaign flows is it's it's bad. Like, in my in my opinion, it is inherently bad design that just needed to be reeled in, which maybe that's what they're doing with Veil Word. Um, I'll I'll probably still get Veil word. I am

in not this context. I am still enjoying this game.

Um, but I'm a different person than you. You know, every everyone has their own things. I have

this is this is like this is the game that my brain works in.

Um, but like deck builders, I'm [ __ ] garbage, right?

I'm so bad at deck builders. Um, and I like that, you know, and I like the exploration. I don't love the grinding grinding. Grinding in a game setting like this is not my favorite. Um so who knows? Maybe I'll play the cinematic mode on my own and I'll be like, "Ah, this is fine."

Yeah,

I can deal with this. I can deal with this for the narrative.

Yeah.

Um but it I mean it shouldn't be that way,

right? I mean even like Madara um they had I mean it wasn't like open world, but you had scenarios that you set up and they had like okay here you need to go from here to here but there's a bunch of other stuff to explore. And it got to a point where that extra stuff to explore was never worth it. But Devin is like you, he wanted to see it all. Yeah.

And I was like, and I remember specifically there was one session where I was like, "Okay, I'll humor you. We will go see that." And it was some [ __ ] trap that made it that was like nothing here. We took damage and it was enemies. That is

and I told him, "We are never doing that again."

Like it it's the same thing with Dragon Eclipse. I mean, yeah, you I've I've played a little bit of that. you know, you get the map that is the the overarching area. Yeah.

And you have all of these points of interest you can go to, but you have a timer,

right?

Um and you know, some of them might do nothing for you, but waste time.

Yeah.

And it's you kind of have to wrap your your head around and be like, I don't need to do everything,

right?

Um but I do need There is a benefit to looking at everything, but there's not always a benefit to doing everything.

Yeah. that I actually enjoy because it rewards replayability and it's not like you went somewhere and it wasted time and your missing died. Yes. Or you got [ __ ] like I mean we literally had a random field event that we love the field events and it was like hm fight two three star knights as level two.

Yeah. And okay so no you're not doing that so go around and get penalized. It's like okay that's that's [ __ ] fair.

It was either die or um still lose something.

Yeah. So, it's like, okay, great. So, that's that's uh awful. And

um

I mean, even the game I I was playing with uh with Bailey, which was Fate Forge,

um

was such a clean experience. Like, cuz what I enjoy in, you know, narrative driven campaign games, and what is kind of a makeorb breakak deal for some of them is character build. Yeah. Like if you restrict me super hard on character builds, then what am I what am I playing?

There's got to be individuality.

Yeah. And Fate Forge had that. Um Dragon Eclipse I don't really count because it wasn't a charact I mean you can build your deck but not in the story,

right?

Um

um

you can change it a little bit.

Yeah, you had

because you can unlock cards. Yeah, you have 16 cards and you just Anyway, um but here

it it just felt like okay, yeah, technically I can kind of upgrade. I I upgrade my bag and I change my cards out a little bit, but unfortunately if you do everything, you get too much lux. So then you have everything at your uh disposal

on the skill tree. So, you run out of [ __ ] to do and it's like, well, the game is too long for me to have any sort of depth

for characters. So, I'm immediately bored with the actual mechanisms of the game. So, I don't enjoy the bag building. Um, it's monotonous. It's just it's it's just inherently unfun. if every session was curated as a almost a scenario. Cut the open world [ __ ] out um and like have it be like let's do a side quest and you just do the side quest.

Oh, let's do a caravan quest. You just do the caravan quest. Um that would make it way more manageable.

Mhm.

And you honestly could. That's that's actually I mean that's kind of a brilliant thing of isoparian guard which is

you don't have to do everything. Well,

you don't do

you don't have to play it.

Yeah,

there is nothing stopping you. And I highly recommend if you want to get into the narrative, which is still excellent.

Mhm.

Um

I mean, it's a it's a 10 out of 10 for the narrative. So good.

The and the voice acting is amazing for the most part

for for everyone but Catherine.

Um and even she wasn't like god awful. She was just flat. I mean, I on a scale of 1 to 10, I would give most of these characters an eight to a 10.

Yeah,

Catherine's like a She's like a seven.

Five. Oh, man. I'm like maybe five or a six.

Um,

but here's what you could easily just easily do, and we've done this.

Spend $15 on Foreller.

No, no, no. Is Yeah, just spend just buy Foreller and just listen to the story. No. if you want to actually play the game is you cut the open world [ __ ] out.

It's like, oh, we need to get like, okay, we need to we have a caravan quest. We go from 61 to 20. You move 50. What? You draw from the bag. It's Oh, it's a two skull. What is it?

There's There's a combat in here. Make it I mean, man, there's a game that does this really well. I'm trying to slay the spire. Slay the spire. So whenever you move from node to node one, you have a choice and you know what's going to happen in each one. Yeah.

Um so you it's still node traveling and there's multiple paths to to the end.

Yeah.

Um you know if you're going to fight, you know if you're going to do an event Oh,

and then it's a mystery.

Yeah.

If they could set this up in that way where you kind of know what's going on like in a scenario basis.

Oh, I see what you're saying.

That would improve this the the the o open world of this game 100%. Well, uh, that would be interesting. My thought was, have you played, um, you probably haven't. Metaphor Refantasio.

Have you played Persona 5?

Mhm.

Okay.

I refuse.

Interesting.

Not for like any reason.

That's a weird st. I refuse. [ __ ] the people who play those.

No, it's not. Well, I don't know. Um, it's I'm just not a big JRPG guy.

Gotcha. Well, that's funny enough because that's their inspiration for this is JRPG. They call this a JRPG.

That's insane. Um, and it's like I or inspired by

it's turnbased.

It's inspired by JRPGs. Anyway, I bring those games up because in Metaphor there's like the open world where you see the enemies and you can attack.

And if you attack them and you surprise them and you initiate combat. However, if you are a higher level than what you were, you just instantly kill them in the open world.

Yeah.

That's a system they should have had here, which is kind of what we were at, you know, home brewing. Draw. It's a level one. One skull, we just kill it.

Skull, we might take some damage. Three skull, we're fighting it,

right?

Yeah.

Um, and that should have just been inherently baked in because you could just do that whenever it's like, okay, remove from 61 to 53, draw it. It's two, um, one, you could just be like, okay, let's 50/50 and see if we want to fight it. Or just be like, oh, it's a it's a hand of move and okay, this is just what we get. Just to beline it to exactly the meat of the game.

Yeah. the the narrative, the fun part,

right? Um and do all the legitimate fights in the narrative. Uh

that because that whenever we did the the red door where it was again Brian Marauders if we didn't do the actual open world fights, I would have fought them.

No, it would have been fine because we wouldn't have fought three other backtoback marauders in the open world.

Exactly.

Today.

Yeah. So

I think I could tell you what every single card a Bergen Marauder can draw.

Right. No. Exactly. And it's like I know exactly what we're going to get from them. Yep. So I don't want to fight them again. Uh because I know exactly what I'm going to do every single turn.

I I know what works against them. I'm going to do it again. I have I have honed this to a practice.

And it reduces the amount of exhaustion you get from playing your character because you're not you're doing such minimal fights. It it prevents the watered downness of your character because it's like, "Oh, I still have some interesting things that I can do. I'm still Yeah, you're not getting as much lux. Um, but if you're still doing the side quest and the caravan quest, you're going to get enough items and enough lux to still level up

or just [ __ ] inflate the numbers.

Yeah.

Like you are allowed to. And I mean, I guess the the question is, well, why aren't we doing that? Like

I want to break the game. I want to play it for what it what they put it out, right? I shouldn't have to make that many changes to have fun.

No, exactly. Um Yeah. And it's like like I mean cuz like in the the campaign that we were just doing, I mean, we flubbed not rolls, but draws where it's like, "Oh, we

I just I full health and I just got five hearts.

Yeah.

I'm going to draw all of those immediately because I only have six tokens that count towards my limit." No, exactly. So, it's like I guess those are wasted. That's that's a fun reward. Or um Oh, man. We just got our teeth kicked in from a random two skull thing. Oh, how much is it to rest in stroa? More than we got.

Okay, I guess we just we're It cost 14.

Yeah.

So, it's like Yeah. I mean, we're technically cheating, but that's the only way we can enjoy it.

Mhm.

And when you have to make so many modifications to a game, why even play the game?

Yep. So, it's it's unfortunate uh because like I said, everything about this game sounds so good on paper.

Mhm.

And you know what would have been fine? If they just released two guards, which is what they're doing with Veil Word.

Well, I mean, even if they gave you the eight and you just picked

Oh, pick two to go through the whole campaign.

Um Yeah. Yeah, that's true. cuz I like the the simultaneous nature.

Yeah. Do the eight, you pick two, you have um you have, you know, their specific abilities, but then you also have some cards that can be shared.

Yeah.

Some like universal.

Yeah. That way I can have, you know, I can have lance strike and I can have bodyguard and I can have advancement. Um but maybe I can also or you can have your stuff so that you can do burst, but maybe you also have a card in there that gives you AP,

right? Yeah. actual like yeah shared deeper customization don't have the skill tree just be like how do I want to build this like build this character like okay I know she like and you can even kind of restrict it she has to use a bow so there are here's here's her

kind of like uh funny enough dragon Eclipse hey this is a water character you can only use water cards well here's your deck of water cards build your deck

yeah pick something

it's like

and I mean I'm fine with only having six cards

no that's perfectly fine yeah Um, but find a way to maximize it to how you want to play the character.

Um,

like, man, I'm really struggling,

especially so it doesn't feel stale. If you have a whole deck to pull from, you can kind of vary vary it and make it different and it'll be fun.

Yeah. And it's like the way I would build her is different than the way you would build her.

Uh, but you can't really do that. It kind of comes down to, oh, I'm going to go right instead of left.

And whenever I looked at her skill tree and I was like, oh, she doesn't have an innate way to give AP. This is awful. This is going to be a very bad time.

Anyway, I realize a lot of this discussion is what this game should have been. Um, and unfortunately, it's not,

but this is where we have landed.

We've playing this game for a while at this point.

Yes. So,

and with how many campaigns are on the horizon, like I could we have Dante, we have I have Madara, act two and three. I we story of many lands of Evershade.

Um God,

I'm so excited for Evershade.

Which uh wow, The Coven. It wasn't The Coven.

I don't know if you

think you're right. I didn't back that one.

You didn't back that one. I did.

I know you did. Yeah.

Witch Coven or something like that. Yeah. Um like I I have so many campaign games because they're my favorite board games to play.

Yeah. I mean, we we grew up on RPGs.

Exactly.

Um and if this was the only one I had or the only one I could afford, yeah, I'd stick it out. Unfortunately, fortunately, I'm in a position that it's not

This one isn't I mean, and this one isn't even that cheap,

which is a huge plus. I mean for for everything you get the the the quality of the game is

good. But I mean Dante's $100 more.

Yeah.

It's boss babbler.

Yeah.

But and we haven't played it so we don't

I mean it could be dog.

It could be it could be garbage. We'll repeat it. It's fine.

Yeah. We'll get there.

Yeah. We'll we'll talk about it when we get there. Um but I mean like I mean I'm so excited for Lance of Evershade. Yeah.

Because it has I mean it has what I like from D and D,

right?

I'm excited to play a D and D game where I don't have to have a GM. Um, yeah, which is sick.

I'm excited. Yeah, there's so many that I'm excited for and that I I stuck out and with these longunning campaigns, I have to pick and choose like because Fate Forge is a B. Like, even if we finish this, the game doesn't have enough replayability to ever play it again.

It's like, oh man, that was a great story. I'm done.

I mean, most of most of the decisions are this or that,

and they're arbitrary. Yeah. Honestly, I'm doing I'm we're doing the this is me and Mason are doing the that's and and that's getting me the whole thing.

No. Exactly. And it's not changing your It's not It's not a choice-based campaign.

It's not like, oh, you made this decision that's going to drastically change the outcome. No, the story is what it is, and that's perfectly fine. They they have a story they want to tell. Um I I love the world. I think the creatur it's it's a fantasy world that is unique

is amazing. The map the map style is amazing. The the characters are fun and they're interesting. Um I mean a lot of the dynamics between the car like NPCs and PCs are interesting. I mean like having Captain Abbe as Yuri's dad, that is a fascinating dynamic.

That was cool. Catherine didn't care.

No, she didn't care about it.

No, that's true. She was that that girl was zonked out. Having like her backstory intertwined with the sear the circle of seers was cool.

Like there is

great great great aspect.

You know you're doing it right with a narrative campaign whenever we theorize or talk about the story on like outside of the actual game. That's how I knew Madara's story was amazing because Devon and I were like what do you think is going to happen?

And most board games are aren't given that. It's like, oh, you know, we're making decisions while we're playing, but once we pack it up, it's it's done.

It's done.

Um,

and but what makes Fate Forge and Dragon Eclipse, um, now that I finished that one,

uh, equally good is they were very bite-sized. They like I'm done. Like Fate Forge is or not Fate Forge, uh, Dragon Eclipse is like nine series. That's that's it. I mean, and you make some decisions to change out the outcome. There's like six different endings.

It's pretty quick. And it's like great, I could replay this and I can make different decisions.

You can I mean you could build a whole different team. You can do you can do each

play different sequence differently. Yeah.

Yeah. Um and atto my that's my favorite game.

I I will probably never replay cycle those cycles. They take so [ __ ] long

and there's millions of different decisions to make. But

here it's like everything to do to get through the narrative. It's like

all right. Well, even if I did stick it out, I would never replay it.

So, might as well just listen to the story, which I only care about, and then just get rid of the game.

Yeah.

Um, and probably still back Veil word. Oh, wait. No, I can't. If I get rid of the game, I Veil word, you have to have the base.

You have to have the base.

I have the base.

Um, that's true. I'll just let you get Veil word and then I'll just

And then I just won't won't waste the waste the money.

Um, so yeah, it's it's unfortunate. There's going to be people out there who wholeheartedly disagree, which is fine,

which is perfectly fine. Like, if you love this game, great. Us dis or me disliking.

Yeah. Even even at this table, we have differing opinions. I still like this game.

Yeah.

Even though, you know, I sit here and listen to stuff complain about all the time. But that's

to be fair,

I share a lot of the same sentiments. I just

I just approach that. I'm a different person.

You just suffer through it. Deon's the same way. He listens to me, [ __ ] and he still suffers through it.

Yeah. Um, and I will never understand that. I hate wasting time.

Yeah,

I have. But also at the same time, my game

I mean, look at my I have that like,

you know, I have I have way more board game time than you do.

Exactly. And you're um what was I going to say? Uh it was um oh I was going to say to be fair before we even did the discussion I walked in here and you're like you're like I'm hitting a wall with this game and I was thinking about it of like okay maybe we just suffer through it and I can hate play it like I hate

well my my hitting a wall was I need I don't want to play this anymore today.

Yeah. Um, I was fine with continuing it, but you I mean I I understand your sentiment. And I'm not gonna I'm not gonna make you play this if you're not having fun. No, exactly. Whenever we can play

13 other games that you do have fun playing.

Yeah. Exactly. Like I when the the this silver or not silver lining, the decision for it was like if I wasn't going to stick it out through Agamonia, why am I sticking it out through this one?

No. And I understand that.

And that's kind of what it came down to. uh like it it just doesn't doesn't make any sense.

Yeah. And that's perfectly reasonable.

So, what I will do is I will do a video on my thoughts on the narrative because I will just listen to that and

Yeah.

and just talk about what I think on the overall story.

Yeah.

Uh and maybe I'll look through what the other characters how they how they play, but I'm not I'm I'm not playing it anymore. That's fine.

So, Keith, on a scale of 1 to 10,

I'm rocking I'm rocking a seven. Five.

Still a seven.

The narrative is probably five of those points.

That's fair.

Um I I love the narrative of this game.

Yes.

Um that is that is what keeps me coming back.

You know what's interesting is the community has this best at at one. I wonder how many people like on Discord and stuff are actually only playing it solo.

I Yeah,

I wonder

I wonder I want to know what the I might I mean

well playing it solo you still have to play the two cards.

Exactly.

But here's here's my theory. If you're playing it solo, no one is around to watch you

crash out,

cheat or crash out maybe. Um no, no one's around to watch you.

Well, and that I mean I I don't want to toot my own horn. kind of goes with my theory of having this set up,

playing it for a couple hours a day.

You know, you you get bored and you're like, "Oh, I'm gonna go I'm going to go progress a little bit in Isafarian Guard."

Yeah.

Especially if you're solo, dude. I mean, I play this sometimes once a week,

right?

Because I'm playing with another person.

Um, and it's taking a very long time. But if I if I was playing this by myself, dude, I mean,

I'd probably be I probably I would have passed us. Yeah.

Like months ago.

No, exactly. I mean that's also the thing is because your other campaign you play weekly. Yeah.

So you have the luxury of breaking up what we do in in once a month 8 hour sessions. You get to do that twoour sessions once a week. Yeah.

So one it stays fresh still. Yeah.

Um but you're also

well and I'm not doing I'm not doing four of the same fight back to back to back in the same day.

Yeah. Uh so maybe I mean maybe a lot of it is just the way we did it the way we played it. Maybe that was never their intention and that's fair. Um then this 100% just isn't was never a game that was going to work.

Yeah. It just it it does not fit this Yeah.

format.

Yeah. And again to be fair, almost no campaign does.

Yeah. And that's

I

So okay.

Yeah. No, 100%. Like the the two games I've been giving examples for, Madara and atto, I am over it by the end.

Yeah. Um because Madara was like against narrative is amazing, gameplay was fun, and then at the end I'm pissed off because die rolls.

Yeah,

Ho's the exact same way. Narrative is amazing, gameplay is amazing.

Now I'm pissed off by die rolls and I'm just over it.

Any game with a dice.

That's almost any game.

Yeah, any

like

I mean they have to have a random aspect otherwise what's the point of playing the game? No, I mean I I do agree with that deterministic stuff is so boring, but I'm just talking about like I mean I couldn't sit around and play Elen Ring for eight hours. I'd have a meltdown. I'd [ __ ] family annihilate.

Well, I mean we did do it for a little while.

Um

Elen Ring.

Yeah, we played hard on Elen Ring, dude.

Oh, I not together.

No.

Yeah,

but I I sat I mean I definitely had eight hour stances of that game,

right? Um but I'm upset.

You beat it.

I Oh, yeah. I beat it. You beat it.

No, I I mean I love those games, but there's It has to be such a chill game.

I got to break it up, dude.

Yeah.

I mean, I do I do an 8 hour stent, but you better believe I'm going to eat in the middle of that.

Yeah. So, I mean, take it take, you know, a little bit I'll I'll um

take it with a grain of salt.

Well, that is what I was going to say, but then it's like I'll um submit a little bit to it's it's the schedule. It's the way we play. that is hurting this game. It's not necessarily the game itself. Um

I do think I mean even the way I play I do think there's ways that it could be improved.

Oh god. Yeah.

But I mean what else?

Maybe that's Veil Word.

Every maybe

I don't know.

I'll find Eric Eric doesn't like me enough to let me let me pro preview Veil Word.

Come on Eric.

Um there's no way in hell he's doing that. That guy would never wants to talk to me ever again. Well, but if you want to throw it my way, you know, I'm not going to review it.

And to be fair, there's this is not all my negative reviews. I remember people like, "That's so mean. They work so hard." I've had a few people that were like really upset that I give negative reviews. It's like, well, first of all, it's it's my opinion, so it it doesn't matter.

Um, and at the end of the day, it's never a reflection on the designer. No. Like, I'm not sitting here saying, "I have so many issues with this game, therefore I hate Eric Bman as a person."

No, Eric's great. Um,

seems like a very nice guy. I've talked to him multiple times. Um, and unless he's just a super nice guy and when I walk away he's like, "Fuck that dude." Which he could very well do. I mean, I that would make sense. Um, but every time I've talked to him, he's always been extremely friendly. Um, and it's nothing against him. Um,

yeah.

In fact, like I remember being in the Discord and I responded because there were people complaining that what they were adding was making the game too complex. Uh, and I I chimed in cuz they he asked he's like, "Hey, is what does everyone else think?" And I was like, "No, you need more depth to this game.

This this needs to be

like I cuz I I think I I'm paraphrasing, but I was like those because it's two guards, you need more complexity, more

depth." So s

Yeah. Um because what you're adding doesn't take away from the core aspect of what you're wanting to make.

Uh so I'm I'm somewhat excited for the way Bailword is looking. Mhm.

Because it's it's just not a watered down bag builder that it tends to be. So,

who knows?

We'll see. Cross that vision. We'll get there. What's your 1 to 10?

Um, six.

Yeah.

Um,

or five of those points story.

Six of those points for story. No, because at at this point I don't like the bad building. I don't I really don't like anything mechanically about the game except the story. Um

I Yeah, and that's that's the God's honest truth. I especially with the way Vera works that was that's so disgustingly bad

that I again with everything we said if everything was way more accessible to get um this game would be still fairly high.

Yeah.

But I I just

there's room to grow

cuz I I was looking at like I mean because they have a bunch of accessories. We've gotten items that were great, the paintbrush and stuff and

you only have one of them. you can only have one of them or we were looking at one of the early training art things of like this thing that doubles the sill of and it's like well you have to get that if you want to be able to afford you have to be able to get that but we can't fight that [ __ ] thing so yeah

um yeah so

it it I know I'm I'm beating a dead horse and saying the same thing over and over but yeah it's it's it's a six for me and that's honestly me cuz I was originally thinking five. Um, and the way I bitched this whole time, people are like, "Really? It's not like a three or a two."

I I'm surprised by your size.

Um, it's because I don't know actually. I can't really justify. I feel like a five or a four is too low.

Um.

Oh, that's fair.

Because again, it's not like this game is is designed so bad that I can't just homebrew it. We've obviously I mean we've we've put enough stock in it that we've played it for two years.

Yeah. I mean that's probably it. That is probably like some time some cost fallacy or or some cost or sunk time fallacy where it's like I've spent so much time I might as well just give it a higher score.

It earned something.

But it's a six literally on narrative alone. Um

God the narrative

everything else I I have no interest um to to play.

Yeah.

All right.

All right. Well that's it everyone. That's our thoughts on Isafarian Guard. Um, I hope you enjoyed the series for what it was. Uh, let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. And like, sh comment, share, and subscribe. And have a wonderful whatever day it is for you.

Progress saved