Skip to main content
Loading video...

Cthulhu Wars Duel: Extinction rounds out the game - CW Duel & Extinction Reviews

Transcript 7:45

cthulhu war's duel is the comparatively dimunitive little brother to the massive 2015 hit taking the same tight modern yet classic area control concepts and hyper asymmetric design philosophy it's essentially the same game just retooled for exclusively two players and replacing the totemic statues that are so iconic of the original with equally massive two-dimensional standees and setting up the release model to be mix and matchable standalone games featuring two lovecraftian factions at a time the original duel from 2020 featured the big daddy cute thulu himself as well as everyone's favorite doting mother the black goat of the woods now we have cthulhu wars extinction toting a new map and two new contenders sleeper vs wind walker so with all this new excitement of course it was time to put all of these new baddies as well as the much anticipated mixing and matching to the test while the new eldritch enigmas are the big draw one of the most curious and welcome things of extinction is the new map in cthulhu wars your main thrust forward was to spread out your acolytes create and control gates which then grant you power the economy through which you recruit units but on this map there are dark towers that populate in the doom phase initially in the two-player starting areas but from then

on in two areas at the first player's discretion that permanently displace any cultists from local gates and as in the original uncontrolled gates grant all players one power each which re-contextualizes conventional strategy players have a more transient lifestyle aggressively spreading out to claim new territory because of the inevitable displacement and being first player matters so incredibly much when you get to be the one who doles out the towers and in general i prefer the new map it sort of underscores the rapid forward momentum that i prefer about duel over ogcw this desperate pressure that comes largely from duel's decay system where actions become more and more costly for players who slow played their round that said this map is disproportionately tough on factions that benefit specifically through controlling gates sorry chubby and factions that benefit from opponent gate control sorry big guy but not so much that it feels entirely one-sided let's just say there's a sort of home-field advantage for sonny and cher speaking of which let's talk elder gods in the original duel you had kind of a strange matchup big green is pretty conventional strong and broadly useful his abilities which in this game all factions have a set of six unique spell cards that you can choose to put one into play each time you fill in one of your six faction requirements they're

flexible and intuitive cthulhu wants to spread out in water get the big guy out consolidate a force and attack pinky on the other hand is a bit more abstract ultimately the black goat is strong but relies on a much firmer understanding of her capabilities and not seeing toe-to-toe combat as her primary way of moving forward leading her to being relegated to more experienced players or those looking for a bit of a challenge extinction kind of goes the same way the windwalker powers are just good from the passive on windigos to scare away combatants pre-battle to recruiting free wendigos after battles to the faction passive to pass and hold on to power to the next round to ithaca's ability to pull around a posse of his faction units moving everyone for one power at a time when unlimited battle is opened up as a result of either player managing to get all six spells into play this dude is terrifying but pig frog well pig frog is no joke especially considering that his strength in combat is equal to the current amount of power that your opponent is rocking it's just his abilities are a little less conventional put serpent man on an opposing faction board to copy their passive wizards allow a bonus action pre-battle these are strong but situational his most useful abilities are to freely accrue his faction's own cheapest monsters during the doom phase or for their formless monsters to eventually rock up

to five dice in combat each and a spell to make it so combat either relegates our opponent's sixes normally kills to the normal result from a four or five that just makes you flee a unit or the opponent can nullify the spell by letting you get an elder sign at the beginning of combat for some tasty pointage the sleeper is all about defense and survivability but agility he has not lending to some trickier strategies focus on gate control or making sure that you're always hitting the ritual of power rather than relying on attrition and always killing enemy units in battle ultimately duel and dual extinction complement one another they're designed with one another in mind and one of the joys of cthulhu wars in general is seeing the different matchups from wildly asymmetric factions something missing from either dual release on their own personally if i had to recommend one over the other extinction is the way to go the challenge gap between the factions while still there isn't as prominent i think the map's dark tower mechanic is really compelling and i'm alaskan so yeah i gotta support my arctic boys what i really like though is that the pairing of the two sets together gives me enough variety and variability that duel has actually eclipsed cthulhu wars proper for me don't get me wrong there are still different experiences but the fundamental gameplay is so close whereas that dedicated two-player design lends it that great aggressive forward

momentum though be aware the 10 minute per player on the side of the box is just an adorable lie and to that that it takes up way less shelf space and you know what i'm gonna say it i actually really like the vibrance of the full color standies and will take them over unpainted minis any day i mean sometimes there'll still be a cluttered mess on the table but that's a big part of cthulhu wars charm anyway so if you like love crafty and spookiness you like area control you like the rich tension that comes from dedicated two-player games and you like games that are just mighty in what they offer they have you swing in a ton of dice at a time they have these enormous almost obscene little 2d standees in the place of the original statues if you like that much extra in a game and you like games where asymmetry is cranked up so much to the point where there's going to be some uneven matches and in some ways that unevenness is what makes the game intriguing in and of itself then this game hits all those boxes and sounds like it might just be the thing for you and that's our review let us know what did you think what do you think of cthulhu the wars duel have you played the original have you played this one what's the comparison and what are some of your favorite two player area control games whether they're dedicated to player experiences or not put them in the comments below and as always thanks for watching thanks for supporting thanks for being an awesome community

you make this all worthwhile i've been jack for the cardboard herald

Progress saved