Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mystic Curling Club Review! (Flicking Dice and Taking Names!)

Transcript 9:45

Hi everybody.

Hello, I'm Ryan.

I'm Bethany.

And we are Ryan and Bethany Board Game Reviews.

And today we get to talk about Mystic Curling Club. This is designed by Chris Sieslack and it is published by Asmadi Games.

Every four years something wonderful happens. And it's the Winter Olympics, obviously.

Obviously.

Most

You should have known that. You should have known that's exactly what Ryan was saying.

Most specifically, the most important part of the Winter Olympics is curling. Every four years, by the way, in between Olympics I never watch even a second of curling. Think about it, zero seconds of the time.

it exists.

But during the Winter Olympics specifically, I become an expert on all things curling. And I'm like, "Oh, did you see how they did that? That was That was no good. And that over there, though, that's a good pitch." or whatever. And I use the lingo, and I do the things, and I am a die-hard curling fan for two weeks of every four years.

Wasn't there like a big hubbub that happened this past Olympics where they accused like Canada of cheating or something?

That they would, those Canadians and their curling, man.

a real thing. Can you let me know in the comments below? And like I felt like there was some something that happened with curling at the Olympics, and now I can't remember what it is. Back to the game.

All right. So, in reality, curling is a very niche sport. Uh nevertheless, it is intriguing and it is fun to watch. It reminds me of something like shuffleboard, where you're trying to slide like a puck down and try to land in a certain spot of the board. There's bocce ball. There's all kinds of games that do something something a little bit similar. This just one that happens to do it on ice. All right. So, Mystic Curling Club, you guessed it, it is just curling but in board game format. You are basically the characters who are you are sending your dice down uh this curling lane, and you're trying to get as close to the middle as possible in order to get the most amount of points, uh and kind of vie for that best position so that way you can get, you know, the best points. Use special abilities cuz you're all These characters have asynchronous special abilities, and it is just a dexterity flicking good time.

Um so, in the game, there's these spells and charms that you can have. And so, essentially, you can modify your dice or do some like special ability with them. And it's really cool. You're just flipping through these. It's you and your familiar. That's how you get these special abilities. And um you can like mess with the results. You can do lots of fun things. But it's What I like about it is it's it's enough to make it feel like you have a lot of control over your gameplay, while nobody else thinks the game is broken because of your ability. So, I like that it's a perfect blend of giving you some I don't know, some control over what you're doing without making it unfun for other people.

This has the basic rules of curling. They tried to stay very true to it. The number of rounds, all those different things going on. Even the terminology they use, they tried to use the curling terminology in this game, which was really kind of cool because I'm going to be honest, I didn't know what some of the terms meant, even as a die-hard fan.

Yes. Once every 4 years.

4 years. As a die-hard fan, there were still some terms

Once every 4 years.

I was like, "Oh, so that's what that means. Oh, that's why that Okay, cool." So, now I understand that part of that better. Uh

[snorts]

so, they there are some small modifications they had to make because this the next game on was a dice instead of ice, you know. Uh and so, there were some small modifications that needed to be made, but they're all very clear in the rules, too. Um so, they had to make it make sense with the tabletop format with dice instead of these pucks, all those different things going on. So, uh the way they broke ties, the way that the rings worked in the distances, is all very very very similar to curling with some modifications, which I appreciated.

Speaking of those modifications, one of the things they did is um instead of it being as closest to wherever in a ring, it's the lowest number die in that ring. So, that's one of that's going to score. And it's cool when you're playing cuz you start with your lowest number die. And of course, when you flick it or send it across, it can change numbers, that happens. But you're still starting with the one and then working your way up to the eight. So, the one that has the potential to out to outrank everybody, you're actually playing first. And the one that has the least potential to outrank everybody, you're playing last. But also, you might have a chance to manipulate what's having happening on the board with that one as well. So, I just like how the the number system work. I had mentioned the spells earlier. One of the things that they do that's really cool is it has a number associated with it. So, you have like you line up your die 1 2 3 4 1 through 8. And if your spell's a three, you just take your three die and put it on that card. So, when it comes time for you to play your three die, you remember that you can do that ability. So, I just I like how those two things work out where makes it easy for the player to play instead of having to think about that all the time.

All right. They will say this is from two to five players. The it plays differently from two to five players, but they're all good. Some games play best at some numbers, worse at other numbers. This, they all are viable. They're all fun. Just it's a different experience. In a two-player game, it's much thinkier and more strategic as you're trying to really kind of plan out where you're going to go and knock out your opponent. In a five-player game, it's much more chaotic. So much more dice going on at the end of the table. More special abilities, more more chaos. More dice are going to score as well. But uh the it's a lot more chaotic. Things Your dice that you had perfectly planted, they're not sticking around. They're going to get knocked around a little bit. So, you have to two-player, much more strategic, much more thinky, much more precise.

Five-player game, just blast everybody out of the way.

So, whichever your style of game play is, that's the best player count for you. Um and everything in the middle, obviously, you got to have variations of that as well.

Okay. Um saying it now, I think this game has the potential to be on my top 10 of 2026. I

Wow.

really liked it. It was so much fun. I felt like every time we were playing, we were laughing. I had mentioned earlier, like you get a little bit of control, but it's a dexterity game, so you only get so much control over what's happening. And I just had such a great time with this game. I immediately wanted to play it again as soon as we played. It's a game It's one of those games where you think about when you're done playing it. And it's also one of those games that creates those moments that you'll be talking about for years to come. There's certain games that just create those stories that are hilarious and and you keep coming back to them. This is one of those games that has the potential to create that. Now, mind you, with all of that said, I do have one really tiny, tiny, tiny, tiny nitpicking thing, and it's just because I'm a spoiled gamer. It has nothing to do with the gameplay whatsoever. Like I said, potential top 10 of 2026. So, it's nothing about the gameplay.

Gosh, this is so nitpicky. Um some So, there's card art on on the on the mat, and then you turn it over and it's just white. It's blank. There's nothing there, not even like Mystic Curling Club on it. And I Like I said, that is as nitpicky as you can possibly be. I just know that some people will look at that and be like, "Why didn't they put anything here?" Like I thought, "Why didn't they put anything here?" So, it's just cuz I'm a spoiled gamer. That's all it is. I'm just spoiled, so I expect to see something everywhere. But let me reiterate, potential top 10 of 2026.

I like that this game had some strategy, had things that you were aiming for. Uh but at the same time, it's with dexterity. Those things don't generally line up together. Uh because of that, I it was just a blast. I think this would be a great game to have have tournament with. Um

just line up a tournament best the best two people advance forward whatever the case is. I think that would be an absolute riot. Never dull like literally never dull. Every single shot whether it's a perfect shot or a terrible shot is exciting and funny and fun no matter who whether it's yours or an opponent's use everything single time is fun. I knew right away I was going to like this one. Um So Bethany is absolutely right. It does have simple art and the components um are under arted if that's a word. Um I when I first unboxed it I was like that's that's a waste. That's a absolute waste of a cool thing they could have done. But I actually spun around on this one.

Okay. Okay.

Uh the things that have a white background just plain are things that are sitting on the table the whole time. It literally it never comes into play. It's not part of the table presence. It's not part of the game area. It's not anything you're going to see outside of when you are literally just setting it up and tearing it down. I'm okay with that. It doesn't affect the game play at all. And I'm not a big art person anyways so maybe that's probably affecting that but yeah the things that were kind of just plain white that's fine.

It's fine. It has zero bearing on anything that you're looking at visually because it's all face down.

at all not even a like an iota.

Yeah cuz it's face down. It's it's not even there except for when you're setting it up and tearing it down. So that being said really really silly good time.

Everybody thank you so much for watching and don't forget to subscribe so you can see our videos as they come out. Until then you can find us in all of these places.

Yeah thanks for watching and we will see you next time. Bye.

Bye.

You guys thanks so much for watching. Uh this game was provided to us by a publisher for in exchange for a fair and honest review.

And if you want to see more stuff check out over here to see something we think you might like.

And over here we think that YouTube has picked out a great video for you that you're going to love. Thanks, guys. We'll see you next time.

Bye.

Progress saved