Waterloo Solitaire | Review
Transcript
hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and today i'm doing a quick review of waterloo solitaire a game book from worthington press so let's have a look at waterloo solitaire as advertised this is a game book from worthington and uh all you need in addition to the book is a die a pen and of course a sense of adventure the book is not too thick but it does contain several games inside so let's just pop it open and say look when you open up there is a table of contents so the rules are fairly short they give you a detailed example of play so you can actually read through a game in action and then the book is actually divided up into french player games and allied player games that are in various levels of difficulty so you can play against challenging veteran and tough bots as both the french and as the allied player and you're going to get 12 games per side so what's kind of fun is that some of your early battles you'll see flipped and then you'll get to fight them from the other perspective which is really cool probably my only serious beef with this book is that i hate the way the rules are printed because it's more like a scroll like you have to look at it horizontally i mean the game is played horizontally as well but something bothers me about it being the rules but here are all the rules they are fairly concise they are pretty easy to work through and i actually found that with a quick rules read and then the aids that are on the actual games it's pretty easy to get started with this which i thought was good so here you have a detailed example of play which will help you see how to mark spots off but i'm actually going to talk about it as well
so this is the first game i played and i just wrote straight on the book you probably can't see it super well because it's in pencil but i've done experimentation with other ways to play you know sometimes people don't want to write out a book or they want to keep in case they want to play in the future and we we will get to that discussion but when you're actually playing this top page is nice because it tells you everything you need to know pretty much and then you can just reference the rules in the front of the book if you need more detail but you're going to have a sequence of play it's going to remind you what to do you have a chart that helps you interpret your die results which you're really going to need here are the die actions that you can roll for when you're playing the bot turn and then if the bot gets a tactical event you roll again and these are the tactical events so everything you need is really right there which i thought was pretty cool and then you have the actual gameplay area itself which is again actually fairly simple you will be playing the french in the first game and you have a limited number of turns in which to defeat the right and left wings of the allied army one thing that's interesting about this game is that i personally think your victory conditions as the french are a little bit harder you have to actually destroy parts of the allied army in order to win the allied army just has to outlast the french army which is a different matter entirely the allies also have some extra help from some additional units as long as they maintain control of those units you have to attack them to rest control away so the way this game basically works is that everybody has their right and left wings you will have an imperial guard and cavalry as the french there's some prussians over here who have an impact
on the game and then here are all the parts of the allied army and basically on your turn what's going to happen is you're going to choose one of these actions to take and figure out who you're going to target so if i want to go crazy and try to take out the right wing i might pick actions that help me do that then you can't actually activate what you've done until the allied side goes so you're going to select what you want to do then the allies actually take their turn so you don't get to respond to them by seeing what they do you have to make a decision first then the allied stuff is going to go through whatever the allies do and then you get to actually play your french action and then you mark off that a turn happened and then you begin a new turn some of the other subtleties of the game include that you cannot take an action two turns in a row so basically whenever you're doing activations down here you write the turn numbers to indicate that you did not do that and it's also kind of fun because it can help you trace what's happening in a game and there's also an option up here for combined arms tactics where you do two things on one turn but it burns both of those things out for your next turn so you definitely want to have a plan your guys are going to get hit too so you're going to be able to add reinforcements which are these dudes that are colored in here and the other thing you should know is that the die rolls are actually pretty brutal so right here we have a chart of what happens based on your die roll but basically um depending on how high you roll that determines how many hits the french get so if you get a high result if you're roll six is two french hits
but if you roll a one the allies hit you twice oops and if you're in the middle each person gets hit once which can feel like a bit of a tit for tat that doesn't get you anywhere so the actions and formations will shift as you go throughout the game but essentially what happens is you choose an action the other side does their action you do your action resolve everything and then take another turn and as you flip through the book you have several different battles to try and you can try them from different perspectives which i think is very cool indeed so that is an overview of waterloo solitaire let's go ahead and have some final thoughts all right so now for some final thoughts overall i really like waterloo solitaire and i think it's such a cool game idea i'm sure there's been stuff like this before but i've never encountered a game book of this nature to me it's very very exciting i think what i like the best about it is its combination of simplicity and portability this book has just been in my backpack forever while i was getting some review plays in and i thought that was great i could just slip it in with all my books it is flat it holds up pretty well and so i was able to just cart it all over the place until i got enough plays in to do this review which i really appreciated and twinned with that is the fact the game is fairly simple you really just do what the rules say it the game itself tells you what order to do everything in and you follow the order and when you roll for a specific action you do the text that is written on the page and you know everything just flows pretty well and that's something that i really appreciated i didn't feel like i had to do like if i it took me a while between
plays i didn't have to do some giant refresh to start playing again it was very easy to get going again and then maybe consult the front for some detail which i thought was really good um you know one of my biggest issues with games is that i play them a lot while i'm reviewing them and then i have a hard time returning to them because i've forgotten all the rules so waterloo solitaire was a nice game for me to review during a really busy time because i didn't have to play it like five times in a row to feel like i got it down i was able to kind of pick it up play a game put it back in my bag take it out play another game put it back in my bag and i really appreciated that that said the rules are pretty simple but that doesn't mean that the game itself is just totally simplistic there are actually a lot of interesting choices to make in each battle and the challenge levels were legit there are a range of challenges to take on in this game i thought that was really good i think the most interesting part is trying to decide how to do your actions and in what order and whether to take a combined action there's actually a lot of choice there because some of your more powerful actions will have better odds on the dice and they may attack more targets but because you can only do each of your actions so many times per game you're like oh man do i want to just like waste these now or do i want to do something that'll only attack the right wing and like maybe the odds aren't great but i might get a hidden on the right wing and i can use that better action for something else so kind of deciding what your odds are and how many activations you have and how to use them correctly is really i think the heart of the game and it made it a lot of fun even when i got
wrecked off of bad die rolls it still made me feel like i was making decisions that meant something and that's what kept me going all the way through the game but that said i will warn y'all if you don't like to be at the mercy of the dice let's just say that napoleon got smashed a few times especially as i was working over the first half of the game i mean i got a little smarter later but still um if you get a lot of really bad die rolls you're just not gonna do so hot in this game and of course dice hate us which is why we like to play games with them so much um but if you get a whole bunch of bad roles you're just gonna feel frustrated you really can get unlucky in this game because of the way that it's structured i personally didn't really care about that i was just in it to go through the different scenarios and have a good time and as long as you're approaching this game with that kind of attitude of like i'll try to do the best thing i can do but maybe the dice won't be with me then i think that you can have a good time with this one if you need to feel like you built an optimized engine that works and you can prove that it works and you know you you have these really carefully laid plans and they all went off without a hitch this is not your game so make sure that you're aware of your own self and your preferences and the way you like to play before you pick this up because it was fun for me but it will not be fun for you if you really don't like being at the mercy of that one single d6 which was occasionally really mean to me the other thing about this game that you kind of need to know yourself to approach correctly is that this is a game book and it's it's not laminated it's not really bound in a way that's
meant for you to play this again and again if you just want to play it through one time and put it in the recycling bin you really could do that and i'm actually thinking about doing that now that i've done this review i might just like play through everything one more time and then recycle it um i'm not sure that this is a game that i want to like play again and again over the years i don't know that it's a forever game it's definitely a fun game so you know i'm visiting my parents soon and i might take bismarck solitaire with me on the airplane because waterloo solitaire kept me super entertained in kind of similar situations lunch break just waiting for something else to happen quick game and i did say the game has some good choices and options but that doesn't mean that it's sort of the depth of game that i'd want to play again and again for the next decade i just don't see myself returning to this one repeatedly that said if you don't want to destroy your book you do have options other than like write on the book you know it's not like you have to tear up the book after you finish a battle or anything like that in fact i tried out a few different options and i'm gonna give them to you here so if you get this game and you want to know how to preserve your book and play it repeatedly because that's what you like then there are ways to do that so i just wrote in pencil lightly on the first game it's gonna be pretty easy to race and i'm not worried about game preservation but i did try out some other options that were good if you don't care about color and it didn't really matter to be honest i thought that maybe having it in grayscale when the book is printed in red and blue might bother me but it actually didn't so you can actually just make a copy of these sheets on a photocopier and it was fine
and that was no big deal at all other options one that i actually really liked because it also keeps digital copies of things that i can just pull up again and again is i have an ipad and i have notability so i like to scan this game and then just kind of have the game on my ipad and write on it in a note-taking app with my stylus and then you can just undo everything you did or just make a copy and write all over that and that was an easy way to do this if you are techy and you don't mind having an ipad with you while you're playing your game if you want to just keep the book and make things erasable i think another good option depending on what you have is some sort of combination of transparencies or even like um those page protectors that you can get at target just those clear sleeves that you can put around a piece of paper you can actually write on those with dry erase markers i actually tried this with a transparency because i'm a teacher and i have still access to old school transparencies and wet erase markers so you can just stick a transparency over the game and like right over it and then clean the transparency off no problem but i haven't tested this i feel pretty sure that you could just attach me with paper clips um a page protector to the page in your book that you're playing and write on it probably with a dry erase marker and because page protectors is so cheap if you mess it up you can just toss it and get another one so i think you have a lot of options for preserving your game if you want to return to it or if it just bothers you to mess up a book maybe you want to play all the games and pass it off to somebody else etc etc you do have
options for that and so hopefully that gives you some ideas for how to handle it if you decide to get this book and also keep it for yourself and for posterity so that's waterloo solitaire it was simple it was fun i don't know if it's a forever game but i would absolutely play another different game book just maybe not this one a whole bunch of times in a row and i hope that worthington keeps making these because they're about 30 bucks they give a good amount of entertainment i mean i would say i got way more hours of entertainment from this than i would have paying 30 bucks to go to the movies and these are great for kind of slipping into your bag and then using to while away a 30 minute break in your day so that's waterloo solitaire from worthington i'll be probably back soon with a review of bismarck solitaire since i got that one on the back of waterloo solitaire and i will be looking forward to future game books because these are super simple and quite fun thank you so much for watching uh please let me know if you've played this game what you think like subscribe and most of all happy gaming
you