Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mountain Goats Legacy Board Game Review

Transcript 7:42

Hey y'all, thanks for joining us at Tantrum House Studio 3. I'm Will Meadows.

And I'm Sarah Meadows. Today we're chatting about our experiences playing Mountain Goats Legacy from All Play. This is from designers Alex Cutler and Mike Mihalsic, and it features artwork from Sindara Tang.

This legacy version of the game takes the classic dice rolling game and adds tons of new mechanics, little twists and turns and surprises, and it leads you on an adventure through an endearing little storyline that's full of choices that you're going to actually get to have impact your game experience.

Yep. While we're going to try to avoid spoiling too much of the game in this review, the good news is that each round of the game, the winner gets to decide which branching path of the story to take, meaning that no two games are going to be exactly the same anyway.

So, while we got to explore like the icy mountain tops and the crooked trails and the winding rivers in our first run through the game, your experience could be totally different. And so, with that said, let's go ahead and jump in. We'll give you a little feel for how the base game plays, and then um

We'll talk about our experiences.

Yeah.

In the base game of Mountain Goats, you are going to build your mountain with ascending columns of matching numbered cards. And then, each turn you will roll all of the dice and assign them to whichever of your goats you'd like to use the matching numbers to climb the mountains.

When you make it to the top, you'll collect a point card, and you'll continue to do so each round if you assign matching dice until one of the other players' goats comes and kicks you out of your spot on the mountain. That'll send you back to the bottom, and then you have to work your way up again. After three decks of point cards have been exhausted, the game will end, and the player with the most points will win the game.

In this legacy version, though, you're going to be going through an overarching story, cool boxes you'll get to open, and lots of new components will be added to the gameplay.

So, like in any good legacy game, you're going to start off the first level of the game, you're going to play the basic version of the game. And when you get to the end of that, and you know how to play, then the story is going to begin to unfold.

Yes. So, the story actually kind of reminded me a little bit of one of the Land Before Time stories where the grandparents are bringing the children along to a new destination, and they're going to go through all kinds of crazy issues along the way, and you know, the story's going to unfold depending on who picks which area to go to.

Yeah, that's actually a pretty good comparison. I didn't see that coming. Well done on that. I will say that unlike most legacy, I mean, maybe it's just cuz this was kind of a warm and fuzzy story throughout. Most of the time I don't even really care about the story. Like, when we've played Pandemic, oh, something terrible happened, new outbreaks. When we played Ticket to Ride, oh, tycoons and whatever. In this story, you've got grandpa trying to give wisdom and lead. You've got the littlest goat, and she's asking all the questions. I actually found the story kind of delightful. Like, that doesn't usually happen in board game where I really even care, but I was like, I hope they make it. You know,

I was emotionally invested in this story. I hope they make it. It's up to you whether they make it. I hope they make it. [gasps]

Yeah, so in the game, regardless of what happens for gameplay, so obviously one player is going to end up with more points, and they will get to write their name on the journal entry. There's 10 slots for the 10 games that you will play, and then there are some slots at the end of the line, so it helps you put together some of the new components. They will go into this little box called grandfather's knapsack. And so, the next time you pull out the game to play the next game, it records all your notes from before so that you can easily just set up and start over.

I will say that like in many legacy style games, you're going to play the first two or three rounds, and there's not going to be a whole lot of craziness. Uh Nothing really gets shaken up. You're kind of just learning to play the game. However, there are some pretty cool little things that get added to the board. I don't think I'm spoiling too much to say obviously you're opening these boxes, you're pulling out some new components. We didn't get any more goats. That is one thing I'm going to spoil in case you were thinking that. Sometimes I feel like games add another player component or something like that. Most of it was in the way that the that you're scaling the mountain. New hurdles that get in your way, new additional steps.

There are no more goats, but you can purchase the little goat packs. So you can get alternate goats. And you can trade those with friends if you'd like.

So the winner of each round is going to get to pick just based on the title which kind of direction they want to head in next, which is going to determine which boxes you unlock next and will give you a little bit of a hint of what the gameplay experience might change to each round. I would say the game does get progressively more complicated but not but you've already mastered all the basic rules so it's not harder, but the math does become a little more interesting and the choices that you have to make are more interesting.

Yeah, so it may have you put some of the components away that you used in one of the games and you won't see them again until maybe later or maybe not at all and depending on which story line you follow and those components that you're swapping in and out, they do create new choices in the game that you didn't have before. So it does become more thinking instead of just rolling the dice and oh, I got three fives so I'm just going to move up. Now there's maybe reasons I don't want to go up that track and I I'm trying to really hard to go up a different track and so it provides ways for you to be a little more creative in how you use your dice with your goats.

Yeah, I definitely agree with that. And then also like any good legacy game, I'm just going to keep referring to the genre. You can replay it at the end, so it's totally playable with all the components that you've unlocked over the course of the game. You can pick out which pieces you like most and you can play with those. You can also continue to explore new things. You can start over because you can pick different branches to travel from the beginning. As soon as you finish the game, you can compare all of the achievements that you've unlocked. That immediately gives you a bunch of new boxes that you can open or you can go back and restart and do the whole adventure again.

Yeah, so the components there's several boxes that you'll get to open along the way. And then there's also a bunch of punch boards and I was worried about the punch board situation of like I don't want to cuz it just says keep these face down and punch what you need. But actually it was easy to punch the tile that you know tile or tiles that you needed for the next game without spoiling any of the components, which I found interesting cuz I thought there's no way I'm going to be able to get all these punched and then it was fine. And I was able to reset it all as well keeping the boards that the tokens go in.

The story does end with a nice little crescendo. The story wraps up nicely assuming you win. I don't know, we didn't lose on the last one but

assuming you win and yeah, that is all repackageable to play again. We had a great time playing Mountain Goats. We we played it with each other. We played it as two players. We played it as four players. We kind of just experienced everything that the that one trip through the the mountain had to offer us.

have players drop out and it's not a problem. Like because you're the base game allows for different player counts and it doesn't really change a whole lot. You can have players drop in and out during the campaign and it doesn't change the game play.

If that sounds like something you'd be interested in, check out Mountain Goat Legacy from All Play. And then as always, let us know any questions you have, thoughts or ideas, put them in the comments. We'll sure to try and get to those and answer them and then we'll see you guys in the next video.

Progress saved