Ticket To Ride Small / Mini Box Comparison - Which Is Best?
Transcript
in this video i'm going to do something slightly different i'm going to compare the three mini ticket to ride box sets that you can buy these days we first had new york now we've got london and now amsterdam which one is best what are the key differences well that's what you're here to find out hi i'm luke hector from the broken me boy and if you're new to this channel and you want to find out about board games and the people who play them then click the subscribe button and ring the bell for future notifications any videos or websites that i talk about in this video will of course be presented as links in the description below ticket to ride has been one of those ever agreeing titles that is like the quintessential gateway game that you should use to bring new players into the hobby what is all this gloomhaven stuff at number one on bgg i've always advocated that ticket to ride should be the number one game on bgg because let's face it who in the board gaming hobby has never heard of ticket to ride who has not used ticket to ride to bring a completely new player into the hobby how many times do you see this being sold and played and tore and this is a game that has been sold since 2004 a decade and a half ago this is the game that deserves to be ranked number one not some 150 pound monster thing that most people don't even know how to get or play and as you can see from the decor in my studio can i call it that
this ticket derived franchise has gone on for a long time and spawned a lot of expansions and this is just five of them on the wall five of the map packs you can get there are other ones and they're all contained in my lovely jumbo box there check out my shelf by shell video if you want to know more about this crate in general i believe it's number 49 in the series so now days of wonder have gone the extra mile or shortened the mile i guess so depending on your perspective and brought out these small box expansions first there was new york and now we've got london and amsterdam so these are essentially meant to be 15 minute filler versions of the big set of ticket to ride but what's the point is there a point and which one is best well that's what i'm here to tell you if you have never heard of ticket to ride before and if so you must be fairly new to the hobby in which case welcome one and all then tick of the ride is just a classic gateway game you collect sets of coloured cards in order to play train routes on a map connect up locations and score points by completing tickets and you score points for bigger routes that you can collect you can block off other players there are all sorts of different maps each with their own nuances and layouts and occasional extra mechanics it is just such a great game you could pick up any of these ticket to ride sets and have a blast and if you go to your local board game cafe i guarantee that if the cafe is even worth mentioning at all it has a copy of ticket to ride somewhere in there for you to play so what do these new sets provide well if you're used to ticket to ride then it brings pretty much the same rule set across you collect sets of colored cards you play them in order to put your vehicles in this case because it's no longer trains
on the board and connect up cities for points and each one has a slight nuance to the scoring over the other aside from that they are pretty much identical games but there are occasional differences with regards to the aesthetics and that little nuance of extra scoring can make the difference as to which one you prefer not to mention the map layout is different among them as well so let's talk aesthetics first the first of the two main differences here with this the board for new york is fairly light colored but it's easy to see the roots on there it's been darkened up slightly it is definitely a taller and thinner map which makes it look different from the other two because the other two are more kind of rectangular fat maps if that makes sense and then use the taxis they are basically very basic plastic sculpts of taxis the artwork on the cards is vibrant and colorful and it does the job very nicely for a cheap 15 pound or less package with london you get a little bit more of an inspirational feel with regards to the scoring track and some of the decor around the board you're now using buses instead of taxis the one problem that this one has compared to the other two though is that the board is very light colored in fact a little bit too light colored if you look at the background of the board compared with the tracks on the board they do blend in a little bit more it's not like one is darker than the other in order to bring out more contrast with this one london is probably the hardest to visualize on the table but that is still a minor nitpick because frankly this table presence is so small you're going to be sat around it pretty
close anyway and you should be able to see what's going on but from a distance you can argue that it's a little bit harder to see the london board compared to the other two amsterdam though does not have this problem this is easily the best looking of the free sets that you can get it has the nicest looking board with a map of historical amsterdam in the background but with perfectly contrasted roots on the board as well it is easy to see where the roots go which ones have cart symbols it's just so easy on the eye so that people even of like bad sight should be able to make out what is going on and the point track is clear the cards themselves are really vibrant colors i love the use of different modes of transportation for the different cars like one of them is a mule the other one is a little sailing boat and everything just really pops on the table easily the best for aesthetics out of the free but despite looking the best of the three of these sets there is one issue i have with the aesthetics of amsterdam and that is the wagons themselves it uses mule wagons instead of trains for the placement on the board but these wagons are smaller and more spindly and fiddly than the buses and trains and taxis we've had in the past and they're smaller than the route networks themselves whereas previously the train used to cover up the entire segment it just kind of looks a bit weird on the table and from a distance it's sometimes a bit hard to tell who's covered what particular route so whereas london has the issue with the board part i think amsterdam has a slight issue with the wagon pieces so now looking at the other difference between them the nuance would score in
what little quirk does it throw in in order to differentiate itself well new york is the weakest of the three in my opinion here all you have is a few locations on the board with a one next to it and if you connect those up you get that additional point on top of claiming the route and getting the tickets it's about as boring an extra scoring mechanism as you can get it literally is just a case of play the game as you were and if you happen to be going across those routes hopefully your ticket wants you to you'll get some extra points and it's not even a great deal of extra points i mean we're talking one point for each of these locations and other people can get them as well so they don't have that big of an impact really you might as well call new york ticket to ride usa for the small box sets that little bit of extra scoring is negligible it's not even worth mentioning and it just basically makes new york the bare bones version of these three london has a similar mechanism with roots on the board giving you extra points but the difference here is that rather than just connecting from a to b there are districts and you have to connect all the tracks in a district like in a big ring in order to collect the points from worth one to five obviously it is a lot harder to do the five point district than it is to do the one point district this is my favorite of the three new scoring mechanisms because as well as making a fair difference to the score at the end of the game having those districts because chances are if you've been spending a lot of time getting the big districts you probably haven't got as many tickets or you just haven't claimed as many routes in general but people fight for those routes and it gets quite clogged
up nice and easily and it's just a nice little incentive i mean you can make it your focus of the game rather than go for so many tickets you might decide right but i'm not going to go for many tickets i'll go for the districts so you have at least two decent distinct paths to victory for a 15-minute filler amsterdam's one is a little unappealing as well you might as well call it share certificates they call it merchandise cards but what is the difference really here every time you connect a route with cart symbols on it you draw a merchandise card and at the end of the game whoever has the most gets a certain amount of points second most next third most is basically a majority holding it could be merchandise share certificates whatever it could be anything and it will work it's not a bad mechanic though in practice because you do have that distinction of do i go for tickets or do i try and get those cards maybe they work in conjunction you don't know and depending on what positions everybody is on the score track the differential and points can make a decent amount of difference granted that the top two players are fighting for the victory and they're both first and second on those current symbols then three points isn't going to make a difference half the time but that differential between first place and last place on the merchandise cards could swing the game for somebody so i certainly prefer this much more to new york but i think london takes the edge on it slightly so how do i rank these three personally well in third place easily new york it looks fine on the board and it does the job but i just don't think the penny location is particularly interesting really the only thing that saves new york is the fact that the map being
slightly long and squished is a slightly different feel from the other two but comparing it to all three this is the weakest of them and it's why it's not in my collection but i would still give it a seven out of ten and say it's a perfectly decent game second place and third place are a little bit closer to core but i would give amsterdam the second place spot it certainly looks the best from a board perspective but those wagon spindly pieces are a little bit of an off put for me and also the merchandise cards are nice and all but again i don't feel that they create too much of an interesting dynamic during the game compared to the london one in a minute but i still think this is a solid one i would play this one over new york and this one will still remain in my collection and i would give it a decent eight out of ten but my number one spot has to go to the london map and no this is not because i'm from britain i would much rather visit new york than amsterdam than london any day but london with that district scoring i think just creates that streamlined yet interesting feel for a ticket to ride gabe granted the amsterdam one is probably better from an aesthetics perspective but this one i think just takes the slight nudge from a gameplay perspective but that being said it was a close call amsterdam in london i could take it or leave it but i think london just gets that little bit of an edge from me with new york clearly being the underdog in this particular list but at the end of the day 7 out of 10 8 out of 10 8 out of 10 you could pick any of these maps and still do fine they do a great job of bringing ticket to ride down to a filler game level and i still maintain everybody should have a copy of ticket to ride in their
collection even if it's just one map you need a copy i still think it should be the number one on board game geek do i give it a 10 out of 10 no but that's not the point it's not a case of whether i give it a 10 it's a case of whether i think the game is deserving of such a rank and it is every cafe has one every time i teach it to people that goes over well i have friends who love it my dad loves it it's his favorite game from the modern era that i have brought home to show every time i come home he's always like oh can we play ticket to ride india please please he just wants to get it out and every time i bring a new map home it's like hey dad look i've got a new map for you and he just wants to play it that brings me so much joy to see and to be fair i've not even shown him these little ones actually so i'm going up to visit the folks in about a week's time of recording this video so you know what i'm going to take amsterdam in london with me and see what he says but yeah honestly pick your poison all i've done is compared and contrasted the free told you my opinions it's up to you to make the final decision now i hope you've been enjoying the video content i've been bringing out but i'm not the only content creator out there that deserves your support so therefore why didn't you check these two out and see what you think hey guys what's up i'm jody and i'm justin and we are board game perspective so our passions are board games and photography and we want to show off the awesome world of board games through high quality how to play videos cinematic sequences and photography etc so our channel is in honor of my brother he's actually the one that got us into loving board games unfortunately he
passed away a few years ago but he wanted to leave us his entire bourdain collection which consisted of over 200 board games some of them of which are even behind us now so if you guys are interested in following our channel go ahead and search board game perspective on youtube or you can find us at board game perspective on instagram if you want to follow some of our board game photography so thanks for watching today we'll see y'all later and thanks luke for the shout out so that's it for me on this video if you liked what you see send a like click the button in the center to subscribe and ring the bell for future notifications if you want to check out additional content there's always my board game glossary or my recent podcast showing take care and remember it's only a game