A Game of Thrones The Board Game - Quick Review
Transcript
ladies and gentlemen this is a review a very quick review of the game of thrones and the board game second edition first released in 2011 and so recently got a like an expansion for this one so I'm gonna have a look look at this one and then in a separate video we're gonna have a look at the the new mother of dragons expansion see what's changed where it makes it get better worse or maybe it doesn't do nothing so yeah let's come back after this board games in addition I mean this is a Bittman old classic now on it you know I say but first with like I said first released in 2011 and it's and it's got that that reputation for being like a bit of an epic game really I mean that's like a six PI game and it really worked best with whip six I mean if you've got less than six players and you plan it with them some of the areas and end up on a board and that's a blessing and a curse so everybody in this game take control of a house or a faction that's in in the books it's not based on the TV series because when this was first released to think that first it was 2003 Utley when this was first released the TV series wasn't weren't out so it's based
on the characters and the stories in the book I guess and yes I take control of one over six houses and he would mean this games got a bit of a reputation of being a bit of a complex base book because the rulebook so poor I mean it's this big massive beast of a rulebook once you peel off all the gum and you get down to the core rules you can you can have like a cheat sheet of what one sheet so what you got you've got the the game as is it's divided into three phases you got the Westeros phase where you've got three decks of cards and you reveal one the top card of each deck and resolve them and that will allow yunusov muster new troops on the board it will allow you to realign your supply lines and it would also affect the chances of a war been invasion from the north fight and then you've got the planning phase so you've got the ones got these command tokens and you put them face down on regions where you've got plastic units where you've got your armies and then everyone reveals them and then you resolve the command tokens those various commands hogs you've got a raid order which allows you to after all the tokens have been revealed you can remove some tokens from adjacent areas you got the March order which allows you to move your units into adjacent areas and attack but you can move more than one unit but you can only ever have one back and then you've got the defense orders which shore up which show up the regions where you've got your your token and then you've got the then you've got support orders which allow you to gift
this strength of your army where the support water token is to either your army or somebody else's army in an adjacent region and that's where the game kind of shines really because you may be asking for somebody support thinking like could you put a support order in Winterfell or something to protect me from another player and they put the little taco down when I flip over if I could consolidate power time yes I could solve that pairing when you put that however that allows you to gain power stalkers which is saw like a currency in a game in that allows you to bid on one of the free tracks you got your front track which is you take your phone you break ties and then you've got the fiefdom track which gives you the Valyrian steel blade which gives you a +1 in combat then you've got the Kings called traps gives gives you the messenger raven and if you've got if you were in possession of that then you can change one of your command tokens after they've all been reveal or you can look at the top card of the wildling deck and stick it underneath if you want to so you see little silver bill heads up on what's coming on the wildling track so I mean combat in this game is it's relatively simple a little bit mathy based not that bad so what you first think when you move one of your tokens into into an opposing players region one of their armies the game sort of temporarily stops and you call for support so like we said you look at all the support tokens and rejection you you take their strength and yeah if each each units got a different strength so you got footmen which is worth 1 Knights worth 2 in combat and siege engines are worth 4 but they can only attack in
areas where this castles they're not useful for defense so you take all the support tokens that's strength of your army and then you choose one of your cards from your deck of house carter and you you had the the strength for that to the Attili army and if you got it you can flip the Valyrian steel blade to give you plus 1 so you had a whole con much the player who has the highest combat strength is victorious and depending on how many swords are on the combat card that you played that's how many troops are destroyed and any other remaining shows I have to retreat into a friendly region or an empty region if I can't they're destroyed by oh yeah I mean there's a few convoluted rules around Porter's on what you can do and if you hit you're gonna player so it's a good idea just to get that into your head and get everyone get the pork fingers insert a pro 6 it's a bit of a pain in the neck but erm essentially you win the game if you control 7 strongholds or castles and nobody control 7 and you play 10 pounds whoever controls the most is the winner after 10 rounds unless essentially the game really so what do we like about this one so one of the things that really draws us to this game the fact that has been herself in our collection for quite a number of years and it's still being supported after all those times because it's a six player ethic you got that you got that Twila Imperium epic feel to this one and the fact that is is it's basically only pliable in its some
vanilla form with six players is like a blessing and a curse because obviously you need supplies to play it but then when you're going to get six players to play this game I mean you know if you've got Twyla Imperium then you're gonna want to play that as well so it limits the amount of time this is gonna get to the table right yeah I mean another thing that is pretty goodness is the sense of negotiation you know you've got that if you do this for me I'll do that for you and then that Alliance can shift so nothing in this game is ever concrete which is which is really really really juicy prospect when you played this one because you don't know where ever your mate in Winterfell is going to go over and do over the Bereans or whatever or vice versa so there's that this negotiation is very simple when it's it's not it feels kind of neutered in an in a sense but a thing that fits the fits a game is it's not a massive massive part of the particle but number plus is once you actually get around the rule book and you've got the rules into your mind it's actually quite simple game is just putting tokens on the board flipping them over and resolving them and that is it once you once I mean so I say once you get the audio ports in your head the game is actually a very very simple game it's just it makes it look because the game so is so broad a big it makes it look bigger than the sum of its parts of him but yes it's a very simple game it is there's not that much ATP people call it well there's not much of
this analysis paralysis because by the time your turn comes around I think you've already decided what you what are you going to do you've already put you your counters down you know you should have formulated a plan so the fact that your turns come round quite slowly it gives you that opportunity to plan what you're going to do and also limits the amount of time that people spend just fixated on the board that's a big plus for game of this yeah I mean combat is broody quite simple in it you just I basically had an up all the combat strength you choosing a card dump it down and yeah that's it I mean this it's just whoever's got the highest score and it's a yes that's what you want in a going list you know you want to just bang boom bang done combats done and it's over with so there's none of this it's not protracted it's not it's not a complicated processes and essays a bit little bit math if it's just that add an up number so it that's a big big plus of a let's go complain for combat and it's over pretty quickly I know the game pauses but it's kind of brief once you once you get into the swing weight combat works it's very very brief so what don't we like that kind of phone is a ball game so one of the things that I'll find it quite makes a game it doesn't bump up to really high is the fact there's no progression so there's no real sense that you've building your armies up and you gain a special abilities you know you've got your cards off the bat coat you can choose from and okay you can upgrade your army units but you can do that
whenever you want really so there's no real you can't Bob on you know more weapons you can't have an enhanced version of a siege engine or you know there's no sense of progression in a game and there's a bit of disappointment really I mean one of the other things is like we've already said the game is it's probably too long for what his you know I mean some people say they play this for five hours I mean there's no chance with duda so but you know if you if you play with the right people with an Oda game and can keep the game moving and cut down on the amount of bots tearing yeah you can do this in about three hours which is probably about right and it's a yeah it's probably a bit too long really I think you know yeah also games quite fiddly I mean you've got a because the ports I bet you've got a reach over and you're gonna the regions get very very and packed very quickly so you in fact you got flip these tokens over you you know if you lose one they could fly off the board or you can fly somewhere else and you constantly sort of try to flip things and stuff like that fingers it's hard to sort of putting your hand a bowl of stew and it's quite fiddly Gaiman s that's a bit of a pain in the neck yeah one of the biggest pains in this game are the portals they are one for you one of those get the portals into your head I mean if anything really they could be taken out if that's one of the ways you could stream on the going to say yeah so one of the other things that we don't like about it is that you see it spire ball with Leicester six players but it's also compatible with lesser six
bars because you got all those empty areas a carton ice and plans for three or four players maybe get one five but really you need to play it with six and that's one of the down assist that you can't really get it to the table dolphin but there's when you plan a six players you probably want to play something else really like Twilight period or you know for this for the link for the game because if you've got six players yeah you can oh you're getting a deaf people maybe drop into a power than diverse it's just a pain in the neck very having six players less than six platanus no no don't do it yeah so but I'll think that stops us get to the table is that players must learn the rules beforehand you can't you can't you can do it like course you could do it but you I would advise everybody to watch the Fantasy Flight official rules video multiple times get get the portals into your head and then do a bit research and there come to the table not winging the rulebook and prepare some handouts of it for people you know you want to cheat sheet so you could be gotten wrong all the rules and finally you can condense it down at one page but yeah that's it that's another thing is to it the rulebook sucks it really does it's all force his tube it's too much fluff and it's laid out really badly and yes oh yeah definitely learn the rules before you play so in summary I can refine support game it is a frustratingly epic the board game is I mean we're not going to get rid of it because the expansions come out but it doesn't get to the table that much panda that's probably a good thing because I
wouldn't want to play this all the time it's not that sort of game it's all just one of them games where you got to vote that I would devote a an extended evening or maybe even a full day to this one if you're gonna play with six players or I wouldn't expansion oh my god oh my god it's one of them epic games that you need to set aside so look we're going to play this everybody go I read the rules get the rule get fluent with the rules learn another language learn Sanskrit or something that's what it feels up in your lowness won't come to the table work I would off you go I know yeah but yeah it's got that Massey's go ahead bixie experience there's lots of backstabbing there's a shift in alliances it's tense it's exciting it's it's a big big big game it's like it's like um I cannot describe it it's like the ten commandments on an inch out nest and movies you know it's a big hitter it really is is so it's really really fitting of the books and and it does mirror that that cutthroat nature in a books and all these characters you're gonna we're gonna get knocked off yeah so yeah it's the same thing you don't know when someone's gonna turn out and stab you in the back so yes but one of the good things about it yeah so I set this big is epic it's exciting tense negotiation is really good but but that's also its flaws as well because it's not going to get to the table it's when you're learning it it's it's migraine inducing is this boring to learn it's a struggle
a small washing machine yeah Game of Thrones the port game I would recommend this one it's definitely worth it you know and the fact that they still been supported and there's an expansion which we're going to talk about next which may or may not make the game better then I would recommend this one def go and get it because it's not that expensive when you pay about 30 quid for it faithful good for so yeah if you like those six player big epic games then just want you to definitely be on your radar