SHASN: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games on like and d and I are doing I what did you say you like hate this game I'm out are doing a discussion over shaen the political strategy board game now to be fair disclaimer this was sent to me as a review copy which I know a bunch of reviewers say that at the beginning like oh this is sponsored this is not sponsored I'm not being paid to do this but it was s but they gave us free game they free game which is kind of weird because it's like why disclose that information if it's like no one would assume it was sent to you for free um but years ago this okay so this is going to be a very interesting discussion I think um because we're going to argue back and forth we're going to go over every single card and debate our legitimate political ideologies um on this fun lightboard gaming channel no I'm going to try very well I can probably do it uh this review is not going to be political in any way believe what you want I really don't give a [ __ ] at this point um no I'm very nihilistic at this point in my life it's like I'm going be so racist I'm going to get your channel ripped off of YouTube so bad dude no it prob no it probably boost my numbers honestly um no so shaen is is a extremely intriguing game because it came out in 2021 and years ago I had actually had a uh either a run through and a review um back
then but I wanted to come back uh years later especially because Shas and naadi came out and kind of revisit it uh to see how it stands the test of time mhm um and we're also going to be including a review over the two-player game we just got done playing the two-player variant Devon has not played the multiplayer but I have so I I'll be able to shed some light on the multiplayer uh short answer is this game is very much a multiplayer game um but what what I find extremely fascinating about this game is one depending on which campaign you pick is going to be most likely geared towards where you are in the world like we are most likely going to uh uh relate to the US one because we're in the US if you're from India you do the India one if you're from 40 BCE Rome you're going to relate to that one obvious a lot uh but then brexit loock him lock the thinkers and then there's the future of humanity which is 2040 not that far off at this point um but I find this game what's also going to be kind of cool is we have hegemony to compare this to which is kind of a sociopolitical economic game uh what I find so interesting about this one is it it brings up clearly controversial
or highly debated topics in a relatively light game MH and that ju position between those I it's I find it difficult to kind of rank where I sit on it now CU years ago was I felt like it was a lot easier to be like oh yeah know you can just play this and not have a not have a you know that big of a a deal with these these questions that you're being asked but nowadays everyone's just so angry that I feel like you almost have to tiptoe around who you play this with um like this is not a go to the local game store and play with rando's game yeah it's like how old are you right like are you in your 40ss are you a boomer definitely not in your 50s we're not playing with 50 yeah um but I don't know I it's because I love I like if this game didn't have those campaign ideology cards I would not really care about this game it's it's simple Resource Management uh that you use to buy numbered cards to place in zones right that's literally the game but the ideology cards kind of help dictate it and push it along um in a very interesting way so Devon I am curi curious on what your thoughts were over sha not the two-player experience specifically the two player experience um if we have to qualify it then I don't think I want to talk about it um well
what did I think of shaen if you're going to restrict my freedom of speech exactly okay we're already going Su Primo all right that's how you do it that's how you win apparently um but anyway I like the flavor of this game I do I feel like it was easy to grasp um it I I enjoyed the questions I thought they were all very oddly per you know pertinent yeah uh for our current um you know you said this was created in 2023 2022 shots that came out 2021 the US deck which I don't know is 2022 to 23 um now I don't know if that was um if those were updated I can't remember if the version I originally played was earlier than that yeah and then they updated it to which is kind of an interesting thing you almost have to almost constantly update them if it's modern times yeah I mean I guess a few years difference isn't a big deal but anyway I uh yeah essentially you have like four different personas that you could build up kind of naturally based on I mean obviously like you said you're trying to gather particular resources uh to sway particular voters which are going to come out in a random draw um h of course the dictating the zones that's also very interesting an extra layer cuz I was like okay even though I was behind I wasn't super behind so you know you got a bunch of Voters you know but I was able to make the the the check offs for the majorities in different areas it wasn't that
crippling um yeah and you you will unlock like abilities yeah you just I mean naturally as the game kind of goes on it's like who who are these Nob buies you start off with like really struggling withth resources and then middle of the game you start really like SW and resources now the supro in a two-player game is heavily op it's like cuz all it does is restrict one another person in a multiplayer game it's like oh you have a fund and you have a fund I need two funds I'm going to take both of those um that makes a lot easier and with the with the trading and stuff with multiplayer that makes it a lot easier you can start negotiating hey I have a lot of trust do you want to set you know I'll give you three trust for one one clout or whatever it might be um let's see here I I like the questions I thought those were really cool um helps kind of stir some conversation amongst the table right um which is you know that's what you want in a board game you want something to talk about yeah so yeah no I would uh I wouldn't play the two players I'll just I'll just cut to the chase uh Supremo was busted uh espe I mean since I went showstopper originally which doesn't have an additional resource generating motive um originally and then he went SU so then he just got to steal all my resources in the early game which was utterly crippling on top of the fact that my conspiracy cards all gave me like the very first one I drew let me choose the resources from either side I still had got the idealog from the one I
picked but it's like uh I don't need any more power I'm going to get you know more uh funds I choose so yeah it very much swayed my way way early on and it kind of was more of just like a B biting for time like while I had all of these uh conditions I had to meet it's like I'm just gonna like make everything hard for you while I eventually get what I want right which is the supro so yeah so anyway two player not great wouldn't do it do it in uh four probably optimal this is definitely a big group uh what's the player five five five it goes up to five I think more would just be better in this one yeah and I but it's funny you know you know that we run off a two-party system I know this is like oh okay so one no it it is very funny cuz that's why I thought the two-player was going to work cuz I'm like oh yeah you just play the two- party system right it it really it doesn't Unfortunately they got a Nerf either and for the record cuz I know you haven't seen it the um that they have a specific board uh to do the two-player mode um there's also an oath of office on the back of the but this is the actual four to five player board oh okay so there's just a smaller one and then there are these uh tokens you can do just kind of also alter the districts um these cards are only specifically for the two-player game uh which I mean I really like I thought these were cool they made like it a lot more interesting if cuz these are just place where you want to place and then it's a lot of jockey this this is only for two players
interesting yeah so this board is a lot of jockeying for positions um and what's really cool is that as the game goes on and you get conspiracy cards or hell even headline cards you can make a lot of really cool plays like you did a uh a POS um an ability where I thought I had the middle area locked down and then you ended up coming in and like you're like oh I'm going to go ahead and uh buy a bunch of these because I can get discounts and then get more voters and then with my conspiracy card I'm going to gerrymander into it and get an extra voter which gives me a majority M and a lot of this game is doing those kinds of moves to then end the game and be like and that's the final one and I swung that ninepoint you know Battleground into my favor and the final scoring which I actually kind of really like in this kind of game is it's all out there I'm getting seven points I'm getting six points I'm getting so you that's like I'm at 13 points uh plus the eight here so um 21 points and oh you took that nine so that puts you at 23 or whatever so you you just win that's how that's how simple the endgame scoring is but unfortunately in a two-player game the writing is on the wall yeah for a lot of it where it's pretty clear I mean I mean yeah I just don't see two player working out too great you got the supro where you're removing them and then you've got uh only where you can convert them yeah but it's like I I just take two of your resources and use those
two resources to remove two of your voters exactly whereas like id id list is very good at converting because you can well with discard payback and tough love you can break majorities but that cost you so many resour ources and so you need four resources two needing to be trust and I mean if I just am constantly taking your resources you that's like all you're doing on your turn almost right and it's like yeah you've got to at least have a minimum of three supro if you want to like exist so then you're stealing back and forth so yeah unless you have some way to alter the voting cards um where it's like oh yeah it it it develops some I Nerf it I I mean that's the one thing like one resource or just one voter I don't know that's what I wish they did in a two-player game these abilities are modified um because they really don't change much except adding these cards and the bidding at the in a multiplayer game you vote on who starts which is gimmicky but it works for the theme uh cuz it's like a lot of people are kind of going to vote and you have to have a majority vote so if it's a tie in a four player game then you then you revote so it's like obviously I can't vote for myself but you're you're if I vote for you then that means all at least go second so I'm going to try and vote for you the most okay uh so it just kind of it it's it works MH but in a two-player game everyone starts with eight resources and you kind of bid to be first player who cares I'd rather start with
eight resources be like I don't I'll go I'll go second I'll just keep all eight of my resources uh so it it really just doesn't work which is why they probably sell the two player boards separate and they're like I mean if people want to play a two I guess we'll make money off of it but you made an interesting point that I definitely want to focus back on because the the area control aspect I think is clean it works you get a lot of cool moves the conspiracy cards are really powerful um and can sway the the course of the game the headline cards are just a universal event that might hurt you if you're the one that went into but sometimes you might want to go into it because it locks you into that spot you are guaranteed to be in a in a Zone if you suffer the headline and some of them might be I don't know there and what's also kind of frustrating with the two-player game is certain conspiracy cards are disgusting like the one that I had where it's like hey pick an area where you have a majority remove all of your voters there and if it's empty or if there are any empty spots by the start of your your next turn fill it with all of yours yeah good luck doing that with one person exactly one person's not doing it unless I mean you could have with like your last turn where you buy got eight voters and then you could fill it all up but in a two-player game as well with these conditions if you're not meeting that condition you also can't take it but then a multiplayer game that's like a king of the hill aspect where everyone is like oh [ __ ] okay everyone start
start filling it in yeah uh so that's also kind of which they do take out cards for uh a two-player game with headlines and conspiracies but not enough it was like two from each deck got and that one's just kind of disgusting um but I really really like the conspiracy and the headlines I think one they're thematic they have flavor text and they are not they're they're broken but not like I don't know I feel like they're not like a big old [ __ ] you to the to like the players like with the headlines or the conspiracies they really seem like I mean they're just kind of like oh hey now I can use one of your idealog abilities right neat mhm and then the yeah the additional from Jerry mandering whatnot keep two reuse them next turn that could be powerful in a different circumstance where I could actually get voters um yeah I mean in that case it's like okay great now and the The Edge case scenarios aren't super clear I would say this rule book is actually very bad it pretty much just describes a bunch of like concepts of the game and then it's like so what do I do on my turn and it's like oh all the all the concepts I just explained is what you do it sounds like since I didn't realize these were two-player exclusive like it sounds like they just kind of tacked on the two-player rules that's how like an additional like I mean like oh let's make this work real quick I mean well the game like the bones are great this is this is a fun game yeah uh in a big group I think it'd be a great time absolutely and this is one that I still
think now obviously if you're into politics in any way actually if you're into politics this is going to be right up your alley because um and even if you're not into politics it's a solid area control game if everyone is levelheaded if you're not playing with you know Uncle Jim who gets all of his information from when he's playing board games he's out there shooting you're you bring this to Thanksgiving all right family that I kind of hate let's all play this yeah let's argue all day um because clearly the the the obnoxious people on social media they're the loudest but they're the minority I have had I can have conversations with people that I know were not going to agree on it like years ago when Trump was first elected I was talking to I worked at a factory in in the Midwest and I was just I would hey why this guy and we would just Converse and we went on our way we had a great working relationship nowadays that might not be as easy cuz it's a little bit it's a it's a little bit worse but I've been a able to have these kinds of conversations with the IDE ideology cards that um that they tackle mhm and have been fine um and I think that kind of where you're saying this this game is fun is you can you can do that you can kind of have a drink I once they get shitfaced and then play and then play the game oh yeah um but yeah you could have a four five player group and then
the Twist on these cards that I kind of um and taken instead of more of like where do you stand on Senate filibusters being abolished um that's actually a great example of what I was about to say instead of being like where do you stand this can also be used as a good educational game M if it's like what's filibustering and someone who knows could inform you on that versus uh whether or not you want to argue yes or no and they clearly have a tongue and cheek kind of thing with the answers they're not like no it's very clear which way they're leaning of the four it's like if it's just Pleasant for the good of the people it's idealist if it's like obviously a a headline Grabber show stoper if it's [ __ ] you know I want to control it's control and power and spear it's a primo and then if there's money involved it's capitalist yeah exactly and I like the fact that when you're reading those cards you're not sure what resources you're going to get but you know what the generally what it is now not all the time some of them it's like oh oh interesting that was supro okay and then there's some where you're reading it and it's like you're going to answer it and you're like no okay yeah I'll answer that with the way I agree and then it goes like way too far like the one about gender affirming yeah and I was like well and then it like went way into like like leaned heavily on one side I'm like oh okay NOP there's no Towing the line in this game it's one side or the other yes everybody
can and then it's like no nobody should ever can yeah I was like should children get it and then and I was like well probably not no no one can even if you're an adult and I'm like oh well okay well I got to answer one of them um but I think at least maybe not in this rule book I think in one of them they recommended hey don't answer those off your own political views yeah like they kind of was like pick like roleplay it pick a pick a side or just play it to game it game the game oh I want the abilities I'm going to answer those you're a politician it's like I need these numbers so I'm going to go this way and it is kind of cool that the game is naturally thematic that way and a game of just these gen a good way to put it yeah naturally thematic yeah uh good use of gameplay right for a game that's so clean and simple there's a lot of depth to it and it it really focuses around like this is the Crux of the game um where I mean hell like like we had this many left to go over uh so yeah at some point these are going to be if you play this game a lot you're going to see these and you're going to know oh that one is going to get me if I answer no on this one it's going to get me you know the capitalist and these resources but then it kind of becomes more less about the fun party aspect and more about the area control and I think
weirdly enough they both go hand inand uh even in today's day and age I I still think this game can now be less of a oh oh you and your abortion rights or whatever it is it's it's less about that but more about hopefully if someone at the table doesn't know something you can actually educate them like whenever we were playing I I was like what what's I don't what's Jerry mandering it's like oh that's whenever they draw the it's like oh cool now I know and there needs to more of that in politics more education not not [ __ ] on someone for what they believe it's like well if they don't know help educate them or if they want to change their alignment don't be like well [ __ ] you you didn't agree with me at the beginning it's like well Embrace that that they're trying to learn more MH and that's a win for your side um it's just it's such an intriguing game nothing else is like it on the market and the fact that it's from from like an Indian developer an Indian designer and Publishing Company M I think they hit the nail on the head especially for like the like all the US cards now one thing about these cards because I know this is the the whole thing there are two types of cards there are the uh mature content and the trigger warning mhm now some of them um because we're all adults here Devon is uh how old are you now 40
yeah I'm in my 50 oh so you're the guy yeah um some of them which is also kind of neat you can if you're I wouldn't say play this with kids but you could take out these double exclamation points um or or the single exclamation points to kind of ease like your your child into the real world um here we go I'm going to read two examples of both of those so there's parental advisory which is a single one should there be consequences for adult I mean you you were able to curate this game um kind of based off the age if you want to play with your kids yeah um well Dad what's adultery well it's what your [ __ ] mom is doing um and then yes and then no or the two where it's uh the two which is trigger warning uh should the military use surgical drone strikes yes bomb the [ __ ] out of them or no drone strikes have killed far too many Innocents it's cold blooded murderer now between the two it's kind of interesting which one would you say is the worst one like to read and play I feel like the adultery would be a little bit more trigger happy trigger warning uh well I mean like you said the one explation point is Parental Advisory maybe it was more themed towards sex probably and then the double to the double exclamation points more is someone probably going to freak out at the table some some idealist at your
table going to freak out maybe that's probably what they they probably just have them clearly divided versus like once's a higher level version right yeah so I so you could go through the entire deck and be like okay I don't really know these people all that well I want to play a game I don't really want to start arguing with people I'll take out these trigger warning ones maybe keep the parental advisory or uh oh you brought your kid they're 15 let's take out these parental advisory ones no I want him to know all right uh I don't want to play with you anymore but I will say this could just be because we're from the us and we're just desensitized all these the I I went through the India ones like literally the first it it was wild like what was it it was so a single one is do you support death penalties okay that's but it's the the flavor text is geared towards the India India ones cuz well not really that one feels like a little bit more generic but two was should marle rape remain legal remain legal that's I [ __ ] about India but I'm like oh [ __ ] yeah that's it's insane of how they do not shy away from any any of they're Indian developers they probably like they want to bring attention to current Indian issues so yeah no and I completely appreciate that cuz this game I don't think would work as well if it was like baby's first politics yeah where's our marital rape Clause that's some guy I'm going to start a party like oh okay I'm going to take my drink I'm going to go over here cuz you know what I'm just going to
scoop I don't want to play anymore um it's it's so it's just so fascinating and even in those scenarios that could be turned educational if you're coming in with an open mind and that's the key open mind where it's like if you play the India campaign it's like is that really real is Merill you know rape a thing and then someone could inform you yes it was a very real like you could play this with people of different cultures if you're playing with someone who's from India they could inform you and be like no that's a very real thing it's a constant running ramp it it's like oh dear God what can we do about it well drone strike drone strike surgical drone strike yeah yeah which is so that's when you combine the campaign cards um which I guess you could there's really no reason why you couldn't combine the campaigns I me you'd be swinging all over the place yeah it be I mean but it then kind of be more of a world State uh just for funsies let's see a two um for the future of humanity do you support serving refugees with cheap nutrient deficient food in order to save costs mhm uh and then there's a one let's see so kble feed the refugees kble or like some dirt yeah some dirt with water cat food uh cat food uh and again there's not that many in the entire deck it's not like uh you're just constantly uh triggering people man
apparently there's not a single one in the future of humanity which parental advisory not no parental advisories probably because you know probably because there is no future of humanity I'm actually amazed I thought there would be probably more for the more the current you know yeah current events yeah there was like two two I guess because the future of humanity is literally just all speculation exactly um but they do have more they have so they have the UK brexit they have the US uh future of humanity and the India one and then uh the fall of Rome which would be cool and I think there's a few more that are extra somewhere but yeah and then what's also neat which we didn't touch on but I've played with these before you can actually start gearing yourself towards Elites based off of your supro to give you an extra special power oh so like with you right now you would be a an activist so you'd be the activist which gives you you can actually the right to information the tides of change wait for none we will take what is ours you can Peak at any conspiracy cards held by an opponent okay and you can have multiples of these I would be right now the gorilla um nothing says Revolution like violence bathed in the ideals of Liberty once per turn move up to four of your voters into adjacent zones and they're like based off of oh sorry actually you would not be the activist because you can't have any capitalists oh no capitalist yep uh and it is also kind of
intriguing how in both of in this game you had no supro not even one and I had no capitalist which both of our political standings uh you're definitely Supremo everything your entire being anyone whose favorite movie is the intern you disine camps yep you're dead no you're hung up and uh and I'm all about money so anything can do to just you know push the little guy down to boost my profit that's what I'm about anyway I think this game still holds a a place in in someone's collection there's nothing else like it uh even games like hegemony are way more serious and a lot more I think I mean that's geared more towards the economic side of side of of things with a little bit of sociopolitical in it um nothing in hemony would rather be a debate oh this is a hard number yeah you would never vote for You' never put minimum wage down and discuss it yeah I mean you can make jokes during the game that because it's how appropriate because you know I'm the capitalist and I can't make any money what the [ __ ] you guys Tak how dare you [ __ ] me with these government reforms I can't be a billionaire if I'm paying you more than minimum wage exactly uh but in this game a card will say should we raise minimum wage to fast food workers and you get to say yes or no to that and you can be like and you can have a hopefully casual discussion about uh why no fast food
workers are not people but I'm going to go and demand their services while I'm subsequently uh degrading them that's that's who I am uh yeah this game is great not at two it is and I would even say it sucks cuz I I really like these cards um but I re worked uh yeah it supro or something it needed it needed to be more rebalanced in there needed to be specific two-player conspiracy and headlines specific uh IV log powers for two players not just smaller zones and restrictions on them and unfortunately it's not even a it's serviceable at two you can play this at two yes should you no literally find two other people which now is is hard to do uh de do you have anything else oh man on shaen um it's uh hey it's it's a great you know area control with a lovely little party twist that's a conversation starter um solid quality ingredients Farm to Table uh table to mouth boots on the ground boots on the ground bootstraps pulling them up yeah uh get this game it's good stuff um on scale of 1 to 10 what would you give shaen um well I will give a two- player three um and then my theoretical four player
um I'll give it a solid seven solid seven a good game it's a good game yeah two players um I would agree I would say three don't play the it's not like the only the only way I would ever say play it at two is if if you you have the house roll this a little bit Yeah you got maybe I mean okay if you take everything down to one snatching one resource the capitalist you only trade one for one but you get whatever resource you're looking for um showstopper kind of stays the same yeah then ID list two discounts to one discount it's almost like the conflict C the portion needs to be modified um because the show stoer an idealist except maybe converting one voter but you'd have to modify the resources for that too convert one for one but that doesn't really do you a whole lot of good yeah um the other problem with these cards is if you get the incorrect kind of if you make a misplay then you can actually lock yourself out of it for ending the game like it's like oh okay like for example the Grassroots movement you need at least one non-majority voter in every Zone well if we have if we fill up every Zone it's like oh wait we can't do that mhm okay I guess we'll just stalemate and call it short of converting or doing something just tug of war back and forth and then it's like okay this is just being drawn out way too long and but you could also kind of sit here and be like
and okay seven n 8 six even if you got that one I'd still win okay let's just call it right um but yeah uh two player I'm giving a three uh multiplayer which uh I have played is man I'm gonna say for gameplay purposes an
eight I'm going to finalize on a nine though because I'm going to give it that extra point because no other game one tackles topics like this two I mean you can clearly tell where the designers are leaning where they stand because there's a lot of in jokes more about certain politicians than older politicians like there's no no reference to bush in here or someone that's all clearly uh our current president but um but the fact that it's very tongue and cheek that you can have educational topics and legitimate discussions is I think a feed in and of itself honestly no it's good stuff uh so yeah this one is is certainly a unique one so that's it everyone that's our thoughts on shaen let us see you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share And subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you