Port Royal Card game review
Transcript
this is a europhile review of port royal by alexander fiesta i think that's how you pronounce it i have no idea actually let's call them alexander feaster um so i don't know anything about this designer apart from i know we've got one other game by him which is uh the minds of zavindor another thing about these and it's the thing that first attracted me to port royal is that they're both illustrated by clemens franz so clemens franz is the guy who most famously illustrated agricola but then the rest of that series of games so caverna and the harv or lebora and at the gates of liang now i love cleveland's friend's artwork it always makes me look at a game uh so so it always draws my attention to it and with port royal the other thing that really was the decider in me picking this up is that it features mechanics from what is now called incan gold in its most recent editions although it used to be diamond um by alan moon and bruno fiduti so that's the the classic card game that push your luck game where you turn over cards and you take treasure but but there's going to be traps there so how long can i keep turning over those cards before the traps get me and i lose everything well the same sort of thing happens in port royal we turn over cards we reveal ships but too many uh of those things will lead to you know disaster lead to the end of your turn and losing everything that you've gained in that turn so it's got elements
of diamond and ink and gold but it's also got engine building and euro type mechanics in there as well this is purely a card game there's nothing else in this box and it's a pretty decent sized box on a decent number of cards for 10 pounds which is how much it costs it's really cheap game that's another major selling point for it cheap game um considering the size of it and and also the fantastic artwork on it um so let's have a look at how it plays and then i'll let you know what i think of it so this is the box for port royale it says on here it's for two to five players 20 to 50 minutes which seems realistic inside we've got this sheet of rules which are a fold-out sheet there's some bad english translation on there but basically they're very easy to follow and they're nice clear pictures and all that sort of thing um so that's fine inside the box there's just two sections for cards but the cards are all part of the same deck apart from this one which gets mixed in if you play with five players hence the five hats on the back otherwise you don't use this card so basically you've just got one large deck of cards and and so that's what's going to form the bulk of the game now these cards are going to come from this deck and form a tableau in front of you you're going to lay out cards in front of you throughout the game the other thing about these cards like a lot of modern card games is that they're dual use so you can either use them as coins so you can have the coins which are on the back of the card or they can be used
for their their face sort of uh purpose whatever's on the face of the cards you start the game with three of these cards in front of you representing coins it doesn't matter what's on the back of them you don't look at the back of them it doesn't matter because they're only coins um and you're only ever going to use them as such so i would have three coins in front of me initially as would every other player if it was my turn what i get to do is form the harbour by turning over the top card of the deck i can then choose whether i want to use this card or not in this instance it would be a case of buying this card or not to gain the benefits that it gives me let's have a little look at what some of the cards that you might get in the game are so the first type of card are the ships when a ship comes into the harbor it brings these coins with it so if i decided that i wanted to use this i would take three coins off the top of the deck and i would add them to my own personal supply of coins however i don't have to use it i can keep on turning over more cards from the deck if i like so that's where the push your luck side comes in so i could turn over another one okay now you see this is a disaster because we've now got two red ships if two of the same color come out at any point then your turn is over these are discarded into the discard pile and the whole thing is void but if that hadn't come out then i could
keep going so now i've drawn a yellow one this one's only only going to give me two i can only take one of these cards so maybe i'd keep going okay now i have a black one so i've got three different colors here and i can keep going and keep pushing my luck so now i've got a green one now what happens is because i've got four different colors out here i'm now allowed to select two of them to use so i could for example select these two in which case i would take seven coins from the deck four plus three and put them into my personal supply now on your turn as well as me taking something every other player then gets a turn to take something from this selection as well but if they do so they have to pay me a coin um for the privilege of doing it so everybody's involved on each individual turn if i kept on turning over okay now i've got a blue so now i've got five different colored ships no duplicates that allows me to take three cards if i want to which is the best possible situation it's hard to get to that point though because there's half this deck is made up of ships so um they're constantly coming out and it's very easy to get a pair so that push your luck thing it's there but it doesn't come into play massively often here's another black one for example so if i pulled that one out now my turn would be over i'd lose all of these and i would gain nothing okay let's keep looking so here we have a sailor this guy has some swords now the benefit of the swords is if you have a lot of these swords in front of you
so if i had these three swords for example here then i pulled out a ship like like this one and let's say that this was a duplicate i'd already got a blue down there then i could say right i'm going to use my swords to repel the ship because i've got three swords and this ship only has a strength of two and i could also repel this one if this one had just come out but i wouldn't be able to repel this one for example because it's got six and i wouldn't be able to repel this one because this skull means it is not possible to repel it so one tactic in the game is to build up this these swords in front of you in order that you can repel ships push it up can take more cards each turn in taking these uh sailors or the pirates i pay five coins in order to do so and i'm going to gain two victory points which are going to sit in front of me in my tableau so that's what the sailors and pirates do this type of card is a tax so when this comes out it says anyone who's got 12 or more coins will lose half of their money and the person who has the most swords will gain one money so tax comes out and it applies to everybody from time to time throughout the deck the next type is expeditions so expeditions are these bright orange cards these are placed to one side for everybody to aim for they're like little missions so the aim here is to try and get two of these crosses if you do so you'll gain four victory
points and two money so we put this to one side and we keep drawing from here this is another expedition this time he wants two of these settlers huts four victory points two coins again so again that would be set aside as another mission that all players could aim towards now here's how you start to complete these missions if this guy turned up the jack of all trades he offers me either an anchor or a cross or a settler's hut so i could use him as one of the resources necessary to claim one of these two missions so i'd put him in front of me and then i could discard him later in the game in order to claim these missions it most of the the resources come as single ones like for this priest we've got the cross and we've got the settlers hut on the settler here and we've got this anchor on this captain so these would all be resources used for completing these expeditions they all cost varying amounts of money and the the jack of all trades is six coins where the others are four um so you'd be spending coins from in front of you if you did that okay then all right there's another ship so we've seen some ships these green ships coming out now yellow we've got a run of ships there set there so you know each turn i'd be turning over one or more likely multiple cards and then people would be getting a choice this is what i'm looking for so these are the characters so the characters will all do various different special abilities and offer them to you if you put them in front of you
this trader for example means that when you take a blue ship and take the money from it you gain one extra money and this one gives you a resource there's another ship i told you half of it's half of its ships and now i'm looking for these characters right let's see what i've got over here so this one for example the man was l she makes every character um one coin cheaper um for you they also will give you victory points as well um trying to find interesting cards in this deck but all i'm getting is ships and resources this one is a green ship gives you one extra coin here's a red that gives you one extra coin here's the discount one again this one means that if the card row gets to five so if people have turned over five cards there's five cards in the harbor and it comes around to your turn to take something from that remember that everybody can take a card on your turn you'll gain two coins if it's got that length and there's various other cards that do different things along the same sort of lines remember that you can also take this this is quite an interesting one the jester so the jester means that if a player has forfeited because he's turned over two of the same matching ships then uh the player with the jester gets to take one coin if somebody else is forfeited
or if it comes to his turn to take a card from the display and on someone else's turn it's his opportunity to take a card and there's no cards left there he gains one coin so jester's quite a nice card but there's various different little abilities like that so you can build up a slight sort of strategy a little bit of an engine and decide how you're going to rack up those victory points which are going to be the things that will win you the game the game ends when someone's got 12 victory points then you look at who's who has the most victory points at the end of that round and that person is the winner although there is also a variant game end listed in the rule book which is very similar 12 victory points but someone must have completed an expedition in order to win and that's how the game works um so simple push your luck stuff and a little bit of engine building and resource management and that sort of thing but it's basically just gather the victory points using these dual use cards as coins or as whatever's on their face poor royal is a decent game it works basically it works the push your luck side of it is not massively present because it's it's quite hard to even get to the four ships of different colors um without without you know turning over a second one of the same color and forfeiting your turn and so players don't tend to push their luck particularly in the games that i've played but you could play a strategy where you try and build up those swords in order to repel ships um but the push of that stuff is is is
there it is present the artwork's great it all looks really nice basically it feels like a medium sort of uh fairly short but a medium weight uh euro game of victory point grabbing and um you know using resources but but also with a bit of push your luck and it's a bit odd in that in that it comes in this little box it feels it's it's a bit heavier than you would expect for a little game like this and frankly if i wanted to play something in this weight um then i would probably play something like um something like san juan instead san juan also has that dual use of cards um but but but it does it in a a more interesting way really and building up that tableau in front of you but also being able to spend cards in order to do different things um so the problem really with port royal is that it falls between two stalls um i mean if i want to play a light card game a small light card game i'm probably gonna go for something you know if i'm not going for the super light trick taking six nymph type things and i might go for something like um lost cities uh but but this is a bit heavier there's a bit more to it longer than lost cities uh and yet it doesn't feel as substantial as san juan it's somewhere in this awkward middle territory um and i think if i wanted to play a game in that sort of area then then i'm not sure port royal
would be the thing that i would leap for i think that's what i'm trying to say i would i would either go for lost cities or something in that sort of ilk or all the trick taking games or i would go for something a bit meatier like san juan but this port right it's a bit odd stuck there in the middle and and if i wanted to push a luck thing i would go for diamond or or incan gold um so there's something just not quite satisfying me with this game um that's that said it it works perfectly fine it's a decent well-designed game um i found the ending a little anticlimactic you know just suddenly one player says yeah i've got 12 now and everyone else says oh okay there's not much that you could have done to stop them or anything like that you play to the end of the round or maybe they're the last player in the round anyway so it just ends instantly the fact that they've added in this weird little variant rule where you also have to have an expedition which is practically the same as the main rule because people are likely to have expeditions anyway it doesn't really add anything to the game but it just gives me this little hint that maybe the designer was unsure about the ending and thought well i'm not quite sure which is the best way to go with this so they stuck both endings in and frankly both are a little bit anticlimactic it's something about being able to see all the victory points building up there's so few victory points is you know 12 is not a big target to get to that you can see how everyone's doing and you know okay he's got this much he's got this much i'm unlikely to catch up before it happens and and so you know there's not an exciting finish
that's that's what i'm saying really so port royal main things going for it beautiful artwork decent weight game in a small box uh cheap 10 pounds brilliant really good cheap uh game uh it's portable um there's there's nothing wrong with it basically there's nothing wrong with it but i can't get excited about it so that is port royal uh by pegasus spiel and alexander i'm calling him alexander alcorn feaster feaster alexander there you go port royal