Council of 4 Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to John kids games today I'll be reviewing it counselor for now in this game each player is trying to build out a vast trade empire and they're gonna do that too via hand management - in order to influence a variety of guilds throughout the land so that they can get permits in order to influence the various cities now as you expand out and connect your cities together your overall power is going to grow so that by the end of the game hopefully you will be the most powerful merchant guild and you'll win it now first I'm gonna explain how the game plays and then I'm gonna jump in a my review but before we go into that I would like to briefly ask that if you enjoyed this video that you consider clicking the like button down below as well as the subscribe button also if you'd like to directly support the channel please check out John gets games.com slash support to see a variety of ways that you could do that alright let's go ahead and see how the game plays out here we have the game fully setup for three players now the first thing that I like to point out are these four different councils of four now if they are made up by these miniature tokens right here and you we randomly put them out into these different spots and as you can see there's quite a few of them that are not currently in the game now the next thing that I'd like to point out are these little bonus tokens now these are randomized of every single game and you put one of them down on every one of the cities except for this city J right here which as you can see is connected to four other cities and that's kind of its bonus it's the most connected one on the board let's now take a look at one of the player boards in order to see how a player's turn works now you'll see over here on the left hand side there are four different options and this icon right here means a main action on the right-hand side we have four other options and this little envelope means a quick action now on
each player's turn they're gonna be able to take one main action and one quick action if they like and they can do them in either order but they cannot double up on either of them now let's go ahead and talk about how some of these work this top main action right here is pretty simple you can see a little councilman with a green arrow that's pushing out to one with a pink arrow and then you get for money now what this means is it you can go ahead and take a councilman who is not on the board right now and there's push them in on the left hand side and scooch out to the other one so this is one of the big ways you can modify these different councils now of course as a benefit of this we actually gain for money and that's kept it over here on this track so in this case we would go from 10 up to 14 with that action at this point let's go ahead and talk about the next three main actions before we talk about these quick one's over here now this second one right here is one of the more important ones in the game because this is where our hand of cards comes in now we start the game with six of these in our hand and there are six different colors but there are also these wild cards that you could potentially draw into your hand now the way this action works is you're gonna spend at cards and/or money in order to grab permits and you're gonna do set collection that based off of the different councils on the board so that means if we want to grab a permanent from this green council right here it's the green middle part of the board that we would have to discard a yellow card a purple card a brown card and a gray card and this is of course one of the reasons why we might do this action up here to modify the council's so in this case we do have a yellow a brown a grey and let's see here we have a purple as well so that means we paid a full price and if we look down on the bottom part of our board that means we can just spend those four cards and no money if we only
had it three of the matching cards then that would be fine we just discard all three of them but we'd have to pay for money likewise over here if we only had two matching cards we could pay seven bucks and finally if we only had one card that matched we could go ahead and spend ten money so it is important to try and have the cards in your hand that match with these but there are ways to get around that by spending lots of money the last thing that I'd like to mention is this wild right here this is obviously a very powerful effect but if you ever use a wild in order to grab one of these permits you do have to pay one money as a penalty for using its really strong ability so let's come back to our example and we can see that we've discarded all of these cards of match and that means we're now going to grab one of these two permits from this section that lines up with this council when we come up here to the top of the board we can see that there's always going to be two permits in each one of the regions now the bottom part of the permanent is a bonus that you get immediately for grabbing it so in this case if we took at this permanent right here we could immediately grab on to new cards randomly off the top of the deck in this case over here we can instead grab this and we gain one more servant from the supply and I haven't talked about them just yet but they're pretty good and then we would also get a nobility track bump now for the case of example let's go ahead and say that we took this one and it's also worth noting that these tiles have these letters along the top some of them have three letters available to themselves but if we look deep into the stack we can see that some have two and some also have one now in general it seems like if there are more letters than the effect of the bottom part is going to be less impactful but either way let's go ahead and say that we took this one as soon as that happens we have to immediately refill this and then we get to take these bonuses as I just
mentioned this first one is easy it just gains us a servant into our area and the second one involves the nobility track now the way this works is we're gonna go ahead and take our token and we're gonna bump it once up on the track for each one of these symbols that we get so in this case we bumped up right there and then whenever we put our token onto a slot that has a bonus we immediately take it so in this case we would get two money and two victory points which we can just track over here on the board now when we zoom out we can see that there are quite a few slots that don't give you a bonus over here on the nobility track but many of them do they might allow you to reactivate sidney's that you've already influenced and I'll talk about that soon they might give you extra main actions and they also might just give you victory points and cards the last thing that happens with this action is we bring the permit into our area and now we leave it face up so that we can activate it on a later turn or four main action this leads us right into this third option and all this means is activate an apartment that you have this means you're going to go ahead and flip the permit over and then you're going to take one of your merchants and put it down into a city that matches one of the letters let's once again zoom out over here we can see that the F city is up here the AI city is right here and J is down right there now in this case maybe I'd say that we would go into the F city so in this case we'd take our merchants and we put it right here into that slot next up this apartment is going to get flipped over to show that we only get to use it once next up we can now activate the bonus of the city as well as the bonus on any other city that currently has one of our merchants in it and is connected back to the one that we just put the merchants down into now in this case we just have the one city so we'd get one gold and one servant but if for instance we had a
merchant right here as well as right here then we would in addition to getting a money and a servant we would grab another one of these nobility buffs but in this case we can see that this a city is not actually connected over here just yet so we would not get that bonus the last thing that I like to say about cities involves what happens when our opponents get there first now if we go ahead and use a permanent in the future in order to put one of our merchants down into the sea city we're gonna have to spend one servant for every opposing merchants that's currently in the city so this is one of the reasons why you do want to have these servants available and it's also worth noting that every city has four slots in it and you're never allowed to put to merchants of the same color into that city so it can be full up in a four-player game but if it was just a two-player game then there'd only ever be two in each one okay let's now talk about the fourth and final main action option now if you look at the iconography on here you can see it's pretty similar to the second action and third action combined what this allows us to do is take one of our merchants and put it down into the city where the Queen is now we're gonna get to spend cards from our hand as well as money with the same ratio as before and then you can spend it to money in order to move the Queen around and wherever the Queen lands we can then take a merchant and put it down onto that spot when it comes to paying cards for this action we're actually gonna look over here on this council on the far left now this is on the separate board and is associated with the queen figure over here so in this case we could spend this green card as well as this wild and that matches the green and then one of the other ones that means we could spend 7 extra money to make up for the 2 councilmen that we didn't satisfy and then of course won
more money on top of that because we use this wild so we'd spend 8 money right there and that would then allow us to put this merchant right down into the city with a queen of course like I mentioned before we could spend it to more money as many times as we wanted to to move the Queen around to a better city that's located for us as soon as you put the merchants down into that City you're gonna activate that city as well as every other one that's connected just like we talked about when we activated the permits it's now time for us to talk about these four quick action options now they're pretty self-explanatory if we look up here to the top we can spend three money in order to grab another one of these servants which is nice if we find ourselves in a bind the second one allows us to spend one of our servants in order to ditch both permits for more of the regions and draw two more this third one allows us to spend one of our servants to push a new councillor into one of the cities we of course don't get the gold benefit for this but we could do this quick action before our main action which might allow us to modify things so that the cards in our hand to make a lot more sense for trying to cash it out and then this fourth one is potentially the most important and this allows you to spend at 3 of your servants in order to take a second main action so by spending those three servants you can activate two main actions in a turn all right at this point you now understand all of the different options that you can take on your turn and I just realized I forgot to mention that at the start of every one of your turns you can draw one card into your hand I should have mentioned that before but either way you now understand it and once you have taken on one main action and potentially one quick action your turn will be over and play will go clockwise to the next player you're gonna keep playing the game going around and around a table until any one player has put all ten of their merchants down onto the board at that
point that player is gonna get three bonus feature points and then every one of the opponents is gonna get one extra turn once that happens people can then calculate their final scores but let's hold off on explaining that just for a moment that's because I'd like to describe how these reward tiles work first now you'll notice that there's a yellow purple orange and blue one up here and when we look out to the cities there are yellow purple orange and blue cities now there are only two blue cities and there are five of the yellow cities and if we look a little bit closer at these rewards we can see that the victory points on them is going to vary now you're going to get to grab any of these as soon as you have one of your merchants in every one of the applicable cities so again that there are two blue cities so if you have a merchant in both of them you can grab it this one right here it's a lot harder to get this 20-point yellow one but it's also a lot more points now the other thing you get whenever you grab at any one of these reward tiles is you also grab at the top a Queen's reward tile now you'll notice this first one is 25 points the second one is 18 and then it goes down to 12 etc all the way down to 3 points right there and this is essentially a way to force players to try and achieve these rewards quicker than their opponents well there are three more of these rewards and they're associated with the three regions out on the board you can see over here we have this coastal region one and this is going to give you five points if you are the first person to get one of your merchants into all five of the cities within that given region when you take these you of course grab one of these as well as long as there's one available okay now let's go ahead and talk about final scoring so of course you're gonna have a certain number of points based off of all the things you did throughout the game and then the person who is
farthest along on this nobility track is gonna get five bonus points the second-place person is gonna grab at two points and then the last bonus is gonna go to the person who collected the most of these permit tiles throughout the game and that will be three extra points once you add all of that stuff up together you're gonna see who has the most points and that person's gonna be the winner let's now begin the review for councillor for by starting with a few positive points and for the first of these I'd like to discuss at the networking escalation mechanism now what I'm talking about here is where when you put it merge it down into a city and if it's adjacent to another city that you've already put a merchant into you need to activate both of those cities and potentially even more based off of the network of connected cities that you have now this is a very satisfying thing because as you were playing the game it means that once you get into the like middle and later parts of the game you can get a lot of stuff for just putting a single margin down in the beginning of parts of the game it feels a little bit less impactful because you maybe put it down and just get to server door 2 or maybe a money here or there or maybe some cards but either way as you build out this network you definitely feel more powerful as you're playing through the game and that's a satisfying thing although it is worth mentioning that when you get to the very tail end of the game like when you're putting your like 8th 9th and 10th version out they can feel a little bit of a chore as you're just reactivating everything over and over again sometimes even within the same turn you'll do it twice or maybe even three times if you're doing very good and that's just a lot of busy work just moving the victory points and the money around but overall it seemed to work out pretty well and like I said before I just enjoyed the big potent turns that really came out of it at the
end of the game next up we have positive number 2 and for this one I want to talk specifically about the way that this game forces you to try and grab at bonuses wherever you can so what I'm talking about here is you're not just getting stuff for the city activations you're also getting bonuses when you grab those permits and you'll get on different bonuses when you go up that nobility track and when you add all these things together you are just trying to piece together a plan to continue getting these merchants out on the board often times you will find yourself in a position where maybe you're eyeballing a permit because you have the cards in your hand they're gonna work for grabbing that permit but more importantly the bonus of on that permit is really good for your current situation you just are really a servant starved and maybe that permit is gonna give you three servants or you need a lot of money and that gives you a bunch of money like whatever you need you could potentially grab from a variety of different places and I've enjoyed trying to piece all those things together to make it a cohesive strategy as I'm playing the game for my third and final positive point I'd like to talk about balancing your resources now there are three main resources in the game you have cards in your hand as well as money the money track and then servants that you can use to do quick actions as well as pay for the ability to put your merchants down into cities where your opponents already are now the first game of this that I played I remember feeling very card starved like I just ran out of cards in my hand and I just felt like that really stymied everything that I tried to do so in my second game I said okay you know what I'm just gonna go crazy on getting cards I'm gonna go for all the cities they give cards I'm gonna go for the permits and gift cards and I ended that game with like 15 cards in my hand I couldn't spend the cards fast
enough but instead now I was servant starved and so what I found after playing this game several times is it really feels like a three-way teeter totter and you were constantly trying to find a balance right in the middle and oftentimes it seems like the person who wins is the person who has not that much left in the tank if that makes sense you know maybe they just have just enough cards and just enough money and just enough servants to try and squeeze as many points as they can and oftentimes I've seen the game end where somebody as just like maybe peeked out had 20 money and they just can't spend it fast enough or maybe they're just buried in servants and they can't spend them quickly enough because they over prioritize one of these versus another now I have also seen a game end with a sizeable win and somebody does have a bunch of cards in their hand so you don't have to run out of everything at the very end but I do like the balance that the game really forces on you it's not just about getting a lot of one of these specific resources you really have to go after all of them alright it's now time to talk about a few neutral points and for the first of these I'd like to talk about the important initial analysis that comes into this game now what I'm talking about here is the fact that you are going to be randomizing all of the city tokens throughout the map at the beginning of every single game and some of those bonuses are just strictly way better than other ones and that means that when you sit down to play this game you really need to analyze the situation and you need to look around and try to find the clumping of the really good tokens and also try to find the kind of desert areas where that not-so-good tokens are all next to each other and then you're gonna want to try and focus on getting permits that you can perverts down into the really good
areas in particular you're gonna probably try to get some specific combos like a couple cities that maybe give you card draw as well as well of course servants and money those are the three main things but it is good to try and synergize all of these together and have founded that in at least one of the games that I played where I didn't really think about it that much I just kind of looked at my starting hand at cards and I'd started taking permits and building out into the board and I realized you know about a third the way through the game that I was probably just gonna lose because I had not done that analysis before my first turn and the way or the place I started was just not the place to start and I was already way behind my opponents so that's why this is a neutral point it's just something you need to go into the game understanding that one of the most important things you do in the entire play comes in at the very start of the game wouldn't just look out to see how those tokens laid out next up we have neutral number two and for this one I'd like to talk about card draw luck now you have this big a deck of it surprisingly small cards in the game and you are gonna be spending these cards as well as money in order to get the permits that you need in order to put your merchants out on the board now I just mentioned in the first neutral point that it's very important for you to analyze the board and try to see where you want to put down your merchants but at the same time you might start the game and look out and realize that this area is really good for you but you have no cards that work for that instead your cards kind of work for this area over here but maybe that's not as good of a network setup as this first one and what that means is you're probably gonna have to end up going over there maybe trying to work your way back into the area that you really liked and you're gonna be able to do that by modifying the council's through various
actions and then also you're gonna continue to draw cards through a variety of different ways so odds are good at some point you're gonna be able to find yourself getting into those good spots but it does mean that it's possible that one player draws a hand whose cards just match a lot better with that really awesome spot on the board versus the other players and it does feel like that player is gonna be at a advantage compared to everybody else in the game now I haven't necessarily felt like you're just gonna win or lose the game based off of your initial card draw and there is so much card drawn in the game that I do think that overall this is gonna probably balance itself out and then of course you can get around to bad luck with your cards by just spending a bunch of money so there's definitely a reason to try and get a decent money engine going because then you just need one or two cards in order to make it happen you spend a bunch of money but maybe you've built out to a network that's gonna be able to give you money back in so I think there are ways to get around the card draw luck in the game but it is something that is going to have some sort of influence on the play now let's talk about my third neutral point and for this I'd like to discuss what I've been calling the blue city gambit so what I mean here is out there on the board there are two different blue cities and they are in different corners of the board and when you get a merchant down into both of those if you're the first person to do that you're gonna get to the blue token and that is five picture points now the thing that's happened that I've noticed is that in every single game that I played this is the first of the bonus tokens that gets grabbed and that means that when you take that five point bonus token you also take the top of red token which is 25 points so that means that the first person to get a merchant into the blue City and to either both of the blue cities that is is gonna get 30
victory points which is a sizable amount when you look at the ending scores now this is a neutral point and not a negative because it does influence the players to try and jockey back and forth for that and then of course it is a less attractive thing to do to put a merchant over in this corner and an emergent way down there because obviously they're not going to be connecting at any point soon when you do that especially when you try and do this thing in the earlier stages of the game and I have not seen this necessarily win the game for players I've seen people do this and lose and I have seen people do this and win I do think it's a strong play and it may be does till the balance a little bit more towards you winning it but it's also something that is pretty obvious to most of the people around the table so it's something that everybody's constantly paying attention to in the early stages of the game to see where each person is at and potentially going after this and then of course at a certain point it becomes obvious that maybe you're not in contention and then it's just maybe two players jockeying back and forth for it so yeah I think overall it's it's a little bit strange I feel like maybe that stack of the red bonuses could be a little bit less victory points like having the first one be 25 does seem very high especially when you consider how easy it is to get into both of those blue cities but I haven't played the game enough times to necessarily say that I think it's a problem okay let's now move into the negative point section and here I'd like to talk about one specific thing and that is a inevitable winner syndrome that I've seen pop up in a few of the games now what I mean here is you will find yourself or you can't find yourself in a situation and be like 2/3 ish way through the game spot where you look across the table and realize that one player is probably gonna win
and there's really not much you can do about that now this comes into play for two different reasons at the first is that this is an engine building game so odds are good you look at that one player and you see that they just have a better network of bonuses that they're getting every single time they activate their network by putting new merchants out and if my network is not as good as theirs then they're already just kind of ahead of me like I'm gonna have a hard time getting into it because they're probably in the better clustering of tokens so if I try to get over there I'm gonna to spend a bunch of servants and I'm just already behind because they're already there and they've already been activating that really good Network now the other thing that comes into play here is the relatively low amount of player interaction in the game now you of course can to modify the counsels and that can completely disrupt other people's plans but this feels like a random thing as opposed to a targeted thing because you have no idea what cards are in your opponent's hands so you might look down to this camp's council and see that that person really needs to get a permit for this one specific spot and well you if you modify the council you might actually make it better for them because they might have the card that matches that now sure you could use a quick action in order to discard one of your servants to get rid of some of the permits and in that case maybe you get rid of the permit that they needed and when you deal a couple more out the permit that they need does not show up but they could also potentially do that back in order to shuffle those away and often times it seems like if you have a really solid network already you can maybe just move in a slightly different direction so yeah overall it seems like I haven't seen too many blowout victories more often than not it's just been one person
kind of solidifying a lead and everybody just not really being able to do anything about that for the last you know third quarter of the game alright it's now time to discuss the variability for council before and I feel like it's a little bit less than I expected going in now when you first open up the box you're gonna notice that this is a double-sided board and I have played both of the sides one side is much more connected than the other one but when I played the kind of more advanced side it didn't feel that much different than the first one I suppose the networks were a little bit more spindly and a little bit more intricate so that does add a little bit of variability there but it's not as impactful as I maybe would have expected a secondary board to be also you have the random layout of all of the city bonuses at the beginning of every game and this feels like the main punch for variability because you might have this area to be really important this game at this area be really important in that game but by and large the locations on the board don't super matter especially when you're playing with the basic board and I've also found that you know there's only three main currencies in the game and you just kind of mix these things up but every single time you're playing this game you really do feel like it's the same kind of setup you were doing before like there are no differing endgame conditions or anything like that it's a very focused game in that respect so I don't think this is necessarily a problem but it does mean that after playing the game a few times I found that when I'm playing it now it doesn't feel like it's bringing as much new stuff as I potentially would have expected it to when it comes to player account counsel of four supports two to
four players and I've only played it at three and four but I do think that the four player game is probably the best way to play it now the main difference between all these player counts has to do with the amount of opposing merchants that are gonna be out there on the board now I haven't played the two-player game yet but I do know that the rules say that when you start the game you're gonna be drawing some permits and putting down some dummy merchants into various cities to kind of gum up the works a little bit and that probably works out okay I wouldn't surprise me if it is more similar to the three player game than the four player game in that respect and the three player game those worked out pretty well but it does seem like and there will be parts of the board that are relatively empty until the very last stages of the game but when I played this at four players the board has really filled out quite well especially by like the just over halfway point and I think that it just feels like it works better in that setting although I don't think I would say no to playing it again at three and I would try it at two if I was in the right position so overall I don't think there's a bad player count here but for just felt best in the conclusion I played Council two four or five times at this point and I've enjoyed every one of those plays I think that the core of this game is a very streamlined and focused idea of trying to have you work through your hand management while also balancing all of these different resources to try and get to your ultimate goal of expanding out to have this wonderful escalating network of merchants that are going to give you more and more stuff and this is definitely a game that just showers you with resources and victory points and just stuff that you like and come through a variety of different ways you of course have the actual activation of
your city but then you're also gonna be trying to scramble together to get the permits that are not only going to open up the cities that you like but also give you the bonuses that you need in order to continue moving forward if you never draw cards in any way besides the one card to draw and return then you're definitely gonna stall out so you have to make sure that you're bouncing all of these different resources so that you have enough cards in your hand enough money out in your track and enough servants in order to continue to activate extra quick actions as well as pay penalties for going into cities where your opponent's already are now I feel like the satisfying nature of escalating and this network on the map is the kind of shining point of this game if that makes sense like it's almost like you're pressing a button and every time you press it the button gets bigger and more satisfying to press as I mentioned it can feel a little bit like busywork near the later stages of the game where you're potentially gonna be activating your entire network a couple times within a given turn but you know it's busy work as you're just getting a bunch of stuff which is also nice I guess one other thing I'd like to mention it has to do with the variability that I already discussed I did say that I've enjoyed every one of these plays but I do think that I enjoyed it my first couple plays more than my latter ones and a big part of that has to do with a feeling of discovery in those first couple games as I really tried to balance him everything out and try to work myself towards getting everything that I needed and in those later games it kind of felt like I was doing the stuff that I had already done like I wasn't really finding as much new and compelling depth type things that I was expecting to and I
think that it's very possible that I will be playing this one again in the future because it is a very streamlined gaming experience but I think I will be more likely playing this in the future because it makes sense for the specific crowd as opposed to me being excited to get more plays in it of it for myself so yeah I think overall I do recommend this game even if it doesn't quite have the staying power that I hoped it would as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including all of these producer level patreon backers if you two would like to directly support the channel please check out John gets Gamescom see a variety of ways with which you could do that also if you enjoyed this video please consider clicking the like button down below as well as a subscribe button thanks for watching