Luthier Review: Luxe Luthier
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel.
I'm Wendy Y.
And I'm Chris Ye.
Today we're taking a look at a fairly big game here in many different ways. A big game in it takes up a lot of table space.
A game that uh takes a while to play. Would you say it's heavy physically?
Not too bad. Actually, I have felt some pretty heavy games lately. Uh, this is Luier, the art of the instrument about the people who built instruments and fixed them for the classical music crowd. These folks were popular back in the day,
for the fancy aristocrats,
just like they're popular today.
Jonathan Yamaha, his name's everywhere.
Well, yeah, I was going to say I only know a few like the guy who made the violins and Stratus. Yeah. Um, but anyway, that's what this game is about. Let's take a look at how it plays and we'll be back.
Here is the main board and I'm going to be kind of giving a highlevel overview in this game. But the whole point of this game is to build instruments, repair instruments, and perform music so that you can become the leading chair in different parts of this orchestra. There are other ways to get points. There are achievements that you can try to get, but the whole goal is to get points, and much of it is about manipulating and building instruments to go into the orchestra. As the game goes by, you're going to be getting patronons to come. And these patronons each turn are going to give you bonuses. This guy gives you a wood cube. This guy gives you six coins. And you, that's great. They're helping you out. But if they get to the end, they're going to be annoyed because you haven't met their desires. Each of them wants a desire. Like here, uh, Chopen wants a stringed instrument and he wants either a keyboard or repair keyboard or a musical piece and then he'll give you five victory points and help increase your fame and you'll flip them over and he'll give you a permanent ability for the rest of the game. So these patrons are kind of what your game is being built around. The main part of the game is players going to be taking different workers that they have and placing them face down on different sections of the board. You can place it where somebody else goes. And in fact, if you want to, you can place a worker along with an apprentice, which will add to the value of that number. Everyone starts with the same numbers. And as the rounds of the game go, you'll be adding more workers, and you even have the
ability to get special workers. Once everyone has done that, each player will take a turn and pick a spot on the board. And then you'll take all the workers on that spot and put them on this board. You'll put them from highest to lowest. And if there's two the same number, then whoever went there first goes first. And each person can take the action of that section. Or if you don't want to take the action, you can always take two money. So what do the different sections do? Well, going up here to the salon will give you more patronons. Patronons are ways to get a lot of points. Also, when you take a patron, you're going to be able to put it on your board and get the bonus of the thing that you cover up. Now, as this spot and with all other spots, you'll notice there's ones, twos, and threes. At the beginning of the game, you're going to have a fame marker here on this track. And until you get to the twos or threes, you must pick only from the ones. And these cards aren't immediately refilled on a player's turn. So, if you want to take a card from here, you'll have to pay more money um to get these cards. So, you have to keep in mind, and that's the same at every spot. The next spot is perform. When you go to perform, you are going to roll some dice. You'll pick a performance. Roll dice for that performance. Here I got four. Add the value of the worker that you sent there.
So that's six. And it will give you money and possibly you can give your performance will make the orchestra. You also if you put a certain number here and I should mention that every spot you go to gives you alternate things like this one here. You can take three animal parts if you want to. And if you put a four or higher there, you'll also move up in this track, which will give you rerolls and black dice, which have better numbers on them. At the repair spot, you're going to be paying resources to repair an instrument. Rather than building a new one, you'll repair that instrument. And repairing instruments and singing songs is going to allow you to place tokens out on the main board. When I repair, I'll put one of these tokens out. when we perform music that will go out and whoever has the most tokens in a spot gets to be the first chair which again at the end of the games is a lot of victory points will give you bonuses during the game but nothing's as good as building an instrument to build an instrument you got to go to the guild and get the plans for building an instrument it's going to tell you how much it costs if I want for example to do the violin I'm going to need to pay these costs so you'll take it into your hand once you get the plans the next step is to build your instruments So, you'll be placing workers on your board at the beginning of a turn. You can put some instruments on the roughing bench and then you'll need to pay this first cost to move them over here to the finishing bench. Then you'll play the pay the finishing cost to get the points here and put that instrument in the orchestra. Also, instruments that you get might be worth it if I build this harps accord. Then this guy's going to be pretty happy. And
it's also going to be one of the three things that he needs. By the way, whenever you finish anything, whether it's a repair, a song, if it matches one of these guys' needs, it might make them your Patreon for good. And it will also reset their cube back to the beginning because as the, you know, if they get to the end, it's going to be bad. But you're at least showing them that you're making some progress. And as I said, putting out instruments here. First of all, that always beats tokens for the lead. Um, so you want to it's going to be hard to take those leading chairs from people, but it is a major way of getting points in this game. And that's the main parts of the game. There's other spots to put workers here where you can fight to get these rewards that do two different things. It will give you points, but also they'll remove these reward tokens from the board, giving me more spots to put resources or let me pick a royal patron or getting to roll this cool purple cube whenever I do a performance. And so that stuff will be added in when you go up here. You also have a chance to get more apprentices.
There's also a market down here where you can buy resources that you need. And you do that once a turn just by putting this on here. You can buy more apprentices and you can buy workers and cubes. Not not workers, but just cubes. And that's going to depend on the price which will change based on a market card that will be here showing you the three different cubes. I will mention here that the cubes which animal parts wood and iron here are the actual cubes themselves. So keep that in mind. There's also inspiration tokens which you can use to make things cheaper in the market or to make your performances better. There's also tracks you can move up which will give you special workers where you will get a card that will tell you what that worker does and if you use that worker in a specific spot, they'll give you some bonuses. So this is going to continue for six rounds. At the end of six rounds, you'll do final scoring.
Everyone has secret agenda cards or personal goal cards, which you know, if you get enough of those, you'll score some bonus points. And the number of first chairs you have will also score you points. Whoever has the most points is the winner.
Okay, there's a lot going on in this game. Uh, but there's two things I want to mention component-wise. One negative and one positive. My negative one is I don't love that they use black and white illustrations to show the cubes.
Oh, that the wood is the in between one with the grain.
Yeah.
But that means tan,
right? And the metal is the darker one. And then the one that has no color is white.
Yeah,
I get it. They're trying. I mean, I it might have made it not look as pretty on the board, but there were many times where I was like, I need that's stinking wood, you know? I thought it was a different piece.
Got it.
Or the one that's wood, I think, is wild. Their symbol for wild I didn't love either cuz it shows all three.
It's not all three colors. It's that
my positive is I think the rule book, which is a little tough. There's a lot going on in this game.
But this game does something that I'm not a huge fan of in a sense of it tells you to pick a family. And on the back of each family portrait,
there's special setup and a special thing that they do. And then you're picking some other cards. You're picking several things at the beginning of the game. However, this game comes with a rule book, an extra rule book that walks you through your first game.
It tells you how the whole game plays. It tells you here's things you start with.
That is amazing. I think every company when they tell you to pick something I'm like I don't want to pick
I don't know
you know here's what you do for your first game and I really like that
I agree did the very similar thing with distilled the exact same walkth through first game type thing and they said at any point just choose to stop following the book and kind of play your own game or for some people that really like learning by just setting up the game and walking through that booklet. I think that's an incredibly impressive thing to do for a game of this of this weight, right? There's a lot going on in it, but it's not it's not uh undicernable. But I think that's still a nice like, hey, here's a first- timer help.
Yeah. But I didn't I mean, when I was playing the first time, I was like, I don't know what cards to take, what personal goals to take. I don't know what, you know, what special ability is better than other ones. And I'm not convinced. They're 100% balanced. I feel like the one that gives you an extra worker feels a little stronger than other ones. like, hey, you get to start with an extra, you know, repair token. I'll take that extra worker 10 times.
Yeah,
that's interesting.
But after that, you're just going to go in different ways. And this game definitely has a very unique worker placement that I've not seen in any other game.
It's very interactive. It reminds me a little bit of Aladdin's Dragons, but not I mean, it obviously is not fully the same.
It's Yeah. Yeah. I agree. Right. the face down numbers that you put out, but the fact that you then go around the table in clockwise order and choose to resolve which spaces
or go to market usually giving everyone else like a sigh of relief of like, oh good, cuz I wasn't ready for the patron spot to activate yet, you know, and now I'll get to go to market before that happens and stuff.
Or the opposite where I'm like, are you kidding me? I needed these resources first. By the way, speaking of the market, I do like the fact that the market is basically a free action that you can do whenever that you can put your piece there and take the market action on a turn. But I know you meant you were like, I needed the cubes from this spot to get these.
Yeah. And it wasn't quite my turn yet.
Um I I I that piece that you passed around I thought was really dumb until I realized how important it was because you can't count how many discs people have left
because they may have had two places activated that had two discs of their own at each
or they took market actions or Yeah.
Yeah. There's a lot going on and so I find I find that to be a useful thing to pass around the board.
I will say the game is long.
It's It says 90 to 150 minutes. That's pretty accurate. And I you'd have to really know what you're doing to get 90 even with two players. I think
I think I think so. And there's that little tension too in two players because each I don't know why but like I it's almost more like if you're playing with three or four you're like all right what's going to happen is going to happen but with two players you're a little bit more kind of methodical I think just
you're really trying to read the other player for sure.
Yeah.
Yeah. I could see people having people that want their very like soloish style group games. You know what I mean? multiplayer solitire kind of people being frustrated with the interaction of this with the way that that game plays. Um, but I also like that you can read like you can tell if someone puts out a disc and they put in a couple extra of those like special worker helper people then you know that they're they're like really in this one. They want they're invested and so you can read a little bit of what's going on with the players but you at the end of the day you don't know if they're putting in a one or a five. like
it's a very interactive game from the area control in the middle of the board
to taking the cards other people want to putting the workers in the spots who goes first and what have you.
And because of that it actually again this comes down to my talking about game length. It lengthens the game because I'm sitting there going, "Okay, I'm going to put this token on the board. I could put it in any of the horn spaces."
Mhm.
Does anyone here have a trumpet? Does anyone even looking at a trumpet? you know, and you have to go around and look and you have to watch everybody else very carefully
because what they're doing could really mess you over.
This is I mean someone could go up and get an award before you
because let's say an award says have two instruments in the orchestra or one, two or three
and there's the one spot has already been taken. I'm like I want that two spot. You also have two.
So that matters who goes there first.
Okay.
But you might not even be going for it.
And so I'm you know there's that there's that constant what is everyone else doing? You cannot. It's not multiplayer solitary by any means.
No, no, no, no.
I agree. And I think that that is one of its biggest strengths because it it kind of looks like it. In fact, the look, the elegance of this game uh both mechanically, I think, as well as uh obviously just art-wise, Vincent Dut's artwork all over this thing looks amazing. Yeah,
it reminds me a little bit of the sprawl and the elegant look of Unconscious Mind, which I think I I don't think even the people who love that game would argue that that's not really multiplayer solitire. This one isn't. And I think that this is going to appeal to both people who like a lot of modern Eurogame tropes. There's there's a lot of mechanisms. There's a lot of mini games going on. The racing for those awards and those trophies, the activating the different areas, there's a market phase. Oh, that has a little card that changes each round and so like the, you know, the the price of goods is going to change. There's a lot going on in this game, but at its core, it matters a lot the other players at the table and what they're doing. And I like a game that still forces me to kind of look up. You I love multiplayer solitary, don't get me wrong. I I'm fine just looking down, seeing what I'm doing. Woohoo. This isn't exclusively that, and I think that's a huge strength of this game.
I like what you mentioned about the mini games. I think that that is a big plus for me on this is I enjoy that you can pick a few different strategies. Do I want to repair a lot? Do I want to build a lot? Um, but at the same time, I'm doing these mini games of like I have to keep my fancy rich people, my aristocrats, I have to keep them happy and how am I going to time that timing to keep them happy, but also I want to go perform some music over here and I want to get the benefits of that and which track do I want to move up on? Like I just I enjoy that there's a few different things that you can lean into a little more one way, a little more another way, and there's ways to engine build into those different strategies as well.
I don't want to sound like I'm the only one doesn't like it, but I will say I'm not convinced that the instruments isn't by far the most powerful thing to do, which again is the name of the game. That's the point. Yeah.
Well, I know you say it's the point, but
you mentioned the singing and I and then the last game I played this, I'm like, I say performance, I say it's singing.
I went all in on that.
Yeah.
And it's just not enough. It's not enough to do that performing and repairing. They're just not as strong as the instruments. There's so many more points. It's more steps. The performance I can just do right now. Hey, I did a performance. But the instrument, you got to get the plans, then do the roughing, then do the finishing, then hopefully you got the right one for your patron. Definitely in your first game as your grand would go,
I took the wrong instrument. Do you mind if I switch back, you know, because because there's so much of that going around and matching symbols and the right orchestra.
Well, the way I see it is that um the main point is that you are building instruments, but you have to keep people happy. You have to do the things that earn you enough money so that you can do your craft. And I think that's the point of it is like sure, like what instrument builder really wants to spend their time repairing instruments? probably no artisan is like, "Yep, that's what I want to do." Like, fix stuff.
I'll take your son's janky violin that he hasn't, you know, polished up in eight years.
People appreciate that.
I'll give it scratches. Or do I want to like craft something new and beautiful and amazing and like, you know what I mean?
They probably want to do the fancy parts.
And I think that is represented visually on the board, right? Where I think the patrons and the creating the instruments are the top part and then the repair and performance are the lower story of it. not to. And so it's okay for me in games that not all action paths are equal. You you want to craft instruments. That's the main focus I think. And then how much of the other ones do you do? What what degree do you do you balance those out in and I'm okay with that.
And I will say the theme I think is very strong,
incredibly
like I like classical music a lot. And this I just was very happy with the instrument choices, with the Patreon choices, with just how the whole thing flows. And in reality, fighting for first seat in an orchestra is pretty cutthroat.
It is.
It really is. And so this game is the same way.
Knowing that though, no, you got to know it's cutthroat. And in the last game of this I played, somebody took the first um chair from someone on the very final turn.
Oh yeah.
Which lost them that point, lost them points for having final chairs, but also lost them their personal goal.
You know, it was a lot. It was a big swing of points. But then that's the way that game worked out. So, you need to know that I'm giving this a 7 out of 10, which is going to sound low. I'm assuming that their scores, I like it. I think it's a little long. I wish there was a few things shaved off. What are those things? I don't know. I can't pick anything in here that I don't like, but there's just a lot going on. This is a three-hour game. I know it says 90 to 150 minutes, but with four players, it's an easy three-hour game, and I and I'm having a good time playing it. I'm giving it a positive review. I like it, but I would have to think before I would pull it out all the time. And I'd have to play with people who aren't going to get upset when I go after them or I have to be in the mood where I would have to live with sometimes I got a harps accord or I built I got a patreon who needed a piano and no piano show up for a while and I have to figure out how I'm going to deal with that and finally piano shows up and Chris takes it and I don't stab him, you know. So, so there's a lot going on this game. I think it's a very well done game. I'm very happy with the theme. I'm giving it a seven cuz I enjoy it. I just don't want to play it all the time.
Cool. Well, I'm going to give it an 8.5. So, a little bit higher than that.
I figured.
Yeah. Right. Um I I love the mini games. I love the theme and I love the way that they tied the theme into the mechanisms. I really enjoy the timing that you have to work with with those aristocrats to keep them happy, but also then they give you bonuses and all these benefits and the way that like once you've completely made them happy, then they're like these permanent engine building upgrades. Like I just really love a lot of what's going on here. Um, I think this could have been a nine or a 9.5, but the interaction is a little bit cutthroat like you mentioned. But also, I'm mostly going to play this at two because it is a big game. It is a heavy game. I'm probably going to pull it out with Chris. Um, and so it is a different thinky puzzle with two and I enjoy what's going on with that. So 8.5 for me.
I'm coming at a nine. I I think this is one of the coolest games to come out in a while. Thematically it's brilliant. I think mechanically there's a lot going on, but once you get it, it starts flowing. And yeah, there are those moments. I'll agree, right? It's still going to be long, but I I see this getting quicker with more plays, but not like lightning fast. That 90 minutes because you are definitely watching what your opponents do. You can't ignore it, I don't think.
Yeah. Yeah. Um to to a point that you brought up, right, that luck of waiting for the instruments to come out. There is that option. It's expensive.
Oh, yeah. It's true. I didn't mention this rules overview because it hardly ever happens, but you can spend 10 money and kill an apprentice forever. like they're out of the game to search that deck for a very specific thing you need.
And I appreciate that because it forces you to play the game as kind of, you know, as the cards reveal. But if you're in that position, you're like, I need a piano. This is worth it. Goodbye forever.
I You're sending him out on a journey. He just doesn't get back before the game ends. I guess I think is that what it is? But the piano gets there in time.
I traded him for a piano. He didn't know that.
Another string is made of cat gut. Yes. cat gut.
Oh, that's dark.
So, anyway, the point being there are those workarounds. You're not completely beholden to luck, but it's going to cost you. And so, it it encourages you to play the game as the cards kind of fall, but also you do have those outs. And I think that that's kind of emblematic of a lot about this game for me, right? You play the game as it comes along, but as you like, it's it's got the depth there to keep coming back to. And I love the fact that it's not just mechanism soup. It is a little bit of that. I agree. I don't know what they could have smoothened out, but it feels like some stuff there. But it's not all of that for lack of player interaction. I think that this is a nice mix of what a lot of people complain about modern multiplayer solitaire games, how they've forgotten that the other players at the table matter. This one hasn't forgotten. It it it mixes those things nicely, which is a very sweet spot for me. So, a nine out of 10.
There you go, folks. That's Luierre, the art of the instrument. I'm Tom Vassel. I'm Wendy Y.
And I'm Chris Y.
See you next time. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.