The Hungry Gamer Reviews The Hobbit There and Back Again
Transcript
Oo, that looks tasty. Welcome folks to the Hungry Gamer is back with another game review and today we're talking about The Hobbit. There and back again designed by Riner Kitia and published by Office Dog Games. Thank you to Office Dog and Asay for sending me this copy so I can make this video. What this game is, this is a roll and write game in which you are going to be playing through the entire story of The Hobbit. As you go through, each different page of the story will be a different part of the story and will have slightly different rules as you play through. But as I said, at its core, it is a roll and write game. And before I get started, please make sure you turn on your cling on subtitles because if I make any mistakes in the rules overview, that's where you'll find the corrections. Now, if you are not interested in how this game is played and want to jump ahead to my final thoughts, then you want to go to the time stamp on the screen right now. For those of us still here, let's talk about how this game is played. And for this, I'm simply going to use the part one or the beginning of the story. And as I said, just understand that there will be some slightly different rules as you go through each and every scenario. So what's going to happen is in this first scenario, your goal is to get all of the dwarves into Bilbo's house. And there's some extra points for the first person gets both Thorne and or Gandalf into the house as well. So what's going to happen is on the turn, the player will roll the dice and you will take turns drafting these dice. And the first player who actually rolled the dice will actually get more dice than the other players.
And then the dice will get passed on. And so what we have here, and I'm just going to make a couple changes like so, is I have some swords, a Gandalf hat, and some paths. I also point out that bread is an option of something that you can get as well. And so let's just say that my first choice is going to be this path here. You'll see that it has a single line going through three squares. And so what that means is I could simply go one, two, three. And now I'm getting this dwarf closer to Bilbo's house like so. Now later on perhaps I take something like this. And then I could actually have this path go like this. And now I've connected that dwarf to that path. And eventually through different things they'll get there. And now in this case this dwarf would be there and this dwarf would be there. And as you're going through here, if you cross through a sword, you would get to pick up a sword. I'll talk about what those are for in just a bit. And then the same with the Gandalf hats over here, as well as the bread. Now, the bread, which you're going to get through either stepping on it on the board or rolling it and claiming it on a die, you're going to be using over here. And so, as each dwarf arrives, you fill it in. And if you have bread for them, you fill it in down here. And that's going to be points at the end of the game. And as you can see, you get one point for that dwarf, one point for that dwarf, and if
they have bread, another one and two. And you go over, the more you get, the more points you get. Same thing with Gandalf and Thorn. They're worth points. And they want two bread cuz they're extra hungry. Then down here, however many swords you've collected are going to be worth points based on this chart right here. These points are are actually being the one to get Thoren and or Gandalf into the house first. And then I mentioned there were the Gandalf hats. Each time you use one of those, you get to fill in one of these and you get a specific thing for it. So two Gandalf hats here would give me two bread, etc. And then you can always just say, you know what, I'm not going to use my die and I'm going to use it to get one of those things there. And as soon as someone gets all of the dwarves, not counting Thorne and Gandalf to the house, that round will be the last round. You total up your points and whoever has the most wins and then you go on to the next part. So, with that said, what do I like about this game?
The first thing is it's pretty darn portable. I actually just took it with me on a trip across the country. I just put it in my suitcase, no problem, and was able to introduce my brother and his wife to it. And that was great. It also plays on any size table pretty much. Very, very easy to get it played. And along with that, I'll say it's a beautiful production. I love the artwork. It is like with Fate of the Fellowship. It feels like a bit of a throwback to that 70s8s Lord of the Rings Hobbit animated series. It just really really like the look of it. All the cardboard bits are just real chunky. The books are really nice and they lay pretty darn flat even on the like the the first adventure so you don't have that kind of like folding up thing going on. Comes with dry erase markers. I always I really like a roll and write that is dry erasable so I don't feel like I'm using tons and tons of paper.
So really really like the way all that is done. Great production portable all that's great. Now moving into the game itself. I really like that each of the successive stories are kind of an increase in challenge. Each one just feels more difficult. Which brings me to my next thing which is it's a roll and right that's actually thematic because you're doing something with everything that you have. It's we are trying to get from here to here. I mean it's there and back again. So the most so most of the dice are the kind of the shapes that you're using because you are traveling. you are trying to get somewhere. You are trying to do something and it just feels more thematic. But along with that, you're going to be getting Gandalf hats, and we all know Gandalf shows up when he just needs to be there and saves the day. Or you're getting swords, or you're getting bread, things that are very important to our dear little hobbit as we're going through. And each scenario though, the bread and the swords do different things. And maybe not all of them, but they constantly do different things. For example, in the first scenario, which is one that I showed you, the bread, you're just going to pair it with the dwarves, and for each dwarf that gets paired with bread, you're going to get more points. And the swords, just collect them, and it's a kind of a sliding scale of how much they're worth point-wise at the end. In the second one, the bread's going to do that. And the sword you have to use to be able to go into certain spaces. If
you use a sword going into all four sides of a troll, then you've defeated that troll and you're going to get points for that. And it's just really clever that each successive scenario, say that three times fast, each successive scenario uses the things in a slightly different way. And I really, really like the way that it works. All in all, I'm just really pleased with this. I do occasionally enjoy Roland rights, but I rarely keep them for a long time. I still have Hrien's Wall and I play that decently regularly. I still have Three Sisters and I still play that on occasion, but that's pretty much all the ones I've actually kept. And those are, I would say, pretty widely regarded as some of the top rolling rights, period. So, really, really good. If you disagree with that, by the way, drop down in the comments. Tell me what your favorite rolling rights are. I'm happy to hear it. There's some other great ones. You know, Gonchan Clever is really good, but whatever. Drop down. Tell me what you think is also a really good roll and write. But my point is this one is right there. Maybe a little bit more so because I can always change up what it is I'm going to do in any given game which keeps it feeling fresh. So I really really like that. So what are my quibbles with the game? I don't know what it is but every single time I've played people have struggled with drawing the paths.
And I think, well, I don't know why, but people constantly get confused of how the T's work and how far over does it go. And it just takes a while for people to grasp that is each shape is one square. I don't know why, but literally every time I play and introduce someone to it the first time, I have to kind of watch around the table and be like, "Oh, no, no, no, no. One square just like this." and it just takes longer than it should. And I don't know what it is about it, but it just takes longer than it should every single time. Next thing I'll say is, especially if you're playing four players, sometimes your turn is lame. I got a bread. Done. And it's never happens for long that you get hit with something like that, but you can go two turns.
Absolutely. And be like, I got a bread. I got a sword. That's it. That's all I did. Oh, next turn. I got a bread. That's all I did. And so sometimes it can feel a little bit lame and boring, but it's only a 30-minute game, so it's not that bad, but it does come up every now and then. Next thing I'll say is sometimes it's really hard to figure out what to do. Not rules-wise are all very simple, but really as you're going through these things the first time, it becomes a real hard question of, well, what do I want to do? Do I want to try to get all the way to the end? Do I want to try to go and fight these trolls? Do I want to make sure I get Gandalf and Thor to the house first? Like, what is it that I want to do? And it's bizarre how you can just feel like you're just flailing around the first time you play.
And so, when you combine that, sometimes feeling like you're just flailing around. I don't know what to do with a couple not not satisfying drafts, it can feel a little bit off on occasion. Next thing I'll say is the solo mode is enjoyable, but it's not nearly as satisfying as a multiplayer. And I really think that's because you just have some limitations placed on you and it does kind of a neat way that you draft the dice. But there's no score this many points and you won the scenario or something like that. It's just this is the limitations and boom, you're done. What are your points? And I think that's a little bit of a bummer, a little bit of a miss. Last thing I'll just say, because I said how great it was to be able to travel with this thing, is it's really heavy for the size of the box. I mean, it's not 10 lbs or something, but you do not usually think of something weighing this much.
So, it's a little bit heavy if you're just trying to shove it in your suitcase or something. But there you have it, folks. I think this one is a top tier rolling rate game. Top top tier. an amazing production and truly a thematic roll and write and I don't know that I've ever said that before. So there you have it folks. As always, if you found this video useful, please like, subscribe, share, maybe become a channel member. As always, thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful, wonderful day.