Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 159: Marco Arnaudo on The Tabletop Revolution

Transcript 58:52

it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce that the beyon soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations although the kicks start campaign for their next game hydrologic cycle has ended you can now pre-order copies of the game so go and support science games if you are so inclined their next Kickstarter campaign for eyeball to eyeball a cold war simulation game will launch in late June clgs also continues to offer classes and partnership with genon their next course will be intermediate role-playing game design with a ly lasanta which starts June 19th I know it would be fantastic reports from his students have been nothing but glowing and if you want to support this podcast please visit patreon.com beon soliter and help me Li on but for now let's get on with the show yes indeed I'm I'm loving the Marcus Aurelius call back I didn't even notice that I didn't know that but during the pandemic where my hair looked like this and I had a long be like hey do you do you know that you are The Reincarnation of the guy I was like that's funny and when people started posting that I was literally traveling with the meditations in my backpack because he is one of my favorite thinkers he is a real you know I read a lot of books that uh have interesting stuff in it but Marcos actually really inspires me really I use his knowledge almost every day so and I never noticed that there's this weird resemblance according to other people all right so uh I might just leave this in but if y'all are watching the video um we've got a Marcus Rees lookalike also known as Marco arnado so hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson this is Beyond soliter podcast and this week my special

guest is Professor Marco arnado he is a professor at Indiana University he's the designer of four against the great old ones as as well as some other games and Rule sets um and he's also author of several essays about games and two books about games one of which we're here to talk about today so how you doing Marco pretty good how about you I'm doing all right I'm actually super happy to have you on the podcast because you were in season one and I haven't had you back on since so this is good it has been a while yes was that before the pandemic it was during the pandemic was 2020 yeah so about 10,000 years ago I mean that's my perception of time has since but yes so thank you for having me again yes so it's it's super great to to see you again um and just sort of an update so actually last time you were on we talked about narrative and storytelling in games so your first book and now we're here to talk about your second so do you want to introduce your your second book to the people who are listening yes it's called the tabletop Revolution um and it's a book that I wrote Because I needed it the from my other essays or books that I wrote Because I thought they were interesting I actually needed this book and I couldn't find it so I had to I was teaching uh classes about game design and modern game history for the media school at Indiana University and I just realized that there was no textbook no General overview that could give them a sense of the main processes the main Dynamics some of the mechanics

and so on and so forth and so I was forced to as the students maybe to wear a book to read two chapters or to look at just some entries from the encyclopedia game mechanics look for a video blog here a YouTube post there also you know what I'm just gonna write a book in which I from beginning to end explain what has changed in the last 2025 years in gaming and why uh tabletop gaming has changed more dramatically in my opinion in the last quarter of a century than in the previous centuries or Millennia there's really been like a singularity events that has pushed game design and game production and and game play in completely new ways and so here starts from the history why that happened and then it breaks it down into chapters which again I've designed so I can use it in my classrooms and so now this is a g this is a book that can be easily you can people can read it and I believe it works as an essay but can also be split into each chapter can be assign in a week and you pretty much have the syllabus written if you're teaching a class of about game design because that's the book that I need it yeah I feel like um you know I have parlett like history Oxford history of board gaming book but that thing needs a major update um would you say that your book is in some ways an attempt to do that my book in page one of the

introduction talks about that talks about a good starting point is the Oxford history of board games by David paret originally published in 1999 because I want to point out how that book feels so outdated 25 years later however it was so complete in 1999 because what he talks about in 1999 was perfectly complete he talks about rolling move he talks about gambling he talks about game I go and chess and and even says like in in 20th century pretty much those trends that date back to ancient times have continueed but then what happened after that is so different and pretty much I mentioned if pet had traveled back in time to mavi's time in the Renaissance mavelli was playing a version of back gamon he was he was absolutely fanatic about that he could travel back to ancient China and play earlier versions of go travel back to ancient India and play earlier version of Chess but instead of traveling back in time from 1999 it travels back 10 15 years now you got Legacy now you got worker placement car drafting open or close car drafting you have people destroying components your have people staring at the table without doing anything which is the main mechanic of the Mind the mind has managed to turn waiting into a mechanic all of these

things have little to no precedent and so my book tries to cover precisely that all of the biggest Innovations now it's not that these things necessarily did not exist say in the 70s or 80s but they were very Niche matter of fact paret himself had missed some of those things and that's another interesting point that I like to make that Innovation is not so much about just one person having the great idea because some of these ideas they showed up in the 80s or 90s and they were super Niche the very same ideas when they come back in 2005 instead of 1985 become huge so it looks like creativity in general in game design for sure is of an intersection between somebody having an idea and an idea capturing the needs desires and style of the community right for example I talk about alart that's a game that had like a single Edition in the 1990s and then you have like 20 editions in 2010 and there is in 2011 and there's a pattern there for sever other the games that show hey there was a tiny addition back in the day and now so many additions and variants and ideas that have exploded so that shows you is not only the idea but the community now is looking for something new that did not exist until like 40 years ago when the idea stayed

Niche just explode later I'll give you one last example which actually haven't mentioned in the book because I couldn't find the reference I remember reading in an article in a war game magazines from the 70s or 60s I wish I could find it maybe some of the viewers will help me an article in a war game magazine that said uh sure we're looking for realism in war games but we're definitely not going to throw away our soldiers and gain components at the end of a battle to represent losses I'm thinking well in Legacy games we do that we destroy and throw away the stuff I found that article I can't retrieve it anymore I don't know where I found it in which the author literally says it' be absurd to destroy gain components to represent loss and that's one of the biggest strengths in the last 14 years oh man that's a really fun way to think about it so when you talk about the community and its needs yes who is who is included in the community for you and how did you decide to draw those lines um I my definition of and my emphasis is on Obby games of course again you still have traditional games children games Mass Market games that rely on those uh older conventions my my emphasis is on Hobby Games and hobby Gamers and the best definition that I found is a bit circular but it it works because hobby gamers are people who who

play games as their Hobby and mainly gravitate toward Hobby Games and so a hobby gamer is more likely to play Splendor Sagrada or a legacy game than clue Monopoly and a hobby game is the kind of game that appeals to people who play games regularly as their hobby again it's circular but it does allow us to distinguish between different types of people playing games and different kind of games because again Monopoly I don't know a jenon I don't see a Jen people say oh yeah we play this every week it's just like people who play games at least twice a week they don't tend to gravitate towards um uh towards M Market games for example so that's how I Define the community the community is people who play games regularly as their hobby this a several other implications means we tend to think of not so many children but uh from teenagers young adults all the way into uh older Ages which is fairly new phenomenon as well um we tend to look at um at the middle class because he can be it's not the most expensive hobby out there but it can be and also another interesting trend is this that a hobby gamer tends to play more games Each of which fewer times than traditional

casual gamers who just play the same games over and over and over and over again that also means another nontrivial element to me a hobby gamer usually somebody who is more okay with learning new mechanics and ideas than otherwise for many casual gamers the idea of learning a new game is a huge psychological obstacle and it really is psychological not cognitive emotional I would say uh I knew a professor at a you she does incredible stuff incredibly complicated stuff I can't tell you what it is because it's a very narrow field then I don't know if she wants to be quoted but me Stu that I would never be able to do told me oh my friends want try to get me to play this game oh my gosh like million rules million things was so tough do you remember what it is something about trains and I'm thinking 18xx I'm like oh no you mean there was Ticket to Ride yeah that one that one I can't I can't begin to handle that so I know that this person can learn things that are million times more complicated but when in front of a game her brain turns out it's like no I can't it's too hard for me I don't want to learn I can't learn so again I Define hobby Gamers as people who are willing to learn new games all the time simply because that is the P pattern of consumption that I see in the market you could not explain the number of games

that are successfully released unless there was an audience who is willing to at least acquire and potentially even play all the many games that come out you have a good point um you used a ton of different examples uh in your book some of which were like from 1970 uh and some of which were super recent games that I've never heard of um so out of curiosity how did you choose which games went into your book as examples is it based on just your own personal experience with games you do go by Marco Omni gamer after all or did you have to kind of poke around and do additional research looking for like the perfect version of game to mention when making your points um when talking about the earlier games I did more targeted research and for some things I use for example the taxs the labels of of working geek I know that I don't need to make a huge research to find today's worker rep placement games I just stumble upon them anytime you walk into a game store um but I want to wonder what how new is the mechanic when did it happen then they start using borang geek and they do more targeted research uh for narrative games that I did that I already done the research because I already look for when did game start telling G telling stories for the previous book so when I talking about some earlier precedents I did specific research

looking for them I poked around in a certain sense then what I found determined the cannon because if there is one game that did it well that's the one that's C called precedent uh when it comes to Modern games uh then there were so many more examples and I decided to give as as not as many as I could because work rep placements I could mention thousands but a good critical mths I think that when we're talking about Trends the quantity has a quality of its own I think it's different than if I tell you oh this is a very popular thing or if I give you a paragraph which is basically a long list or some of the most popular ones and for those again I use my own experience the games that all my friends talk about and they want to play and they've become modern Classics if you're part of the community you probably don't need a lot of research to figure out what are some of the most popular Legacy games uh so for those again it's been the community and again and some of the rankings of B Game Geek that have pointed the way this being said there is always an element of personal taste maybe there's a game that I played a lot more and I'm able to share more detail insights and I think look there are like 10 games that exemplify this mechanic or the specific point I'm trying to make why shouldn't I go they all feel kind of equivalent why shouldn't I go specifically for the ones that I know

better and seem to be more uh insightful makes sense makes sense uh you mentioned that a lot of the information in the book might not be new to somebody who's already kind of entrenched in the hobby Community um that said I did notice that I was very interested in some of your insights about not that there were there was an explosion of new mechanisms but what they were doing for players and why those mechanisms might exist so um I would love to to hear you expand on that so you know we've had an explosion of different mechanisms you know we talk about things like lower luck more player choice um why are these things Suddenly at a premium after what appears to have been so much standstill in terms of development of new game mechanisms when it comes to the deeper sociological elements I have to resort to hypothesis but it seems to me that there are several trends that get together and the idea is that among hobby Gamers there is an almost unprecedented emphasis on game play itself we play the game to enjoy the game as opposed to before then uh you look at games play by adults there seem to be two major Trends one is games that are just meant to socialize and this is a more recent style of games by Mor reca I'm talking about the Renaissance we have like early role playing games of the Renaissance that

were meant to structure conversation uh and in some of those hey the courtiers are pretending to be Wizards and they describe the kind of spells that they would that they would cast but there is like victory points you don't roll dice so I either games that facilitate conversation and social interaction but the game itself doesn't matter much or gambling games and by which I mean games with an external reward is I should say that because actually some games that would play for an external rewards the wearing gambling chess was played for for uh for money now you also see when people are playing games for money which is again huge through uh human history people are playing games for money they don't want to learn new games they don't say oh we're going to try a new scenario and the person in front of me may know that's oh we're going to play a variant that you know and I don't that's just a way of taking my money with more steps so you also see why the idea like playing the same games over and over again and going deep into that was very massive when people were playing for money even some games Goose that was a gambling game again for the European Renaissance even the first commercial versions of goose for children the date to the 19th century they still say that to play people should the kids should put some candies or some some other kind of like treat on in the middle of the board to form the pot and whoever WIS

gets that even that so when you remove so what we see here and again why it has happened I'm not 100% sure but for sure now these are the two trends of adults that play game with an emphasis on having fun with the game itself not just only with the conversation rounding it and playing it for the joy of playing the game rather than for an external reward these are obvious things if people for hobby Gamers of the last 20 25 years but they are historically revolutionary these were not things that happen with adults playing games before and but so what happens is again then you have engagement then people want to have fun with the game itself engage with it and then you see how these mechanics that emphasize player choice reduce luck but again you can summarize I believe the the trends that I describ in the book with games Drive engagement by giving us interesting choices and and by placing Gameplay at the core of the experience I think we can kind of summarize that again some you achieved that positively by which I mean adding mechanics and rules and some negatively meaning by removing what used to be normal conventions such as player elimination long downtime but that was still struggling with that one some

games still have that a lot but play elimination that should be obvious um runaway leaders that used to be very obvious and yes if you're playing for money I'm the runaway leader I'm happy in that position I want to stay there and take your money if I'm playing for the Dr plane even as a Runway leader I get bored I may just be as you know unengaged with the game as runaway leader as the people who can't catch up so these are some of the factors that I think changed but again they go around the idea game is interesting by itself for gameplay so I need to be able to play it not to be kicked out of the game I need to be able to believe that I can win to be emotionally engaged although winning is not the point I believe playing the game well in order to win is the key experience of modern hobby game oh I instinctively I feel like you're headed in the right direction with that I can't you know obviously I'm also not a sociological expert but that feels like there's truth in it um one other thing I was wondering as I was reading your book is I feel like over the years I've done my podcast actually um board games and scholarship have gotten a lot friendlier with each other um what what kinds of changes have you noticed in that realm over the last few years and I know that your book is for students but do you see it being used for scholarly purposes as well

absolutely as I said my primary need was to have a book that I could use in the classroom for undergraduate students but then I'm getting a lot of interest from more traditional game Scholars because gaming became of interest in at least in American Academia in the early 2000s but it was 100% inti and only digital gaming you didn't even say I specialize in video games somebody says I'm a game scholar and they have an academic tenure profession position you can assume they specialize in video games that's not shocking because if you were studying games in the early 2000s well guess what partlet book tells us that tabletop gaming was still very conservative was still very similar to how it has been but video games had been incredibly Innovative they were experimenting in terms of story and things like that mind the menu that had analog uh foundations but that was not put and that was not obvious so D so the Academia started exploring games entirely entirely from 2. of digital gaming that meant that how what the journals were publishing what people getting jobs uh we doing and of course then these people with an academic job they're the ones directing you know leading undergrads and directing grad student dissertations so these great

students will specialize in digital gaming and so on and so forth long story short I go to conference I talk about these games and I see my colleagues especially in digital gaming who had no idea that hobby gaming tabletop gaming has been so Innovative and they ask me wow we can I get a good sense of these things and I was like well back then I say there may be a book at some point that gives you a general cover so this is again also designed for other Scholars for GR students and academic Scholars who interested in gaming and they simply need to catch up they simply need to catch up they're just I would say when we talk Among Us tabletop Gamers we know the PS5 is innovative has a lot of new Xbox we know about digital games games more than Scholars of digital gaming know about about board games in when we talk among us we don't think that Donkey Kong or Pacman are the newest the greatest new things but the other side so to speak in an artificial distinction and I hope he'll fall apart soon but I've seen scholarship written by digital Scholars who still compare you know when we come to example still Monopoly or and they say well of course an analog gaming cannot tell a story the way a video game does because look monop look at Jen I'm like yeah but if you look at Gloom Haven that it's a

different story but they have never heard of that so I think it fills a gap in Academia also at the higher levels and again when it comes to hobby Gamers as yourself still seeing all of these mechanics and dynamics that we know of instinctive put in a single place and I hope logically organized I think there may still be an advantage uh there may still be a way of mapping things that you have maybe you have seen individually getting some insight from somebody who has given some thought to this and again one of the purpose of the long list is also well people may get to explore they may get to learn about new games that they haven't heard because no one has played every hobby game including myself but I played a few and so that may still help uh readers explore new designs one thing I noticed in your comments was that you wanted to see sort of a breakdown of boundaries between digital and analog gaming and I feel like that's already happening in two ways one is that I'm noticing tons and tons of board game apps and scheme and switch implementations and the other is seeing tons of board game mechanisms making it into video games like something like slay the Spire is basically a deck builder with more math than a person wants to do on the table um how do you how do you understand these Trends and see board and video gaming like moving together well actually allow me to

clarify uh what I definitely want to be seen breaking down is the divide in the players habits rather than design themselves and especially again when it comes to digital Scholars because again a lot of for the Hobby People Play boy who play video games as the main thing they I think they're picking up games and they're probably not picking up Monopoly they're picking up hob but in Academia it's very strong and the job is hard you need to read a lot and work a lot and so the fact that on top of what you specialize it may be good to also Branch out it's tough simply tough practically speaking but I do hope the digital Scholars more and more understand the vitality and the richness and inventiveness of what has been happening on the tabletop in the last quarter of a century when it comes to the design themselves I see that they tend to converge as you notice also but I don't think they they are overlapping much and I don't think they will because once they do they lose their specific I think it's called proposition propositional value something like that something fanc that they the individuality and therefore they lose part of the market for example we know that we know about app enhance games and that's like the last decade or so I bu with descent we we men some Madness and you scan things and they are

present and some are very good I love Chronicles of crime the whole system but if you look at some interviews from experts from the early 2000s there was the idea that board gaming was going to be completely annihilated and the if analog forms are going to survive they had to they had to Ally themselves with with digital elements that has not been the case at least so far about 10 years since 10 years into having some games with apps that enance them they remain a minority the apps have not being the savior of analog gaming they are a presence they do some things well for example they do the map they give us a little bit of soundrack uh they allow us in some cases but they're not the same if you look at the top 100 is not well 90% of them have apps or digital elements because without those nobody would play games anymore so I believe that the quintessential materiality of analog games is still very much the leading element and I believe actually it's PR it's not just the SPID of the digital Revolution but because but because because because so many of our interactions are now mediated digitally then now the material element has become so prominent it's so exotic you know now looking at you know manipulating those wooden meatballs and

shuffling those cards and moving around those tokens and those nice piles of metal coins and I have a whole chapter about that how material production has become more uh intense is the right word I hope but not overproduced because in 1980s or 199s you did have games with a ton of plastic and they were meant to wow you just from the point of material production but all of the stuff wasn't necessarily needed didn't make the game better is the quintessential over production when the production is not necessary now you have games that are beautifully produced and tangible and I should say the production even more tangible yet at the same time still functional to gameplay but a lot of these games that have metal coins the design could work with the paper money I know I almost struggle to say because I myself have that sense of like um those wooden meeples you could have cheaper plastic tokens so I believe that the matal element is very much important and that's why I don't think that board games will disappear will melt into the digital world another thing um very often when a board game gets not a companion app but a conversion into a digital version then the number of physical sales goes up almost as if if I'm in the line at the post office then

I can play my board game if I'm laying down and no one is around and want to get up and play the game I'll do this but it feels like a plan B uh I don't know that I just and that this may be my ignorance I don't know board games that have been out of business because the digital app was released I don't know just because we can play Catan on the phone now no one now they can't sell copies anymore I don't have any game that just stopped that was successful before and they stopped selling the physical copy and they migrated into the app when that became available yeah I actually anecdotally hear that people often buy games that they've played digitally because they want to bring it into their physical space absolutely and I do the same sometimes I I read you know like I I listen to an audio book and then I buy the book just to put it on the Shelf got your trophy that um I think that there's a there's a trend there and the app may give you a way of trying the game for free or for very cheap before you decide if you want to invest May been a beautiful production but again the experience of playing say Sagrada with those nice colorful dice that you rolling around or again G with a nice cardboard wooden wooden element is very different from pressing on the screen because also again we press on the screen and do

these things for our job but usually so the kind of experience that you have is now very different from what you do for your job and again we're talking about middle class people who are able to afford these games so many of us as part of their job we steer a screens and press plastic buttons for a certain amount of time every day and so you see how plain beautifully produced and tangible board games become EXO becomes exotic and different from your job in a way that playing games on a screen is not necessarily quite the same that is a really cool way to look at it um you know at the same time of course Digital Life has I think really changed both your gaming life and mine because we both have YouTube channels we make videos about games we talk to people online about games how would you say that at this point your YouTube and digital presence connects with your scholarly life if it does at all H well one thing and it's uh it's uh very simple um I started as a hobby well it's still has a hobby say I I don't get paid for what I do I don't play every time it's still a hobby 100% but it does give me an incentive because I like the idea of of sharing my my ideas with others and it gives me an incentive when I play a game to kind of like think about it systematically if nothing else then I clarify for myself how I feel I clarify

what are the things that I like I don't like so much and very simply scholarly speaking when I was writing both of my books I would go back and read watch my videos so think of those as like notes because I know that's what I thought at the time I know that's that's my opinion um and so I have a summary of gameplay with my own video a summary of what I thought at the time so I was like you know I'll revisit that but it's a good starting point before making my videos I did not use to write down a paragraph or a summary for each game that I play but with my video I basically do with the incent intive of sharing my ideas with others and so that's that's something other people can use also yes I had a friend who worked for the military and he said that he also uses my videos as quick summaries of the games when he was doing his research so if nothing else academically it allows me to have an archive of notes that then I can refer to I can tell my students hey you know that's uh just go and watch that video and you get a sense of this or that thing uh if from teaching about a certain game so it's a good Archive of information that I use I practically have used and still use and since I share it other people can use it too it's really interesting to hear you say that because I feel like during my PhD years it's probably because I didn't do anything like media studies right I did ancient Christianity was very you know old school um in topic and style um

but I would never ever have imagined a world where Board Game Geek or a YouTube video could be used as a scholarly Source uh but in several interviews of the past couple years I've talked to people who are using you know they're citing Reddit posts as part of their research uh what do you think about I guess kind of the convergence of the scholarly world and attempts to comment more on board games and the necessity of interacting with more normal people and like popular sources as part of that um I think it's an opportunity and like in every opportunity you got to be uh careful that you don't get you know carried away so of course the way we interact and the information we find on Reddit we found on YouTube we find on Facebook I quoted Facebook ads in some of my things uh it's information so if it's accurate it's a huge advantage of course that's that's the biggest if then you got to have a responsibility to check what is it that you find and and make it reliable if again if I did you know my research that is could be published or sometimes is published on a in a peer review article and then I give you a summary on the video on Facebook then it passes the same academic standards as we have in peer review which is the highest not perfect but the highest and strictest standard of examination that

we have figured out in Academia but then somebody else goes and says something and I don't know if what they're saying is peer reviewed quality or not so it all depends and again you got to take this opportunity but you have to check to check everything but I don't see any any problem with that I believe actually that uh in my dissertation for my Italian ba and that was the year 2000 I was quoting some information I found online uh which ended up being accurate but I remember my advisor be like it's on the internet can't be good I'm like well that's you're going too far the other way something doesn't become automatic it falls because on the internet but it is true that you have to sift through things a little bit more because there reason a a filter to start with but you know everything needs to be read if if fact say for example something that I used almost religiously in my book in my last book is Boran geek ratings now not because they tell me if a game is good or bad but because they do tell me if a game is popular and successful or not and of course that means a game has thousands and thousands of games or votes by Hobby Gamers by Hobby Gamers and they are very very positive it probably is good at least to me probably I'm going to enjoy it there's a chance at least but I know for

a certainty that it has been successful and it meets the standards and the taste of today's community and again it may be circular because people who go and rate things on Board Game Geek are passionate Gamers but that is the study of this is the object of my resarch to start TW incidentally no I don't rate things on Bard Game Geek uh because grading is my least favorite part of my job as an academic and so then having to figure out this is and since I do it seriously all the time so serious in my job then I really be gr willing is is really seven maybe 7.5 then I would wake up at night no it's really 7.2 but it's kind of good May so I don't do it I give you my narrative description and then if you wanna Quantified it it's up to the viewers to do that that's very very fair um so speaking of grating I know that you also teach students about uh born games and that's you know sort of the birth of this project what are you hoping that your students will take away from your class about board games and also what are they coming in with I'm just sort of curious uh they come in from several Paths of of Life initially I was teaching this class for the media school so it's a fairly it's a fairly self- selected group and so their students interested in media and some of those yes their plan was to get into the Borg industry

that's what they wanted to do uh some many of them they were starting to enter the video game industry and yes I see they wow they could quote every you know single video game ever but they never play some of these board games so that to us like foundational they never heard about about deck building for example or they like he in video games i' seen that oh that's where so it enriches their understanding of digital G gaming in ways that were not taught before that they hadn't seen in class about digital gaming and then people in journalism well that's something that they can write about and if nothing else this is super important classes about games in which students play games together they create a sense of community and that is really important the biggest predictor of academic success is not income as everybody beli believed is not anything not gender race uh orientation nothing it's whether the students make friends or not if somebody goes to college and they don't make a group of friends in the first semester their chances of graduating plummet if they don't have a group of friends by the end of the first year they virtually never complete college and so having students playing together and they told me that we born in this class we stay we see them years later we have we remain friends because we play games together there that add that Value Plus again so

many different things nurology our gam tell stories if they're into any kind of literature English is a natural fit because many of our narrative devices were invented by Americans and English designers um but any kind of literature now you know how to tell an interactive story now you tell story that responds to the decisions of the of the players now that was when I taught in the media School started from the from the fall I'm teaching in the college so it caters to a broader kind of student so from anybody who's interested in the humanities and or the sciences and so going to be for 120 students so open up to a much larger group first was 20 students um and so that really is for a huge range of people graphic designs game design sociology History Literature again because so much of this is Interactive fiction so it te is the class and the students find that find it and when they come to class and they tell me why they take it sometimes they take it for reasons that I did not expect but if they identified as something is interesting to them well I'm happy that they gave them the opportunity I like that I also love that you kind of see some of the value of your class as something that's more of a soft value I think that we talk about education now and I mean my bias is showing is a classicist right we talk a lot about what's useful and like sort of utilitarian aspects of class and you

know oh I took this so I could design a game or I took this so I could be a journalist um you know what do you I mean do you feel that you're teaching about board games is also sort of part of our larger fight for the Humanities he it wasn't like that when I started I thought there were just very cool skills on top of the knowledge that you acquired the literal knowledge there were skills that students were developing it just so happens that the conversation we're having about why teaching the humanities now they're making this more explicit because when you play games you are developing valuable skills it's problem solving again now again you think of traditional games you're all the dice and see what happens but no you're teaching problem solving you're teaching prioritizing your objective Resource Management that's literally a mechanic that we have resource management these are valuable skills people who go to college probably they want to get in position of leadership where they'll make decisions that's good training another huge thing that that games teach is tolerance of ambiguity it seems obvious to us because you and I come from the humanities and so most of the problems in the humanities they can't be solved they're not solvable we we learn we we we normally live with the idea can go this way or that way may never be solved and maybe that's not the point but there are students who go for this a harder path

can be medicine can be engineering and they tend to just look for the quick clear solution but reality is under an obligation of offerings Clear Solutions right away and so if the student or the young professional cannot tolerate ambiguity there are risk of plugin in whichever of the three four methods that you know seems right at that time rather than to slow down wait for the further evidence that may or may not come up and again so in med school students I think it's Virginia Tech that they are taking uh they they're asked to take art classes to learn how to tolerate questions that can be answered right away maybe never uh I read a paper from an engineering conference last year and again they said we're desperately needing we're desperately need young Engineers who have problem solving intolerance of ambiguity and when you're playing a game and the secret and there are secret objectives for all the other players and there are several moving factors I'm definitely training problem solving tolerance of ambiguity uh critical thinking budgeting resources taking calculated risks no matter what my students will do in life chances are they'll need it and an metaphor an analogy that sometimes I say hey military training probably you know people lift weights and do push-ups but in the battlefield they're not going to drop on the floor and give

20 to the enemy impressing them with their with their push-ups and planks so why do they do that they're not going to literally do those moves they're strengthening themselves they're learning the skills they're learning things that they will use and you may never plan another the game again or when you take M about literature you may never read Baro book again but when you were delving into those baroes son it's oh did you learn to tolerate ambiguity oh yes you were questioning everything so there are definitely valuable skills that can be learned from pretty much every in any field of humanities but I believe gaming has even that extra value that it actively engages you when I teach about literature yes some students May drift into the background they may even look interested they may even have learned the autopilot m well they're thinking about who knows what but you can't do that when you're playing a game you can't pretend to be paying attention people will can tell you have to take your move you have to make your things people start doing Rand things randomly then it shows right away so it encourages active engagement in a way that other fields do not nice as good an argument as any I think um and then I want to ask sort of a YouTube related question so the last time I had you on the show we did a double episode one about your book and

then one about the future of wargaming uh you just you'd very recently become Marco Omni gamer instead of Marco War gamer and you were somewhat pessimistic about the future of War games but optimistic about the future of games in general um do you feel that that has changed uh you know your feelings on that how have things borne out what's your current I guess positioning in relation to work War gaming its future especially well um I play fewer war games than I used to and both I'm older and I guess more tired and my and I and my family doesn't play as many games as many war games of that games of that kind my friends some move out of town and and so and that's already tells you something though when your work gaming friend moves out of town it's harder to replace them than when your friend who play sagada or the crypto orever that M out of time to you can replace those more easily my opinion hasn't changed because I haven't seen any any change any evidence meaning there used to be a divide five six seven years ago uh between War gaming old school which kept being old school and being played by older players and that hasn't changed and I think I don't really see a way out because now some big companies they

start revolutionizing everything they lose those fewer people that that's fairly Niche group of people who have been playing games since the 1970s so they lose that audience but audience is not going to be around forever biologically speaking so I don't think you can convince those old scho Gamers to change the style um um and just but so the idea the hobby survives if is if it attracts new people and younger people especially I think it's going to be a very har cell I believe actually that just in today's world is a lot harder to convince younger people to play games about war to start with I think it's just very an appealing topic um we have a broader and more diverse audience for games than there was in the 1970s and many constituents are just not interested in that topic so it's about the older mechanics that are not particular appealing and they may just not be games about war not many games about war in the future uh so now I I believe that the old school War gaming is still on its way out I don't see a new generation of all School Gamers coming up and I think that there just so many fun and exciting things happening outside work

gameing that other styles of game will keep being dominant now of course every trend has its exception say look at da Thompson with things like unded then he's taking modern game Concepts and applying them to where gaming with stunning results and DED is one of my favorite games of all time but you're not going to have a huge Market of War games based on this one or other you can you can quote 15 more if you can find them that have the new wave feel and the theme of historical Warfare if you can find 1015 that'd be great I can't think of 1015 and even that would not be enough to keep a hobby up so no I think it's a I'm still pessimistic pessimistic Styles come and go you know how much I love historical war game the hundreds of videos that I made about it and then it became stagnant and other styles became more exciting I didn't reduce my number of games that I played in that style because of some political decision because they did in the long run they are a little more static and less exciting relative to the context around them which has so much yeah yeah in the 19 yeah 30 years ago we gaming was super exciting and

complex and about gamep playay and all these decisions and the alternative was rolling dice around the Monopoly board but as the other context so it's not just that word gaming has I would say you know Monopoly has been stagnant since the 1930s but that's all that there was war gaming has been very static for the last 50 years and while that was still the most most complex and oriented style that was fine but the context around them has become so much more appealing than where gaming also I think have become more appealing in comparison less sorry where gaming has become less generally appealing by contrast we know that has happened oh that's a really interesting way to look at it I feel more optimistic but it's also because well I think that you have to decide what you're willing to think of as a war game I think that you can either sort of mix war and historical games together and see lots of interesting Trends moving in cool directions or you can be very strict about what a war game is and watch it die abolutely and that's 100% my agreement I would say in fact when we to refine what I said a little bit more instead of war game pessimistic about war gaming you could think of pessimistic about old school War gaming larger hex based map we hundreds of counters 10 combat tables and modifiers 60 Minute setup and so on and so forth which again I enjoyed very much

uh and occasionally I still enjoy but there just so many other Alternatives that are more appealing that I don't see anybody who is 19 or 29 or 20 now getting into that people always post the picture of this one person at that convention again but that one person will need to buy 500 copies of every game and that's not not going to be liking so yeah you can say old school war games and again some people out there are very annoyed that they say that but I stand by the evidence that I think that's that's where it is going incidentally what I call old school it's a very specific style of games they came out at a specific time and a specific place the people who started playing games in 1970s and are still in love with that Hax base combat TBL ET Etc they were playing the games that were exciting and new when they were young they weren't playing the word games that were exciting and new at the times of agws they weren't playing games that were excited new 60 years prior you understand that right there's also this element of being in love with the thing that was there when they were teenagers hls remember you play play little toy soldiers and with cannons that actually shot little balls hitting those soldiers so the the GMT the SPI the Avalon H War Gamers they weren't playing those they were acting probably just na about those so why should somebody who is Young a teager now looking for fun games to play played the games from 50

years prior when the old school War Gamers were not doing that they were looking at what was exciting at the time um so on that note I'll I'll go into my softball question uh which is what games have you been enjoying right now well as you know I play a a whirlwind of new rotating games all the time uh but I do have some games that I that have become and have a footnote in my book about it but around those there are some games that I've always enjoyed and that when a game we're playing we want to play another game or sometimes we play a game that FS like God this is like we're not we don't need to finish this thing then we just pull one of those games from the from the wall from the shelf and I would say those are my modern Classics that I could always play and so my mini cannon is Sagrada Splendor CI uh the crypto and probably some micro macro Crime City that's that's always uh fun to play so I've been I can't think of another game that you know I played recently I was like w this I'm going to play so so so much you look at my channel I love games all the time but I try new games all the time and it's I'm lucky that there are just so many great games out there I'll would say there isn't any game that I play in the last year or two that has like come across as immediately

joining those four five that I like to play I guess I guess micro macro is from the last two three years but that would be that would be that and I've been reading a lot of game books that also has been a long a long passion for me and I I been spending a lot of time playing game books because well guess what similar to boy games in the last 10 years or so more recent they become more interesting and exciting than they used to be in the 1980s and 90s so now we also have a bit of a golden age of the game book that started from the 2010s following in on the Innovations of board gaming that started from the 2000 early 2000s you have deck building game books now what are the odds that that does come from tech building tabletop games oh that's really cool that's that may be the subject of something entirely different in the future now where can you be found online if people want to follow your work oh Marco Omni gamer my YouTube channel if you Google my name it's either the first or the second thing that you find so it's very easy Mark orado name is down here Google that you'll find my YouTube Channel people want to send me a message they can figure it yeah it's not that hard to find an email address for me or a social a social media contact fair enough um I of course can be found anywhere as Beyond solitire uh but Marco thank you so much for coming

on uh it's been wonderful to catch back up and I really appreciate the time thank you Liz this was so much fun all right everybody out there please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming m

Progress saved