Sine Tempore: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for cna temporary now if you started watching the series uh there are only two videos for that and initially my plan was to do uh you know the narrative missions at least record the narrative missions for the series which would have been about seven videos total um but i just don't wanna play this game seven more times at least record seven more times because this game is not that good it is so okay so this game came on kickstarter and it is one of the perfect examples of kickstarter bloat there's all this content but no real honing of the actual game to make it fun and it's a real shame because ludus magnus studios has done a game that i absolutely love which is black rose wars that game is phenomenal and i feel like i know this game came out before then but that game is just capture the magic of what makes a competitive board game fun here there's just nothing to this game it's just stuff that is just thrown together with no real thought or or care put into it to make an exhilarating sci-fi
rpg and my biggest examples for that is the rule book in and the campaign book they are all over the place there's no real you know front to back cohesion of those rule books to make you be like yes i now understand how to play this game oh how do i start your campaign oh well i don't really know because what they do is they do the classic example of okay well as we're typing this up well we know what this stuff is so it's going to make sense to them so they fail to explain how certain things go the procedural procedural step uh you know step-by-step instructions of how they even get started on an exploration mission or a campaign mission are just out the window it just tells you hey put these together and or okay you want to set up the map okay with what tiles the tiles aren't even labeled like even generically now you don't have to give them a name like some games do a1 would would be great and a little map to show you which tiles you're wanting me to put on um for it just says set up the decks what which decks am i supposed to set up okay i guess i'm the resource deck the other cards that i happen to get i guess the serious wounds i can do in oblivion and but there's no real instruction on how to do what you're supposed to be doing especially dear god the enemies spawn it's so it's like every mission that
i've done and i've played this game more times than just the recording every mission i've done i'm just like there's always okay what am i supposed to do am i supposed to every time spawn like enemies on the on both spot points like is it supposed to feel kind of like a like a battle rail or a dungeon crawl um or am i supposed to be able to kill all the enemies in the mission and be like okay well that's that both times in both of the recordings i did you i killed all the enemies and i'm just like okay so i have to i have to wait you know seven more turns before because i guess they're not coming back that's all of them so i'm just gonna say i won it's so so poorly executed um not even to mention that the missions themselves are extremely bland and boring for the two that were recorded for the session it's okay make sure enemies aren't near the antenna well those enemies have no health and no defense so any one attack is going to kill them and it's like all right i get it that's the first mission so it's maybe it's not meant to be hard and it'll ramp up as we level up but then the second mission was okay well those guys are just running but they can't really run that fast so i have range i guess i'll just shoot them and kill them okay well killed those guys now i just have to try and make it back while the enemies are weirdly doing things each game i've done that has had an ai system where they're
supposed to they have their own stats and they have their own uh you know tier system what is it's not even the back of the rule book or the campaign book their own checklist of what the enemies do it's just never worked this and sword and sorcerer the two that come to mind where they have an ai system and it's just it's always flopped for me it always feels clunky uh tedious and monotonous to be like okay well what makes sense well technically you know jukas has higher threat than ajab but ahab's closer but i guess because jukis has a higher threat they're gonna shoot him based off that but why why can't it just be like okay whoever's closer you know or okay they're they're tied for closeness okay now whoever went first you know gloomhaven rules or or any other game with enemies it's it's just so i'd i've never liked board game ai systems it doesn't ever feel like it's replicating a video game um and it never can like you you as the player have to move everything and you have to make the decisions when a video game does all that for you uh depending on if it's good or not it can also just be very bad you know shitty ai but here this this reminds me of like a really bad video game ai system uh versus something that could be just just streamlined and good where it's like okay well for example
gloomhaven it's like well the archers have range they're gonna shoot the person that's closest why would they shoot someone that's not close to them they can hit the guy that's closest um so it's just they they they have so many things in this game that make it cumbersome to play and none of it's ever really unique like the theme they tried to make this world uh of their own and it's just not that exciting like there's no atmosphere there's no story the stories are in the campaigns are just oh hey you want to make a landing zone clear the antenna okay the second one hey they stole something off your ship get it back all right and all the missions in between this is actually the worst part of the campaign all the missions that you have to do you can't even just do the narrative stories they filled it with just fetch quest and and bloat to give the game some substance where it's like okay to do this one to do this narrative mission you have to conquer two areas and it's like okay in those two areas those are just side missions that they all have the exact same victory and defeat conditions i'm gonna spoil some of that for you one exploration mission wrecking bully now they play different but to set them up they didn't even come
up with any fun creative way to make these unique with the tiles it's just whatever tiles you feel like putting in that matches it's like oh well where would we fight him that's stupid this is dumb and yeah it tells you where to put it's like oh random random terrain just throw we didn't really want to put in the effort to you know give you some at least some exhilarating side story uh or exploration mission so just [ __ ] the enemies are random the the terrain's random the tiles they're random just just figure it out you [ __ ] thanks for the 300 uh and then the rewards for all of these trust me i checked our the concrete area provides you with its elements add them to your reserves the concrete area provides you with its elements add them to your reserves the concrete area provides you with its elements add them to your reserves the concrete area provides that they're all the same and the defeat is ah you can take on this mission at a later stage once your wounds of healing your equipment has been repaired you can take on this mission at a later stage once your wounds have healed and your equipment has been repaired it's like that that if you watch angry joe is that meme of where they were playing godzilla where it's like godzilla is approaching the generator the generator is being destroyed or whatever it is that's what that is that's that's that oh okay yep the area has been conquered uh take the elements add them to your reserves and it's the same thing and so all you do with those elements
instead of having some rhyme or reason for you to just be like ooh okay we need to go conquer blue ones before we can do welcome to the jungle whether it's the rift of the heaven and neptune lake oh the heaven sounds cool i wonder what unique thing is about that oh no it's not even called the heaven you just shuffle some defcon 4 expiration cards and draw one randomly and that's where it goes and then you conquered the heaven or neptune lake or whatever and then you get those elements what would you use those elements for to upgrade your ship but the ship's not really that exciting the colony phase is extremely boring uh so then you're like well i guess what do i want to do do i want to you know upgrade one of my guns well the problem with that is you don't get enough elements to really make anyone feel worthwhile so you it's like okay well we have enough elements to upgrade one item for one person and that's that and um i'm glad we conquered two blue two blue missions two or two yeah two blue areas to be able to do that and then to go to god the third level is three exploration so you have to do three of essentially the same thing just probably a little bit more difficult where you just do three games three games whether you know the rewards are the same so what incentive is there there's no like side mission like for example a good thing with side missions is star wars imperial assault where it's like okay we have these side
missions available ooh this one lets one of us get our special weapon that gives the jedi her lightsaber or this one gives us an ally or they have different you know rewards depending on which side mission that you go and do that gives the players incentive to want to go do something or a side mission in gloomhaven there's not a whole lot of them but they are there here it's just like okay well we get no special rewards for doing these so how about instead of actually just doing that we just say we did it let's look at the three green that we have to do here okay well the three green is the fortress falling leaves emerald river acid swap butterflies and thunder grave now all those sound cool but you just shuffle the defcon 3 ones and it's like all right well we did the rift in the heavens so those are tied to these four green so we just have to do three of those all right we'll just say we did falling leaves thunder grave and and butterfly bites and we'll just take those elements okay we did that time to move on to the narrative mission the fact that they put in zero effort into a majority of this game there's seven mind you narrative missions and you have to and before you even get to the third narrative mission you are doing five exploration so you're already doing more [ __ ] side stuff than you are their actual narrative so it's like it's like they basically wanted you not to play this game by not making the other objectives
exciting in any way you don't get xp you don't get special things where it's like okay well if we do have we can actually get his second level his his second gun no no no even even by the time you get to the next narrative mission have any more abilities now the abilities here are i mean they're cool they they are unique they make each person feel you know their role and the fact that each hero does have two paths that they can go down this i like i like the characters i like all that but the problem is in an rpg setting you want to level up you want to feel like you're accomplishing something and the game actively prohibits you from feeling that or at least from doing so it's like by the time you get to your second narrative mission you will and finish it you will have two xp now none of these ever really cost more than that like they cost one or two xp to get so the the skills it's not like you have to save up seven or something before you can get something really cool like it's one or two and they're they're all pretty good so they do a pretty good job at making the heroes feel powerful and okay each one is unique juke this is a psionic you can do those cool psionic abilities andromeda is the sniper a jab's the upfront brute and then alexander is the medic those are the four and then they have a bunch of other heroes that are there if you want to play if you want to have a gag you play as the uh you know the struggling crew or the
struggles from spaceballs but even then it's like well they're funny but they're only funny because i know the movie but there's no scenes or scenarios that i would i would put them in like you know what i'm saying so it's like well it's not there's any spaceball scenes where you get even more references nope you just have the four characters the campaign is just so bad even just doing the exploration mission by itself is so bad there's like there's not even i mean they do have nemesis monsters that have their own their own decks and their their own unique way to play but they're an extra thing they're from the stretch goals to where you can incorporate them into the store and as an exploration mission you can just go fight them and that is where you can get special items like rewards for doing things but that's not base game like that's all extra stuff and it's like well that's kind of [ __ ] stupid uh even the four heroes that you can't come out and play as you actually have to go do their special mission to recruit them it's just like but why like the game's not that long in terms of narrative stuff so i would just be going to recruit them just to say i recruited them there's no real story-driven reason why i would ever go out and do that why can't i just say i did that you get so you pretty much go what i'm saying half the game is why can't i just say i did that and just play the narrative missions and just okay well i got
you know was it lubrico i got i got the cow guy all right yeah all right moving on like nothing changes um so as for as for the mechanics of the game it is okay like i actually like the action point allocation system that is i like that in games anyway um but once again they made it to convoluted this this rondelle or this momentum track i i've seen other games do it and i do like that idea in concept where it's like okay well i'm gonna do this big action that cost five time there was one fireflies i think was it briggins and brown coats uh it did something like that as well where it's like i'm gonna do this major big attack action that costs five time to do and then i'll just move up the track and you just go up the bottom and okay well i'm gonna move one so that pops up and you just keep going so you can do a lot of little stuff and then uh and then or just one big thing but you're gonna wait for a little bit i like that idea but this game just made it way more complicated than it needed to be it could have just been that it could have just been the damn rondelle and you move it but nope you can't just do a bunch of little stuff on your turn when you do your action points you have to do enough to be able to get your token to touch an enemy token and it's because they then really implement any system that makes the ai why don't they just do turns why didn't they just do initiative like
you can still do that but i mean they wanted the momentum but it's like okay so to make the enemies do something instead of just standing there like idiots they you have to at least move it to where they you touch a an enemy enemy token okay fine that that's uh you know that's that's a way of making the enemies get to go that they'll always be doing something but the other sis the other problem is they have their reaction so it's like if i'm a hero and i'm doing my turn and i go past an enemy and it's like oh [ __ ] okay uh did the enemy okay they get to do the reaction they have their okay what's their stat okay their control areas three okay whenever i moved past them did i no i'm not three squares away okay so i guess they're not doing anything they're not reacting really what it kind of comes down to is if you're already interacting with them and you do something then they're going to react if you're already melee fighting between you and a blood hunter and he his turn goes and then he attacks you you defend then your turn comes around then you go to attack him well he's gonna he's gonna react because you're you're obviously interacting with him um the way that that system kind of works is that the enemies are almost gonna be going a little bit more than the heroes uh which is fine because they're cannon fodder they're so easy to kill that it's like okay that it is what it is um but at the same time a lot of what
a lot of what this game is is this this monotony of con okay one two three four okay so you i you have to announce how many you're moving so i moved three so i'm gonna move three and then oh who am i gonna attack and then you try to strategize and then you sit there and you're like oh crap okay so i did that but how many action points do i have left oh crap oh no i actually still need to attack which costs three so no i'm only going to move two and then so you might as well just always do your max action points and just call it a wash like if for example i'm not moving ahab and he has six and i'm going to use my cup my my chain attack of 4 ap you know i'll just move it six and just say i waited twice they actually have an action called waiting so it's like all right you know let's just say i did that they they tried they had so many actions that don't really a lot of them don't matter the biggest one is movement and attacking and then okay well i can spend one to interact and i guess i can focus but you never think to focus because you're always rolling dice uh i don't know and then this game is i mean added score a dice chucker with some euro elements you know with the rondelle or the momentum track but man whenever you're you're rolling dice to attack you're just like okay there's so many symbols on these that you're like wait did i did i get a fist oh okay i did it doesn't really it kind of looks like a fist so there's there's one okay so now their defense is zero so i dealt one damage
okay but oh wait no they get to react but wait so if they react do they only get one at one attack nope i guess they would still get their full attack but you don't move them on the momentum track so it's like does the frag spriggan get to attack me twice okay so i guess i'll roll defense and okay so i have i i got okay what's the symbol okay so i got that that's good oh he's attacking me again and then you're rolling all weird you're just constantly rolling and it is annoying like i don't mind dice where you get to your actions are okay we're gonna do this through this but man there was the reaction of just constantly just okay and then again okay and then i get that and then i'm immune to bleed and they have all these things and it's just too much it's it's too much it's not streamlined in any way uh that you just you feel like you're missing something like this is the equivalent of a game being rushed before it was finished this is no man's sky or sea of thieves where it's like here's the game and then it's just surface level it's like where's the depth no no no you no you don't go under you don't go this is what we got you see all this stuff you see all of this stuff all these all these you know miniatures uh all these cards yeah yeah that's good right yeah but you know is it any good that's just what it that's just what this game feels like
not to even mention the plethora of [ __ ] tokens like of status tokens this is a sheet of uh you know all the status tokens you have so many negative brain damage contagion electric overcharge fire hindered nail down poison slow down soul breaker stunned hemorrhoid tamper spider web target prey three ares uh whatever that is um inhibition uh nitrogen wounds bleed engage acted re-roll oblivion although reroll is uh that's a good one oh and then positive status ap uh two ap cyanic shell speed up improved endurance strength endurance concentration select the point resilience death fortress minefield that's just so much oh and i forgot to mention because of the ai system every enemy has their own you know special attacks or special keywords that you also have to remember it's like what's weak attack do okay so it only does one damage okay well there's climb uh crazy dash disarm just like it's just so much that you don't need to make an rpg you don't need all of this you don't need all of that all the tokens you know all the cards you just need solid mechanics and at least a decent story that lets the players level up
feel their progression and feel like that they're making a difference with the decisions that like the game technically has decision it's not even decisions you if you pass or fail it just determines what what the next mission is and it's like well that's not that fun i'd like to actually sit here and be able to decide where i'm going and let that be like okay well i chose to do this and because of that the rewards i got there prevent me from doing something else that's progression uh not okay play six [ __ ] exploration missions get nothing for them except elements to slightly upgrade your ship and maybe get a decent a decent second weapon and then only the narrative missions you get xp which you can use to buy one upgrade you know one skill or or hold on how about you save up for the big level two gets you you need to spend two xp to do it and uh how about you play 10 more games before you can do that sounds pretty good right no it doesn't and the cumbersome nature of this game just makes it not fun there's just there's just it's bloat it's kickstarter bloat and oh man it's just not not fun i mean i know there's a lot of people who are even trying to figure out how to play this game how to even get
started on a campaign when that should be the easiest thing to do the campaign should be almost a hold your hand scenario at least to get into the first [ __ ] mission not i don't know even how do i just do i just wait what are these spawn points like do i just okay there's an enemy spawn thing it just half-ass gives me half a paragraph to explain how enemies spawn why not just give enough you know enough enemies for me to deal with at the beginning and if you're gonna spawn do something where it's like a separate room or at least make it super hey by the way at you know momentum 2.1 this enemy shows up that's it that's it oh you have these enemies to start with okay well more of these enemies are going to come in you don't need a whole separate deck especially if you have all the expansions of it says oh use only troop enemies okay well do i just throw in all troop enemies because that's going to bring in some spiders or some you know wolves or something it's like i guess you can um and in terms that just makes it even more cumbersome because then you have to have all these min like miniatures off to the side that may not even come in because you you're like well i don't know if i'm gonna draw them on the spawn okay well it's the mower reaper this time all right i guess the six other bags of miniatures i have out aren't they're not coming in so i'm glad i had those prepped for nothing this game is just not not good and i know it has a high rating on board game
geek and i it's it's i think it's a kdm mentality where people spent money on this and they just can't they just lie to themselves and just say no no it's really good you just have to you just really have to it gets really good by narrative mission five just play 30 games and then man it's solid man the the extra content well maybe not everyone has the extra content maybe they just bought this you know they just had enough money to play the base game and this is what they got and yeah the the extra stuff shouldn't make the game worthwhile especially for kickstarter it's just i mean the miniatures look great like and that's kind of what they promoted on their kickstarter page hey a high detailed miniature game yeah they're they're really good like for ahab or ahab whatever his [ __ ] name is he uh like he has a cigar in his mouth and the cigar you can see in his mouth on the miniature that is amazing the detail on these is i mean it is actually extraordinary so like props to them for that but it's just it looks cool the game looks cool but there is absolutely no substance here i don't really yeah i i don't really like it i mean i there's no way in hell i could have done i could have done five five more games for the series uh not
even that i would have had to technically play uh let's see so for to go the narrative mission two or two three we would have needed uh we needed to kill or we needed to complete three green missions so that would have been on the hunt for stupid rocks then uh then you have to complete three yellow missions so right now we are at eight exploration missions um so the machinations of doom um and then three red areas so we are at 11 exploration missions let's say we win each one of these um and then yeah so then you're at well i say 11th and 13 because then you have to complete two purple so that gets us to evil inside and then after that uh yeah before facing it you must conquer at least 15 areas so then you have to go back and do two more to get 15 before you get back if this is just if you win to do the take back your destiny which brings in yeah a boss i mean the map gets bigger um and it probably just gets more complicated but then yep then you complete it and you're like that wow that was that and now i guess i can go on so you have to do 15 exploration missions that are all the same and seven total narrative missions so 22 games
and seven of them are only progressing the story and that's just not something that i i want to get into and that is just asinine to actually just have that in a game i'd rather just play a campaign of near and far and just play near and far 10 times like at least at least that has story and and actual exploring uh and a shorter shorter game well the game's not that long that is a plus that each mission takes about 45 minutes to an hour that is nice it'd be even worse if it was way longer i just wish that there was more substance to this uh besides it just being okay will you roll dice and just get whiplash from all the symbols that get thrown at you when you just roll five dice you're just like oh okay arrows arrows uh arrows okay i need bullets okay there are the bullets everything else is everything else is gone so oh wait they're immune to this so what does well immune means they okay that die doesn't count oh i have three wounds that means i get a penalty die oh that takes that just make your game streamlined it doesn't have to have all this [ __ ] to be good and it has all this [ __ ] and it's still not good so i don't know i can keep going on and on but at the end of the day just play something else um on a scale of 1 to 10
can i even call this average i think i will i think if i give this a 5 out of 10. even though i just bitched about it i mean it works the one you know no it doesn't i'm gonna give it a four it's a four out of ten the rule book is so bad it explains what things are but it doesn't explain how you even get started you have to read through 15 pages before you even get what can i do on my [ __ ] turn and then let alone it mentions in the actual rulebook oh if you want to do the campaign go read the campaign book which is not unheard of other games do that but at least whenever you read the campaign book you know exactly what to do it starts off with like hey an exploration mission you're like wait a minute but i thought i'm doing the narrative mission first and the narrative mission is like okay just kind of get the decks ready put them on the landing zone and have at it and you're like what how do i even set up the the thing i'd like i don't even know how to sub the mission well just look at the picture you'll figure it out everything will be on the mission sheet no it's not like it doesn't even the nowhere in the actual i mean in the rulebook technically in the statuses thing like that's the campaign book in the rulebook where it's like okay well loot tokens i guess it says okay once an enemy is killed it it drops a loot token okay well loots are really just resources that you can use to buff your
uh some of your items or give you a one-time ability but it's like technically on on something else i've seen that tiny enemies don't actually drop loot but nowhere in the rules does it say that uh hell even the threat thing is just you know meaningless it's like because half the enemies are tiny so it's like killing enemy or wounding an enemy if they're tiny doesn't give you any threat and it's like okay well there's only one non-tiny enemy so i guess we're not really going to have threat but they're still coming after us so but we have to compare their threat of the objective to our threat and we're always lower until we attack them but then but would they still want to protect their objective because it's just yeah and then no no none of that's explained so it's uh it's a four out of ten it is slightly below average i cannot willingly give it an average rating because the game acts like it doesn't even want you to play it and that's just not that's that's not good so four out of ten for cna temporary um and that's it everyone let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon
and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you