A Bunch Of Broken Meeple Reviews!! - Part III (Solar Sphere & Scout)
Transcript
thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences get on with it okay during the games now makes an appearance with solar sphere so if you remember our little game called solar storm this was a game I reviewed quite a long time ago neat little game kind of a bit like Forbidden Island makes a pandemic in a sense little Co-op 7 out of ten it was good fine nothing amazing but it was good it was well produced in a nice little portable card game well now they've decided to go a little bit heavier on the weight side and bring out solar sphere by no means is this like a heavyweight game in fact I'm not even certain I would call it mid weight I'd say it's still light but there's a lot more going on in this one than in what sort of a storm had so with this one as you can see there's already a lot of more pieces when you've got a slight double layer board you've got a bunch of cards everybody's got Dyson cubes there's a massive Sun map that you build on the board it's a pretty impressive looking table presence once you get everything out but already you can tell that there's a lot more going on in this game than there is in other ones so in solosphere you're essentially trying to rebuild you know civilization for Earth but this involves building a solar sphere around the giant you know giant Sun enhancing its power the corporation wants everybody to do this and they're going to reward the person who does it the best but then there's also a resistance group that for some reason don't want you to do this don't
ask me why they wouldn't want you to do this but whatever that's the theme of the game and so you're having to fend off some of these ships while also trying to build up these the solar sphere and mitigate your own resources and obviously get victory points because that's the name of every game so the idea with this is that you have a double layer board with spotsfield dice and started around roll the dice and allocate them so I've got a one here and I've got three fives now I cannot stack three fives on this board for obvious reasons at an angle but I would stack him up a bit like this in a big column you then game morale based on what dice you've used so the higher the number is the less morale you get the lower number is the more hour you get this is tracked up here where basically you can spend morale in order to gain like extra freebies from the corporation it's like look look we got a good reputation with you things are pretty good here we could use a little bit of a kickback just a little bit of a nice thing to help us out and the more reputation you've got the better the rewards you get but obviously you need to keep replenishing your morale in order to keep that kind of level things up because if you're on low morale you could potentially have issues on that front and so the rest of the game is kind of done with regards to these cubes so you have a bunch of these cubes which represent drones it's kind of like a separate currency in the game you can make them and you have space on your board to manipulate them and essentially whenever you're doing various actions like you know going out and building certain areas or like fighting off resistance ships you're spending these drones you're having to get them back bake more you've got quite an extensive list of them but basically it's kind of like your action currency a
sense this is the main thing you're using to do the action but then the other bits and the action you do are based on these drones you then take turns to deploy said drones to the various actions like go out and build the solar sphere or go out and hunt down these ships or potentially hire characters that you can have that give you special abilities the resistant ships all have a defense value and a reward but they basically allow you to place drones on them and whoever places the most drones at the point when they get destroyed gets the bigger reward but everybody who chips in gets a little prize as well and they just come in various different shapes and sizes you're trying to gain three different types of resource in order to build the solar sphere and the different parts of the sobosphere require different resources so again it's a resource management game you know through and through but then you've also got these characters that you can grab so you can add only so many characters to your repertoire before you gotta get rid of them but then they're still worth points if you've got them so it's cool to get characters in general and basically they just give you some cool abilities like being able to gain free resources or to trade X for y or every time you do this get something else you know they're pretty straightforward abilities but there's a decent selection of them I mean there's a whole bag of them here this is just a small amount of them but it's something that you can do to kind of develop your engine and differentiate yourself a little bit so the game just carries on through multiple rounds while this is done and of course at the end of the game you see who's like built the most in the sphere who's like defended like a bunch of ships what characters everyone's got total up the VP and who wins this is an interesting light game
it doesn't do anything different and that's one thing about this this isn't what I would call Unique you've seen every mechanic in this in every game that there is but then again that was also the case with solar storm there was nothing original in that either you've seen that everywhere now in terms of the rules there is quite a bit to absorb in this I said there was a light game it's Crossing into Midway territory but I would say it's still light in terms of what you're doing but there's quite a fair amount of overhead to to get in before you get started you need to understand how this board works how your drones work then you've got the different phases what the different uh like effects do so there's a decent amount of overhead to learn up front but then when you get into the game it's not that complicated you know it's just manipulating these drones rolling the dice and deciding how you're going to spend those dice there's a bonus you know there's good mitigation for having low and high numbers because High numbers is all well and good but having that low morale can get you some pretty nice stuff as the game goes on so it's a good little self catch up production wise wow I mean this game is not that expensive but the solar sphere has good presence on the table the art works really nice I really like it a linen finished rule book not that I really care too much of a Robux linen finish but fine you know you want to go the extra mile who would have like something other than Cubes but to keep the cost down it's a nice easy thing to manipulate just to say Cube Cube Cube here or whatever and double layer board yeah production quality pretty sound pretty solid the game it's self also plays quite smoothly once you've got that rules overhead in mind you know the
rounds are not particularly complex there's only four phases to them and most of it is just the uh deploying of dice in turn although the rest of them are kind of like are resolver battle and such so the sphere essentially does what solar storm does it sets out what it wants to do goes out achieves it and is happy with that nothing about it is necessarily original it's not going 120 and giving you like all outstanding outstanding but they're good they're good games they set out it's what it says on the tin here's the tin it's got this on it and you eat it and you go that was good that was good I'd have that again and that's the thing it doesn't taste bad it doesn't have like oh we set out to be a resource management game with some variety and it was some variety in play and a little bit of a dice manipulation okay and then fails on the dice manipulation it doesn't do that it does well at what it does but again much like so the storm this is a good game just not one that I find to be outstanding it does the job there's a bit of rules overhead to get over before you start playing which is probably the one negative I have it's it's kind of like uh you know for a game that's not the heaviest game ever I feel like I'm teaching quite a bit of stuff here I mean that's why I'm a little bit like is this a light game or is this Midway hard to tell I mean it's it's creeping towards Midway in terms of how much rules you need to learn but then once you've got those rules down the game itself is not particularly that heavy it's like you know the choices are relatively straightforward and at the end of the day you're gonna focus on
what it is you want to do but you got to pay attention to what's going on so maybe it is Midway it's hard to tell it's definitely on that borderline and no I don't do this like mid nonsense you know it's like pick light pick mid pick one of the two but it's very hard to pick for this one but the game itself is still solid would I play it again yeah I would play it again if it was on the table if it if people want to play it for the week I'll gladly step in and I would have a good time it's just not one that I would probably keep on the Shelf it's not one that I would bring out you know too often but I would be able to say yeah you want a nice you want a lighter Resource Management game that looks good is well well precised well produced for the price you know it's a decent game so I would give it a 7 out of ten I'd say it's good not amazing but it's good I can give it a seal of endorsement and I can say that if you are a fan of solar storm and you thought oh this feels like a good refresh of something we've seen before but done well then I reckon you'll enjoy this as well it's kind of the exact same thing it's a refresh of stuff we've seen before but done well in a nice little package and it's good to see you know these smaller Publishers come out and do these games and actually produce some decent quality stuff so solosphere 7 out of ten give it a look particularly if you are a fan of solar storm but remember they are different games of course and finally to wrap up this bumper collection of reviews which I swear by the time I do this is gonna have to be multiple episodes I don't think this is going to be a one episode thing but we get to scout this one was
an interesting one because this was a spiliaris nominee and I made the meme at the other one with the Gremlins doing the conga line dance saying that Cascadia as soon as they found out that they were up against Scout and top 10 I thought come on they've got to be celebrating the win already yeah I mean let's face it Cascadia was going to win that hands down top 10 I never saw was going to be that that good a Spiel the Yaris game but I didn't know anything about Scout I thought what is this card game that people that's talking so highly about let's jump into it now being from oink games it means that it costs an arm and a leg because nothing from weight games is ever cheap for some reason but the you know you're talking 20 pound for this tiny little box granted you get some cool chips and some well-produced cards in there but still you're paying a decent price point for these but they're small and they're portable and some of their collection has been pretty good in quirky but I thought right I gotta jump into this and find out what is everybody going on about here because I've heard some good Buzz for this and the fact that it was nominated for spiliaris means that it's got to be good right oh my dear doctor you have been naive oh boy ready to make some enemies yeah I did not see the point of this this just felt like Rummy with extra steps that's literally what this game is it's Rummy with some more restrictive rules in it I mean all you're basically doing in this game is you get a bunch of cards in your hand and they're double effectively double-sided you've got a number on one side and then if you were to turn it
over it would be another number okay great and the idea is is that players are putting out sets so for example I mean if I get a bunch of cards here I can go four a five and a six I could put out a set of three here's my set and then players afterwards are either trying to beat that set and there's various rules for what set beats what or they're scouting which means that when they've got their hand they're going oh I could use that six on the end you know what I'm gonna take that six from you there you go but you can have a scout chip which is a victory point for the fact that I couldn't beat your set eventually that set is getting lower and lower until somebody can eventually beat it and this process keeps rinsing and repeating here's the quirks for this game though the unique selling points firstly the fact that they've got two numbers okay well how does that come into play well when you pick up a card from a set you can turn it whichever way you like the six or the five but at that point it must stay in that way you also cannot change the orientation of any card in your hand so as soon as you've got your hand fixed around that's it that's the way it has to be in that order if you're picking up a scout set it can go alongside something but then it's got to stay there and at the start of the round you'll get dealt your cards and go hmm do I like this hand or do I like that hand so you have that one opportunity to turn your entire hand over and go you know what I prefer this hand okay cool we'll run with that I wanted this to be more prevalent in the game sadly that's the only time you
do it this whole thing where it's like oh I get to turn the card side away that sounds really cool it's literally just one thing you do at the start of the round it's completely pointless because it's basically just a weird fancy way of describing Mulligan essentially because that's all it is you have no basis as to how the round is going to go what sets are going to get played so you don't know if your hand's good or Garbage yeah you're just basically going well that's got barely any sets that one's got slightly more fine I'll turn it over it's just a deluxified mulligan basically and then okay when I take a card I can turn it either way okay that's fairly cool but this box quotes 20 minutes 20 minutes for a game most rounds take 20 minutes let alone a game take in 20 minutes what sorry especially if you're playing this with four or five players no the rounds take 15 to 20 minutes not the entire game this is not a filler by the time you're done with it I feel I mean God it it feels like it in there it feels like it it drags on and on but this game just frustrated me when people are sort of going mad for this game and sort of going oh yeah I really enjoyed this as a quirky game it's Rummy with extra steps except it's more punishing than normal rummy yeah you've got a few more choices than normal running but let's face it is that really a bar that you who kind of quote as being oh we beat the bar of rubby we have extra choices yeah but it's rummy what more did you want but I just found this to be punishing because most of the
time set comes around to me and I'm like well I can't beat that sir because the cards in my hand are John's birthday you are fine one credit for a violation of the verbal morality statute oh I better believe that one out but you know again all right fine I'll just Scout and take I'll just Scout and take your card here okay fine still never that close to a set oh let's come back around oh what a surprise I can't beat it again all right fine I'll Scout and take another card all right well still not exactly great all the while I'm giving other people points so they're getting some mate and I'm getting Zippo and then I go ah finally I can make a set fine here's my four five and six good right fine and then the next players and puts out oh yeah but I've got seven eight nine ten Boom there you go it's like well great that was a thing I didn't know we had a better set but you know somebody else managed to go around the table once or twice before they got their set beaten and I barely get a turn and there's no way I can mitigate that or plan for it it's literally just dumb luck or bad luck in my case and I've played multiple games of this trying to think okay maybe that first game was just bad I played it at Essen and Paul Grogan taught a bunch of her so this was like the first round took 20 minutes seriously what the first round took 20 minutes come on and it was quoted oh yeah that was a weird happenstance because surely the rounds would normally go quicker than that um it wasn't a weird happenstance that happens a lot with a lot of players the game just takes a bit of a while to do but I mean with two or three players maybe it's a lot quicker but frankly I find myself playing this with four or five but I really did not enjoy it from that game so I thought okay I've got to
play a bit more at home let's take it home let's play a bit more maybe I missed something maybe I maybe I didn't get it the first time now I've played it a few more times and believe me I get it at least I'd get the rules and I know how to you know I have won the game before but I don't feel like I won it by crafty play I Won it by dumb luck that's all this game is dumb luck you have a little choice at the start of a round which means nothing but a mulligan who cares you then have the only choice really being can I make the set or not if so is there any card in there that would be good for me yes or no if there isn't you've still got a scout in which case you're taking the rubbish card that's meaningless but if there's a card that you like fine I'll take it but then other times it's just a case of the set comes round can I beat it yes or no it's not like I can do some crafty tactical play or go oh I can gauge what you're doing engage what you're doing and get in your mindset no it's just Rummy with extra stats let the heat flow through you oh I'm getting frustrated just talking about it no I don't get this this was a Spiel the yara's nominee are you kidding me this was a Spiel the yara's nominee Cascadia if I literally had played this game and then later on play Cascadia and then you told me that the two of them were going head-to-head in The Spill the Yaris nobody I would literally be like if you like the game fine but you know we can all like different games but this I don't just I don't just find average
or mere I don't like this game I think it's bad I I don't I can't really say it's a one or a two because I don't think it's that I don't know it's making me angry but I don't think it's quite that bad but I'm giving this a 3 out of ten three out of ten I think this is just bad I don't find this game that interesting I don't find it you know to be anything more than some little Quirk that they throw in about the different orientation of the cards which most of the time is just a tiny bit of luck mitigation or a mulligan as I say and I wanted this to be the Forefront I wanted a game where I was like continuously going all right I'm gonna turn my hand this way now okay and then as the game goes on I'm like you know what it'd be better if my hand was this way around now and do it multiple times in a round not just once at the start of a round when I have no information to go on that's pointless you might as well give me a random hand of cards I go like this and then I just go through there's my hat makes the same amount of difference I don't know I don't get this it's well produced you've got some cool tokens it definitely you know fits in a small package and it's not a it's not a complex game but people do trip up on the first game trying to think okay so what exactly am I trying to do here and it's like well you're just trying to beat cards that's all it is maybe that was the intention maybe that was it maybe it was literally just trying to be Rummy with extra steps in which case you succeeded great but then don't put yourself up as a spill the Yaris nominee we can do better okay
I'm probably gonna get a lot of hate for this but sorry I didn't like this game three out of ten Scout wasting my money did not like it it's going out of the collection fast and there we go what a note to end on eh all those reviews and I end on my worst game of the lot but that's just the thing with these I mean I had so many games here to review World Exchange of solosphere fantasy Realms Vengeance World splitter canopy one iron ores or whatever you pronounce it Scout there was a ton of stuff to get reviewed and it was a good even mix of good and bad Scout really didn't like Vengeance kind of a bit of a dud for me canopy though really loved World exchangers a good surprise fantasy Realms Deluxe great if you can afford it but a great filler Game World Splitters solo Spear and when I remote good charming and they do what they say on the tin just not outstanding so good mix of reviews there either for good mixer ratings I'm sure many of you are going to come down on hard on me for this possibly even the Vengeance but as I say we all like different game that's just the way it is but it's a good thing that even though this is going to take a lot of time to edit and a lot of time to get these out I mean I'm sure this is going to be like four episodes or something because I don't want to have a 60 Minute video of this I'm probably gonna have to split this up into four parts or something but it's good to have got a bunch of these out but that's not like I've oh now I've got no games to review I've still got to do endless winter northgard heat possibly wolves converter expansion Meadow expansion I got a lot of content to do and that's
before we even get to the top 10 of the year that's a lot to get done but a video like this just helps it helps me get stuff done you know in the time that I've got this is why the top 100 moved to a different time period because this probably won't be a thing next time but we'll see but anyway hope you've enjoyed all those videos hope they were good fun whether I was raving or ranting about a particular game but by all means get your comments Down Below in all those four videos you know I haven't bothered to do a an outro to every single one I've just done it as a four-parter but get your comments on these videos let me know your thoughts on all the games good or bad I'm sure you're going to disagree with me on a bunch of these but by all means and when I hear your reasoned thoughts as to why you love or hate these particular games but of course like them share them on social media like him on Board Game Geek if I can get them on Board Game Geek board game geek's a bit funny when you try to put up compilation videos up there but we'll see we'll see what I can do but like I say just hope you enjoyed watching and of course there's plenty more content to come so that's it for me I'll see you on the next broken meeple episode and if you like what you see you can check out more content on the channel including reviews I have done for deal with the devil but also the collaboration video I did with all aboard gamer where we talk about 10 overrated games in our humble opinions okay but yeah you want to hear us rant about a bunch more games just like I did with Scout there's a bunch on there but like I say Different Strokes different folks take care and remember as always regardless of which game you like at the
end of the day there's still only games bye for now use your aggressive feelings boy