Architects of the Colosseum - First Play Review
Transcript
Hey there, I'm Jonathan with Getting Games and these are my first play opinions for the Architects of the Colosseum. Now, what you're going to watch here was recorded live with the Patreon supporters of the channel. And if you'd like to learn more about that and also see the hundreds of other segments I've talked about for games, then please go to gettingames.com/support. Now, if you have thoughts about this game, then please leave those as comments down below. Also, if you enjoy the video, then please click the like button and the subscribe button for the channel. All right, let's talk about the game. All right, Architects of the uh Coliseum. I almost said West Kingdom. Architects of the Coliseum. This game came out in 2016 and uh this one was pitched to me by my good friend Anastasia who is here in the chat and uh she taught this game to me. Now, the pitch for this one was designed by Klaus Jurgen Reed, aka the designer of Carcassone, which I adore, but also the designer of Bali, which is a game she taught to me like a month and a half ago, two months ago. I've talked about Bali here on the channel and I went to great lengths in that to say I loved the action selection in the game and I really didn't like how things scored.
Well, apparently like 12 years later or whatever, uh, Klaus Jurgen Reed designed a game using that same action selection system with a different way to score things and I was so excited to play this game. So, let's talk about how it plays. It's a very straightforward game. Uh, the way this works is probably going to sound familiar if you know Bali or you saw my Bali episode. Uh, when it's your turn, you are going to be moving this piece around a rondell. The rondell isn't in Bali, but when you stop, you are either going to do some set collection, uh, or I guess kind of cashing in recipe fulfillment, or you're going to take a token from this board. Let's zoom in a little bit. So, with this um this piece, if you moved it over here, for example, you could take this forest tile that's the closest one to the board. You take that one and you put it in front of you.
You're kind of building a tableau. You line them up based off of their type. This is just like Bali. Then, just like Bali, you're going to activate the next tile in that line. So, in this case, you take a forest and then you activate all of the forests. But if the marker was over here, you would take a farm and then activate all mountains cuz mountain is the next one. And when I say all, I do mean that every single player is going to activate them. So once again, if you go here and take the the farm and then activate mountains, I'm going to activate my mountains. Uh Anastasia across the table is going to activate mountains. Jessica, who's over here to my left, is going to activate the mountains as well. So you're trying to build out your tableau because this generates you stuff. Every piece that you have is going to give you a card of that color. You keep it in your hand. And so you're trying to build up your engine, but you're also trying not to give too much stuff to your opponents.
Now, interestingly, if you get nothing when somebody goes, like, let's say Anastasia goes and then uh activates mountains and I have no mountains, I can get a victory point. You just take a victory point whenever you don't take something. In fact, if you could take something, like if forests were activated, instead of taking two forest cards into my hand, I could take a victory point. This is a fascinating element to this game. The winning scores seem to be in my two plays like in the 50s, 40s, like kind of around there. So getting a point here or there is significant, but getting the cards is more important. And the reason for that is because instead of taking one of these things and building up your tableau when you move on the rondelle, you can cash in recipe fulfillment for these little uh pieces of the coliseum. So like for example, this one, if you moved right here, you could pay two green cards from your hand and two blue cards. You would then get four points and then you actually slot it into the board uh which is inside the box. So, you were actually constructing the coliseum. This is completely superfluous.
The only reason this here is eye candy. It looks cool. Like, there's no reason not to do it. It looks really neat. This is also the endgame timer. As soon as the coliseum is completely built, the game ends immediately. So, it is slightly useful, but this could have just been a track. But, I'm so glad that they built this because it looks so neat on the table, even though it means the insert underneath here is a total pain, but whatever. So, coming back over here, um, another thing to keep in mind is your hand limit. Uh, you start the game only being able to hold four cards, but you can increase that based off of landing in this spot right here in the middle. Uh, you also have these wheels in front of you that you can spend to go further on the rondelle, which I really enjoy. So, that's the mechanics of the game. That that's essentially the game in a nutshell. There's a couple more things going on, like a 3:1 cash in and whatnot, but you're going to play it like this. The game takes like 40-ish minutes and I played it twice. Both times were at three players and I really enjoyed both of these plays. I did win both of them. Wait, did I win the second one? I don't remember. Anyway, I definitely won the first one and it was close. Um, but I really enjoyed both of these plays because I love this action selection system. I loved it in Bali and I love it here. I love that in this game the way you choose things is based off of a rondelle that you can manipulate.
Oh, I didn't mention you could go further on this rondell by just spending victory points. So, you could always go anywhere on here. The question is, how many wheels do you have to spend? And how many victory points are you willing to spend to do that, which I think is so cool. You have all of this flexibility. It's such a flexible game. And I love getting stuff when it's not my turn. I love that element of somebody goes onto a spot, they activate mountains, and I get stuff on my turn. I get those mountains. Or worst case, I get a victory point. Thanks for the point. That just feels good. So, we played it at three both times. Uh Jessica was in both of these games, and it was her feeling that she didn't love it at three. It seemed like there's no player count balancing. It seems like the you just set the game up, you play the game, it's the same game from all player counts. Anastasia has played it at two and four uh as well. I've only played it at three, but it did seem like this rondelle maybe should have been like a different number of spaces with the different player counts. It seemed like very often you would go, the next person would go, then next person, it comes back to you, and the person with the Rondell piece would be in about the same spot. Like very frequently, it's like every single turn, I I start in like these two locations. I want to get out of this part of the board and get somewhere else. Of course, you can by spending your wheels and spending your victory points. And that might jostle things around a little bit, and now you just spend a few turns starting over here. It just felt like that happened in a three-player game. And supposedly, according to Anastasia, that doesn't really happen at two and four. She really liked it at two and four players as well. Um, after the first play, I liked it and she gifted the game to me, so I now have it, which is why I was able to play it again. And I'm going to
be keeping this one around. This is a weight that I really like. This is like a 10ish minute teach. It's like a 40 45minute game, which means it's like an hour total, which is a great chunk of time to play a game where you're getting stuff back and forth. Generally, I'm not a huge fan of recipe fulfillment. like this is the weakest part of the game, but I don't actively dislike it like I did in Bali, which had some memory elements and majorities. There's no majorities in this game. It just has the awesome action selection system and then a tacked on good enough recipe fulfillment thing to make it all work. So, I like it a lot. It's going to be sticking around. Uh Klaus Jurgen Reed continues to be a designer that I really like and he's designed a lot more games, so I should probably look into more of those and give those a go. Yeah. Uh Riy pointed out it's a chunky marker. It is a really chunky marker. I like it a lot even though it's kind of hard to fit into the uh the insert. Uh Anastasia says the get points if you get nothing or don't want stuff rule really threw us off. It seemed almost too friendly when you read the rules, but it works very well in practice. Yeah, I agree. It essentially means on every player's turn, you get something as long as they didn't cash things in, which means you kind of always engaged, which is nice. I mean, there's very little downtime in this game, but even so, you are just always engaged and always getting stuff.