Skip to main content
Loading video...

Sicily '43 Impressions | Assault Games | World War 2 Tactical Wargame Review

Transcript 20:44

hi everybody I'm zitz and welcome today I thought I would offer up my Impressions on Sicily 43 from assault games I've spent about 15 hours now playing the game in about 5 hours kind of reading through the rules and learning the game and kind of exploring the components and things so I I'm I hesitate to call this a full review because there's elements of the game I haven't looked at like offboard artillery uh close combat that much and then I haven't played The Campaign which is a huge part of this package but I've spent enough time with the game and a bunch of people asked for my impressions as we were posting the playthrough of the game on the channel so I thought I would make this short video to touch on some of the aspects and share my thoughts on the game and on the system as they stand right now let's do a brief overview of the game before we start digging in this assault Sicily 43 is the second game in the assault games system first was Red Horizon 41 which was Eastern Front this game takes the combat to the Western Front specifically Sicily in 1943 and more specifically the action surrounding the jell Beach head forces in this core package are German and Italian forces against US forces there are plans underway to add British forces as an expansion to this module this game is a tactical World War II combat game you've got individual squads individual individual Vehicles fighting it out over a plethora of scenarios as well as an extensive Dynamic Campaign which is really kind of probably the one of the hearts of the strengths of this game box package so Impressions let's start out first up the physical components themselves I think are worth calling out

here because they are uh particularly of note both in terms of functional design and in terms of visual appeal in particular I really like the maps they're heavy cardboard that very thick cardboard and you can put them together in all sorts of different ways to make all sorts of different shapes the the visual presentation of the terrain just looks really cool and gritty and tactical and it's the kind of maps are such a big factor right in terms of drawing in interest and appeal and a good map makes you look at it and you want to play the game these Maps succeed at that you look at it you're like oh I just want to play with this you know it just makes you want to put your hands on it put them together and set up a battle and get going likewise I think the units and the unit cards are really really good and I want to mention those in combination because I think there's something to be said that connects to the visual appeal and the artistic design behind this is the the hexes are really large and you've got hex-shaped counters that fit on the hex's and give you space to add like little terrain components like trenches and stuff like that but the stacking rules are also really light like there's very few circumstances under which you're going to have more than one unit in a hex like vehicle transport and close combat are two of those most common exceptions but for the most of the time you're going to have one unit in a hex the hexes are nice and big so you can see the terrain behind the unit for the most part and then all of the unit information sits on cards and these cards are you just arranged on the outside of the game play so as you're looking at the map and

playing the game it's got you I I don't really feel like Miniatures is the right word for it but you could very easily use Miniatures to play this system right because everything is visually represented visually represent in front of you you don't have any stacking so units are buried under particular Stacks you're not fiddling through them it's easy on the fingers and all the unit information off the outside makes it a very clean visual environment for the player to be able to look at the map understand what's going on and understand the decision Matrix that they're operating with visually I think the design and the art come together to this game to make it a really fun experience to just parse and look at so I'm starting to repeat myself but to summarize that visual presentation combined with some of the game design decisions really make it for a beautiful environment to play a tactical game in the other thing that I don't think can be understated is just how much is is in this box I me you got tons of maps tons of units tons of unit cards formation cards you've got a campaign scenarios and I think it's worth mentioning now too about so so I think all of this stuff is replayable but one of the things that really I think highlights this system is the way they use formations in the game and so you might have a scenario that's going to bring together say you know two infantry formations in an armor formation for the Germans against two armor formations infantry formation for the US forces say or something or the axis forces US

forces however it works out and those you have formation cards and you basically pick your formation or you could do it randomly or you could do it your opponent picks I mean there's so many ways you could take this formation system and play with it and that means that every time you play a scenario depending upon the formations that you've picked you could pick completely different infantry formations for example and get a completely different interplay of units almost feeling like a completely different scenario so the formation cards here just make this a Sandbox game it's very much I think a system purchase in that there is almost unlimited gameplay here I mean this is kind of a desert island game you could take this and play this for hundreds of hours just with different combinations Maps making your own scenarios playing The Campaign which is branching and forking is going to be different every time I mean there's just so much stuff in the package that allows for a great variety of gameplay and that brings us to gameplay I want to divide it up into two parts because I have a lot to say about combat and I want to save that for the end but everything else movement the back and forth nature of it creates this Dynamic fun toplay system so you know basically you each side is activating units in sequence and it's dep based on based on your command and control and different elements so there's so much back and forth between the games so as a player playing two-player you're not waiting for your opponent to be done for well it's it's a fast playing game where you're constantly engaged and you constantly stay in touch with with the

action which I think is a really fun way to build a tactical system soliter 2 there isn't a dedicated bot for this but it works really well there's some Minefield elements here that I think you'd have to work around with but those don't show up in very many scenarios and they're easy to figure out as a soliter player so playing BT sides soliter because of the back and forth nature I find this a really fun experience and I would definitely recommend it to a soliter player now I want to talk about the combat where I'm going to spend most of the time in this Impressions video because I think there's a lot to say about it and I've had a lot of thoughts about it and I've got a lot a longer experience with this I don't think I can do this quickly so sit back and relax if you're interested in listening to some thoughts and random musings on the combat system first off this is a very unique system I've not played with a system like this in a tactical combat game like this and the way it works is you've got colored dice of different strengths R red is the strongest or the most kind of deadly diey if you would all the way down to the blue Dy which is the weakest Dy of all of them so you get red yellow green blue and as you're calculating combat you know you're looking at the the range of the unit firing and you're going to pick out certain set of colored Dice and then the unit has defensive characteristics and you're going to be adding Dice and you create a pool of attack Dice and defensive Dice and then both sides both players roll their Dice and then you use a matching up system to basically knock off the results so if the attacker scores a critical hit and two hits and a suppression over however many dice they

roll the defender might roll like two hits and a suppression but not roll a critical hit and you match those up the the matching ones negate each other what's ever left over in excess on the attacking side causes damage to the defending unit so as you're calculating combat you're factoring and everything runs through this system right so it's range it's the defensive characteristics of the unit the terrain the unit is any intervening terrain things like smoke and stuff like that is the unit dug in is the unit digging in has the unit just had a fast action movement you've got a spotting mechanic that is done for a good number of the combat situations depend upon the def depending upon the defensive status of the unit so this is a a rather detailed process to evaluate each firing opportunity this is for ranged combat again for each firing opportunity in the game what you end up with is kind of a mathless combat system which I found as I played the game more was really cool because I realized how often our tactical combat games and War Games in general are dependent upon odds and math and combat points and factors and so a lot of times when I play other games I'm thinking okay I've got a strength of combat strength of seven if I add this unit and I'll get to a combat strength of nine their defensive strength is three it's got a one colum shift well if I bring in this air power I can shift the column back so you're doing a lot of things in most games that have numbers in your head and this game takes the numbers out now there of course is math behind this system but

it's not readily apparent to the player as you're doing it but what happens as you play more and this is where I think is the the real strength of the combat system is that you're getting this kind of organic feel and the decisions you're making for me felt more connected to kind of tactical decisions a Combat Commander or a squad leader would be making in a certain situation right so you're thinking okay I've got this certain Firepower and it's like oh red red yellow that's pretty strong that's a strong defensive unit though they're got a pretty good position we might not have any success and oh we got a fire through smoke and stuff like that but maybe I can have this other Squad beside us add in and that's going to give us a little bit better chance so your your brain becomes kind of grounded more in the Tactical decisions rather than in the numbers behind those decisions like you know the closer you are the better you're going to be and you can see that represented in strong ER and more dice perhaps but you don't get locked into that math behind it which is a really really fun way for me to play a tactical combat game it feels like the decisions the math doesn't get in the way it feels like the decisions are more directly connected to the Tactical decisions you'd be making on a battlefield and that in itself I think is a really really fun thing to experience in a tactical combat system it's really cool that's what I really like about the combat system and that's why I think it's really the heart and this of the superpower behind this system is this

color die system that doesn't rely on numbers that relies on types of hits and strength of dice okay but this this system comes with the cost and that cost is something I want to talk about but before I talk about the that cost to this system I need to talk about what in particular is unique about my experience with the game I think it's very important for me to state that as I was learning combat I got a prototype from about three months ago or so and the core nature of the gameplay hasn't changed since that prototype that I received but what has changed is a lot of work done clarifying the rules organizing the rules organizing the player AIDS revising the player AIDS so the interface by which the player interacts with the game in the course of the three months that I've had the game has vastly improved so I think that's really important to understand because I think if you're getting this as part of the kickstarter your experience learning the game is going to be very different from my experience learning the game because you're going to have the updated and improved player AIDS and the updated and improved rulebook experience and that I think played a big factor in some of the things that I was experienc experiencing as I was trying to learn this game and and that gets to the next part which is really that there isn't any other way for me to say this I found this a hard game to wrap my head around the combat system not from a conceptual standpoint I felt like that was easy but the fact that there just are so many factors involved

in calculating arranged combat um you know you've got the strength of the unit the defensive strength of the unit the terrain of the unit the units in intervening hexes that are inside whether you need to spot the unit and the spotting of the unit has actually a diroll that has diroll modifiers to it depending upon intervening terrain whether the unit has done a fast action in the previous turnover is under a fast action uh whether it's got dug in or not dug in the unit's experience level the defending units experience level there are a number of factors the unique characteristics of the unit some units have on their cards unique characteristics of combat so there are a lot of factors and as I was learning the game I felt like the rule it was hard for me to pull to find that information in one place that was reliable so I often found myself digging in the rules and I couldn't find something or looking on the player Aid and saying well it's not on this player Aid I can't find it and then it's it it was just a process that I felt like I was two or three hours in it's like wow this feels really hard for me to execute it was just taking a long time it's not so much that it was hard to execute it was just taking a long time to get the information I needed and figure out the process for rain ranged combat in a way that felt smooth so it felt like I was struggling at that aspect of the game now what also happened during this time was there was a lot of play testing going on I I mean I was playing the game and I know a bunch of other people playing the game and if you know one thing about assault games and the team

behind the game I don't I'm not sure I've seen a game Design Studio that works as fast and as hard as these guys do because I would say hey I I'm a little bit struggling here you know I'd send off like a a communication say I'm a little bit struggling here this I don't understand this rule or this feels a little bit complex I'm not quite sure where the information is and they'll say okay I'll red I I see what you're saying let me redo that and I figured okay it's going to be like a week later that I'm going to get this stuff back and then literally within an hour like this whole thing would be redesigned it's like here I'm like what how many people do you have work like how did you do that so fast and it would solve the problem you know and so I and then I would get updates to rules that were happening from other people playing and stuff like that and player AIDS and stuff like that and by the time I got to the end of that three-month process and I'll talk about this part momentarily uh the information is so much better organized the player AIDS I really like the player Aid now it's got everything I need on it it's so much faster to execute the combat it's so much easier to understand what's going on and I feel like the that's going to change the nature of the people's learning experiences that go beyond the Prototype that I've got so the final version I think that experience will be better I I think kind of highlighting my experience in learning the combat might help with some of this so at the 1 to 4our Mark I felt like I was struggling with the combat system it was taking a long long time to executed I was having difficulty finding stuff in the rules the player AIDS felt like they had some information the rule book felt like it had some information but there wasn't a complete set in both places so it was just it was it was hard

to execute and it was taking a long time to execute a fire ranged combat for me to the point it's like wow this is it's a lot of work right um and then kind of like after I'm going to say like four to eight hours or so of gameplay the rules started to kind of come together in a different organized format the player AIDS started to come together and be different the kind of the evolution of the player AIDS over the course of those three months uh and I was looking at it's like oh this is starting to come together right it's it started to feel better it wasn't taking as long to calculate range combat but still even for me up to like that eight hour mark it's like this is still kind of a lot of a lot of time involved a lot of things to do and I was forgetting things and omitting things and leaving things out and stuff like that or getting little things wrong it's like I didn't feel like I really had that combat system down to the place where I could play a game and it flowed really really organically as I feel like a tactical combat system should but then the player AIDS kind of reached their their most evolved state the rule book came together and I mean constant like little iterate iterative changes and then some big changes along the way I feel like the rule book and the player AIDS have really crystallized over the last three months of the game's development but as those came together and as I started kind of Crossing that eight hour mark roughly everything came together the gameplay crystallized and I got to the point where I could execute that combat really fast but I do think it's worth saying that the the amount of steps in the combat system until you get up to speed with that it's still going to feel like you've got kind of a learning curve to cross so the combat system in essence

I think is the greatest strength because it's so cool and when you get to that end point where you don't need the math it's I feel like it's faster than executing combat in other systems you know well because you don't really have to do math you're just like okay red red yellow oh green for that okay green for this okay red for this red for this put them together roll them done it's super fast once you get to the level of being able to execute it well but it is going to take you time and that's the weakness I think is that I think it would be easy to experience this game get like two or three hours in and say wow I I really you know this combat system is taking me a long time and it's feels like work to kind of get up to speed with it and to say h i kind of give up you know and so the the other element to this again too is that if you're buying this game you're buying it as a systems purchase so I think for me when I'm buying a game as a system purchase like that I'm more willing to invest that time to get up to the point where I can execute the game well and I don't have I mean everyone's going to be different right some people will probably take longer than me some people will be a lot faster than than me for sure but I think you want to expect if you start digging in and when you start digging in and if you're going to buy this game that there's going to be an element of time it takes for you to get up to speed with the combat system with the ranged combat right this isn't really talking about the close combat or the offboard artillery and things like that or the the campaign rules but that heart of the game and heart of ATT tacal system again is that ranged combat and it's going to take some time I think before you get up to speed with it hopefully that makes sense those are all my thoughts and Impressions with the game and with in particular the combat

system but I felt like it wasn't an easy thing to just say combat's great right or combat's complicated because it's both of those things so it's GNA take time uh and again I think within that context of the rules evolving as I was playing it I I think think people who go next will have an easier experience of it and maybe even learn substantially faster than I did but we come to the final Point like would I recommend this game do I think this game is good did I have a fun time playing it I had a I had a really fun time playing it when I got to the point where I could execute the gameplay fast like really fun like this is cool I can't wait to play wait to play the campaign I'm going to wait for the final version because the Prototype that I have has evolved a lot in terms of some of the numbers on the units and the unit visual presentation so I'm going to wait to play the campaign game until the final version but I am really excited for the campaign game for the system and also for the future of the game I know that there's uh the assault games has signed a production agreement with sound of drums to help with that so they can focus more on the design elements uh they're incredibly hardworking and dedicated team to making this game and making this system the best it can be so I think that over time going forward uh this has an incredible amount of Promise as a World War II tactical combat system and it's living up to it already in terms of it's just it's a fun system it's very unique I love the diceless combat system uh when you get to that point where you can execute it really fast it's just a fun experience the visual presentation the

unit cards the stacking it all comes together this is a really cool system and I can't wait to play it more so yes I would recommend it but you do want to be ready you got to get over that hump you got to get fluent at executing the range combat and it these types of things may apply to the Tactical combat and the offboard artillery too I haven't again Impressions video not a full review so there may be learning curves with those systems too that I just haven't really bumped into yet but once you get those things down I think this is going to be a game that is just uh a joy to play it is a joy to play I really in particular the back half of the scenario that I did with the video series on it was like kind of when it all came together for me I'm like a this is really cool so yeah thumbs up for me I think this is a really fun system I'm excited to see the future I'm excited to get that final version to play it more let me know if you have questions down below I'll answer them to the best of my ability if you're interested in seeing more of the game here is a link to episode one in our playthrough thanks for watching everybody

Progress saved