Village Big Box - Review For Two
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are doing an on-camera review which is not something we usually do and we're talking about Village big box that's an important part of that as well usually what we do is we write a script then we record that script and we do photos of every aspect of that script and we edit those photos and we put all that together when we make a video and it takes us like five-ish success hours but we got a lot more games that we want to talk about so we're going to try to do some of these live on camera ones as well and see if it's a bit of a different Dynamic and hopefully we can talk about a few more games than we usually talk about so we are starting with Village big box and it plays one to five players takes two players about an hour to play and the village big box has all of the expansions included and in it you are essentially starting off as a of family you've got a few members of the first generation and as you go along you are performing actions like getting horses and visiting the various like traveling around all kinds of things but your first generation slowly get older time passes they die away new family members come into play as well and you're hoping that enough family members are kind of historied or like chronicled you want to kill enough people that you get enough points while keeping enough other people alive that they could do some stuff
which sounds Grim but it's not that Grim let's actually let's look at how it plays and then we'll come back and talk about it a bit more in Village you start with a farmyard of first generation of family members in a main board filled with little cubes each turn you will be taking one of those cubes from any location on the board and then performing that location's action these include gaining wheat adding family members moving up the council chambers so selling Goods at the market traveling to visit other towns sending people to church or visiting the craft buildings where you can gain items many of the actions force you to place one of your family members and or spend time which is meant to represent the passing years of the village and every time your time goes past midnight you have to choose one of your lowest numbered family members to die and be memorialized forever in the town Chronicle or if the place where they worked is already full in the unmarked graves in town the game ends once either the chronicle or the graveyard is full and then everybody adds up points from the deals they made in the market The Villages they visited on the Travel board the family members in the church and at the Town Council their leftover coins and everyone they enshrined in the chronicle and then the greatest family is named so that's how it plays and you probably saw a lot of
pictures of it so let's start with how it looks and this is a little little bit controversial because they redid All of the art for the big box version yeah everything it used to be much more euro-y much more I don't know if Franz Clemens did it but it was a very intimate style yeah yeah and so this one a lot more colors I like the colorful aspect I think the actions are a bit clearer it just more bright to me but I think you kind of prefer the older style I'm torn on it I really am torn because I like I like that kind of classic board game art I am a sucker for that sort of artwork for sure but when and when I first saw this I thought oh I kind of wish it was the old one I know a lot of people did as well I saw that in the forums but when I played it I just thought I get it now like it is just it's so much cleaner it's so much easier especially in the uh in the work buildings here it's just it's really clear and it there was there's like a charm in the muddledness of the older one it's not model like it's still clear enough but the clarity of this really does help especially when you add all of these expansions as well yeah yeah and just one more thing though about the components too is I really like for the big box that the chronicle comes as a separate book which is just lovely as opposed to being a bit on the board and the bags and everything included are really nice as well they are they're all really top quality yeah in this book so
what it used to be is the bottom part of this board just had kind of a printed on book and you put them on loosely and now it's got this you know double layered so it's nicely inset and it's so clear how many players it's with and just this you know being able to close it this is just a really nice touch and I think there's a lot of these in this game as well the player boards are double layered now that the inboard doesn't like plump on top it sits kind of nicely off to the if you have a big enough table it connects and even that the the travel so it used to be that the Port board would go over the top so if you want to use this travel or if you want to use the port but now oh you just flip it over and then you would use the port on the other side because you can never use both at the same time anyway so that's really nice too and what do you because the big selling point of this big box is that it's a big box so it's got all the stuff in its big box this is everything that there has ever been for Village plus some more stuff so in Port marriage is a new one as well as gold cards as well as just a few little bits and pieces of extra stuff as well but what do you think about all of the expansions I really like having it included it adds a lot to replayability because it can feel a bit the same but now you can choose to add one or you can choose to add two one time we added three and I think that was too many
um but you can easily add a couple to mix things up and they do all feel really different for the port side you've got to hire a captain and you got a pre-stock your boat with the goods that you want to deliver so it takes a little bit more forward planning for the marriage you you go there and you hope you're going to end up in a marriage ceremony yeah it's kind of like a partner like floating about looking for people or something I like to picture that there is like one of those old like matchmakers yes that's trying to trying to connect up um the spinsters together but yeah it is it's it's kind of funny how it works mechanically yeah but it it works well and the bonus for that is if you get matched up then you get bread or tools which is an interesting new element they've added in and if you end up in family housing that's a way to get new members of the Next Generation which is kind of neat as well and then the in expansion adds beer that you're brewing and it also adds these cards that can either be immediate use cards that can come in quite handy or actually end game scoring cards cards so give you another Target to work towards yeah and I really like that as well another part of the expansion that I really like is just the end game goals because it differentiates this game it already kind of has quite a bit of replayability just inherently but that adds just that little bit extra like something to Target towards which I
think we both really like but the the end game goals are generally the ones I go for for the in as well because it just bumps up the scoring a little bit like a lot of them make you know the travel scoring this scores for how many different cities you've visited and on here maybe it's six points for three cities but if you get this whoever it might be you bump that up to getting like 10 points for three cities which is a big big bump in this game because this is a game that at least for us we tend to score somewhere like 80 90-ish points it really depends on how many expansions you have but with 80 points you know four or five points that's a big chunkier point it came and it's interesting when you said end game goals because they do happen at the end but one of the new additions for the big box is like the lifetime goals that you can get at the beginning and so those are interesting too because there are two different levels so you can do one that is something to Target towards at some point in the game you might just have to have certain number of resources at any point and when you have that you score those points but there is also the one that you can do for the end of the game and that gives you a bit of a route to try and aim towards because I think that is one thing that this is lacking a little bit is when I went into it I kind of thought there'd be a sense of like this is my family and maybe they're specializing in a certain area and that knowledge is getting passed down across the generations and that's that's not it it's a very interesting mechanic and it's nice that it's not like being sad when people die but the end game goals
at least gives a little bit towards of like throughout the generations you are maybe working towards this one product at the end that was one of the tricky parts for me the first time that I played it because when I heard about this game I thought that there was going to be this big narrative structure of people getting older and wiser and then slowly dying out but them being kind of like family members and I don't know maybe the other family members grieved them by this whole picture of this narrative structure and that is not what's in this and that makes sense I don't know how you would have done that part of it it would be a totally different game so you kind of have to realize that your people like your ones are gonna die first just because they got ones on their tummies so you want to put them in places where you want them to die because you want them to end up in the right parts of this here Chronicles so if Jess has killed two of her workers already and she's filled the two workspaces yeah that there's no more workers to be remembered they're the only remembered ones so now the other ones go to this sad like poppers gray Mark graveyard and they're forgotten forever and they don't get you any points so I want to be able to move this guy over to like my farm or over to somewhere else so that they'll die there because they die in order because the ones are the oldest um so it's interesting but it doesn't quite have that narrative element but it has a really interesting mechanical element you just got to realize that your people are kind of resources yes
and what is interesting is it feels like a very simple decision on your turn because you do just pick a cube and add a spot and at that spot you perform that action but there is a lot to decide with where to go so some of it is that maybe you want a particular colored Cube so that might influence your decision another would be the action that you want to perform so that would influence it another one would be if you want to spend time because maybe there's a bit of a race about who can be chronicled next so I do want my worker to get older and die and end up in the book and another one is if you even have a worker because if you don't have somebody to put out then you do have to spend the cube so you're factoring in all of this at the same time yeah because there's only one space that really gives you more work or so workers are are very valuable resource that's the interesting thing with the marriage board is that it gives you a way that you're gaining new workers each turn without using the worker space but otherwise we spend a lot of time getting three extra matching cubes because you can always spend those to do any action you want um and like you were saying the being able to take it like the dual action of taking the cube initiates the action but the cube you take is also the resource that initiates that action super interesting and it is totally it's such a race game this is a race to kill your family this is a race to fill up that book and a race to get things done you
want your family to be remembered and that is signified in the chronicle because that can be worth a lot of points for them to end up there and part of that race too is thinking about what the other players are going to do so some key spots are like the market action there's only ever one Cube there so it could be that I wasn't going to do the market action first but I did have Goods that I could sell and I see that Sean doesn't in which case maybe I'll do that first so that he doesn't get the chance to do the market action so there is that little bit of trying to maybe block spots or anticipate what the other person's gonna do yeah it's it's a sort of game it's a sort of interaction I think that we generally like where there's not a there's not any real take that no but there certainly is I see that you definitely want this space you often just will look at oh Shawn has no family members I'm going to the family member thing three turns in a row if you want a family member you have to go there or I'm taking them all um so there's that sort of thing a lot or I will even see like oh Jessica's got two pink Cubes but she's gonna need an orange Cube if she wants to travel from this place to this place I'm not giving her that orange Cube I'm going to take that orange Cube or the black cubes actually move your time as well so those ones you kind of want to stick other people with as well so and and the terms are so fast that I'm never worried like oh I don't get to do something for a
while but everything you do affects me yeah in some way and even if it doesn't it's my turn again in like 30 seconds so I'm not that worried yeah so that brings us to player account really and we've only played this at two players so that's a bit of our caveat and love it at two players because of all of that you're able to plan enough of your actions but you're also able to get in the way a little bit of the other player because it's only one other player you're worried about but I think it would play really well at more as well and it does open it up so the end game triggers are the chronicle being full or the graveyard being full and so at more players there's more of those spaces to put people uh so it would it would I think work and it's really easy to set up there's different cards for different player counts depending on you know what expansions you using and how many cubes go where so I I do I do think it would work uh but as from our experience as a two-player game it's great I I totally agree I think that this is going to play pretty much the same because there isn't any of that really direct interaction but there is all of that loose interaction um it's really just gonna be like if it's 40 minutes for two players it's going to be 60 Minutes for three players 80 minutes for four players but it moves so fast that I don't think you're gonna mine much if there are more people yeah but also I don't know how much it adds it gives you a little bit more opportunity perhaps to specialize because obviously if there are five players and there's four spaces in one of these and someone really does a lot
of this early they can really that's true fill this up so maybe that would be part of it especially with the travel that could be part of it there also might be a bit more of a race to to the market and also to this red building that I don't I think it's like a government building but to these two buildings there might be a little bit more of a race and maybe even a little bit more of a competition here at the uh Abbey or whatever it is is because whoever's the highest on here yeah gets two points gets two points so that could be a bit more of a competition as well but I think if you play the two you're never gonna feel like oh I'm missing out on the full game and if you play it with more I don't think you're gonna think oh I think this is too long it could go quicker too I think you're gonna be happy no matter what counts yeah I would be interested to try with more specifically for the marriage expansion yes because I think that adds an interesting element instead of adding just kind of a random Wanderer it's going to be probably be another player that's actually a really good point with the expansions the both marriage and the end because there may be a race for those it's not necessarily like there are cards that are always going to be better but there are certainly games where some of these cards are going to be much better for somebody so this could be more of a race this could be more of a race and because the placement as well whoever is higher up on this loses out like the odd the odd person doesn't get married off if there's an odd number so that could certainly play
into it and people are going to bet more because if you go in a lower space you have a better chance of getting married but you also get worse stuff but let's also talk about just who who is this for what who do you think are going to be the players who are really into this game I think this Falls nicely in that mid-weight slightly higher than mid-weight Euro category so I think it works really well for people who have played more of the lighter Medium games like maybe a wingspan are looking for the next step without it being too heavy but also for people who play heavier games that want a little bit something a bit lighter that still has a lot of strategy and enough of a sense of decision making I think this fits in there as well yeah this isn't one I would like take home for the holidays to play with my non-gaming family that's for sure but it is it it could really be an entry point for people like like you say who just want that kind of next bump up and I think it fills kind of a slightly different Niche like we were thinking what other games is this like yeah and I can't really like a lot of times I can think of an almost one-to-one comparison it but here not really it's got a little bit of a feel of Istanbul if you played Istanbul which you kind of want to say is a work replacement but it isn't quite a worker placement and you're kind of like people are kind of a resource and you're kind of trying to find these little roots that are going to get you points but those roots could really differ each
game depending on what other people do so it has some of those similarities and a little bit of that same Euro we feel but I I certainly would not say they're one-to-one like I don't think there's any other game that I would say oh you have that then Village you don't need Village it it's already covered yes yeah exactly because when I was thinking about it as well there are a few games that use time as a resource like Sulkin but it uses it in such a different way and I feel like that is a bit of a more complex decision making there than than here but still an interesting element to decide what you want to do and how you want to spend your time overall my I I really really like this game I really like the original I wanted to buy it pretty much right after we played it first we played at a board game Cafe and I wanted to buy it right away but then I saw that this was coming out and I thought you know what I'll wait because the expansions to the original very hard to find and I'm glad that I did this it's lovely it goes in the box so nicely all of the bits are there everything is laid out so perfectly they've put so much thought into this and the art is going to be a little bit of a hiccup for some folks and some folks just might want there to be more narrative in it but I think if those two aren't going to be a bar for you like that this is it's just it's a really great game this is one we're gonna be playing a lot yes yeah I really like the the quickness of the turns but still enough depth into the in the
decision making and I think the replayability is so big with the expansion so that's why if you don't have alien Village and you think you might like it the big box does come with everything and that really does add a lot I'm always so excited to play because I'm like oh now what if I tried again with these two combinations and we've played all of the combinations and they've all felt very different yeah they do uh I would say don't play with all of them so it's it's too much it's too much we tried it and we just felt like oh boy this is a lot going on um so I would say oh like I would say always bring in one or two pretty much because it just it adds that little bit Yeah but um but I would say just bring in one or two every time
to play in it please do put that in the comments please as usual like And subscribe and we'll see you next time for another game foreign