Comanauts Review
Transcript
in our last video we promised you a review of Kut a storybook game that's not quite like the others so here it is the game that broke us and made us feel less like Mar kode and more like Peter o hanra hanran of the board game World Kuts is special in everything from its presentation to its ambitious narrative structure to the fact that in our opinion it is perhaps not a very good game didn't didn't you tell me you love this game mhm but it's not very good how does that work curiously in Kuts we're saving the world from a tiny Singularity AKA miniature black hole and the only way to do that is to take on the role of people who dive into a com scientist psyche to wake him up that alone would be enough for Christopher Nolan but designer Jerry hwon famous for mice and Mystics is saying do you know what let's add a few more layers and by layers he means pages of a book that when you play you actually flip and not only is there story but you put your actual characters into the book in his psyche we take on the role of avatars ranging from a cowboy a Burger Chef a lady with a gravity gun Arno who is really just Arno and a sort of Vinnie the Pooh bya Toy Story I can safely say that Pooh never looked so good but wait there's more not only do we have to
navigate a Dreamscape managerie of weird locals like a futuristic Starbucks the wild west rooftop of a tech company or an actual D and D Adventure but we also have to track down and fight a demon manifested from the most negative aspects of Martin's that's the name of the scientist subconscious surely you can love Kuts for that alone but what if I told you that this crazy parade of ideas and Concepts is just the tip of the iceberg and there's so much more behind the curtain what then then we've got you hooked and that buys us some time to dip into the rules under the covers Kuts is a Dungeon Crawler each Avatar you control is your hero and each Dreamscape you visit is a dungeon at the start of the game five of the 11 available locations will be chosen and will form the bases of your JN each of these locations has an ID tied to it and when I say ID I of course mean in a demon for example ples view Martin's hometown is associated with the IDE of fear and if you think your childhood memories would evoke more pleasant emotions then might I remind you of such Greatest Hits as that time you got ill and they stuck a giant needle in you and thinking about snakes every single day of your life snakes why did you think about snakes Soviet childhood selain it's really hard to explain certainly harder to explain
than this game one of these IDs will be randomly selected to be the prime ID and your job is to find it and defeat it when you start playing you don't know which ID is the prime ID you just know that it's not the one in your starting location so you'll hop from dream to dream Gathering clues about which location it is that you actually need to find sometimes finishing entire locations sometimes visiting a glowing bunny rabbit that will let you jump through an interdimensional dream Hall until you find the right location finish it completely and cure whatever is ailing Martin's broken mind and and somehow that all still makes sense each of these places the childhood home the comic book fantasy there's a duality to them they puzzle pieces that put together form that broken mind for example you will find characters in Martin's youth that you'll encounter later on in his life and you'll realize that they've become familiar and important to you but these locations are puzzles themselves each one doesn't just introduce new rules and new ways to approach the game but is lited with challenges challenges that are not quite like in the heroes versus monster games that you are used to okay let's imagine an example say you're sitting in Martin's physics lecture but Martin's physics lecture is a Dungeon Crawler now can you imagine a scenario where one of the challenges is CRI ding some homework ludicrous I know but you better imagine
it because this one is real when it's your turn you'll dip into a bag of dice and much like a hit and run on a pck AIX stand you'll end up with a handful of delicious possibilities and licorice each white dye will potentially add Clarity a universal token that can be spent on the Oho precious rolls or even activating your Avatar's Uber ultimate ability each black diet will go on the threat track gather enough of these and you'll provoke an attack from Martin's mind's defense mechanisms and your dreamcap will erupt into Fish Head policemen chasing you down with lollipop batons Landing bullets with your Dead eyee Revolver or balancing on the precipice of a rooftop ledge requires green dice whereas bashing anything with anything bashel requires red blue dice are good for protecting yourself and yellow will help you with braining the situation I used to have a bachelor's degree in braining oh yeah what happened here's the thing this system has problems problems that make it hard for us to recommend commants but before we get into that I'd like to tell you why we adore it regardless from the tedious minutia of World building in detective to the predictable Bland trop of Arkham Horror board games have bludgeoned one fact into us when it comes to narrative they can really only do surface level stuff and even then with mixed results even our favorite game of all time Gloom Haven features a story that is just about serviceable and while certainly
with Quirk and charm it's just there to propel the game along but what happens when you get a game with a story that is actually good through Kuts we get to see Martin's life his friends lovers hardship Frailty and hope and through Martin we get to see ourselves it would have been also easy to call Kuts a mashup of inception and ready player one and then just be done with it but that would reductive thankfully Mr haon understands that that's just the surface level which has been handled expertly with bright colors and imaginative characters and surreal twists on familiar locations but delve deeper and you'll find the real human being whose experiences are Universal and therefore relatable when we explore Martin's life we see ourselves in him a location might start as pure escapism only to realize that what you're actually exploring is a medley on how escapism affects us how we plunge into it avoiding facing life crashing events and how they eventually catch up with you no matter what by the end I could barely stop myself from balling my eyes out in fact even just thinking about it I oh God crying huh yes it's very sad was that in your lap what no that's that's just tissue don't worry about it what lift it I said lift it I thought so Kuts is not the first
game to try and tackle a serious narrative this war of mine and holding on the troubled life of Billy Kerr have taken on the challenge before and the latter one shares a lot of beats with today's subject but whereas those felt like brutes sent to beat you down with the club of misery this one has no interest in holding your empathy hostage it just wants to tell a person's story and hopes that that is in enough and it is EA will you put that onion away crucially I want to tell you so much more about the story and Kut but I fear I'm already in the territory of coming across like a pretentious twit and really I'd rather leave you to discover it for yourselves but that is the question should you discover it for yourselves after all we did say that the system in this game has problems it does but it also does a lot of things right the rules are simple and keep the game going at a Brisk Pace once you get to grips with them once again no thanks to the not so great rule book from plad games each new element it introduces in new scenes feels intuitive and there's some very elegant things happening when it comes to scaling for play counts where it falls down and this is key is the core mechanism of drawing Dice from a bag and those dice determining what you can actually do now chance is a very big sticking point here at MPI but to be more prec excise it's more about how chance is implemented let's show you an example say I'm fighting an angsty college student if I want to bash them I
simply need to roll above the target number and their anguished wailing is no longer my problem the great thing is that if I want to I can pull as many red dice as I've drawn together for a single roll to make sure that I get a high enough result and even if I fail I can use Clarity tokens to roll them the trouble is actually drawing the requis a dice far too frequently we felt like we knew which story choice we wanted to make but we couldn't actually advance in that direction simply because we couldn't draw the dice that would let us do the actions that would let us advance in that direction it felt like the dice bag was making choices for us and when it didn't then the path was pretty straight and narrow there's quite a few mechanisms in place to mitigate this such as wild purple dice that serve as any color the ability to save a die between turns and even passing it D to another player but even with all of these we have somehow continuously found ourselves being stuck and constantly drawing and rolling drawing and rolling drawing and rolling you can even exchange any two dice for a dive from the discard pile but as if to pour salt on the wound the system constantly forces you to put dice bag into the bag before you can make a meaningful swap it felt infuriating and and I suspect that for some this won't be an issue some folks just want pure escapism from their games and that's fine that's totally okay as reviewers were so focused on
measuring the quality of a game in terms of its mechanical Fidelity but with Kuts is that even the main concern well it's okay for a game to have wonky mechanisms if your game is spinning a good Tail as long as those mechanisms don't get in the way of the spinning what's worse is finding layers and meaning in that yarn only to be defeated by a series of frustrating Unfortunate Events and having to go back and Replay that yarn every time you play your five out of 11 dream Scopes will be assigned randomly and whilst you'll never have to revisit a place that has been designated as the Prime in a demon's domain you might still Venture into places that you've already fully explored and within that there's not much scope for new exploration each beat has a predetermined path that will make you feel like you're just retracing your footsteps so we can't recommend Kuts can we but I really want to the story isn't just good it's the best story I've seen in any bulb game and second place isn't even close okay so how about we compromise we recommend comonads but with the caveat that the gaml will most likely frustrate you but perhaps that doesn't even matter a recommendation If Ever I heard one so close but I don't feel like com ODS quite cut the mustard but I'll tell you what if you do enjoy a good mustard or just a good board game review then
you should subscribe to our Channel not only will you find a plethora of previous board game reviews but also if you feel like we've been a little bit on the negative side lately you'll be very pleased to find out that next time we will feature a board game that was a game of the year for 2018 isn't that something