Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 107: Ian Brown on The Krulak Center

Transcript 51:41

thank you time for a quick ad break Beyond Solitaire is proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and they are launching their Kickstarter campaign for 500 year old vampire at the end of March designer Jason Cox has adapted Tim Hutchings solo RPG design to create a Cooperative experience that can either be played among friends or as a creative exercise in classrooms in fact it is written to satisfy National English and art standards this one is going to be good so I recommend you check it out I also want to put in a quick plug for myself I absolutely love working on Beyond Solitaire and I wish I had more time to put into it you can help me make that possible by giving to my patreon at patreon.com Beyond Solitaire My ultimate goal is to get to a point where I no longer have to teach summer school so I can budget my time for game work and summer conventions instead but no matter what thanks for listening and let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and this week on the podcast I'm a very special guest this is Ian Brown he is a major in the Marine Corps and I have brought him on a talk about his work at the crew like Center how you doing I'm good how are you I am fantastic I'm super excited to talk to you um so talk to us about the crew Life Center what do you do there and uh how you liking it sure so I I Gotta Give like the standard boilerplate these your opinions are my own I don't represent the crew like Center Marine Corps and agency of the US government Etc so now that's out of the way I worked so that I worked the Brew Crew like Center for Innovation future warfare that's the full name but we go by crew like Center because it's kind of a mouth and it's at Marine Corps University at

Marine Corps Base Quantico in Virginia and uh I've been there this is my fourth year I'm gonna retire out of there in about six months but the the center's been around for five years so I came in after about the first year but um it's a it's a very unique place and our director like she likes to call it a think tank and do tank um because we we're not tied to one school at the University or or one specific program we're a support entity to all the different schools there and I guess for those not familiar with like the Marine Corps professional military education construct there's Marine Corps University education command is sort of the umbrella umbrella parent organization and underneath it are all of the officer and enlisted educational programs um a lot of the in fact the majority of those are actually distant students so like often you know campuses on around all the Marine Corps Base you know major bases around the world um we do a lot of our work with the resident students but we've tried to to offer non-resident stuff uh you know as best we can with a relatively small amount of people and resources to give those non-resident students you know again some some unique educational opportunities but what we stood up to do was was find ways to inject more critical thinking create a problem solving you know Innovative unconventional ideas resources and uh and programs into the the various schools across the university and that's that that's what we've been doing you know the whole time

I've been there uh the first year was was uh I wasn't there but it was very much a what our uh my predecessor called like building the airplane while flying it because they you know they had you know put in carpet and desks and stuff while you know doing creating programs out of nothing for the schools but um wargaming is one aspect of what we've done and when I got to the crew lack Center it there was a uh a lot of stuff was happening in the Marine Corps at the same time which fed directly into like bumping up our wargaming efforts significantly so I came into the summer of 2019 we had a new comment on General David Berger who took over right about the time I was moving across the country to go there and uh he got there a couple or I got there a couple weeks later he published this document called the common house planning guidance which is like new comment comes in that document lays out the big things he sort of wants the Marine Corps to focus on and and uh you know things he consider is important during his time as commandant and you know every every part of the Marine Corps is like picking it apart to see which part of it you know which part is he talking about what applies to me but wargaming as a theme took up um I think by theme took up the most text of any other specific theme in that document so it takes up a lot of text he must be pretty pretty interested in it right and want to see more of it so education Command put together a a uh a working group to like to stand up a a formal word gaming plan to inject more of it into the schools where it didn't exist and boost programs that were

already underway and so we kind of fell in and helped um helped drive that bus a little bit because we were already doing wargaming as part of our our mandate to inject you know more critical thinking creative problem solving we had done wargaming tournaments in the past we had done like Standalone demonstration days you know but you know now we were at the table to figure out how you bring this in as a educational tool to the formal programs that are there so um that that effort has expanded greatly over the last three years and uh we have to the point where you know we have a wargaming director who now sort of oversees and and uh supports f efforts to to you know have more of it in the schools you know replace exercises that used to be done with PowerPoint with a war game a dynamic environment with thinking human beings on both sides and uh and we still run like the tournaments and we still do uh you know demonstration days familiarization days for those who you know I want to work in but I don't know what a war game is where do I start right so we do those kind of things both you know for students and faculty but also sometimes we'll get requests from the operating for us to be like I want to do it at my unit I don't know where I don't know where to begin you guys you know you hashtag wargame on Twitter all the time you know give me and a part of that is also kind of our my interaction with Sebastian which is you know other than full credit this is how it all happened this uh this discussion here but we had selected a network of like sort of voluntary subject matter experts to be affiliated with us as non-resident fellows and we

selected I think like four four wargaming expertise particularly so you know that helps me like I don't know everything about wargaming but I have some people we can talk to who can expand your options maybe they can come and run something for you if they can't do that they could at least send you maybe some documentation or game recommendations that I you know we can't come up with ourselves so uh that's what I'm doing right now um doing it for uh another six months and uh hoping to do it you know in a continued professional fashion when I get out fantastic so how widespread would you say that buy-in to wargaming is in the Marine Corps right now so uh it it's increasing and I think the the challenge not the challenge but you know um starting from sort of a very low Baseline um so get getting it out and getting sort of everybody to the same same basic standard um is it's not you know not going to be overnight right but um you know one having the commandant the boss tell everybody go do it it's hugely helpful for encouraging you know incentivizing people to find ways to do it at their own units um but also before General bird took over but um his predecessor I think it was had laid out a plan and project to develop a Marine Corps wargaming Center that was going to be a service level building with um like lots of different you could bring in tons of players right the war games will be run at multiple different levels of classification so you can get really high levels of detail you know

that that is a huge investment what they're building right now in Quantico so kind of between you know between those major things like the uh the bot the buy-in was given right the the fast leadership and current leadership is said you're going to go do more of this because we think it's useful um so really the the the project Now sort of like buying and supporters up here you know along with some resourcing right like the you know wargaming Center is a significant resource uh crew like Center American University shortly after the planning guidance came out we got a bunch of resources to go do more war games for education so now we're kind of like trying to like bring those two I guess a little bit you know for those who can't see my hands like you know there's a little bit of a gap but like we're trying to bring the the Gap you know the the aspiration and the proliferation closer together so that Gap is smaller um and we you know we're we're our main focus is professional military education uh but the nice thing is again that's all around the Marine Corps every base has a satellite thing so I think we sort of tried to start establishing a foundation at the resident schools at Marine Corps University in Quantico and then use that as your platform to you start pushing it out to the other pme campuses around there and um you know part of part of it our you know part of my job too is um is Outreach and increasing awareness and so for those if you're not a pme school but if you're an individual unit or you're a uh if you're like a staff planner for a higher headquarters you can you know you find me on Twitter you find me on our email

distribution list and we can come out and sort of like case-by-case basis provide some resources maybe run something and you know now we planted that seat out there right now you know about us you've seen a little bit of it you go forward and carry that out for where you are because we can't be I can't lose you in a Camp Pendleton and Okinawa you know 24 7. we just can't but we're 24 7 resource and we're happy to push that stuff out to where where you know those folks are and uh you know they build it out where they're planted so what kind of games are you pushing pushing are you I've been enriching classroom experience in the decision making experience are you doing that with hobby games are you doing that with games that have been specifically designed for Marine Corps classes or are you pulling in simulations from you know other professional working environments uh all of the above um so when I first got here we had a kind of like a small really random selection of some computer games that um we Acquired and uh and a bunch of tabletop games and I've got like we were lucky we've had people you know give us uh you know their old game collections right you know my wife wants me to clean out the basement hear my games I hope they go somewhere good um so for about the first year I was there it was kind of you know you know a grab bag of stuff with the wargaming funding and Commandos direction that became much more formalized and so one that's how we have a war gaming director

to provide some oversight but two um one of the big resourcing things was building a war gaming Cloud a digital Cloud environment which is being built under let me get this right the Microsoft Azure Cloud environment which um I not my area of expertise the point is it's building a a a digital platform that that's accessible from anywhere and it's machine agnostic so this this is It's been it was when one operational patent last fall and right now we're in sort of like the you know the beta testing stress testing the current architecture but it's taken it's been a very interesting relationship between our war gaming director uh Microsoft and then uh Matrix Games Slytherin you know commercial game designers they have a whole series of games that were commercial games you know you go buy office Steam for 60 bucks right like command uh modern operations Flashpoint campaigns uh War plan World War II order of battle those have been pulled into the cloud and and sort of tailorized and customized for the cloud environment so that um so Marines from anywhere can access it so how is that being used right now um Flashpoint so Flashpoint campaigns and command professional Edition are sort of the two I'd say the the most proliferative for formal pme programs uh because the level of detail they have it fits in well with several different levels of the you know the ranges of areas of responsibility for the different officer pme programs um but also they're super customizable

and as part of the collaboration with Matrix and Slytherin they've built out like unique Marine Corps specific tables of organization and Equipment capabilities you know scenarios things like that so uh taking the commercial variant and built it kind of expanded into our needs and you put it in the cloud environment one of one of the you know like kind of like I said I can't be everywhere 24 7 to run a game for you um well the cloud helps solve that because you just need to log in Access and a computer with a network connection right and you can get into the cloud from anywhere and that really helps kind of democratize the access to these resources so that you don't just have to come through Quantico you know at random times in your career window see their resident school maybe you take it with you maybe you don't now you can punch you can log into it from anywhere you know Global access and that's going to be a huge um a huge enabler for giving for one for getting more people to do more wargaming around the fleet because now you don't have to go somewhere special but also because the this year with the cloud is sort of the the first year of um plugging it more deeply into the formal programs at residence school you know go through a year of that now we have some lessons learned now we can apply those to the distance programs too so again like you know Rising tide lifts all boats um the work going on this year is going to eventually get out to the rest of the fleet Marine force and the non-resident educational students who are actually the vast majority of POV students most students go to non-resident pme so now we're able to push some of those unique things that

all used to only happen in Resident out to the rest of the fleet now do I do uh there's a number of other games coming online again depending on the school so Sebastian Bay's game actually um our origami director has acquired or is going to acquire a large batch for the enlisted schools right because it's a it's sort of a tactical level game um um but it's uh it's very much a it's a good introductory war game one but also you can play it in a relatively shorter time which is important because the enlisted schools have like much shorter curricula than the officer schools do like there's their curriculum measure in the weeks whereas officer curricular measurement months so they don't have a huge amount of time to like you know to go find do this so we need to offer them options so they can execute rapidly um and we've done that I myself I've run a number of iterations of the Prototype Sebastian's game for the enlisted schools at Quantico uh to help you know help support their program over there um and then we we also do I'll like I've run you know demo days right like wargaming open houses um where I'll set up like six or seven games computer tabletop um to familiarize you know faculty and staff and whatever students whoever are interested if you don't know anything like comment I say go do more wargaming but you've never seen one before well these are some of the ways you can do it right um also like wargaming and I'm doing air quotes here doesn't always mean gaming combat um in fact when sort of one of the genres I've tried to get myself Smarter on to offer more options is games to look at other things besides combat so

uh for I had a I was at Fort Leavenworth a couple months back for their intro to war gaming course and um the final sort of Capstone thing was you had to like learn a brand new game and teach it to your fellow students so I picked this game called Aftershock which is about like earthquake recovery which you know unfortunately is kind of a timely topic right now right but earthquake recovery and you play the rules a bunch of different you can play the home nation government you can play like a U.S military task force you can play a un group you can play like in this non-governmental organization group and you have like nobody has all the resources you have a limited pool resources and you have all these crises breaking out and you have to like sort of prioritize what can we go after um you know who who is everybody's strengths and weaknesses right like home nation they know the land they know they know the people they know the um the infrastructure you know like they and they probably have like really good distribution networks because it's their home right but resources they just got smacked right the resources are wiped out conversely like US military man we're good at like building ports opening airports and things like that um to open up those Avenues to start bringing supplies in um and then U.N and non-governmental organizations you serve you know you start bringing the stuff right you bring you bring the stuff U.S like task force opens the ports and airfields and home nation uses its local networks to distribute but you all have to work together and you all have to like look at what crises you think you can handle with your limited resources sort of like on you know day one to seven there's

very little there you have to make some very hard choices about um do we focus on one area and simply accept that we can't get to these other areas or do you like you know nickel and dime little bits of resources out because you know that that might seem like the right thing to do right but if you do that you might just be wasting those resources Because unless you sort of pull them all together in one pack in one package um you you won't actually solve the problem you'll slap a Band-Aid on it and then the problem just gets worse and more people suffer um so so games like that that you you explore other hard decision making problems but it's not all about fighting or combat or ones that I'm I'm personally fascinated in and that's that's why I'll I'll give plugs to the you know the DS Foundation their free at last game about the Civil Rights Movement I just got speaking of four Circle games I got votes for women and you know very very interested in getting into that learning how to do it because it's still competition and hard decisions you know which are things we're trying to teach from the crew Life Center but it's not not all about war because hey guess what like War doesn't happen all the time um but we may be you know a U.S military may be called on to do things other than a war you know might be good to have have maybe gone through a scenario or situation like that in a in a controlled game environment to learn about some of those hard decisions before you go do all those other things so this actually leads directly into the next question I wanted to ask which was um you know what are you exactly using these games to teach uh you know are using to teach very specific you know

things about history or about logistics or is this really more of a general mindset thing that you're trying to use these games to communicate so I hate to say like it depends but it it depends on it depends on so it depends on like so I'll start with the schools right because each of our pme schools has different learning objectives they want their students to teach at different levels of operations right so like our captains are at a more sort of Tactical level of operations than our Majors who are like our captains might be thinking hours and days right our Majors might be thinking days and weeks our Lieutenant Colonels at the war College are thinking like weeks or months right like the Strategic the grand strategic picture um so we try and have games available that match those those specific needs and the levels they're at so that it feels like it's something relevant you know and it's something our wargaming director has done a lot and this is where like um getting getting Matrix Games Slytherin to Taylor stuff is really useful is like okay like you I'm just picking an example say the captains they need to have an exercise that teaches them about you know um Landing a part of an amphibious Force logistical planning for the first I don't know five days of operations and something that gets them into planning uh airspace deconfliction for different types of air emissions and then indirect fire support missions from the ground

through that airspace to the ground on the other side right um okay well we would we would try and offer them a game that does those things and lets them hit those learning objectives um but what I think is differentiated using the game as opposed to you know like doing it all via PowerPoint or like slapping stuff on a Google map right that you do a screenshot of and then sending it to a a white cell of adjudicators who are sort of you know that they're applying their Professional Knowledge but there's I think sort of an inherent subjectivity to how you do that you do it all in the computer game you have like an actual Dynamic Red Cell that's that's actively doing their own plan and opposing your blue plan um you're hitting those learning objectives but you're also hitting what is you know arguably one of the biggest learning objectives that a leader needs to know in combat especially is things are going to go wrong your enemy is going to do things you don't respect you're going to have to adjust your plan right you might have random random missile blows up your your ammunition dump and you've lost like you're down to one day an ammunition of Supply instead of five you thought you had okay well you don't get to sit on your hands and say well that's not fair or that would never happen in real life right bad stuff is going to happen so you need it's better to do that again in a controlled environment where you can fail a lessons from that failure uh before you have to do that for real you know what lives are on the line kind of thing um and so for the stuff we do for the schools that's what we like we wanna we wanna hit those learning objectives because that's a requirement but doing in a more Dynamic fashion has the added bonus of dynamic decision making you

know that oh oh poop Factor where something happens I didn't expect I am adjusting and teaching that rapid decision making that ability to adjust and change your plan and unexpected circumstances is also a useful skill set that we you know we want people to walk away from um now some of the I'd say for like what we do Sebastian's game for has been often exposing the players to emerging your future Concepts technologies that you know maybe we only have a little now or maybe we don't have it yet but we say we're going to have it in five or ten years but it's it's giving a familiarization like one what's really cool about all of his cards right they're it tells it's like different weapon systems or different ISR systems but it's also almost like a flash card like hey if you've never seen a Chinese Hypersonic missile before this is what it looks like this is what it's called this is you know in a gamified fashion this is its basic capabilities guess what it can go really long and really far and a lot of your your Marine Corps only organic missile defenses can shoot it down well on the blue player side you have Marine Corps stuff but you also have um things from the other forces right like Army Navy Air Force that one could potentially defend you from that missile but also when we're talking you know about our our joint operations or Focus you know against the pacing threat which is China right like we're all going to be working together so there might be a time where a Marine Corps unit hey here's a you're you're now like tied in

Via radio or data link to an Aegis Cruiser that can't intercept that thing right maybe if you had a basic understanding or familiarization via a game exercise what the Aegis Cruiser can do for you and defend against those missiles um you can make more intelligence decisions about how you and that ship are going to operate and how their systems can protect you rather than you having no idea whatsoever and not even knowing that tying into them is an option

and then in sort of for the like the familiarization or demo things that I do like intro to wargaming it's I don't do the Slytherin or the Matrix Game stuff because like that stuff's pretty intensive even for like you know hardcore Gamers I'll do simpler things like again going back to Ford Circle games they're shores of Tripoli game fantastic Marine Corps history right so it's easy very easy for me to put that in front of Marines be like hey this is this is what we did right so teaching Marine Corps history it's a very simple set of game rules um but also the the asymmetric objectives and you having to understand what you need to do to win but also what they need to do to win so you can stop them from getting to that point um it's a fantastic demonstration tool and I'm not teaching like I'm not teaching you the tactics of how to fight Wooden Ships of the line right but I'm teaching you how to balance your objectives I'm teaching you um how to you know you might have to slap a Band-Aid on a problem over here to focus on a bigger problem over there and you're always doing it against the thinking human opponent which is to me that's inherently valuable in itself whatever game you play so this actually uh makes me I was thinking about this question we you've mentioned several times that um you know the reason that gaming is a good educational tool is because it teaches people to respond to changing circumstances some of which are negative uh and that it gives the challenge of like playing against a real thinking human opponent what evidence have you collected to indicate

that this actually does improve decision making and response to negative change among trainees and how are you tracking um the results of the games that you run so that's an excellent question and um part of the answer is that's that part is being built too because there's actually not a huge amount of like hard documented research on that area and at least from from the Marine Corps Marine Corps University acrylic Center side part of the project of injecting more games across the curricula has been that assessment piece and find like you know is this a Better Learning method right like do the students like it more or less are they indifferent to the previous ways of doing it so for us at least that has been a formalized part of this whole process it's not just getting the games themselves but that assessment piece because sort of our the longer term vision is if you're you can assign games as homework right well how do you how do you measure that against the other students right how do you how do you grade that homework you need some sort of you know metric some sort of Benchmark that you're grading it against right so it's not just a totally subjective exercise um and so that I'd say that's kind of a that's a living process at least for us that's going on I think outside of that though that's not something that's really been this is you know JLo's personal opinion here I'm sorry jail is my call sign Ian's personal opinion here um but I always say that in our podcast

just to make sure everybody knows it's me and not like you know not the Marine Corps speaking ease personal opinion um it's it's not well captured and I don't know if that's because there's simply no sort of centralized discipline that could sort of you know give you a common framework for doing it or because and I say this because I just finished reading um uh Natalya's book on uh what is it called she's a NATO wargamer and I'm sure it's called wargaming experiences and she made the point that like there's no discipline because you know sort of your harder scientists don't look at it as a formal discipline so they don't collect the research well then there's no research to go back and look and say whether or not it's actually a useful thing and it's this you know this this circular argument that's very very hard to prove um so I'd say it's something that like the war Gaming Community as a whole is conscious of on record University side the assessment piece is being built into that for what we're doing you know but I've also seen again folks like Sebastian they'll try and offer like a post-game survey of you know when he runs his games what did you learn what did you like what was terrible you know would you would you recommend it would you would you do a different audience kind of thing um I say I think there's there's work moving in a more formalized scientific direction to lay out a a a philosophy and a an intellectual framework and I I'll throw in there um there's a gentleman over at Swedish defense University in Stockholm we went over there last year to do as part of

like a we're invited to go to a leadership conference but they also do some War gaming in their own courses and they have one PhD student through there who is trying to build like a a completely like philosophical conceptual framework for why War gaming works right um and I think once his research is done it's going to be a fantastic tool you know to start getting into that that hard science of because you know you can tell like I'm passionate about it I'm sure a lot of the guests in your program they're passionate about it and it seemed like it's like well it's self-evident right like of course wargaming is great like everybody loves gaming students always students always say like that was fantastic when they walk out the door um how do you prove that right how is it how is it repeatable um how is it quantifiable in a way that others can look at and use for their own efforts so I think the I think that still needs to be built and there's pieces of it out there because like a lot of the better War Gamers I know like they'll do at least like a a hot wash after an exercise and some sort of some sort of documentation where you get enough inputs now you have a data set right like Sebastian has done that for example with all like the hundreds of iterations of electoral Commander he's run he's got a data set broken down by like demographic of are you US military what branch are you not are you some other part of National Security are you just like an academic who likes games and capturing all those different responses it gives you a starting off point but there's really not a larger overarching framework and I think that's that's something that has to be that

should be created because I do think it's I think it's self-evident that it's valuable but there are a lot of Skeptics out there right and it's be great if there was something we could point back to and be like got the science and the data to show you that you should be doing this yeah and um I like you I'm a True Believer and there's you know but all I have is anecdata right but one thing I do notice and I would like to see studied actually um is I've both just from talking to people on this podcast and from playing games in my classroom myself I actually find that I know something's going to be really good if my honor students are skeptical about it because they are so used to school being a certain way and they know how to game that system so when they sense of rules change they become anxious and they have a really specific range of responses to that and so I mean I hear what you're saying right about wanting people to respond to like an oh moment to a little bit of pushback to a little bit of uncertainty um and I wonder if that can be measured because I actually think that the most important thing you can teach a smart person is that being smart isn't enough to solve all their problems and a game can teach you that way better than a PowerPoint yeah no I I agree and I think you know as we start to try and capture some of this feedback like I have my own survey that we offer to everybody who comes through whether whether it's like a one day demo or uh you know a larger um you know multi-week class exercise but a lot of

generalizing a little bit but a lot of the feedback is you know this drove the lesson home a lot more than like what I read or you know what we discussed in class because you get immediate Dynamic feedback into things you don't expect and you know we've had our share of skeptical students come through like there's always one or two who you know they'll make some comment about playing Dungeons and Dragons or you know why are we rolling dice like it's just it's all random luck and chance and you know I I bite my tongue and I I don't say well did you know what Dungeons and Dragons was first advertised as a war game so uh if you play it you're actually origami but um you know I like the chance to if I can get them in there and get them to participate you know I feel like if I'm doing my job properly and I constructed an appropriate game environment that that speaks to things I think is relevant um I can convert some of those Skeptics and that's the best thing like I I I think it's those converts like who are skeptical will come in and then they see they don't just see the value they experience it and then they walk away with that feeling inside them of man I really like I really learned something this was a valuable use of my time I want them to be that seed and go out and plant it like wherever they're going back to um so again so we can sort of shrink that that gap between the aspiration and the activity that's actually going on absolutely so you are doing really awesome work at the Crux Center but it is very clear that you're interested in gaming very much transcends your workspace so what are you hoping to do

after you retire and then um what's what's going on with gaming in your your just personal life in your spare time yeah so um I'm sure my wife would like to know what my uh my retirement plan is going to be um but uh now I'm like I'm I'm looking seriously at some sort of um professional very likely military or national security Affiliated wargaming when I get out because it's I I was surprised in my time at the grill like Center but it's a growth industry um like there's there's think tank or like big Think Tank organizations like the rain Corporation all the way down to sort of much smaller groups that uh they all they're doing different pieces of the of the puzzle and I've been learning more about what's out there and um and you know now that I know that I can get a job where I can like get paid to design and Run games for people you know that that's uh that sounds pretty good to me so excuse me it's probably gonna be something something in that line um in my personal life I've tried to turn my kids into gamers in various ways with varying degrees of success I think I've had the most success with my eldest he's a teenager but uh I I use I used uh Star Wars as our sort of common language and uh I first introduced him to to Battlefront on the Xbox which was a computer game favorite of mine when I was a teenager and I thought yeah I'll teach them how to play it and the old man will beat up on him a little bit but he beats me like nine times out of ten so if it's very humbling but we play a lot of the Star Wars miniatures games so um I play play the X-Wing game with him

which is like Starfighter to Starfighter combat Armada which is like large capital ship Fleet combat and I I really I love the mechanics of armada because to me from a a like a especially a naval perspective you have to think multiple moves ahead for like where your object is going to be in space because stuff moves and object of motion stays in motion and our X-Wing to a certain extent but our motto I think does a really great job of hey like your ship doesn't just like speed up and slow down on a dime you have to think about where that thing is going to be in space and um and it's not necessarily going if if you mess it up you might just like fly right out of the battlefield and now you're no use to anybody um and then we've been we've been getting heavily into the painting The Star Wars Legion game which is like ground tactical combat but I also like Rebellion which is why I'm gonna be running that up at uh the Ford or the circle DC event and you guys separately you know that's with me and my family on my own time I've uh you know would not have thought I would do this a few years ago but in in doing something scenario expansion uh for Sebastian's game of work and then um just getting exposed to more different games I'm trying to design you know my own my own card game now which is uh um heavily influenced by the Star Wars customizable card game but I grew up with as a teenager back in the 90s and I had thousands of cards but I I part of it is I was interested in like designing my own thing because I've like I've

swamping other people's Waters I want to try and swim in My Own Lane um you know but also as a from a perspective of how do I how do we make more wargaming more accessible to more people especially in the Marine Corps right where you know we don't have the same budgets doing the same money wargaming is always a resourcing challenge um how do you get how do you provide something that is simple um and has like a very minimal resource overhead um and to me that was you know Sebastian's game does that that really really well but I was like how how do you make it even simpler right like um so like I remember card game right the Star Wars and you know anybody who's played something like Pokemon or any sort of deck building game like everything you need is in that stack of cards so that's sort of my design philosophy and I I went in and I I'm trying to help gamify different doctrinal concepts for the Marine Corps future you know emerging capabilities whether it's you know stealth aircraft or uas's or uh or things going on in cyber in the information domain and the space domain too which is you know new open territory um but still having it like in that one package where everything you need to play that game is uh is in one box and so all you need is like a light source and a flat table and you can do some War gaming on something that is hopefully relevant to you but also hopefully entertaining and interesting yeah I'll be demoing that as well at the Circle DC thing you know for anybody who wants to see it

yes I will be there and I actually don't know if this episode is going to run before or after we meet in person but we are going to meet in person I'm really excited about it yeah no I'm I'm very much looking forward to that event so I find it very interesting that um you know you're mentioning a deck of cards and then wargaming the same sentence I think that that is a really big sign of how that branch of the hobby has changed what do you consider to be in the world of war gaming um because I think that you know people normally think of it as kind of hex encounter but I also think that's very much in flux now yes like if you'd ask me that question arguably before I got to the crew Life Center I might have said yeah it's either hex for counter or like real-time strategy like Warcraft Starcraft you know you know total war series what have you in in my time in the crew Life Center I've I've been exposed to a lot more things to like it's really expanded aperture so you know I I never seen like a I don't know what you call it like a line and node type game but one of those things that again Sebastian you know introduced to all of us is the game Friedrich which actually I was just I was playing today at the office in preparation for a demo event for the basic school um next week you know but it's it's it's it's an area of movement it's a line and node movement thing it's not hexes you know but it's still working because they're still there's still combat right there's still wins and losses on the battlefield there's still decision making about protecting your supply lines um you know identifying and with you

know with the node system you got to identify those key Avenues and approaches right like which which roads um get me moving to my objective fastest what what intersections do I have to defend um and but then you know expanding the aperture even further into things like um the shores of Tripoli that's not hex encounter that's not even like no node in line that's like that's a Zone type thing that's so to me that's still a war game as well and then you know I I I was very heavily influenced by the Star Wars customizable card game I loved it because it was Star Wars and I was a giant Star War I still am a giant Star Wars nerd but um when I started thinking about you know a card based game for modern military Concepts um it uh I looked back into the Star Wars game I'm like I never played it as a war game I played it because it was Star Wars and I got to like fly Fighters and have lightsaber duels because that that was interesting um but it had a lot of like the basic problems that a war game that we're trying to use for training or educational value has right like you have limited resources um you can't put them everywhere you have to figure out like where and how to master your forces to gain a an advantage against your enemies so you can really beat up on them and cause them significant losses right you need to understand how all the different pieces of your deck work so that you can do things like Ambush um do like slow slow draining attacks on their Logistics right not directly attacking them but if you understand like the whole four strain concept which I won't get into the point is you can

you can deplete your opponent's resources just by you having units in certain key places where they are not and that persistent draining is a huge strategy of that game of reducing your opponent's card count which then limits their ability the freedom of action to do the things they want to do and so like looking back on like it really is a war game and it has a lot lot of the the problems that we're trying to present our own military education students with just it was in Star Wars and a bunch of cards and I didn't really see it until I sort of I came to the center and started getting into that more like a different framework of it's it's not fun like there was real learning and insight that you can get from this although I'll mention our uh that the son of our namesake so Brooke krolak his son Charles krulak is coming out of the Marine Corps back in the late 90s like he tried to get wargaming into the uh into the Marine Corps to the point of like having someone code a Marine Corps Doom skin so you could go play Doom as like you know with Marine units and weapons but he he was in our spaces shortly after I came to the center you know we were talking about the new planning guidance and how war game was all over that was the crew Life Center going to do to support that you know we're going through all these different you know different uses and the value of working one of the last things he said was and remember it should be fun and that struck me as a as an odd comment at the time from a former you know commandant like highly senior military professional you know as well as a guy's a lot older than I am right like I don't I don't know but he looks at his fun but our perspective on fun might be

a little bit different but he said it was fun and then in the last couple years I've kind of realized like fun is just a short description for a deeper emotional and mental engagement with the subject matter because any like if you like doing something you're gonna actively stay engaged with it and you're gonna pull more useful stuff out of it the more you're engaged right so fun is just a way for me to teach you the things that I want you to learn anyway and uh and because you're enjoying yourself the lessons stick with you after you walk away and because Marines are inherently competitive like you put Marines on two sides of a table and tell me how to fight each other like they are gonna get into it right they're gonna all the smack talk um you know excitement when you're missing lenses things to ship despair when you've lost like a key unit and you realize like you can't recover this like game's gonna be over anytime now but that that's emotion yeah that's fun but it's that it it's an emotional mental engagement that that you're going to get those things I want you to and it's going to stick with you in a way that if I just told you to read you know Read 50 pages about the Battleground Canal okay you may or may not remember the vital lessons if I put you on the islands of Guadalcanal and I put you in a situation where the Japanese and Americans where neither one has you know complete Supremacy and in the air or at Sea and you really have to like find those scenes those weaknesses and the temporary weaknesses in your opponent so you can gain Advantage for either like you know resupply the forces on wild Canal or for the Japanese like Ambush

and get after those Marine you know Marine the Navy forces because they that's all I have like if you knock out their Navy they can't Supply the island and it's game over for them um you will I think again I think it's self-evident but I think you will walk away having a better understanding of the challenges of that scenario if you're more deeply engaged in it because you're you're touching it you're interacting with it the whole time yeah and I actually touches on on Hammer hump so we're gonna do it you gave me an opening uh which is it you know when we talk about games and we talk about fun that doesn't necessarily mean frivolous and it doesn't necessarily mean childish and it's not like oh he he like we blew someone up murder's so funny like that's not what fun means in this context fun means engaging and engagement creates memories and it creates you know a deeper communion with the sources and it's just going to be right that thing that you know it's it's fun doesn't mean goofing around fun means I'm really really interested in what's going on and yeah I think that's what it sounds like y'all are going for as well yeah and I'll cite um one of our non-risen fellows of Dr James pigeon Fielder I don't know if he's been on the show or not oh yeah it's great good then uh I'm I'm glad because this will you know lace on the groundwork but one of the uh we've asked him to give like wargaming like why war game things for faculty development um as well as I think we we had a

monarch podcast a couple times but he goes he basically goes through like the construction of imagination imaginary worlds and once you sort of like I think either somebody calls it like the liminal Circle it's some kind of circle but it's like basically once you once you've accepted and you translate into that Circle outside of the boundary into that world and you sort of accept the rules of the world for what they are um you you lose yourself in there and it become it becomes a new world where new lessons can be learned even though it's completely imaginary or it's a you know it's a bunch of the counters on a map right you've accepted the reality of that world and sort of like accepting the reality of a thing it's in a sense it makes it more real for you and so everything that goes on in that world is going to be more real more impactful to you when you've made that transition into accepting it um and so yeah he's I think he's one of those you know folks out there who started to sort of build this larger framework of like the the science and the the discipline behind why should you war game and and his description I was like it's not frivolous but it's not like fun is an emotional response and we want you to get you into that in environment where you're emotionally responding to the things that you're presented with and it could be good or bad emotion again amount of motion yeah we're like the like the Marine is competitive like somebody wins somebody's got to lose like you will remember those losses right because you know we Marines don't like to lose right you don't like to lose in front of your buddies too you don't like to lose in front of your

buddies when they're smack talking you the whole time afterwards about you know how you screwed it all up but you will walk away being like man I am not going to lose that again right that's that's a lesson that sticks with you um and I'll I'll go back to the uh the Aftershock game that I I facilitated for the wargaming course I'd never seen this game before right until like when I first broke it up and I'm like all right how does this whole thing work because I'm just trying to like teach it and teach the players so that I I get done with the course um and I wasn't like thinking really much more about what was in that game right apart from just learning the mechanics so everybody can play it but then as we went through it um it uh it was a really sobering moment because I like it's a game right it's got some cards it's got little meeples and little plastic cubes represent supplies but your challenge is these all these different districts in this nation affected by an earthquake and every district has a crisis that flips up right and then you sort of look at the crises what the what resources need to be applied to resolve that crisis and you very quickly realize one on that first turn like day one through seven of the disaster you're not going to solve most of those problems um and that's that's a humbling um realization for for like I'm with a bunch of military students right like we want we're problem solvers we want to solve everything right like we want to get it done and so you turn one you realize you can't you got to decide where you can have that impact and then another piece was all of these crises have the number of people affected

um and in that first week you're talking like like high hundreds or thousands of people and then when each of those crises when you fail to solve it and it goes away and you get to the next one you realize like that wasn't a car that was like 4 000 people who were stricken by you know an outbreak of Cholera because we didn't solve the infrastructure problem and that crisis is resolved now because they're dead and we fail um and that really like that really put a it it made the game less you know fun and I'm using your quotes here again but I like to me at least it made it a lot more impactful in realizing like there are you want to encounter these problems when there are not lives on the line so you can make better decisions when there are um you know but also realizing that your your job your job as military professionals life is always part of the equation um and so when you when you started doing like the tally at the end of the crises we didn't solve and what that cost um that was really sobering for everybody around the table in in the lives we had failed to save and the crises we had failed to resolve and again this is a Friday morning like at Leavenworth we're all safe we've all had our coffee we all had a nice breakfast and these are just cars with numbers on them there's no faces there's no names but just the fact we all we don't cross that liminal Circle we'd enter the environment um and um that I think that's the kind of impact you can have because it it makes

it real for you and it's it wasn't fun right but we were emotionally engaged and we walked away from that that game being like yeah if this ever happened these are some really horrible hard challenges and decisions you have to make and when you realize you can't save everybody and you have to sort of decide what you can affect with the resources you have um man that's a really that's a really hard thing to Grapple with but we we're all going to have to if we're military professionals we're all gonna have to Grapple with it at some point right so let's do it sooner where we can sort of think through some different options and learn how to prioritize resources to have the Maximum Impact while accepting that we can't solve every problem um and simply letting go of like your your inheritance I want to solve everything right that's it's in my it's in my fitness report I'm a Problem Solver type thing right well you never get there's going to be problems you can't solve and the sooner you understand that that's a thing that's a challenge you might have to face but you're gonna have to just go on to the next day and the day after that and meet whatever other challenge comes up um I think that's one of the that's that emotional again not fun but it's emotional engagement and it's a lesson you walk away with honestly that is the perfect place to stop because that was really good and people have questions for you uh where can you be found online I'm most active on Twitter you can find me at Ian underscore tv03 um or if you follow Sebastian I appear on his feet all the time so

um I'm not hard to find also if you want to follow the crew like Center for my my professional work it's at the crew Life Center on Twitter as well and I think it's the same one we're on Instagram LinkedIn um Facebook YouTube so um look for the crew Life Center we're not hard to find you myself mostly on Twitter fantastic um thank you so much Ian for your time this is a great conversation I really liked learning about the crew like Center and I hope that I just wish you all the best there for the next few months and then at your next Landing Place yeah well thank you I look forward to finally meeting you and seeing you and everybody else up at the Historical DC event yeah let's get you game played all right so for those of you who are out there um hopefully you know by now I can be found anywhere online as Beyond Solitaire uh thank you so much for watching please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming um

Progress saved