Lord of the Rings: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for lord of the rings the reiner canezia version uh that basically tells the entire story of lord of the rings and in fact in the back of the rulebook it literally tells you kind of it's synopsis eat kind of the overarching yeah yeah of the books uh so when did this game come out uh like 40 years ago when they let's see uh right before but i know it's an older game it has a replay it's definitely turn of the century yes uh kind of around the time where uh like these kinds of games were coming out yeah it is shortly after the movies uh actually before it was yeah 2000 first movie came out i think in 2001 really yeah it was 2001 2002 and 2003 because they came out consecutive years god they are 20 years old i was seven when the first one came out anyway this game is going to be a very weird review this game is a lot of fun once okay i have no inkling to play this again because i've seen it you know there's there's no new gandalf cards there's no new decks of cards you there's no new scenarios uh randomness is really the replay randomness is really it but even then you go through the
event deck pretty much uh through each scenario we won so we won as well barely it was literally corruption uh like one corruption away uh i think everyone played extremely well the randomness was wasn't as frustrating as i thought it was gonna be like throughout the game when we kept drawing you know the the events over and over and even before we even got to start yeah that's kind of annoying but they he gives you enough mitigation where you can be like well we have these uh feature cards let's just okay we'll burn that so we can i think there was a time literally in the run through where we burned a feature card because it was like let's just so we can get [ __ ] started on this it's all pretty thematic uh to the the books and the movie but because of that i had fun i would never play this again what do you guys think i i'm i'm kind of on the same page i would play it again just um if somebody asked me to sure but um but i want to yeah i wouldn't like seek it i wouldn't be like yeah let's do lower the rings i'd be like yeah right it i mean it has a pretty good length it's about an hour uh at least with three players i didn't feel it was like hurting for oh [ __ ] we need one more person yeah um in fact i kind of liked it with three uh even less because that's less chances of the event you know stacking on you where it's like oh man we drew all the event tiles that move
this event up you know where we're just okay before we even get to start our entire hands are burned um i think the pacing was really what uh really well you have moria then you go to letharian which gives you some good stuff uh but it's honestly one of those games where it's like like we figured out the strat don't burn through your gandalf cards right um save them till obviously mordor um hold on to your feature cards and and enjoy the lord of the rings ride yeah brett what do you think um i have played it several times yeah um and i find that it is a different game with different people okay so people who are heavy strategy gamers get through it much more quickly because it's not that heavy a strategy game right and it is cooperative so people think about things throw it out and we go okay that makes sense or i think this time i'm gonna try something different because i know a little bit about what's coming up yeah but uh but i didn't remember any of it because it's way too much to remember so i i am not gonna say it is highly replayable i wouldn't pull it out every month but um with different sets of people it is a different experience with different numbers it is a different experience sure you also have to kind of think about and and rate this game kind of when it came out 21 years ago uh that it it was the turn of the century for kind of these games you didn't see cooperative games pandemic hadn't come out until 2007 i think so yeah and tickets arrived were probably the big company right at this time and that's the thing is it's interesting
to think about because pandemic is usually think thought of as the granddaddy of cooperative games yeah and this what this you know was there but where pandemic obviously supersedes this is the fact that it is replayable the setup alone is already going to change how your game is going to be played this game is set up the exact same way uh but just who gets which cards that yeah that's it and i mean it's it's not overly complex it i i very much actually enjoyed that the events had names that followed the scenarios you were in uh so it it had it wasn't super thematic because yes at the end of the day you are just playing cymbals but where as other games who do that do that where it's just symbol heavy and theme is just pasted on they actually give you titles for each of the things for those symbols oh hey fighting we're doing the siege of ministerith okay hiding is the march towards mordor to distract sauron so he gives you enough i think to at least make you could play a card like i did earlier when it's like ah faramir is gonna help you know fight or uh uh aomir is gonna help us fight shilob you can do things like that um that other games that are just icon heavy just to move up a track don't do um yo go ahead oh i was just gonna say something about the theme real quick um i really liked that as as sour on the ice hour and was moving forward it just reminded me of how like
because eventually it did get to bag end how he's just spreading his corruption through the land i think they did a really good really really good job on dean yeah and the the track with sauron i actually kind of enjoyed he moves up in a slowly encroaching way that feels like you mentioned the movies or or the book he wasn't just all of a sudden like oh i'm [ __ ] here like he had to search and over time the weight of the ring uh his his presence was starting to become overbearing and you have ways you can't mitigate him when he moves it's a permanent move up but you have ways hey i'm not gonna play anything in my turn i'm just gonna move back one yeah uh i like that it's just enough for a game that came out 20 years ago that the randomness isn't just hey this is hard for the sake of being hard ghost stories or um that's the one that really popped to my mind or it's like uh hey this is hard well why because it's all random and it's like that's faux difficulty that means the the designers were just like ah we don't really want to balance it like you'll win if the cards go your way you'll win if the dice go your way here uh i'm i'm incredibly impressed that there is randomness of of dice uh and of tile drawing that it's like hey either the ring bearer can move or the or sauron can move or someone can move up twice and it's like well we've made we've played enough that pippen's all the way in the back so yeah we can actually move him
and not worry about it but over time he got all the way up to five for us yeah um and it was sam's op ability i mean it's also games like this where you look at everyone's very strong power and be like okay up the track it's going to be a bunch of die rolls give sam the die rolls right because either chances are he's going to roll either a blank or the pips and he'll he's only ever going to incrementally move up one right in this case it worked because you happen to be the ring bearer which we did not strategize but i did strategize okay to actually be the ring bearer because of that very reason okay that i was i was i thought most the time i was going to be the lowest on the corruption because of his ability that was that's why i was fighting for the ring you as frodo oh i've rolled a three oh moving up three it's like i rolled a three okay sam moves up one and so i was like i want to be ring bearer because chances are i'll be furthest back um and also at the very end of mordor i got lucky with the tiles because it slowly moved me up and moved me up on a win to give me the wild so it did kind of go my way towards the end uh but yeah i mean i i've had a great time like it was nice to kind of reminisce over lord of the rings but this is one of those games so it's like i don't want to own this like i wouldn't i i wouldn't be like ooh let's play this like immediately um when i have at this point so many other cooperative games uh because it's it's a huge genre now
uh a little like you got you anything to talk about no i mean that's uh you you covered it well i just like different mechanics different randomness you know if this were like some kind of a weird dice mechanic it would be awful yeah um i might prefer them as cards just because they'd be easier to shuffle and randomize but that is also true yeah um yeah these tokens were kind of weird like the sun heart and the uh uh and the i mean the ring made sense well it explains they represent i forget they represent things that are thematic but it's again a weak theme pasted onto uh an abstraction right this game does have expansions it does it does i i for some reason thought it it did in 2001 they came up with friends and foes um 2002 it looks like a deck of cards the black gate 2002 they came out with sauron and in 2007 they came out with battlefields yeah so i don't know obviously what any of those bring in battle um what is that battlefields looks like from the ancient ruins of weather oh each of the boards from the main game has a corresponding battlefield and players maneuver heroes and villains on these battlefields to improve their position in the fully integrated main game uh from the ancient ruins of weathertop
to the conflict at the black gate of mordor the journey of the fellowship of the ring is marked with battle will aragorn arrive in time to defend against the witch king of weathertop will boromir's courage hold against the savage urukai will gimli's axe be enough to withstand a horde of orcs at the chamber of mars or bull will sean bean survive this one no he's he always dies that's like in the in the ad like will sean being survived no uh sauron uh let's see um one player takes the part of saron the dark lord and plays against the fellowship sauron watches over the players every move and uses the black rider figure and special sauron and nas google cards to strike all right i don't know if that's its own standalone game no it's it's expansion and then friends and foes two new scenario boards bree and eisenguard adds 13 new feature cards and three new gandalf cards uh yep and it's expanded by the black gate that's pretty neat so um but yeah i mean even with those it's kind of like that would be amazing you have a huge lord of the rings game night but i have two games to kind of already do that hunt for the ring is a one verse many game where it's like one person plays as as frodo trying to get to uh rivendell and then the other people play as nazgul and then there's war of the ring which is the two-player heavy war game but
those can actually be interconnected but obviously those are two different types of games for of of this one where if you want a huge lord of the rings experience and you have all those expansions that'd be pretty cool um but yeah other than that fun fun game like this is great uh is this great gateway game especially if you love lord of the rings this isn't one of those like lords of water deep where it's like hey you like d d here's a game that has d d on it yes this is not bad you actually do i was we were quoting lord of the rings the entire time because the game kind of amplified that it wasn't like we were doing it to get through the game right had a good time all right uh on a scale of one to ten right i'll go eight eight nice it's hard because i'm nostalgia and i'm like i'm gonna give it an eight and a half oh eight point five i am going to give it an eight as well i was gonna give it a seven it's it's weird because it's like i'm gonna give it an eight but i would never play it again yeah but that's not it's great one time then pass it on to someone else yeah exactly like and also because of just my taste in games i i mean for a game being 21 years old it's like like defenders of the realm for example which is you know i think 2010 or something it's not as old as this game but i'd rather play this over that yeah because that one's just right that one is random uh still a fun cooperative game but also this is lord of the rings and does a fantastic job of
encapsulating that so yeah eights all around and we're 8.5 so that's our thoughts on lord of the rings let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you