Skip to main content
Loading video...

Weather Machine Review: A Storm Is Brewing

Transcript 15:38

hi everyone I'm Tali this is Faro and we are bored of it and today we're going to be reviewing weather machine the stormy new vital assert again which is already dividing opinions well more than he usually does in the world of weather machine one to four players will play as scientists attempting to create a second better weather machine after Professor latif's initial one whilst working in one area also created deadly storms across other areas of the globe so not ideal yeah I mean weather machine definitely sounds like more interesting science and the science I used to do but Tyler said again before then you'll know what you're getting into but if you haven't he's a designer known for creating these complex very intricate games that you have to unpick and you'll probably need some practice to be any kind of good app weather machine is another one of those and the core is going to see you in a kind of worker placement style you're going to move you're going to take some actions pretty much anything you do will give you bonuses and then the game is to spin out those bonuses into kind of more resources and more actions and do as much as possible while optimizing what you do because you have a limited amount of time foreign

how to describe this one because it is doozy and we like these types of games and we do a lot of explanations but honestly for this one it's just going to really be a brief overview because otherwise we could be here all day so on your turn what you can do is you're going to move your scientist to a different section than where you are like so and then you're going to take an action or actions in that section and you do this by spinning vouchers and on your player board you're going to have a bunch of voucher tracks one for each section and then a fifth track with kind of wild vouchers that you can spend on anything you like section number one is the supply here you can get all the resources you're going to need for the game and you can also take as many actions as you want as long as you have the vouchers to spend sections two three and four these each have two actions and section two is the government section three is latif's lab section four is research and development and whether you can do one or both of the actions they provide is dependent on which worker place and space you manage to get now the first section in these three are quite similar basically you're going to go there you're going to lease resources behind you're going to get a bonus you're going to move up the track it's corresponding with it and you're kind of contributing to something that will eventually run when it's filled up and it will provide you with points the second action in each of these is a little bit more complex and some of them have a lot of

prerequisites before you can do them in the government the second action is kind of just getting a bunch of bonuses and vouchers and stuff and in the other two it's more about publishing things you've collected you collect research and you get to publish it or kind of building a prototype based on what you've learned so far the main goal is to travel between sections two and four taking actions and getting some research as a reward once you have enough research on a specific type of weather you can publish a paper to score some points and after that you can have a breakthrough on that weather to score even more points alternatively you can help the government build their own weather machines to score more points once everyone has taken an action you'll see if the weather machine in latif's lab will run which requires a certain number of factors which we won't get into the details of here but if it does some people will score some points and rewards the game will end after a variable number of rounds because there are a few different end game triggers most of the time the game will end because you put the last of these weather tiles in the weather machine but it can also end if this section here or this section over here becomes full with kind of players Bots or if a player gets three War tokens and

being a Euro game the player who has the most points at the end of the game will be the winner where the machine is a hard game to review because I mean the first reason is a fatal third game which is divisive anyway some people see him as a genius designer other people see his games as games that are complex just for the sake of being complex with not a lot of fun to be had playing them for our part we're big fans tally is particularly fond of kanbani V I'm particularly fond of on Mars but weather machine is is kind of unique in some ways because while there are elements of previous games there's also departures you know there's kind of more sharp edges than usual to catch yourself on it's a little different in that you do have a lot more kind of one use rules like kind of at odds with each other and the last thing is there's more of a disconnect between the mechanical gameplay and the theme than you'd usually see in his games yeah on the other hand though weather machine is a very rewarding and addictive experience a key aspect that draws a lot of people to lacera's games is the challenge of unpicking the mechanisms going from getting 40 points in your first game to over a hundred in your 10th game learning the intricacies of the design then creates a higher level of play if you play with the same group and weather machine might just be the Pinnacle of

this of the serta's offerings but let's start at the very beginning learning the game much has been made of weather machine having lots of one-off edge case rules particularly with regards to two-player games and we personally feel like people have been a little bit harsher for our part yes they are there but they're not particularly confusing or extra also the additional rules upkeep in the two-player game is so nominal we honestly think it wouldn't have even been mentioned if it wasn't a Lazada game but I think you can't blame people for feeling this way because although the world of weather machine is well realized and the actions are framed smartly and is also a terrifically engaging theme there's an element of Disconnect between the mechanical aspects of the actions you do and the theme for example why is it that in the first section you lose vouchers if someone's to your left but in every other section you gain vouchers if they're to your left why is it that in a laboratory you spend chemicals and place them back in the supply but in research and development you leave them there well we're sure there is a reason for this it's not apparent and that's the issue here and another Infamous little problem that attests to this being a recurring theme is the artwork in latif's lab it shows machine parts which here those machine

parts are just decorative don't mean anything over here they indicate something and well we never had an issue with this it never confused us I can understand people's frustration about this unnecessarily complicating learning process you know we did have it in a game we taught that a player was trying to pay to go here with a machine part and then they kind of feel a bit put out because they thought they were getting the game and suddenly the rugs pulled out from under them but what we will say is that it might be the most beautiful of all the Serta games I think Eno tool has again outdone himself and the components are gorgeous and the hard thing about viewing weather machine is a lot of what we've said is almost negated and rendered by what weather machine is is a game designed to be complex it's a game designed to have a barrier to entry this game designed to reward players who play it repeatedly it's not a game designed for Mass Market appeal it's not a game design for people who are going to play it one two three times and then say no too complex not for me you know because this is a game that gives you a different experience on your first play your fifth player your 10th player your 20th play and it is rewarding to stick with it I wish you could see the joy this game gave tally

in the last two games we've played where she kind of intricately weaved her way through all the systems she combat her bonuses together she got a lot of points most importantly to her she beat me and you know it was a really rewarding experience coming from the first few plays where to be honest the game kind of kicked her ass on the gameplay level weather machine is an interesting one most of the actions you'll do are fairly simplistic and you're fairly rapidly cycle through the turns and rounds however this is in Euro fashion joined with a system of rewards and bonuses almost everything you do will give you something else that you can use and this is a particularly rewarding and engaging puzzle to navigate and this is where the crunch comes in deciding the most optimal path to reach your goal the weather machine is quite good at giving the player interesting options to decide behind for example you have all these different sections and although you do kind of need to do a bit of everything you can if you wanted really focus on one section they each have their own little rewards and different aspects that are alluring to players so it's quite fun and interesting to decide which one you want to kind of specialize in and as another example you have these investment tiles you can spend them to kind of get endgame scoring and like so you register yourself for it or you can

spend them to make the tracks you'd be moving up payout resources and so it's like do you want to speculate to accumulate and hope that you can turn those resources into even more points or do you just want to bank what you reckon you will already get and go for those end game scoring and again this is just a really interesting and kind of fun little decision and weather machine is a game that will be for you if you like these type of games where at any moment you have a number of equally interesting and equally good sounding options and you have to kind of go with gut on what one to get or you know kind of like pure strategize it we particularly like the system of circular actions which allows you to begin a game from any angle and creates a thoughtful riddle about how you Traverse the game in the way that you'd like because you can't do the same action twice in a row the added spice of contending with the other players or Latif in the different locations is equally inspired as it creates some great push-pull decisions should I go to the location where Latif is so I can move him along and get income from him or should I do this actually not I don't particularly want to do right now but it can get me some extra vouchers the one thing I would say about this system of actions is that although it's very smooth it's not 100 smooth I don't really like that for particular actions

there are very specific prerequisites you have to meet to take them because to me it's just a juxtaposition of this kind of circular looping system where I'm supposed to be weaving in between sections going here getting some bonus actions going there figuring out this puzzle but then there are actions along this route that are just like no do not enter maybe it's a personal thing but it just feels a bit off to me I will say though that this looping and kind of very seamless system of moving between the sections it does create for a really nice flow of gameplay because you almost don't feel like there are rounds which there are but because you don't it creates a really nice Pace to the game the last thing we'll touch on is the player count now this is one that does feel very different according to the number of people you have around the table and a key reason for that is you don't shrink the number of spaces that the robots have to go to in order to have the machines run so there's less elbows knocking together at two but it does mean it's going to be harder to fill those spaces and have the machines run and have them pay off we like playing at two we're going to continue to play it too but we would rather play at more it creates a more interesting experience because you have this weirdly Cooperative element where you're working together do you feel the spaces make the machines run plus contending to the worlds and actions of other players is

always a fun problem to navigate so final thoughts do you want a big crunchy brain melting board game do you want a board game that rewards repeated plays do you want to unpick a complex web of actions and bonuses in order to optimize your way to the top of the victory track if yes then we recommend with a machine but if you have not experienced a virtual soda game before we probably almost certainly don't recommend this is where you start because it's one of the most demanding and probably most complex most I don't want to use the word fiddly but you have these one-off rules and honestly even if you are a fertile soda fan I'm not sure it's for everyone I'm not sure I'd recommend it for everyone because it has been quite a divisive game I mean you have channels such as uh board game ramblings who I think both had it as a top game of last year and then you have other reviewers who uh live for tele soda games who are given schools like four and five out of ten so you have a big shift for our part we really enjoyed playing it I don't think either of us would say it's our favorite Tyler Serta game but we're definitely going to keep it and keep playing it and I really look forward to playing it a lot more so that we really do get to unpick these mechanisms yeah it's definitely weirdly addictive because it can be

I guess harsh in a way if things don't quite go your way but it you do just want to start again immediately so I think there's quite a lot to be said for that to be fair that is very true so that was our review of web machine we hope it was helpful hope it was informative if it was please consider subscribing as it's really important to us to grow the channel and if you have any questions feel free to ask us about weather machine and most importantly thanks so much for watching and we'll see you next time

Progress saved